Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pizza Pub 516

    3.6 (42 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza, Salad, Sandwiches
    Open 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Pizza Pub 516 Takeout or Delivery

    Pizza Pub 516 Photos

    Business Info

    PIZZA PUB 516 ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like Pizza Pub 516

    Recommended Reviews - Pizza Pub 516

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Entry to Pizza Pub 516
    Mark K.

    This is a very good pizza place in Bowling Green on the western edge of BGSU campus and the eastern edge of the central business district. This shop shares a building with two other businesses (a Pita Pit and a Subway). The city parking lot in the back is very convenient. There is both indoor and outdoor seating at this restaurant. During our visit on a Sunday evening, it was not busy and everyone was sitting inside. The dining room was perhaps a bit dark but was spacious and comfortable. Social distancing was no problem. Our server did a great job taking care of us. Pizza was unquestionably the feature of the menu. We chose the Greek Pizza. This featured pesto sauce, grilled chicken strips, bacon bits, tomato slices, red onions, Kalamata olives and a three-cheese blend topped with Feta. This was presented with a toasty brown top. The pizza featured an excellent taste, but was very rich. We ordered the eight-slice size and brought five pieces home. The cost was not cheap on the surface. The pizza was $23 USD. With drinks, tax and tip, our final bill was $33. At $16.50 per person, this was not a bad deal, especially if it is considered that there were two additional meals worth of pizza brought home. I would not hesitate to recommend this place if someone wanted pizza in Bowling Green.

    Bosco sticks and pizza sauce.
    Kim F.

    I spent plenty of time enjoying the old Myles Pizza Pub while a student, so for me and many others, this is a sentimental place some might consider sacred in the BG culture. I can say with confidence that you can still find an exceptional pie here. I brought my son here during a very busy school weekend and had my daughter with me two years later, during a slow period at the start of summer. The quality of the pizzas were consistent and our service was solid as well. While I thought a hearty small pizza would be enough for my daughter and I, she saw the Bosco sticks and ordered them to start. I'd never had them before, but they were excellent--5 of them served hot, stuffed with cheese, and covered in garlicky goodness! Then the pizza came. My daughter had never seen a pizza so thick and cheesy, since most of her life she's had only franchise chain pizzas. In her words, after the first bite, "This is the best pizza EVER!" The only knock on this pizza is it's expensive for a restaurant right across from my undergraduate Alma mater. At $20 for a medium, 6-cut pizza, it's no wonder why we ate a lot of cheap, chain store 'za when I was in college. Our bill with sodas came to $30, and that was with a side order of Bosco sticks for an additional $8. Still, the meal was super filling and I got to relive a little slice of my college life with my kid. That was priceless.

    Cassie B.

    Bang for your buck: 8/10 Quality: 10/10 Service: 10/10 Ambiance/Location: 10/10 Overall: 9/10 Okay. I was skeptical. I'll admit it. I stopped into Pizza Pub 516 with hopes that it would just be Myles Pizza. And I was pleasantly surprised that it's very, very close! The interior is the same as my beloved Myles. It's got that same cozy basement bar vibe I always loved about it. Plenty of seating, great selection of beer, and TVs to catch the game. We sat at the bar and waited for a takeaway order and the bartender/server was extremely efficient and lovely. We got the cheese bread and I said a silent prayer that it would live up to that of Myles. It is exactly the same. Best cheese bread in the world!!! We also got an extra cheese pizza, and I personally thought it was better than Myles! The sauce was so much better and the dough has that fluffy thickness but without that burnt edge Myles always got. I would recommend Pizza Pub to everyone who's looking for memories of Myles and to those new freshmen falcons looking to make their own memories. It will not disappoint!

    Look at those hunks of sausage and fresh green peppers!
    Brenda H.

    We visit this pizza place in town often because the food, beer and service is GREAT! I can't think of one bad experience at this restaurant. I always go with the local beer selection - it's awesome and always features current local brew for the season. The pizza is loaded - a lot like Myles Pizza that was the previous owners. I think this pizza place in town has the best salads. The salad is huge and totally fresh! My husband and I split the Greek salad and sometimes have enough to take home.

    Nicholas A.

    Phenomenal garlic cheese bread, and pizza. Pizza is my cheat meal once a week and would highly recommend this place, worth the drive from Toledo. Tons of cheese, a lot of flavor, great ranch, and way over portion sizing.

    Looks messy but amazing!
    Brody R.

    First time trying this place and it brings me back to my visits at Myles! Food was top notch and the service was great. The only complaint I have is the crust was a tad dry. Their salads are amazing!!

    the front of the restaurant
    Steven H.

    This place used to be Myles Pizza. This pizza is better than Myles. Excellent pizza, good service, and still has the atmosphere of the old Myles Pizza.

    Itemized receipt

    See all

    Photo of BJ R.
    29
    12
    0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Pizza Pub 516

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 958 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sterling's Amish Deli

    Sterling's Amish Deli

    3.8
    (19 reviews)
    0.3 mi

    I've had deli sandwiches across the country from NYC, Philadelphia, Chicago, San Francisco, and LA…read moreand more... non-compare to Sterlings Amish deli! Their sandwiches are incredible especially the Rachael and their giant turkey club but on top of that the employees are very welcoming and it's also a great location to visit as they sell a wide variety of jams, jelly, candy, and much more! I highly recommend it - you won't be disappointed!

    Having noticed that the long-standing "coming soon!" sign was not longer in the window, I wanted to…read morecheck out the new Sterling's Amish Deli. Taking over the same storefront as the former Amish Deli (home of "Bowling Green's Biggest, Baddest BLT"), I had high hopes which were only buoyed by the enthusiastic welcome I received from the smiling staff as I entered the establishment. The nice lady at the order counter apologized and said the grill was having issues during their soft opening, but that did not matter to me, as I already had my eyes on trying one of the 2-dog combos. After quickly reviewing my options, I ordered the Sterling dogs with a side of coleslaw, plus a fountain Coke. Before tax, the total came to $9.98, which was pretty reasonable for lunch downtown. As I made my way to one of the booths, I cast my eye around the dining room, and frankly, I liked what I saw! The new laminate floor looked great, as did the brand new -and spotlessly clean- tables, chairs, and booths. The decorations and wall hangings were tasteful and un-cluttered, and I especially liked how the blue light horse silhouette (visible on far-right side of my dining room photo) conveyed a sense of good-Amish-food-meets-21st-century. After a pleasantly short wait, my order was delivered to my booth. The all-beef dogs were garnished with crispy-cooked bacon, red pepper relish, and shredded cheddar cheese. As you can see in my food photo, they looked great, and tasted even better! The side of coleslaw was also very good, which kind of surprised me, as I expected it to be overpowered by the clearly visible chunks of red onion, but the flavours melded together perfectly. I also liked how the staff stopped by my table to ask how the food was, and how speedy and friendly they were any time I took my fountain cup up to the counter for a refill. PROS: very good food, very friendly staff, reasonable prices, and a good atmosphere CONS: for a soft opening, I felt they were great, as I had zero issues! Overall I rate Sterling's Amish Deli as being Very Good, and look forward to returning!

    Photos
    Sterling's Amish Deli
    Ruben Sandwich and fries
    Ruben Sandwich and fries
    The turkey club and Rachael sandwich

    See all

    The turkey club and Rachael sandwich

    Pizza Pub 516 - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...