I had to leave a review because holy crap. I'm 55 years old and I have never had a better burger in my life! I ordered the "Buckaroo" burger and I am going to say it was the best burger I have ever had. Definitely ordering again! About damn time someone made some quality food! read more

Good Food, Bad Vibes Last week I walked in and didn't see slices immediately and asked an employee if they had slices. He silently pointed to the board that listed the slice options with a look on his face like "duh." Then because I can't have red sauce, I asked if the sweet 'n sour chicken had a red sauce or other base and was answered sarcastically. I told my cousin who lives around the corner and has gone there, and she said she also had a bad experience. An older man/manager was berating an employee in front of customers. Please improve professionalism and customer experience - there are lots of other pizza places in the area! read more

After many years of delicious pizza, time to say adios. After several weeks of cold pizza coming past 2 hrs, we called. She told us to call earlier..... So we decided to go once more. My thin crust was ¾" thick, I asked for no cheese, the left off the mozzarella, then sprinkled parm on the whole thing. Good idea. And it took 2 hrs.​ read more

I have to say that there are a lot of pizza and wing places and everyone has their favorites. i won't say this is my favorite but our boss at work buys us subs and pizza from this place regularly since we are close by.I think the subs are just as good as Dibella's and Wegmans and Jersey Mikes. They have one size (looks like a medium (12 in). The bread is always fresh and the cold cuts and toppings aren't skimped on. The pizza is good also. When it is piping hot out of the oven, it's fantastic. It loses something once it starts to cool. Not a fan of microwaving it since the crust looses all crunchiness. I would recommend their lunch pizza to go. You have some nice choices as I've had meat lovers with meatball, pepperoni and sausage. They have a Detroit style with the thicker square slices. Also a Grandma's pizza that has cheese on the bottom and sauce with garlic and paremesan on top. You get a nice portion for the money. I recommend trying the Guida's on Elmgrove. Never been to any of the other locations. read more

We recently had a birthsay party catered from Guida's. I can't tell you how many compliments we received from our guests on the food. The portion sizes were large, the pricing was reasonable, the food was delivered on time, and it tasted absolutely amazing!!! Thank you Lynn from Guida's for making our birthday celebration such a success. Michelle read more

Great Pizza toppings are plentiful. Sauce is excellent and the service is great! All of their food is delicious I wasn't surprised that the pizza was so good. Catering is the best! read more

I came in to eat with two of my boys for lunch. We had a warm welcome, and I had the most delicious soft and fresh slices of pizza served to us. Honestly still thinking about how good it was , made me write this review! Too bad they dont deliver but it's worth driving to , rather than having a horrible pizza delivery from else where( true story). read more

the best pizza that i have ever purchased in the rochester area. so many toppings to choose from to make your own pizza. great customer service. a lot of cheese. does not skimp on toppings like Mark's pizza does, I asked for eggplant and anchovies and there were ample topping that i could taste. mark's workers use a small tweezer to add toppings and i cannot even taste them so why pay for them. there are 4 locations for Guida's Pizzeria. try one!! read more

Pizza and wings were pretty good. Definitely check out this place if you're in the area read more

Guida's Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Terrible Cheese Burger Subs on Sept 12th @ the Gates location on Elmgrove road. My wife placed an order over the phone for 2 cheeseburger subs for pickup. Arrived at the location for pickup, girl indicated it was going to another 5 minutes, actually was 10 minutes or more I waited. When we got home an open up our subs, we both noticed that the hamburgers completely dried out, over cooked to the point they were almost burned. Honestly I would like to be refunded for the terrible food. I guess I will have to look around for better experience read more

I love Guidas for many many reasons! A main one being that this location is .1 miles from my home, and makes them a basic go-to for all things party planning and hosting. In addition to that... 1) The appetizer pizza tray!! YES YES YES. Under $30, delicious, and enough food to feed a whole army. I don't know anywhere else in town that does this thick crust, soft, three-style pizza tray, and I probably won't look very hard as Guidas is NAILING IT. The tray comes with a Greek, a pepperoni, and a garlic bread style 'za. Order this if you're in the mood for something that can sit out for awhile and is an easy crowd pleaser. 2) Their sheet pizzas are just as good as their other size offerings, which is hard to come by! I've ordered sheets from other places in the neighborhood and they just aren't as good. The wings here are also phenom and the hot packs a serious punch. I always forget that they offer great sub options as well, and don't know why I don't walk over for lunch more frequently. Service at this location is fairly hot and miss, and I always feel like they are training new hires on a constant basis. Most of my phone orders take double the time as trainees have to continually check in with their trainer. This doesn't bug me at all but it does lead to inconsistent service. TL;DR - order the appetizer pizza tray and ENJOY! read more

This is for Empire Blvd. location: Pizza is quite good, but they mess up the order 50% of the time I've had delivery. By the time it arrives I'm too tired and hungry to complain. Next time I'll try to order by phone instead of online, maybe it'll make a difference. If not, it's worth the drive to Cams. Less convenient, but tastier and at least they always get it right. read more

Amazing pizza and bbq chicken salad is the best we ever had! So crispy chicken and a huge amount of chicken on the salad! Love the hot honey pizza read more

5 stars for the "Famous Schwartzkoff": "The best sub ever created!" Ham, chicken tenders, swiss, mozzarella, lettuce, onion, mayo, sweet & sour all melted on the roll. Sandwich was awesome when we ate it there freshly made. Though we got it once for delivery and way better when eaten there. This is bfs favorite sandwich that exists. Everything else 4 stars. We got wings (honey garlic buffalo), garlic knots, cheese slices and chicken bacon ranch slices. Pizza slices: come in 2s (I didn't know this and ordered WAY too much food for our family). Salad looked on point for a pizza restaurant and I almost debated ordering one but we had way too much food already. Get it w grilled chicken. Decent amount of seating inside ~10 small tables. Bathroom clean for a pizza restaurant. read more

See all

I ordered a white pizza here it was made wrong and the wrong size they made a red sauce pizza never apologizing for mix up and continued to laugh when I brought the wrong pie back to them one of the worst experiences ever had non professional I will never b coming to another guidas one on main st is run by young kids the sausage they use as a topping isn't even good it's sliced wow ...I am pretty irate from this bad experience I had to post this .complete joke ... read more

Absolutely EMBARRASSING. I used to work here when I was in high school. The quality has gone down but the prices have gone up. $17 for boneless wings? Get outta here with that. I would've been better off going down the road to a more reputable establishment. 0 stars if I could read more

We the people... are Guida people. I really like the enormous slices that are the size of your house served up by Guida. They are sort of like jumbo New York slices. They taste better than the DC equivalent, because that is the other city that I remember being famous for enormous slices other than Rochester. The best places to get slices in Rochester are not these jumbo slice places but places like Pizza Stop downtown. But nevertheless these are worth a try if you are hungry for pizza in this area. Pretty delicious if you ask me, and underrated. read more

Guida's Pizzeria - I read about this in the guidabook - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Solid spot for a slice or an entire pie. It is small and somewhere hot inside but they do offer indoor dining. They also have other options.

One of the best local pizza spots in upstate ny. If you're from Az, I'd compare it to barros. Yummy yummy

Oh man their subs are so good, they'll toast the roll and the ingredients are plentiful. I had the famous schwartzkoff which was all they cracked it up to be. read more

See all

Though the dough is fresh made and tastes good, the sauce is prepared canned and tastes it. The cheese has that slightly chewy rubbery texture. Calzone was overfilled with toppings all on the middle leaving a large portion of the dough on top raw. The dipping sauce was cold, calzone was uncut and was too raw in the middle to pickup and eat. Cutting it lead to ever further issues of eating due to poor topping distribution and quality. Large cheese pizza was properly cooked but again quality of topping ingredients is greatly lacking. Signs were up for masking to enter. Not one of the employees had a mask on. read more

Guida's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and cheese calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Great tasting food. A bit pricey but worth it. We have our family favorite items, and we prefer to get them from Guida's more so than anywhere else. So it's an occasional treat for us... read more

Was told 45 minutes. Waited way over an hour for pizza with car running. Will not come here again!

Had the meatball sub with green peppers and onions, provolone. The bread was toasted and the meatballs were pretty good. I liked the cooked onions and peppers in it. Don't usually do that but glad i did. What I didn't like was the red sauce. I was figuring on a seasoned and cooked tomato sauce. You know. tomatoes simmered and garlic oregano and basil in it. Maybe a little parmesan cheese thrown in. A mother sauce you can put on everything from pasta to calzones to meatball subs. No. It was right out of the can. cold. Tasted awful. Well really no taste at all. Would have been better off not putting it in it at all. Disappointed. You don't want to take the time to make a good sauce, shame on you. read more

Pizza, subs, twists, pastas .... Amazing. The portions are generous and service is great.

We ordered catering from Guida's. It was amazing!!! Chicken french, greens and beans, garlic knots, vodka blush pasta and salad. We are pretty picky and the food was delivered hot and delicious! We will be ordering again. One other note...if you like sauce pizza the appetizer tray is amazing. I always order half garlic and half red sauce. Just like my grandmother used to make. It has become a family party favorite! read more

Guida's helped me send pizza to my teammate who is currently working on the frontlines at a nearby hospital. The owner, Mike, was extremely helpful and understanding considering the specific guidelines the hospital gave regarding outside food. AMAZING PLACE. GIVE THEM YOUR BUSINESS! read more

Guida's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

The meatlovers pizza we ordered several weeks ago was terrible. Both myself and my husband got sick. They also goofed up or chicken wing order. I addressed this twice with two different managers and was met with opposition and they blamed it on the supposed "throw up" bug going around. That is the biggest excuse in the book and not one person that I know complained about any such thing. The second manager I spoke to was absolutely RUDE and unapologetic to any of our concerns. We will NEVER patronize this business again. I gave it one star and that is not even deserved in my humble opinion. You should also go to their website and read some of the horrendus reviews for yourself! They certainly do not care one iota about me or my business! read more

Their pizza has the perfect chew/tenderness. Wings were really really crispy. Delivery early by 10 minutes.

Game Day! Ordered Chili wings, Sicilian pizza ( my all time favorite), bread sticks and chef's salad. Everything was wonderful. The staff from phone to delivery people are terrific. Thanks for helping to make my pre game lunch a success! read more

This is a "Love/Hate" more like "disappointed" review. I've loved Guida's for over 20 years - but tonight I stopped in at 6:05pm and ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza to go. The person at the counter asked the cook to make sure they had it (as the counter staff always does). At 6:25 I asked the same counter staff if they had to make it as it was an unusually long wait for a slice to go. They told me "no" but didn't bother to check. At 6:31pm I walked out with my very expensive bottle of water (meaning I never got my pizza) as I had somewhere to be and at that point was now running late. While waiting someone came in to pick up an order that the staff couldn't find and they too left without anything. Maybe they were just having a very off night. read more

I used to buy pizza from this place, but after I read that Joseph D and husband not only got sick from eating the pizza, but we're extremely and impolitely scoffed at when they reported it to the managers, they'll not get my business nor recommendation anymore. When the managerial staff refuses to take responsibility for their quality control and people get sick from the food, it's time to get the health dept involved. I was in the restaurant business for many years, and it's a serious issue when the staff doesn't know any better than to serve rancid food! And it looks like they didn't care if anyone got sick! read more

Large slice pizza. I've had it twice due to a convenient location connecting to a grocery store, but not impressed. No one in the family loved it, and left overs were tossed. I will not return. read more

Mark and Lyn were amazing helping me coordinate a large catering order on very short notice. I've been feeding this group for 4 years and Guida's is by far the best we've ever had. They helped me estimate the right amount of food for 45 very hungry college baseball players and coaches, made great suggestions, and made everything so simple. (Even advised me I really didn't need a third tray of ziti but I ordered it "just in case" - they were right and I appreciate the honesty!). Everything they said about quantities, portion size, quality was exactly true. Everyone loved the food! Chicken parm, meatballs, ziti, green beans, garlic knots!!!! were all excellent! The garlic knots really are as good as they say! Everyone got plenty. Delivery was exactly on time. And delivered everything we ordered. (Sounds basic but I've had major issues with other restaurants)! Can't say enough good things about Guidas! read more

I miss living in walking distance from this place. Pizza is good, not thin and not super thick or doughy. When we get the wings we get their buffalo wing sauce, it's delicious. Hot sandwiches are unique and good here too. I have gotten the chicken finger ones and turkey ones in the past, never been disappointed. Lately I have used them for catering for work and home. The sub trays are good quality and don't skimp on the toppings. They also give you plenty of condiments, pickles and peppers/onions to put on your sub. The regular trays come with turkey, ham, tuna salad, roast beef and Italian assorted. The Italian is my favorite. I really like their sub trays because of the bread they use. Last time I was here I was 8 months pregnant so I splurged and bought a cookie too.... big cookie and I devoured it pretty quickly. Overall you can't go wrong with this place, everything is good. read more

Ordered for delivery. Got the food more than and hour and a half later. Food was cold. I got a steak sub and there was hardly any steak sauce on it and hardly anything else I asked for on it. Also ordered another sub and that was lacking in ham. Usually they are really good. Very dissatisfied with today's service read more

The last three times my friends and I have ordered take out the order has been messed up or the food is no good. I ordered wings last night. Some burnt. The wings were literally black. Don't know how that happens. I also only got 10 wings instead of 12. I ordered a burger last week, it was a hockey puck. Dry and not appetizing. Customer service is also no good. I know Friday's are busy. But I was told 35 min, and actually didn't get there until an hour after I called, order was still not ready. Guidas use to be good but definitely going downhill. Will not be returning for awhile. read more

I'm not sure why it has crap ratings. I love it here and the food is fabulous! I get the boss hog hot sub which is ham and cheese with a spicy mustard relish on a toasted roll. Side note: They have gluten free pizza crust if you're into that! read more

Guida's Pizzeria - Boss Hog. My favorite. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

This pizza ordered today was phenomenal!!! Hot and perfect dough for sure. The chicken wings crispy ordered were wonderful, buffalo mild too. read more

Guida's Pizzeria - Hot and phenomenal X-lg pizza w wings buff mild . Excellent tasting, clean atmosphere, great customer service, they go above and beyond!! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Good calzone, nice and big, crispy dough. Little greasy but that's to be expected with multi-cheese with pepperoni and sausage. Wings are solid. The medium has a good heat to sweet ratio. The Caesar salad was fresh and tasty. I would hit this spot again. They have TVs and have a good sub selection. read more

See all