Ordered a pepperoni pie tonight for pick up, instead of a fresh pie I was given a pie assembled from slices ,only half were pepperoni. I didn't see that pie was not fresh until I got home! When ordering a pie it should be fresh.....I will not be going back, beyond pissed off read more

We order from them all the time, they never disappoint. Incredibly fast delivery, even on a busy night they are quick. Lots of pizza variety (specialty pies). Almost everything we've had twice on the pizza menu. The Chicken Vodka pie and Buffalo chicken pie are our favorites to get. read more

salads large are amazing but could use more chicken when it is an extra charge. overall service is quick.

eggplant parm no bueno! Slices of dry eggplant layered on top of each other with no sauce or cheese and only sauce n cheese on top layer makes for a very dry eggplant parm read more

My go to place when we don feel lime cooking. Pizzas are excellent! The chicken vodka parmigiana sandwich is amazing! Highly recommend Pizza one Wayne NJ. read more

Excellent, authentic pizza and sandwiches. I highly recommend for multi person orders. They were fast, professional and the food was excellent read more

Yep, I found my new spot! Great portions, spot on quality and a friendly staff. Owner operated and it shows. The grandma pie was excellent. Thank you Moe and staff. We will be back. Anthony read more

I have been ordering from them the last 3 weeks for a training class I've been doing in jersey overall a little upset they've messed up the orders a few times we kept asking them to label the food which they barely ever did and once forgot some ones lunch another time brought us food that we didn't order tasty food which was somewhat consistent which is why I gave them 4 stars Updated 12/21/17 orderd from them again to the office and they messed up half the order you would think after spending over 2 grand there the last few weeks they'd be more consistent for us dissapointed today pretty bad read more

I ordered from Pizza One in Wayne for the first time tonight, and it will be the last time. I waited over an hour for food to be delivered that was not edible. I ordered the eggplant panini and gravy/cheese fries, both of which I unfortunately had to throw away after only a couple bites. Both tasted very much like when something is fried in old oil that is used over and over again. They were heavy, saturated, incredibly salty, with an aftertaste similar to how I'd imagine gasoline would taste. It was not something you could just suck up and eat anyway, despite being really hungry. I have never left a review for any restaurant before, but the food I received tonight from Pizza One was so disappointingly bad that I felt giving others a heads up was the right thing to do. read more

Absolutely amazing food, take out & delivery options are key! Buffalo chicken pizza slices or chicken vodka Parmesan subs are extraordinarily tasteful!! My go-to place is Pizza 1 for two or more good reasons! read more

Worst service ever they're ridiculous and the pizza isn't worth it at all will never return again. How do you call in two slices and then have to wait ten minutes just to find out it's not even ready. read more

I work close by and I love pizza. Thank goodness this gem is here. Very good pizza. Well I only get pepperoni but the crust is thin and crispy the way I like it. Perfect bite everytime. I also tried one of the Fat sandwiches and it was massive. Brought back memories of the grease trucks in Rutgers. Keep it up guys!!! read more

OMG Trippin on a sausage parm with peppers and onions. You fella's got this shit tight. Come here people, dis the place. It all happens here.. read more

Went with my daughter here on 23 wanting a good slice of pizza. Glad I came. The pizza we ordered was a Marguerite and the sauce and dough was sooo tasty!! It was so freshly prepared and I knew I had found my new pizza stop. The mozzarella cheese was super fresh and light and the crust was a little crispy and had a slight char which I love. Our order was promptly completed and I waited very little. Great place for pizza and the selections are ample. Definitely worth trying if you're a pizza connoisseur like me. read more

Good food average pizza but they are becoming way way over priced. I know inflation is a big deal but $25 for a pepperoni pizza I'm going back to licking g up from V&J. read more

This is my favorite pizzerias in New Jersey. Their pizza is so tasty it reminds me of the New York style pizza that you used to get in Manhattan back in the 1990s. The pizza in Manhattan went downhill since the cost of living keeps going up. But this is definitely the best pizza I had. Just walking into the place you get greeted with a smile's and respect they make you feel like you are family and then you look at the display then you can choose which lights you want to have first. Their pizza is really outstanding their salads and sandwiches are amazing the customer service is really great. The place is spotless. Nowadays it's so hard to get good customer service from any place and it's so hard to walk into a very clean place you can tell they really take pride of the work. read more

Pizza One - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

After several deliveries, I think I can safely give 5 stars due to the fact that: 1. My husband is officially addicted to their large chicken parm subs. They're ginormous and make great leftovers or good to split! 2. Their delivery guys are always so friendly and polite. 3. Their ordering online system has lots of custom options. You can add avocado, get gluten free pasta, have your salad chopped, etc. Makes ordering so easy. If delivery took less than a full hour, it would be even better! I like getting the side of meatballs (3) in the sweet, red sauce. Also, for a pizza place, their burgers kick BUTT! Wow! Very reliable place. read more

Very good food at this spot!! The meatball pizza is off the chain!! Best fries in jersey hands down!!

The food here is amazing for a pizza joint! It's well kept and has great service to say the least. read more

Pizza One - Those Daytona Wings!!!! You gotta try em with jalapeno poppers *LOVE* - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Every time I think they've thought of it all they amaze me again. I just had a focaccia pizza sandwich from pizza one and it was absolutely incredible. I will never go to another pizza place as long as pizza one is around. Everything from their menu to staff is excellent but their creativity with pizza is absolutely phenomenal. If you haven't tried it I feel really bad for you. read more

The Carribean salad is the best salad I have ever had in my life it was so good that I went and ate it again the next day and it was equally good the second time. So much fruity walnut healthy goodness!!!!!! read more

Pizza One - Caribbean Salad - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

We Just moved and tried this place out! Excellent pizza , chicken parm hero, antipasto salad !! Wings were awesome ! Food arrived in a timely fashion and it was still hot. Thank you :) read more

Best pizza place in the area! I'm not from Wayne but I work nearby and I order lunch/dine in all of the time- I've literally never had a bad experience. My go-to is the chicken caesar wrap but I've also had many different pizza slices and a few of the paninis which were all absolutely delicious as well. I also know that they have catered lunch to my work before and very willingly held a special night where they donated a percentage of checks to a fundraiser we were having. Great place that clearly values customer satisfaction! read more

I'm almost afraid to post a 5 star review because I'd hate anything to change. The food is terrific, delivery fast, staff is always helpful and very nice. The pricing is very competitive as well. read more

I used to order from here quite a bit but the past few times the pizza wasn't as tasty as it normally is and for the price, it didn't seem worth it. Give it a shot once and see for yourself. read more

Its Memorial day. 2016, went out looking for something to eat, nothing open. Stumbled acroos this place, now i jam a big fan of the Pizza1 in wanaque, but this one in wayne was no comparison. Sat down to eat and didnt realize no waitress service, so after waiting for some one to take n order went to the counter tried to order but the person kept answering the phone. Finally placed my order, paid , and sat and waited and waited and waited, i get the idea. Well after waiting for 25 minutes, i went to check on the order and was told its almist done. Anyone no how long ALMOST IS? Food finally was ready, except they packed it to go, i dont remember sayong "TO GO". Service not so good but the food was good! read more

This stinks. We REALLY like their food (pizza/meatballs/wings), but they are just terrible at delivering it. We've only been in town for 6 months and they've messed up our orders FOUR times. They forgot our soda for two of them, the third time they crushed our pizza so bad they brought us a new one, and now this time they brought the wrong soda. Come on... We're super easy going people and haven't made a big deal out of this or asked for any money back, but this being the 4th time is ridiculous. Like I said it stinks because we like their food, but messing up 4 times in a short amount of time isn't okay, especially on our dime. Too much competition for that to happen! read more

Best place for pizza!! I never ordered anything that tasted less than delicious. My personal favorite is the eggplant salad pizza, which is absolutely great. I could eat it everyday. They also have yummy sandwiches! read more

Pizza One - Eggplant Salad Pie - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

I order from their enough and , I just tried the cavatelli and broccoli and it was 2 good. And heavy def something you eat some of the next day. On top of ti got an Italian sub , which is gigantic. Pizza sauce is my fav also. Only issue is , if you go by the menu prices , alotta times it seems alittle off. But , you get what you pay for . And between the sub and the pasta , that shit must have wieghed ten pounds. read more

I myself am not a huge pizza fan but I know what's good when I have pizza. Let me tell you I am not a big fan of this place when ordering pizza. Their plain pizza has absolutely no taste whatsoever, just in my opinion I don't like this place. Their chicken and fries are 5.5/10 not a big fan but like I said it's my opinion you have to see for yourself. read more

Great food and great service! There's a wide selection of options for lunch and dinner. I've enjoyed various wraps, wings, and pizzas.

I absolutely LOVE this place because its rare to find a pizza place around Woodland Park / Totowa that delivers EXCEPT THIS ONE! They have always hot upon delivery pizza, wings, desserts, etc and the waiting time is average depending on the busyness of the company. They also have an online ordering menu for people who are too lazy ( like myself) to call or cannot. read more

As far a NJ pizzeria go, this place is great! I have been a few times with my family that lives down the street, and last week my friend and I went there to meet them. He and I both live in DC now and miss our good NJ pizza. We asked specifically to go to Pizza One because back in the winter we had a tortellini alfredo pizza there that was out of this world! They did not have the pizza on display, and told us it was not on their menu, but they could make us a custom order. After telling them how thankful we were and how much we love their pizza, they then decided to just make the pizza for display so we could each have a slice instead of having to buy the whole pie. THAT is true customer service! Really, really great staff and the pizza is great too. We also had a chicken cutlet, vodka sauce wrap that was yummo! read more

Pizza One - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Absolutely love this place! Staff is so friendly and food is always spot on. They have the best salads, bread, specialty pizzas, pasta...everything is so good. Great delivery service too. We have been getting from there for years and will absolutely continue to do so! Highly recommend read more

Just got the Hollywood salad for lunch. It was fantastic. They deliver to my job all day... My entire staff loves them. Great food and very fast delivery... Not a bad thing on there extensive menu... read more

Pizza terrible here. It tasted like cardboard. For a place that calls themselves pizza one, the pizza is gross. In my opinion they cook everything with way too much oil. Chicken cheesesteaks should not have that amount of oil all over the bread. Not good. read more

Pizzalicious? Nothing was licious about the pizza. It was some of the worst pizza I have eaten in New Jersey. Which is still 10X better than a pizza anywhere else in the country, but if I compare it to other great Pizzerias in Jersey, Pizzalicious falls way short. The crust should be tough, chewy, and yet tender at the same time with the right amount of air. This crust was just crispy and slightly greasy, but not in a good way. When it comes to grease, it is a tricky thing. The pizza has to have some oil dripping from it. Oil is different than grease. Oil comes from the high fat content of the whole milk mozzarella, from the sauce, from the pepperoni or sausage. Grease is just sloppy. This pizza was greasy. There are other pizzerias in Wayne, this one should be avoided. read more

Thank you so much to Pizza One Wayne for donating pizza to our healthcare employees! We appreciate your generosity during this time! Our staff loves their menu options on a regular basis, so this was greatly appreciated! Keep us the great work! Atrium at Wayne read more

I ordered a couple years ago and I would have given that experience a negative 2 if I had yelp and had an option for that. So I decided to give it another try since it's been so long - it probably would be good now since I see them delivering everywhere- well I was dead ass wrong. If yelp had a negative 3 star rating. It would have gotten thank tank from me. I ordered a few things to try out. I got a buffalo slice. It was smaller than my hand. Which ok that's just the size the slice was eh. I ordered the vodka fries. Cause I love vodka sauce. The sauce isn't good at all. And now here is where the negative stars come into play. I ordered a chipotle chicken sandwich. First thing first. The chipotle mayo was barrrrreelllyy even on the sandwich. The tomatoes tasted rotten and the lettuce WAS ROTTEN. (Look at my pictures) after taken a few bites I noticed a foul taste - so I decided to dissect the sandwich and that when I noticed the god damn disgusting lettuce that should never be on a sandwich or even be served. Then the best part is. They tried hiding the nasty lettuce under decent lettuce. Please look at my pics before ordering. I got sick from this sandwich. I was fine. Then after noticing is was sick on the bowl . read more

Never knew of the one in Haskell but have ordered from the Wayne location a few times now. The food is very fresh and the menu is extensive. Maybe a little too extensive, as it makes it a little hard to choose but I guess that's better than not having enough of a selection. The New Yorker panani is amazing and surprisingly their lobster bisque is very good. Not just lobster flavor like most places but a lot of actual lobster meat! Delivery was very quick and the prices aren't unreasonable! Definitely recommend these guys, they are great read more