The food , service and ambiance And it always makes me feel…read morelike I'm in an Italian eatery in Europe, but better, because it's like right around the corner from my house! I have never had a bad meal ever , the wine list is on point, because obviously the owner knows his Menu and pairs it. Looking forward to getting my taste buds lit Soon! Thank you for staying in the community after the Fire . You did a fantastic job with the new look !5star

I've been to Pellegrini's Italian several times over the last few months, and its my favorite…read moreItalian restaurant in Greeley. The food and service are consistently very good, especially for the price. The fresh pastas are the highlight, and I really like that you can create your own entrée by choosing the pasta, sauce, and proteins or vegetables. On our most recent visit, we started with the burrata appetizer with ham and pistachios, which was excellent. I had the paccheri pasta with a meatball and sausage. The pasta itself was great, though I did not care for the texture of the sausage link, which was too firm for my taste. The desserts were excellent. A nice bonus was that bottles of wine were half off on Wednesdays, and we enjoyed a very good Nero d'Avola for $25. Service was responsive, friendly, and attentive throughout the meal. The dining room is gorgeous, though I really do not like the chairs. They are small, wooden, uncushioned, and uncomfortable. Overall, despite the chairs and the sausage, this is an outstanding place for a meal.

Went here for graduation dinner from Ft Collins. Quaint little spot that doesn't look like much…read more Don't expect the food here to be like a chain restaurant. They make each dish to order. I've had a lot of Italian but this food was so so good. All 8 of us were talking about how much we all like our meals. Our service was great. The manager came by to see us. It was just great food and a good experience. Don't expect "fancy". But expect spectacular food.

Gluten free noodle were awful compared to other places I have been. Order was incorrect and waiter…read moredidn't refill glasses. Silverware was dirty. My daughter did love her carbonara though.

This place was top tier! My family was looking for a good Italian restaurant while we were in…read more Greeley since we didn't know where to go. This one popped up on the top of the maps When we came, we got a salad and it was the perfect size! The homemade pasta is delicious and my husband had a pizza. The crust was amazing! To end our meal we ordered a cookie and it was a large cookie with ice cream. I would highly recommend this place!

Flavor of the food was really lacking, I had been hearing so much about this place and we finally…read morehad the opportunity to go there for our grandsons birthday.i was so disappointed by the Alfredo pasta having very little flavor the wife had chicken that she said was so rubbery in texture , we don't plan to go back and went with friends to a different restaurant this past Friday rather than meet them at santeramos

Sauce is the best! Fast and friendly service, best location in my book. Friendly manager, checked…read moreon us and carried a conversation. Nutty idea pizza is the best

If you need things that are specifically gluten free, this is not the place for a single person to…read morego. If you have an autoimmune disorder that you're not allowed to have nightshades this is not the place to go. They do not have anything to fit a specialized diet. Hit up MOD Pizza.

The pizza was so very good as well as the fried ravioli. It was fun reading about the history of…read morethis place. I would eat there again if I ever make it back to Greeley.

Absolutely love this place! One of the best pizzas you will get in Greeley. It's a little pricey,…read morebut then isn't everything nowadays.

The food was really good. It's loud inside, so I think outside would be better if noise bothers you.read more

Had the Fettuccine Alfredo and Chicken Parmesan delivered. The Fettuccine was $12.99 and the…read moreChicken Parmesan was $18.99. The Fettuccine Alfredo was just ok; didn't taste bad but didn't taste good. It was kind of bland. The sauce just wasn't very flavorful. The pasta was cooked very well. I think Olive Garden has an excellent version of this. The Chicken Parm was very good. The chicken was thick and juicy. The crust was just right in thickness. Excellent cheese. The dish consisted of a very generous 2 chicken pieces and a rigatoni (?) in tomato sauce side. 3 Stars because the Fettuccine Alfredo really spoiled things. I would try this place again, and try something different.

This was once a place I regularly recommended, which makes its recent decline particularly…read moredisappointing. While the specials remain one of the few bright spots, the broader experience is less than impressive. The kitchen was notably slow, the pizza arrived with a burnt bottom crust, and service is inconsistent. Most concerning is management's response to a routine question regarding a service charge... rather than addressing it professionally, the matter was handled with unnecessary hostility and followed by an inappropriate private message. A restaurant's leadership sets the tone for the entire operation, and based on recent experiences, that tone appears to be contributing to the establishment's downward trajectory. I hope they are able to make meaningful changes. Update: After posting this review, the owner texted me: 'Don't EVER come here again. You are not allowed and police will be called. Have the day you deserve.' Screenshots retained. Readers can draw their own conclusions regarding professionalism

Sadly will no longer be giving Romas any of our business…read more We called to ask about their menus and order a few pizzas for delivery. They dont deliver and use door dash which is fine. So we spent the time to order online and got it done , paid and confirmed. 30 min later @ the delivery time we were notified that Romas cancelled our order because they were too busy. Now, I'm not sure why they didn't tell us on the phone that they couldn't take our order and why it was confirmed and then canceled. We had a house full of family doing a move into a new house. Waited the 30 min and have no food . Unfortunately, business that have no concern for their paying customers.... I won't support. There are a lot of other great place for good food and good customer service.

We had a family dinner with you guys on Friday night. Holly…read morewas our server. She was awesome! Always checking on us and so friendly. The food was great! Big portions. The other lady who filled our water was super sweet and so adorable. She was probably the oldest employee there. Great job you guys!

I came here in Mother's day, which is peak busyness for this place. I understand that major…read moreholidays are stressful, and I'm sympathetic towards all the workers and that are trying their best amidst the chaos. But I called ahead the day prior asking if they accept reservations for large parties--they say no, but to call ahead as soon as they open the next day (10:00 am). So I did, I call at 10 the next morning and let the staff know I'll have a large party coming at 2pm. I'm aware that call aheads aren't reservations but just a small shoe-in on the waitlist, which is fine. My problem lies in the fact that my party arrives at 2, checks in, and has to wait an HOUR before being seated. An additional large 12-top comes in after we've been waiting for 30 min and they get seated within 15 minutes. Not only that but the large table sat before us had all their plates, salad, and breadsticks. We had to request more seats, silverware, and we had to ask for breadsticks well after being seated. The food is fine the service is tolerable, but please be more courteous to those who at try to be communicative with their plans and make an effort to be more organized. It felt incredibly unfair.

Friendly young counterman. Lunch special just the right price. Close to NY pizza (from this New…read moreYorker). Glad they added a west Greeley location. Garden City was out of the way for us. Brighter, newer setting.

Terrible service. I ordered a pizza online, came in to pick up my order and the cashier wouldn't…read moreeven look at me. He would only make eye contact with the person I had walked in with, I reached out to take my pizza and they make a detour around the counter to hand it off to the guy I had walked in with. Not me - the person whose name was actually on the order and who paid for the food. Blatantly sexist assholes working the counter that night.