My wife and I had appointments out and on the way home we decided to stop at the Pleasantville Diner for lunch. We've been to the diner several times and have always had a pleasant (no pun intended) experience. Today was no exception. I had Chicken Noodle Soup and a half a Chicken Salad Sandwich. Let's start with the soup. Loads of chicken, loads of noodles and enough carrots and celery. Broth was rich and flavorful. The half sandwich of chicken salad could not have been better. The best chicken salad I have had in a very long time plenty of finely diced chicken and celery and real mayonnaise. Came with a side of fries and pickle and coleslaw. We were seated immediately and our waiter was attentive but not hovering. We ordered and it took slightly longer than usual for our order to arrive, but the food quality made up for it. Parking is not a problem as there is a lot attached to the diner. The decor is what you would expect from a diner and the restaurant is exceptionally clean. We were just here for breakfast earlier in the week so we obviously like the place. read more

Seriously delicious food that arrived promptly at a NY price. Super clean and good service. They have sooo many choices. read more

See all

Starting with the owner who takes pride in the restaurant, the staff is warm and friendly to patrons walking in, the food is very good and the milkshakes are like the ones you had as a child. read more

My friend and I came here for brunch on a Saturday morning around 11am. I had two eggs over easy with multigrain toast and fruit (subbed for has browns). It was okay, a bit over-priced. The waitresses were nice and service was good, but not a stellar diner in my opinion. read more

Pleasantville Diner - Two eggs any style (over easy) with fruit instead of hashbrowns - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

See all

This diner was great! I'll start off with the good things and end with the not so good things. Number one, the burger was cooked perfectly! It was crisp on the edges and the inside was perfect! And also the bun was toasted perfectly!!! Number 2, the fries were crisp and the perfect texture! The edges were crisp and crunchy which means if you know me...count me in!!! Number 3, the service was pretty nice they were very kind! But we didn't get checked on as much. Number 4, The ambiance of the place was very nice and very fancy. If you like fancy and beautiful stuff this is the place for you! Number 5, free parking!!! So after all the good stuff there's 2 things that happened... Number 1, the food was too over priced the bigger the more expensive... But we did get a lot of food! Number 2, there was these kids behind us telling they were all about 17-18-19 years old. They were acting younger tho. If your looking for a fancy, tasty, diner the Pleasantville Diner is the perfect place!!! read more

Pleasantville Diner - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

See all

Food and service both excellent! Recommend eggs, sandwiches, desserts. Coffee could use an upgrade, the only negative.

Owner and staff are nice and friendly! I was scared to wait in the train station late at night so I walked over to the diner to wait here. The diner was about to close but the owner said no problem and welcomed me to wait here. They quickly got me my tea and pie as well within seconds. Thank you!! read more

Pleasantville Diner - Cherry Pie and Tea - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

One of the better diners in Westchester. Friendly, fast service. Never disappoints. Ample parking too

JC from Westchester ; Returned to this diner after we heard it had a new owner and that things were much better, My wife had the brown rice bowl with grilled chicken,she said it was good but a bit pricey at 28.00 dollars and not that much food, if you get a grilled chicken salad is 18. Dollars how much can brown rice cost I had the hamburger(Blackjack) and it was quite good, cooked well My daughter had chicken finger and they were actually over fried But burger was really good, staff was very attentive and very nice, wish them luck read more

See all

Dined there this morning for the first time and the food was amazing. Avocado toast with fresh made guacamole and arugula salad was absolutely delicious. Staff were welcoming, friendly and service was impeccable. I look forward to my next visit. read more

Very disappointed for the second time. Wait time for food was long and when it arrived two of our three meals needed to be sent back. My grandson ordered a grilled cheese with avocado and received grilled cheese with mushroom instead. My husband ordered a pastrami on rye and it came on whole wheat that couldn't be held because it was so soft and crumbly. The waiter brought it back and it was the same bread only blackened and it still disintegrated when you tried to pick it up. I received a wrap that had seemed old and I couldn't find the cheese it was supposed to come with. Terrible experience for the second time! There will not be a third!! read more

It was after our flight into Westchester that we wanted to have a nice diner breakfast and the Pleasantville diner seem to check the boxes. Easy to get to, attractive exterior, inside is spotlessly clean, and the service is extremely efficient. Food was relatively tasteless, however. read more

As I'm always down in Pleasantville and always on the hunt for a new go-to diner, this place gets a quick 5-stars! I was there on Sunday -- slammin' busy at 2 p.m! I took a seat at the counter despite NEVER doing that, I just wanted to eat. Everyone that walked by asked if I needed anything, refilled my coffee, brought me condiments, etc. Very friendly family and staff! Truthfully, I never looked at the menu as I knew what I wanted: Leo omelette (lox & onions) w/ potatoes and whole wheat toast -- best potatoes in a long time too, actually hot for a change! Great! When I got my check, I was a little thrown off until I looked more carefully. I paid $3.99 for a coffee (which is high) and another $3.79 for a muffin (also high). Minus those 2-overpriced items (IMO), everything was first rate. Will definitely return very shortly and see if the return visit holds up! read more

I came here on a Saturday at noon. The service here was very prompt and attentive. I ordered the gyro which was quite flavorful. My son ordered Oreo pancakes which was really well done. Everyone here was gracious. The price was a bit higher than most diners nearby, given the level of service and commitment by the staff it was worth every penny. The new owner has maintained a high quality here. The inside feels like a traditional diner. read more

Pleasantville Diner - Menu - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

My husband and i hadn't been back to Pleasantville Diner since before the pandemic. We had a not so great experience and just had figured the new owners (at the time) were not keeping it at the level it had once been. Well I recently heard it had changed owners again and we decided to give it another try. The interior as of yet has not changed much. Some art on the walls (in the back) had changed but that's about it. It looks like they are waiting for some new tables and chairs. The menu has been downsized from what was a traditional diner sized menu. It had a lot of great options. My husband ordered the Turkey BLT Panini and I ordered a Greek omelet. His entree presented well, as did my omelet. The Turkey looked like it was cut off freshly roasted Turkey breast! It was a generous portion. The fries were delicious as well. My Greek omelet was well prepared and tasted delicious. I also enjoyed the home fries! The service was great, very attentive! At the end of our meal the owner brought over two desserts, on the house, for us to try at home! What a wonderful surprise! Looking forward to enjoying them tomorrow with our family! Our only issue was the prices are a bit high for a diner, but that seems to be the case in most diners in the area. We will be back. read more

See all

Classic diner! Good service and good food. Turkey Club was huge and burger/fries were great.

There are great surprises and food tastes so good the waters are so nice and sweet I would recommend for kids the chicken fingers and fries

The food was good and I ordered a burger and they didn't remove the tomatoes but I just removed them. There was hair in my fries so I asked for a new plate but they just ignored me. The service wasn't that good. When we were leaving, I ordered a sprite to go. It took 30 freaking MINUTES to get it! I had to remind them and then they finally gave it to me and I forgot to mention the atmosphere. There was spit and crumbs from the other family. They didn't even bother to clean the table. They kept playing reruns on the tv and no kids content so it was a major letdown. Go to Mount Kisco diner instead, even though it's expensive. Wouldn't really recommend Pleasantville Diner. read more

I went back last week after being disappointed under the old ownership. I had a cheeseburger, medium rare with French fries and it was perfectly juicy and delicious. The service was great. I usually skip dessert but the manager insisted I try the carrot cake on him. I was not disappointed. I was so busy talking to the waiter, the server and the manager that my wife gave a dirty look for not taking to her. Finally a local diner with good food, good people and attentive staff. Oh, and my wife had a delicious, moist, fresh turkey sandwich that she let me try because she still loves me after 30 years. read more

Been here multiple times and have always had a great experience. Food is well prepared and delicious and the staff is friendly and attentive. Highly recommend. read more

Diners aren't usually my first choice, but a friend and I went here before seeing a movie at the Burns Film Center and I have to say it's probably the most pleasant (pun intended) diner experience I have had. The atmosphere is mid-century retro and extremely clean (I've been to some diners in the past that left much to be desired in the realm cleanliness--and it's a wonder I took chances eating there). I had the California Wrap and, for only $1.50 more, substituted sweet potato fries. The wrap was pressed like a panini and stuffed to the max with chunks of chicken, lettuce, tomato, bacon and some avocado. The wrap was huge--each half was enough for one meal--and came with cole slaw and a dill pickle wedge. The sweet potato fries were ok. A bit mushy. I like them a little crispier than served. My friend had the buffalo chicken salad and enjoyed it. The service is courteous. We did wait a bit for our food. If we hadn't been on our way to see a film, I don't think I would have minded the pacing...you need it for the portions they give you here! If Guy Frieri makes a stop here, do let me know! read more

My husband and I had dinner at the Pleasantville Diner this past Saturday night after seeing a movie at the Jacob Burns. It was our first time, and we were not disappointed. We loved the great diner vibe, the service was excellent and friendly, and our meal was delicious. We started with the French Onion Soup and then each had different salads. Both were fresh, tasty, and large enough portions that we brought some home. We will definitely be back again so we can try the burgers and breakfast foods! read more

Great food, great service. Very enjoyable. The diner is very clean. I sat at the counter, and the staff was very friendly. I ordered their Very Berry Turkey Burger. Most Turkey burgers can be dry...this was not dry at all...I required several napkins. Served with fresh Cole slaw and pickle. It had a side of sweet potato fries that were crispy and had a hint of cinnamon.. it went great with my coffee. Before I left, they sent me out the door with a complimentary slice of delicious chocolate cake....one of the best diner experiences I've had in a long time. I can't wait to go back. read more

Today for breakfast was unpleasant with our server "Anna" who was rude and talking about us because we changed tables to where it was cooler. She never once came to use to ask us if we wanted more coffee. I had to get it from another waitress. She appeared to have an attitude and that is not something you want to deal with when being served. read more

Food was excellent. Very fresh. Sweet potato fries and panini really good. Service was great.

NEVER COME HERE!!! They employ Avalon Towing, which is a complete SCAM! I sat and ate inside the diner, then walked around the farmers market after my meal. When I came back, there was a boot on my car, and they demanded I pay $70 to remove it! I explained that I was a paying customer who had just eaten here and only walked around for 10 minutes. They claimed, "You walked around and left your car." Absolutely terrible! I can't believe the diner employs such awful companies. Never coming back! This happened today at 11:00am terrible read more

I had a tasty Grilled Cheese (and added Bacon) for an afternoon snack. The staff was helpful and I would definitely come back when I'm in Pleasantville again. read more

Pleasantville Diner - Grilled Cheese Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

I loved the diner ambiance here! Felt like an old school diner but with an elevated clean interior. I got a breakfast burrito, it was yummy! Also they were very accommodating with me taking a meeting here. Wifi worked very well. read more

Pleasantville Diner - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

New owners made all the difference. I now give it five stars Great service; great menu. I bring all my friends and family there You can't go wrong And they have parking !!!!!!yippee read more

Went in for a quick after work dinner. This place is so hectic. We were seated. The room was freezing. There was a space heater. The table was not set up. Just one napkin wrapped silverware packet. The Waite took our order rushed us. I could not complete my order. He just moved on to my husband. Still. No set up on the table. No water. Nothing. We tell the very rushed and frantic hostess, maybe manager or owner (not sure) how cold it is. She moves a space heater from another couple. Still.... No water no set up. I told her I could not eat like this... rushed, with my coat on. I cancelled our order. This woman gave me such a shocked look. Almost a look like I was crazy. We walked out. The atmosphere is dank, cheaply put together and looks dirty. The place needs a complete overhaul in esthetics and staff. Not a place for families. Not homey. Not welcoming. read more

As someone born and raised in New Jersey, I often find myself defensive of our local cuisine: we claim our bagels are the best, Wawa beats Sheetz, and shed blood over Taylor Ham vs Porkroll debates. But perhaps the most highly cherished prize of our state is the authentic experience of a bonafide all American diner. The Pleasantville Diner delivers this experience in spades. With heaping portions, rich flavor, and the most welcoming and accommodating host I've ever seen (shout out to Charlie!), the Pleasantville Diner inspired me to make a yelp account just to post this review. read more

First time here. As noted, new owners. Stopped for a bite at after a film at Jacob Burns. It was a lovely experience. Excellent service, food was great and nicely presented. Will definitely be back. The lighting is warm and the space well taken care of. read more

Pleasantville Diner - Grilled cheese w/tomato and French Fries - Diners Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Pleasant experience, friendly service, good diner food. Very good under the new management.

I love this diner! Service was quick and friendly. Food was delicious and the portions were large. Classic diner experience.

Now that the diner has been under new management for a few months, it's amazing. Whether we eat there, or take out, the food is always top notch and delicious. Make sure you don't read any reviews prior to February of this year. It's a totally different diner and owner, Ari, is always on hand making sure everyone is happy. read more

This diner needs to be put on the map for the best customer service. I ordered a gyro came with French fries and a large order of Greek salad! Good so far... however, there was something that tasted sour and it was the lettuce - thought it was wilted so I stopped eating it as it didn't match the parts that were delicious( pita bread was fresh and the meat). I called the diner and spoke to the lady manager and explained my experience. She was humbly so apologetic and ask if she can make it up to me. Of course I was still hungry so I said okay. She said I will personally deliver another order. The diner is 15 minutes away however she showed up with a brand new order and a large piece of carrot cake. Why I write this is because no restaurant has ever treated me with such respect and dignity. This is what customer service is all about- your customers! Btw! The gyro plate which was great until certain bites was made super fresh and the taste was delicious as I was expecting to be the first time. To my surprise she threw in a carrot cake ; the carrot cake was moist with the perfect amount of sweetness. Overall, I want to make this post shouting out the Manager(female)! She really serves their customer to satisfaction! Restaurant managers should learn from this lady! I have shared my experience with my peers and they were in awe and stated this establishment has my business! Thank you lady manager-You are an example of greatness!!!! read more

Under new management. Try the cheesecake and the cookies! Too die for! Menu is soooo much better! I had the mushroom Swiss burger- very good! Such nice people! Best of luck to you all! We will be back!!! read more

I've been here before and after new ownership took over and I can't say there was a major difference. It's not the biggest space so it can get packed in there fast. The servers were doing the best they could. The food was good but nothing memorable. There is another diner in Thornwood but if you're in Pleasantville looking for a diner experience, give this place a shot. 6.5/10 read more

The good: food was very good with generous portions. Nice atmosphere. Crowded, alive. Nice service. The bad: holy moly is it expensive. Chicken quesadilla 20 dollars, burger and fries 17 dollars, grilled cheese with no fries 10 dollars, two eggs 10 bucks. It's good but i am not sure i can justify the prices. A once a while thing with fam but not quick takeout on weekday. read more

Food and service were very good but the prices are higher than diners in a close proximity. They also charge $4.25 for green tea which is pretty outrageous. read more