Friendly employees, tasty food, great environment! My husband, dog and I frequent here quite often. We have always had very nice employees who put up with how much extra mayo I request (I even prefer them to put it on the bread before it goes through the oven). When we first visited this Potbelly it felt like 100 degrees outside and in our apartment. We wanted to eat somewhere cool, so we picked this place which is across from our home. I was very nervous about bringing my dog in because I wasn't sure of their policy. We were so hot, though, and I didn't want to leave him in the boiling house, so I brought him in and hoped for the best. They were very nice and even gave him treats! I've never been asked to leave him outside - which is why I come here so often! Their milkshakes and cookies are both super yummy along with their sandwiches. Plus I love their cute decor and friendly atmosphere! I'm going to keep coming here until I get my own "potbelly" ;) read more

Very, very tasty sandwiches. I always try the meatball sub whenever I try a new sub place and this one has the best meatball sub I've ever had. The sauce was tasty, bread was toasty, and not too much cheese with just the right amount of seasoning. My only complaint about the sub? Not enough marinara. Not bad enough to ding a star though. The place is clean and friendly, had lots of drink selections, had live music when I was there during Sat lunch. read more

Pretty good sandwiches made here by a cheerful looking bunch. Close to home so we often get takeaway from here. I am not a big fan of sandwiches, but wifey loves it more. I like the fact that they do the sandwiches just the way you want them. Pretty healthy and filling! read more

Love the place. Their sandwiches are really good. The staff are very polite and friendly. My personal favorite is their chicken salad sandwich. Yet to try their other sandwiches and stuff on their menu. And I would suggest getting their app on the appstore or playstore because once you enroll in their app you can get a free sandwich for free. You can also earn rewards and points on each purchase. read more

Tried the Skinny TKY as it was Weight Watchers friendly. Very good with the multi grain bread. Hot peppers are definitely Hot.

We LOVE this place! I enjoyed their delicious fare & fun atmosphere for the first time in Plano Texas. Not only clean, friendly & efficient... of course they have GREAT tasting food! We're so lucky to have this place in Redmond :) Try it! The prices are great too :) Anne E. read more

The T-rex is probably the best sandwich I've ever eaten. It's the pizza sandwhich with roast beef and bacon on it. Sounds a little wierd but its the best. And when you get with an orea shake you can't go wrong! They have a wide variety of soups and salads that look good and fairly healthy that I'm going to try next time. Also the wall art and pictures are pretty unique. read more

In case anyone wasn't aware. I like sandwiches. Basically, any sort of meat cheese combo stuffed into some sort of carbs is ok by me. When I heard about Potbelly, I figured it was something along the lines of Jimmy Johns, which it is, but the sandwiches are toasted. I was really quite impressed. I had the Wreck which had turkey, salami and roast beef with cheese. You get to choose your toppings, which is great, so I don't have to yell at people to tell them no tomatoes or pickles. All the sandwiches are one size, and run about $5. They are perfect for lunch, but probably a little small for dinner, unless you're getting a soup or chips with it too(I did not). For a quick meal though, I would definitely come here again. They are popping up all over the Seattle area, so I am sure you will all get your chance! read more

I've been a frequent visitor of the Potbelly Sandwich shop in downtown Bellevue and just happened to be in the area around lunchtime for the grand-opening of this location. The sandwiches are just as tasty at this place, and there's plenty of parking and seats. If you've never been, I'd recommend getting the Italian on multi-grain bread. They also have hot peppers which are very yummy and add a bit of kick and spice to the sandwich. If you are super hungry, they have really good chili (although a bit on the expensive side - but hey, I don't expect good food to be cheap.....it would just be nice). Bottom line, this place's sandwiches are wayyy better than Subway or Quiznos and for about $5 each - it's a 5 star sandwich shop. :D fair warning: can be addictive..... read more

I've really liked the other Potbelly Sandwich Shops I've visited but this one is off. The sandwiches are always dried out. I'm not sure what they're doing but they're off enough that I probably won't eat at any of their shops for a while. I ate at this one about five times because I was working nearby and it kind of ruined it for me. read more

Delicious but overpriced. I got a tuna salad sandwich. It was tiny and thin - the size of a Subway 6-inch with nothing on it. Richy-riches here in Redmond say it's a cheap place to eat. It might be under 10 bucks but it's not a great value at all. read more

Potbelly delivery always comes in a reasonable amount of time (before the bread gets soggy) and who can say no to a great sandwich?

O.K I'm a bit on the lazy side right now so lemme just say one thing. I agree with any of the 4/5 star votes. I disagree with any of the 1/2/3 star votes. 'Nuff said. read more

Cute little shop! First time for me at this location and I was amply satisfied. The staff are surprisingly very friendly. My friend ordered a meatball sandwich and they were low on meatballs so they made some to order. They have fresh shakes and smoothies and oddly enough they have cream soda! The place is very clean and inviting as well. Definitely worth trying a solid sandwich! From what I understand they only have two types of bread and they're a tad bit pricey for the sizes but I will go again. read more

My Sandwich was yummy and the perfect size, overall it is nothing to write home about. It's a tasty sandwich what more can you ask for. The milkshake (Strawberry/Banana) was delicious and I love finding bits of fruit in my shake. What stood out was their service. I had asked if they could heat up the meat I had chosen so it was steaming, and they were more than accommodating. This is a big perk for women who are pregnant and crave deli sandwich as most literature tells us not to consume cold cut/deli meat unless it is steaming. I'll probably be back to try The Wreck because it sounded good, but I wanted to started with something small on the first go. read more

Potbelly has really good toasted sandwiches. The atmosphere is really laid back and relaxing. The Redmond staff is always in good spirits and friendly. They also have the best shakes and smoothies around, absolutely love em. read more

Okay, you know when you go to Subway and you might leave a tip? I wish I COULD have left a tip- the Italian sandwich was AWESOME, DELICIOUS, and with so much flavor! The service was friendly, like being with good friends- check it out when you get a chance! read more

I'm very happy with the food, staff and the service. I have been eating here regularly for the past year, as often as 4 times a month. My orders are consistently simple: Meatball with extra sauce or Italian, but they've never messed them up. There are a couple of people who are exceptional with dealing with customers and at handling an extraordinary number of tasks, but they manage to push through a significant number of sandwiches, soups, salads, drinks, desserts, etc., in a limited amount of time. read more

Awful, I'ts actually worse than going to Quiznos or Subway. I really expected to have an awesome sandwich but I guess I paid more for the hipster vibe. I had the Roast beef and provolone....it was more like a lettuce sandwich. read more

Today I had my first and last experience at Potbelly Sandwich Shop. The only positive: the sandwich was decently assembled. Everything else was disappointing: the "extra" onion/lettuce/tomato on the sandwich were almost non-existent; the mayo on the side was contaminated with other ingredients; the hot peppers on the side were badly oily and mixed or contaminated with other ingredients; the cheese on the sandwich is undetectable and the meat is barely noticeable; the soup was run of the mill, bland except for salt and watery; the prices are a joke for the quality level and portion size; the bacon was rubbery and cold; the entire menu of this shop for my gluten and milk protein (casein) free diet without giving up ingredients they won't replace with cheaper alternatives without charging me extra is one thing - the vegetable soup. The topper for me was that when I wanted to substitute mushrooms instead of blue cheese (and surely the blue cheese costs more) on a salad I was told they won't do that and the mushrooms would cost extra. I skipped getting anything for myself and I won't be going back. Edit: After talking with the regional manager I was encouraged enough that I went back to the Redmond Potbelly. Despite the regional manager's assurances they still insisted on charging me to replace the blue cheese with mushrooms. Worse yet I found that my salad was contaminated with pieces of blue cheese despite asking to not have it on there. My wife's sandwich got feta in it through some similar cross-contamination of ingredients. When I contacted the regional manager about this upsetting experience his response was basically "Thanks for the feedback, I'll keep coaching them." So my final conclusion about them is: the service, quality, selection, attitude and prices add up to failure all the way around. Edit2: I went back a last couple of times mainly because they have more to offer my wife than they do me. By getting the manager first, clearly expressing my allergies and being very attentive I was able to get some plain salads with some meat. My wife was still not terribly thrilled with her sandwiches and I don't like to work that hard for a very plain salad. We stopped going back. read more

I went to the store and didn't know what I wanted. Four times I have done this and every time Mary has made my sandwich. Every time it ha been something different and every time it has been great. Not just okay, but great. She and the rest I'd the staff have been so friendly especially considering that I didn't know what i wanted. Clean restaurant, friendly staff, awesome product, A plus. read more

Potbelly is potbelly, excellent in its own way. We always get veggie sandwiches and soups. Sandwich is very delicious. The broccoli cheddar and spicy (something - can't recollect) soup are very tasty. For us this is way better option than Subway. Staff in this place is nice and warm. Surely going back. read more

Awesome sandwiches! Awesome price! If your looking for a tasty grinder and are on a time crunch or budget then this is the place to go! The wreck would have to be my favorite and is never a let down. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Thank you Potbelly for a new worthwhile lunch spot in Redmond! read more

2-1-13. Here goes. Read the web menu, was really excited to try potbelly. But which one? Let's try Redmond I sez. I had the Wreck, Miss Lorilei had the Italian, No Biggs here, 5¢ extra for vegs & $1. for mayo? Paper thin bacon. The milkshakes were tasty but not thick. The berry smothie was really good. The little cookies on the straws were really cute. The website or the takeout menus dont show prices. Overall tasty but not $19.00+ for two sands & drinks tasty. Try Red Rock Subs in Everett, or Deli-Cut Subs in Seattle for a great comparison experiance. Nuf said, we'll try another P/B location next time. read more

I don't know what happened. I used to love these guys. Maybe they hired new people and they don't know what they're doing. My husband had to open both our sandwiches to figure out which was which. Apparently they can't invest in a marker to mark which sandwich is which, because having to completely unwrap all the sandwiches is unacceptable. Also, they either didn't give me the strawberry shake I asked for, which means they don't know how to listen, or their strawberry shake is disgusting and tastes like a not fresh mixed berry, which is ALSO a shake they have. I used to love them, now they're disappointing. read more

Dropped in to get some lunch on a random Thursday. The Wreck is delicious. I consider myself to be a big eater so the sandwich left me wanting more but mostly because of its quality. I probably would have ate too much had I been given the resources. There is a sauce on the sandwich which seemed very similar to Thousand Island but it was great with the hot peppers. The chocolate chip oatmeal cookies are amazing and cooked perfectly. read more

It's a solid 3.5* Quick place to hit with fresh food during your lunch hour. There is usually a line at lunch but it moves along quickly. I would suggesting making sure you know what you want before you get in line as not to annoy the rest of the patrons who seem to be pros at ordering. I had the italian meats on a thin cut bread with lots of veggies and a bag of chips. If you aren't a crazy person like I am it's a pretty good amount of food (my friend had half her sandwich and was happy). I wasn't hungry when I was done, but I could have had a little more. Maybe I'll have to try the soup next time too. I refrain from 4* because I wasn't blown away by food or service. I'll be sure to come back though and see what else is good. read more

This reminds me of Quiznos, but only better. They seem to be expanding in Seattle and opened up a few places nearby, but my only Potbelly experience so far is in Redmond. Nice, quick, and easy location to get to with ample free parking. I like the option of having a "thin" bread to go with the sandwich as I hate when the bread is so thick it's tough to bite through. Plus, less carbs! I'm sure these sandwiches are not exactly healthy by the time you add all the oil, mayo, and dressings, but they are pretty darn tasty! read more

The shop has lunchtime live music from time to time, which is something really nice in the middle of a crazy day of work while grabbing one of their delicious sandwiches. The staff is always really friendly and they're serious when they say you'll get through the line in 8 minutes or less... and always with your sandwich the way you want it. If you're hungry (like have been fasting since the day prior kind of hungry), grab the t-rex. It's a wreck sandwich with the addition of all the meats found in their pizza sandwich. Super tasty, but definitely filling. Don't forget to top off the meal with one of their shakes or a cup of soup or chili! read more

I had to do some work here at this location, and it was kind of inconvenient for them. But the manager was super sweet and as nice as could be, as well as the staff. I can't recommend them enough. Got some lunch on the way out, and their food is amazing. The atmosphere also is very fun. Very seattle style. Go check them out! read more

I enjoy coming to this shop in particular because I feel the staff are so much more personable. My family and I have always enjoyed the ambiance and the food. So reminiscent of Texas. I usually get The Wreck and share an oatmeal cookie with my kiddo. Prices are good around $5 each! read more

Used to be my favorite because the food was good, however they haven't been able to deliver my past three orders and haven't bothered to alert me until I call asking where my order is. Not worth the wasted time. I will never order from or return to this location again. read more

Came here for lunch and it was sort of busy, not too bad, though, the line moved fast. I grabbed my drink, decided on the roast beef sandwich, let the bread guy know I wanted wheat and proceeded down the line. I added vinaigrette to my sandwich, kept all the usual on there, minus the tomatoes, then got to pay. Total was around $8, not too bad and the sandwich itself is pretty big and yumm. I sat outside on the patio and enjoyed my meal in the sun. I'll definitely be back. read more

Food is a solid 4 to 4.5 for a sandwich shop. The 5 is as its so clean and the employees are so nice.

I really like Potbelly, as most of my family does. They offer several options and their relish is amazing!

We went for an original tuna sandwich and a big roast beef sandwich. Both were made to order and were super fresh and tasty. The atmosphere in the restaurant is casual and welcoming, the staff was nice and friendly to our kids, high chairs were available. We will definitely return. read more

I'm new to the area and wanted a quick bite that wasn't exactly "fast-food" so I came to this location. I had eaten at other Potbelly's when I was visiting Chicago but it had been years since I've had their food. The guy that took my order over the phone had great customer service! I ordered a tuna sandwich and a side of baked potato soup which were super yummy. It was probably the best tuna sandwich I've had in a while. It taste fresh and didn't have too much mayo. When I came to pick up my food, I was greeted by smiling employees. I am impressed by the customer service at this location. I hope the rest of Redmond/Seattle businesses are as friendly as this! read more

Cool decor, decent soups. I had the turkey sandwich on multigrain bread and it was bland. Maybe I'll try the salads next time

Ok it's NOT a BBQ place. The prices are a bit high for what we ordered. The venue was cute and very clean. The sandwich which sorry I can't remember the name was ok but at the same level as subway with a bag of chips for more $$. I was unhappy with the quality and of course not being a BBQ place. Probably won't be back but ok for a pricey subway. read more

They gave me a free cookie. That alone is worth 5 stars. Otherwise it's a potbelly - good sandwiches.