THIS REVIEW IS FOR THOSE GODDAMN CINNAMON ROLLS If those Cinnamon Toast Crunch cartoons had some sluttiness between their legs, it would be these anomalous rolls. Flaky goodness smothered in cinnamon gravy and torturous, dripping sugary goop. I hope this review inspires the danger of these buns within you. Don't lock us in a room with these guys... I fear they will get DEVOURED!!!! read more

This $hit sucks. Worst pizza i have ever put in my mouth. I wouldn't feed this to an alley rat with rabies. This is seriously bad do not eat pizza unless you want flavorless, dry, boring pizza. read more

Um, it's pizza. Is there anything else you have to know? Maybe there's a few things. Like whether it's good or not. That depends on how many bars you've been to. It's no Avalanche. That pizza is pretty good no matter the state of your mind. This pizza is very average. It seems to be a small regional chain. The menu also has subs. A small pizza is about $10, which is still too much. This is not gourmet level pizza. They have delivery. It's recommended over eating inside. The place is pretty filthy and don't you even think of using the bathrooms in there. read more

Plus 1 Pizza - Vegetable Sub - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Ohio

Always like their pizza. Been a long time customer from day 1 when they came to Athens Ohio. I've had issues with them in the past. I used to get senior discount. Now they won't do it anymore, plus they won't give me rewards anymore. So I do my business elsewhere where I'm treated better. No problem with their food, but it seems they are catering to students and not the citizens of Athens. U lost my business because of things listed above. read more

I ordered the crispy thin crust. This is not a thin crust. It is more than a quarter inch thick. It is not crispy. The pizza tastes fine. But don't call it a thin crust. read more

Plus 1 Pizza - pepperoni, sausage, and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Ohio

See all

Great pies! I don't have to talk to Danny about this! Do I get a discount? We're getting married June 11th, Hooray!

pizza was great, got devoured...but not what i ordered.My roommates and i did the 3 medium 2 topping pizzas for 20$ deal and each customized our own. I ordered a pepperoni pizza with a ranch drizzle and fresh basil i received neither of these. Their version of fresh basil was what seemed to be dried italian seasoning flakes from a canister. Their version of ranch drizzle, or so i was told, is apparently cooked under the cheese and resulted in no flavor of ranch. (crazy because my roommates pesto drizzle was on top?) Am i crazy to have expected a beautiful swirl of cold ranch on my pizza Maybe a menu update to actually reflect the ingredients used? The man behind the counter was arrogant and treated me as though i was incompetent when I returned and pointed out the issue. There was no visible ranch or basil on my pizza. He laughed as i walked out the door...embarrassing. read more

Plus 1 Pizza - Pepperoni pizza "with ranch drizzle and fresh basil" - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Ohio

WOW. 3 pizzas fast delivery. Large pepperoni & sausage thin crust, red sauce, Square cut. Fantastic. Large Alfredo sauce, feta, mushroom, jalapeño, onion, with garlic drizzle with all 3 crust toppers, thin crust, square cut, almost converted to white sauce with this one, yummy. 3rd pizza large regular crust regular pie cut, with all 3 crust toppings & broccoli, chicken, meatballs, red sauce..great. Will do this pizza place every time now that we've tried it. read more

We have always eaten some of the best pizza at Plus 1 Athens. From the strangely irresistible Voodoo to the perfectly executed Pepperoni Feast, we've never been disappointed. We haven't met a pizza at Plus 1 we haven't loved! The staff is always friendly and the dining room and restrooms clean. If you sign up for their newsletter they'll email you coupons fairly regularly. A note: we don't live in Athens so we are strictly carry-out folks. I can't speak to their delivery services. read more

Our first trip to this place was great. I read reviews on Google and all were positive except one but there's always one lol. We ordered breadsticks and a deluxe pizza. The breadsticks came out in under 10 minutes and were hot and, had we known how good, we would have ordered the 8 count so it's good we didn't know. The deluxe pizza arrived not long after we finished breadsticks so it was perfectly timed and perfectly hot! Our server was also the pizza preparer and was prompt and courteous and eager for us to like his pizza. We loved it! I would definitely eat here again! We went on a Thursday night and no crowd. read more

Plus 1 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Ohio

See all

Yikes. An hour and fifteen minute wait for luke warm pizza drowned in an excess of ricotta? Didn't seem worth the $12.49 pricetag for a small. read more

Great pizza !! 10x better than your corporate or franchise pizza !!! Spaghetti with added mozzarella is much better than you would think -- good spaghetti !!! read more

THIS PIZZA IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!! The service is great for delivery too! I would suggest this over the other pizza places in the area. I am so over dealing with this large chains that have absolutely no customer service what so ever! There are a couple more locations for Plus 1 Pizza that I am definitely going to give a try. Its great to deal with a local place that actually cares about the people that they serve! read more

HARD 4..plus one..this pizza is the bees knees I'm a person who takes good tasting food rather seriously which is why I gave plus one 4s Ive had some pizza in the past that has literally made me feel like life has meaning and though plus one isn't quite on that level they have excellent deals and are my go to spot in Athens..friendly workers..good ranch..toasty subs..and great paired w buds..give plus one a chance if you haven't yet read more

This is by far our favorite pizza place here. Their veggies are always fresh and their customer service is spectacular! I love using the app to order because you can customize your pizza the exact way you want it and they always get our order right! We will always get our pizza from Plus 1 Pizza!! read more

One of thee best chicken wings and pizza by far for the 3 years I have been ordereding i give a 2 thumbs up on the food and the staff. You all are number 1. read more

They are at least open for inside dining late at night.Mens bathroom was filthy and had no tp or paper towels.Price was very expensive and quality was poor.crust was burned,toppings were sparse.also ordered chocolate cookie,cinnamon bread,both were mediocre,chicken wings as others have mentioned were very tiny for the price.This was our second visit and both times were disappointed.most likely will never return.price was biggest issue spent nearly 50 dollars for mediocre food. read more

I read the reviews here and decided to give it a try. I am staying in a hotel and they had just what I wanted. I have had delivery to hotel coast to coast and I have to say Plus 1 Pizza-Athens is the only one I've given five stars to for a delivery in this region. I read the one bad review and I'm thinking that person needs to have their taste buds examined! My delivery was perfect. It was hot, quick, delivery guy was friendly and smiling and my order was complete! I will definitely recommend them to any co-workers in this area and to all my Yelpers! Deliciousness!!!!!! read more

The pizza itself is on par with Donato's, Dominos, or Pizza Hut-i.e. nothing special at all. The prices are on par with Avalanche, which makes me think Plus One had no idea what they were doing when they opened in Athens. You can get better pizza for the same price, or similar pizza for less. read more

I called to find out if they had a thin-crust. They said they did. I am going to use a benchmark here that is so low that most pizza lovers will laugh at me. Benchmark: Domino's Thin-Crust pep+cheese, extra pep. At Plus 1, the crust is not a thin crust. It is a medium crust, twice as thick. Both the crust and the sauce is extra-sweet, which is a huge no-no. Smacks of lots of corn-syrup. The xtra pep???? Half of reg.pep. The taste? Apart from sweet (re: the corn syrup) --- BLAH. $12.45 vs Dominos (I know, laugh at me, but for GOD"S SAKE, CAN SOMEONE AROUND HERE MAKE AN HONEST THIN-CRUST????) Yeah. The Domino's, which is bigger, costs $7.99 Oh GOD, when is someone around here going to make an honest-to-goodness good thin-crust like Rubino's in Cbus???? Does anyone near Athens even know what a thin-crust pizza is supposed to be???? Just shoot me. read more

The pizza was just alright. The taste reminded me of a fresher verion of a frozen pizza. I went with the robust sauce, not horrible just alright. I also had the chesse bread. Basically their pizza minus the sauce. There on line ordering didn't really work well on my phone, but I was eventually able to order. The price is comparable to some other places in town and delivery time was good. Probably won't order again. There are better options in Athens. read more

Being a local chain restaurant, have the capability to compete against Papa John's and Dominos. Flavor and taste, delivery time are all within standard. read more

There voodoo pizza is a amazing best pizza I've ever tasted. But a little on the expensive side if you do not have coupons

Athens has loads of mediocre pizza places and this one is an addition to the list. My boyfriend got a large and I got a medium. His seemed to be a better made pizza then mine but neither was great and their inconsistencies suggest a quality control problem. Plus One advertises their quality ingredients but this is just your average assembly line pizza that tastes like the cardboard they package it in. I'm so sick of bad pizza in Athens. I was hoping this would be different but alas Athens remains a hidden gold mine for anyone that wants to come into town and open an authentic pizzeria. read more

Goodfellas is fantastic and has been in my years as an undergrad. Recently, however, one worker would refuse my request for crust pieces and having a box to walk a long distance home. Avoid this worker, whose name starts with an A, at all costs! I have LOVED Goodfellas the past few years and was VERY disappointed with this negligent worker. read more

Best pizza in Athens. Always on time, high quality food, fresh ingredients, everything is always right on my order. Price is ABSOLUTELY worth it. Great service, what more can I say. Definitely the best pizza establishment in the town. read more

Food is okay, but there's better pizza in Athens. Price is pretty high for what you get. Was disappointed by the tobasco sticks, they seem to be frozen and made by another company (but still cost $5). Not sure if I'd return, but they do deliver until early morning. read more

The food is great-I will give them that. The punctuality of the delivery is where the problem is. I called in a 9 person order at 10:30 telling them that I needed it before noon. We have lunch from 12-12:20. I called at noon when I still did not have it and at 12:15 again. At 12:18 they showed up. There is no "flex time" in our lunch schedule so the employees may have gotten one bit of their order before they had to go back out on the floor. I realize they are busy, but there was a reason I called so early. Was not offered even an apology. Just kept saying "well, we are trying". Very disappointed read more

I will never eat here again. My husband and I had pizza and 8 piece wings delivered, and the wings were so overcooked that it barely left the bone and the wings were not big enough to call it an 8 piece meal, the pizza was dry and bland. Never again. read more

Wow. What an experience. Plus one pizza really knocked this one out of the park. Every bite of pizza was a new orgasmic adventure. My pizza came out of the hot and steamy I immediately popped a chub. The service was quick but I came quicker. Thank you plus one pizza. read more

Plus One is without a doubt my favorite pizza place in Athens! There are tons of different options; not only on food choice, but also toppings and sauces. The pizzas are cut accurately, cooked to perfection, and always look picture perfect. The service is very great as well, the workers seem to work very hard and try their best to make every customer 100% satisfied. The manager also seems to be very caring about his business. Would recommend this place to anyone looking for great food! The breadsticks can't be beat! read more

I have been eating this pizza for over a year and not one order has taken longer than the estimated time, has always been made correct, and the workers are always kind. The Deep Dish is my regular order but all their pizza is delicious. Their veggies taste fresh and the cheese melts just right! I would recommend it every time. read more

It's a mom-and-pop chain, with a fresh, crisp crust and a sweet tomato sauce. I think it's better than the commercial chains and I highly recommend the ranch-flavored crust. It's pricey, but that's the reality of the food industry. The trademark Voodoo pizza is delicious as long as you ask them to NOT include the BBQ sauce. Beware that the owner will talk your leg off if you let him. Ask them for a mozzarella and cheddar cheese mix for a taste kick. read more

My son and I have eaten here and between us have eaten at every pizza place in town. This is our favorite. Fresh ingredients, excellent sauces (we like the red sauce and the Alfredo) and good deals to boot (check the specials). Plus the owner is on-site and very involved. read more

DP Dough by far has the best public bathroom in all of Athens. After school when I'm homeless (and I WILL be homeless), I can't think of a better place to roll out my sleeping bag for the night. 10 stars. read more

Love plus one pizza. They get our order right, timely and the staff is awesome. One time, our order want right, but i emailed the owner (or manager), and they immediately made it right. Definitely keeps us coming back. read more

Definitely one of the best pizza places for miles! I find that the pizza sauce is too sweet at other chains in Athens, but this one actually tastes like pizza sauce :) Delivery is so good and the drivers are all kind. Pizza is done quick and the dough is so fresh! LOVE the cheesy bread, ask them to put garlic sauce on it, you won't be sorry. Also, LOVE the cinnamon sticks. Overall, quick delivery and great taste! read more