Only place we get gluten free pizza. Decent topping selection. Sauce is nice. Other pizzas are great as well. Good mozz sticks

Been wanting to try this place out after constantly seeing their delivery cars all over town. Pizza was just OK. The slices were very big and the crust was thin and very crispy just like I like it. What took it down a few notches was the marinara sauce tasted like some generic sauce out of a can or jar. Very meh sauce. Other than that, the staff was attentive, even thought they were busy and there is a variety of different pizza types to choose from. Far from terrible, but with an abundance of mom and pop pizzerias in Garfield, there is simply cheaper and better pizza to be found. read more

I ordered a large pue with pepperoni anchovie and onion. The anchovie was only on 2 slices and the onions appeared to ne sauteed then put on the pizza. The pizza was just about raw and my first bite i had a 12 inch piece of hair in my mouth coming from under the cheese. Never will i order again. read more

I have eaten their pizza and mussel's marinara many times in the past. I tried something they call "grandma's pie" which is similiar to a sicilian pie but the crust is much thinner and crunchy. It has always been my favorite pie from this establishment. And I must say, they make the best mussels marinara in the area, bar none. Last night we ordered takeout/ delivery and was psyched for the pie and mussels. The mussels did not disappoint. Awesome! But this time, the pie was just OK. The mussels were steaming hot when I opened them at home. The pie was tepid at best. Not much cheese and the sauce was very much different than the other times we ordered "Grandma's Pie". The sauce was like a very sweet plumb tomatoes sauce and not much cheese. Much too sweet for my taste. But I'm going to try them again. I am hoping that the next time I order Grandma's Pie, it will be like the previous ones I had in the past. read more

Not bad at all--just don't order the Fried Calamari (Appetizer). My wife and I have been ordering from Pizzamania for several years. I first experienced their Cheese Steak pie in 2011 as an alternative to Frank's Pizza in Saddle Brook (their prices went "sky-high" around that time), and it was pretty good. The pie that really impressed us was the Stuffed Meat pie. Lately, our favorite Friday night includes their delicious Brooklyn (Sicilian) and White pies! Recently, we added an order of Fried Calamari to our usual--this was a mistake; it was rubbery and cold to the touch... Order the pizza, avoid the other stuff. The White pie IS good, by the way--not sure what other people are talking about with the negatives... read more

The Cobb Salad is a hit. Specialty slices are tasty. They have a great variety. Lunch specials are creative. Now, it's a one stop shop with Gelato Mania adjacent to it. read more

Far and away the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life. I cannot recommend the Vodka Sauce slices any higher. read more

It was good but i have had much better bruschetta pizza it was definitely skimpy on the toppings and it was pretty flavorless. Service was great. Delivered on time. Cheese pizza was awesome especially since my mother has an allergy to oregano and she was fine read more

I couldn't use credit card at PizzaTown or Lodi Pizza so I came here. I had pepperoni, sausage and "hot peppers" since jalapenos aren't served here. The hot peppers were oil based and not vinegar-based (like jalapenos) so the oil plus my greasy meats ruined the crust and made it floppy. I'd advise you to keep it simple. Above average flavor. Biizarre and huge list of items on the menu- some looked very intriguing. Nice folks that deserve your business. read more

I really like their salads. Great portions and delivery is always on time or earlier than expected. Not the biggest fan of their gourmet slices. But usually grab a salad or eggplant parmigiana with salad instead of pasta and I'm always a happy camper. read more

I ordered a meatball vodka pizza slice. It was soooo tiny. About a 6" rectangular slice. So tiny for $3.60 plus tax. All the prices on their new menu have gone up also. read more

Its good. Just moved to saddle brook on midland ave. Nice to have a good place close by.

Way overrated. I have tried this place a few times and still feel the same. The pizza is ok but not as good as these reviews claim. They have an extensive menu and specialty slices. The subs are all right but I didn't find them to be very packed. read more

The place is accommodating, they have an ice cream bar with other pre-packed options to go. The seating area for the ice cream bar seemed clean. The service was fast. Servers were nice. They have a different seating area for the pizza, although in the same place. The only downfall, to me, was that we were not able to pay once. We had to pay for the pizza and ice cream separately. They have carry out and delivery, and a VIP program. I think they also have an app. read more

I went there during lunch time to pick up an order and as I'm waiting for the food a guy walks in without mask and nobody said anything. Apparently he is known because they greeted him and completely ignored the fact that he was not wearing a mask. Honestly that's not the worse part bc ok fine don't wear it but he was by the glass counter looking at the pizza leaning on it and pointing his finger at the food over the glass. The glass is there for a reason. That was disgustingly and such a bad experience. Last time I order from them. No regard to the public's health just because they know a person. read more

I ordered out of here for my family because it was a close central location to where my grandma lives off Midland Ave. We ordered some pasta dishes and they were all great. The Veal Saltimbocca? FUHGEDABBOUDIT! Haha, so good. Came in a few days later and got some of the specialty slices and they were great. Slices were really good size, and had just the right amount of doneness to the dough. I really thought the chicken francaise pizza really stood out and was delicious. Service was great, people behind the counter were busy and helpful. Nothing bad to say about Pizza Mania, except that I wish we had one in Dallas. read more

Everything about this place is amazing. I get lunch and dinner here. Their lunch specials are so fresh and a great price. I've never had a bad meal here. I had an Avocado burger today at lunch and then got a completely fresh Arugula pizza for dinner. You get everything fresh and I promise you will enjoy. read more

On our first order for pizza Mania, Neil picked up the phone. After telling him we had decided on a margherti pizza, we asked him for a suggestion in an appetizer. We planned on ordering the fried ravioli, but asked him what is another good popular appetizer. Neil said the ravioli is a great choice but the fried Calamari and pepperoni bites are good also. Not only was the pizza awesome but the calimari was spectacular!! We will be ordering again soon. Mark and Debbie. read more

This is my favorite place around. We order lunch from here 2-3 times a week. Their lunch specials are affordable and they always have a variety. Their pizza though, is amazing. They have so many speciality slices there is something everyone will like. The staff is super friendly and works quickly. read more

This place is awesome! Great pizza, great service and a gelato place owned by the same family owners which was also great!! They also have gluten free pizza and they deliver! Overall, great place! read more

Great pizza. Great service. Fast delivery. I've ordered from here several times and have been pleased each time! Definitely give it a try!

Had to be the worst fried Calamari I've ever tasted I threw 3/4 in the garbage, Jalapeno poppers were OK, Pizza seemed like it was made yesterday and reheated, and the eggplant parm. was horrible as they obviously do not make their own sauce, it most likely from a can or a jar. Wont be ordering from here again! read more

This was our first time ordering from Pizza Mania, and were we impressed! We ordered some catering trays and everything was amazing. I can honestly say it was the best I have ever ordered. The food came at the exact time we ordered it for. It came hot, and the trays were filled. The wrap sandwich platter was a huge hit. The cold wraps were cold, and the hot wraps were hot. Just perfect!! All of our guest wanted to take something home with them. I would without a doubt order from them again. The service was amazing, starting with the very nice man who took my order over the phone, to the other nice man who made the delivery. The food was just perfect, and the price can not be beat. Pizza Mania is now my go to place for catering. Now I just have to try their pizza. I am sure it will fantastic!!! read more

I went to go get a couple of slices with my girl and as I walk in I go to wait in line and I come up to say my order so they can take my order and I'm up next and their was a group of people behind me the guy had take the order of the group of people behind taking an order over me and completely ignoring me worst experience there. I honestly didn't appreciate that so I left because completely ignoring me is rude and they don't deserve my money if they want to completely ignore a customer and take their friends orders over a customer who hasent even ordered yet. read more

My favorite place to order, when I order out, don't usually like ordering veal, because I get it and it's tough and no flavor, but Pizzamania made me a delicious veal francaise to die for, was tender and so good, I will always order from here, the Best place in the area and beyond! Everything I have ever ordered was great! And the Gelato, OMG read more

WORST FOOD EVER. Order chicken marsala with ziti... the ziti was under cooked and the chicken had absolutely NO flavor at all.. I ordered 2 slices of cheesecake... I received 2 slices of CHEESESTEAK pizza... never ordering from this place again. I wish I could give 0 stars. read more

pizza was good and tasty. Fries were kinda soggy but ok. Fine with it. 4/5 would try again read more

They said their cheesesteaks are made from sirloin, & I believe it. My daughter was traveling on business & we came here because it was bee her hotel. She craves cheesesteaks, because she hasn't found a good one in Florida in two years. This sandwich was superb, the meat was moist & tender, the roll was crisply crusted & had a great flavor. We shared an order of fries that were crisp on the outside, steamy on the inside; and ended our meal with espressos which were strong but not bitter - an overall excellent meal. read more

Decided to try this place on a whim and very happy that we did! I've never had a go to pizza place in Saddle Brook so I'm always looking for a good one that delivers. We got a Vodka Sauce pie and the Rice Balls Parmigiana- OMG, both out of this world! Will definitely order from here again. read more

this place sucks. i've ordered from here multiple times just to try to give them a shot. first they messed up my order 2+ times. second when i ordered my penne vodka pizza they brought me pizza with vodka sauce and then when they came they asked for the older pizza back so they'll probably sell that in store. Lol the drivers are usually always nice when encountering with them, but for the ones taking orders i cant say the same. the ONLY good thing from here i probably ever had was plain pizza and actual penne with vodka sauce (which is over charged, but whatever) read more

ups and downs. their crazy slices are great. my favorite is the chicken francese. I LOVE this slice it's like seriously to die for. plain slices are blah.... I think they use cheap cheese or something. or maybe the crust has no salt? either way it's totally blah. one time I ordered a salad with chicken as my boyfriend ordered a soup. the soup was 100 percent canned.. you could taste the tin of the can... if I wanted gross soup I could have warmed up a can myself for 1/5 of what we paid for a bowl. then came my salad. the chicken was definitely reheated leftover chicken. grossed me out. if there is one thing you should never do is serve leftovers and canned soup. this turned me off to this place for so so long. yuck thinking about that experience still grosses me out. read more

The pizza and garlic bread here were just average. I don't understand the glowing reviews, but the people were very nice, delivery was pretty fast, and the food was decent. read more

My job recently opened an office in Garfield, and we ordered six varieties of pizza for a meeting. The pizzas came quickly and were all delicious. I was especially impressed with their vegetable pizza, which included, tomatoes, peppers, onions, olives, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, and eggplant! We will order from here regularly. read more

Come here often to pickup. Ordered a delivery. Wait time was estimated at 45 mins. Sausage pie delivered in 20 mins! Always good and never have been disappointed. Stromboli w steak is fantastic, salads are great, pizza is outstanding. read more

My Girlfriend used to work right around the corner from this place, and got me a slice or 2 , every week, pizza was very good, they also have really really good sandwiches. Never had a problem with the food, always friendly on the phone. Great place to eat. read more

My favorite pizzeria in New Jersey. Some of the best specialty slices, sandwiches, and wraps I've ever had. I recommend trying the buffalo chicken, chicken marsala, and vodka sauce slices. They also recently expanded their dining room. read more

This is a very high-quality pizzeria. They have many unique funky pizzas and their traditional plain cheese pie is outstanding as well. The sandwiches and salads are very good too. Things on the menu that are outside of the box of a pizzeria like buffalo wings are not that good at all and are just reheated frozen food. The menu is too extensive not to start using frozen products for things like that, so just stick to the typical Italian pizzeria fare. read more

We get delivery here all the time. They are always fast(usually at least 10 min sooner than the quoted time), accurate, and the food is always good. We usually order with a lot of modifications (my wife is a picky eater) and they always get our order right. I would def recommend this place for delivery in the saddle brook area. read more

Been going here for so long that I feel like I'm now able to give you a more accurate review. The specialty pizza and salads are still the go-to option here, but see below: Go here: Specialty slices (Great variety, highly recommend the pizza without red sauce) Lunch specials ($5-8 deals) Salads Stay away: Dinners and sandwiches (The grilled chicken in sandwiches is an off color and has poor flavor and texture, Dinners like chicken parm never seem to be fresh - soggy, reheated) Anything with red sauce (Tasteless and too sweet IMO) read more

The go to spot for pizza/italian delivery... The salads, pizzas, pasata, subs, and huge rice balls are my go to options.... Tad pricier than other pizza places and generally always takes an hour for delivery but the food is tasty.... read more