*TOO GOOD TO GO REVIEW* For the amount we paid, we got a lot of slices of pizza. Plus, the pick-up time was at a reasonable time frame - actual dinner time and not at 9 PM. We got 4 slices (3 plain, 1 buffalo chicken), and 3 garlic knots. The slices were HUGE. It's probably 1.5x the size of a regular slice. It was only okay though. The crust was too thick for me. There are certain pizzas that are still good even when you reheat it but again, this one was just basic. But still, I can't complain since we got a great deal, and at the end of the day, pizza is pizza. read more

Mamma Mia Pizza - Too good to go box - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Friendly and welcoming staff and owners. Great food , great service, great for take out or dine in.

Great pizza, even better people. They made it to my top 5 pizza place. Came little late while they were closing, but they happily greated me and got what I needed. They even threw in few extras for me to try. I had the buffalo chicken, bbq chicken and garlic knots. Garlic knots actually had garlic, and very soft. The couple who owned the place could not be nicer people. read more

Top notch pizza! Thin crispy crust with the perfect crunch and perfect amount of toppings. Wow I'm blown away. Super friendly people. Small place with a nice little area & tv. read more

Vegan calzone was amazing. Highly recommend! Owners are so nice. Will be there often read more

Do you ever have a customer service experience so great that you immediately went to Yelp to leave a review ? This is that experience. The only thing better than the Pizza were the people who made it. It had the nicest Pizza experience scratch that nicest experience I've had in a very long time. I should've got them their names because it was that good if you're having a bad day and want to have a great experience and feel a little bit better, go get yourself a slice from Mamma Mia. read more

The food is great and so are the owners. This business is run by a dedicated family that prioritizes customer satisfaction, this is evident in their service and high-quality food. I 100% recommend it. read more

My partner and I have passed this quaint family owned pizzeria numerous times as it's only a couple of blocks from the house and wanted to give them a shot since we didn't want to cook and support the local economy. We took the opportunity for their 2 plain pizza pies special at $20 offering only Mondays and Tuesdays. I placed the order by phone for 6pm pickup with extra mushroom on one pie and cheese on the other which were extra cost. Upon arrival, there were 2 patrons enjoying their meal where social distancing was in place. Since our order was ready, I exchanged a few words with the owner Rudy and his niece. The pies arrived home hot and could smell deliciousness. The crust of the pies had a nice consistency crust as it wasn't thin as a Carr's water cracker. The tomato sauce, mushrooms and cheese filled out nicely around the circumference of the crust. Overall it was a good pizza. If you are in the area, we highly recommend this place. read more

See all

This pizza place has the best pizza, tenders, frys, you name it and the owner is super nice he lets me go if im a dollar or two short i give this place a 10/10 read more

Beyond annoyed with their customer service. I placed and order via DoorDash and after waiting 30 mins I got an alert that the restaurant could not fulfill my order. I called and gentlemen on the phone was very rude beyond belief. He did not want to hear me and kept on barking about someone else's order. I had to ask him to take a step back and breathe and listen to me. Never will be ordering from this establishment again. read more

We are a fairly large office and ordering lunch is a daily ritual. Today we saw mamma Mia was offering specials and were delighted to try a new place. Three of us ordered grilled chicken Ceasar, not hard to mess that up right? WRONG! See my attached photos, chicken tasted like it was dipped in black pepper and microwaved for 3 hours. It was not grilled by any means but more of a jerky Needless to say none of us ate the chicken jerky salad read more

Mamma Mia Pizza - Dry chicken jerky passed off as Ceasar - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

Mamma Mia's is an absolute treat! Food was so so so good that you could tell was made with such care. Folks we're delightful and treated you like family. So lucky to have stumbled across this gem! Wish I lived here so I could be a regular read more

Mamma Mia Pizza NEVER disappoints! Their food is unbelievably good and they always have amazing deals! I ALWAYS grab a fresh pie from here with garlic knots. The owner is amazing and always makes sure his customers are well taken care of. The customer service here is exceptional! read more

Got Saturday lunch takeout from this place as we were passing through the area. Excellent pizza (available in three sizes), delicious fresh from oven garlic knots, excellent Greek salad with very tender and juicy grilled chicken! read more

See all

BEST MEATBALLS OF MY LIFE. Everything made by hand. Everything made with love. Sweetest couple serving, delivering and cooking.

Lord I love there pizza and especially there buffalo wings there not these little precooked wings there actual full wings and the cook them to order and on top of that they are always so sweet and so kind... Once you order a time or two they know you and ask you your usual or something different. When I was working in that area I swear we use to order from there at least 3 times a week especially if my coworkers wanted pizza we order a couple of pies I love there pizza and there hospitality so they will always get 5 stars from me read more

Amazing food and specials during this time! Best pizza in Garfield and delicious pasta dishes. Rudy is so sweet and greets you with a smile. Will be my go to spot for takeout! read more

Use to go here all the time when I was taking care of my mother in law then one night felt like a scilian pie when I went to pick up he actually remembered me! Took extra care in boxing up the pie an even had the kid carry it out to my car! An it was really delicious! An we're very fussy on our pizza great job an service mamma Mia! read more

I know there are many pizza places in the area but this is by far the best! Every pizza Is so delicious and the garlic knots are to die for! The service is excellent and everyone is so friendly! Do yourself a favor and stop by or order from Mamma Mia's you will be happy you did! read more

By far the best food ever. Every time I go I always try something new...and let me tell you AMAZING!! Can't go wrong with this place.

Yep yep yep. Yep yep yup yep yup yup. And then one time yep. It was a great day. Ordered in alphabetical order and it was fantastic