Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    3.8 (5 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Potbelly Sandwich Shop Takeout or Delivery

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop Photos

    From this Business

    POTBELLY SANDWICH SHOP ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    More like Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Recommended Reviews - Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 17
    Thanks 5
    Love this 16
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Hummus Republic

    Hummus Republic

    4.8
    (29 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    So glad Hummus Republic has opened in Whitestown. Great location near lots of shopping…read more The fast fresh options are healthy and super tasty. You'll be quickly greeted at the line and asked for your choice of a bowl, a pita, or a wrap. I chose the wrap with the next question being wheat or spinach. Then you can pick up to 3 varieties of hummus. I put black olive, traditional and fiery on my spinach wrap followed by white rice. Instead of rice I could have had cous cous or garbanzo beans. Next decision is protein. Shwarmsa chicken please. Lemon chicken or lamb ($ extra) also available. Top that with cucumber, red onion, feta, and tzikiki and I had a chubby wrap. Very good and very filling. Employees are helpful. I'll be back often!

    Hummus Republic is a chain of make-your-own bowl/pita/wrap filled with Mediterranean-type foods…read more You pick base, protein, toppings and sauce. I like that you can design exactly what you want. You can make it healthy or not. And there are vegetarian option with falafel. The staff is friendly and works quickly. I had a bowl with a lemon chicken protein and couscous base. My bowl was fresh, good and filling but the flavors could have used more spice. I particularly liked the warm veggie mix. The bowl ended up around $16, which I thought was a lot for a quick lunch with a spoonful of chicken. The dining room is small but adequate for the lunch crowd. The parking situation is abysmal. There is only one way into the lot and there are not enough spaces in the lot.

    Photos
    Many fresh lemonade selections to choose from--traditional to spicy jalapeño cucumber, lychee and many more,
    Many fresh lemonade selections to choose from--traditional to spicy jalapeño cucumber, lychee and many more,
    Hummus Republic
    Hummus Republic

    See all

    McAlister's Deli

    McAlister's Deli

    2.8
    (55 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$

    My food was good, unfortunately the service was not…read more I placed an order at the counter to carry out. The restaurant was very slow on this Saturday late afternoon. I was the only person at the counter, and there was one person sitting at a table. There were three employees behind the counter. My order was simple, just a sandwich and side of mac & cheese. I sat down at the nearest table and waited. And waited. And waited. Finally I went back to the counter, thinking maybe my order hadn't been sent to the kitchen. I approached the same employee who had taken my order, and she asked if I had ordered. I said yes, and she looked confused. I reminded her of what I had ordered. She talked to another employee who looked around and found my order sitting with a couple of other orders. He did apologize for letting it sit there and said they should have called out my name. My sandwich was good but not hot like it would have been if it hadn't been left sitting.

    On a cold day, I crave a hot cup of soup. Mc Alister's is a chain that serves sandwiches, soups and…read moresalads. They'd been pushing a special soup called Kicken' Crab Chowder, which sounded really good. You order and pay at the counter when you enter and then get your drink and find a table. This location has a lot of tables and booths that are comfortable. The place is clean, but not particularly interesting. The menu offers a mix of sandwiches and combo plates. The clerk who took my order was friendly and accommodating. The food was to my table so fast, I hardly had time to get my drink. The Kicken' Crab Chowder was surprisingly flavorful with the distinct taste of crab and a hint of spicy heat. The soup was thick and hearty with bits of veggies. All in all, I liked the soup, but it was a bit salty. Also, the bowl that they advertise is larger and more enticing than the paper cup than what I received. There's plenty of parking in their shared lot.

    Photos
    McAlister's Deli
    McAlister's Deli
    McAlister's Deli

    See all

    Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

    Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

    4.0
    (28 reviews)
    5.8 mi

    This sandwich shop was amazing! A lot of food for the price. The ingredients were fresh and the…read moresandwich was loaded with goodies. I got the BLT and side of fries. The fries were also amazing, they were kind of thin which made them so crispy! Nothing like I've had before! An example is pictured below! I even went at lunch time and everything was fresh and the service was quick. I didn't dine in but the aesthetic was very cute, bright and open, making it perfect for a lunch spot! As I mentioned, the fries were amazing. I got the naked fries but they also have options to get loaded fries and I cannot wait to go back and try them!

    This was my first visit to a Capriotti's. They are located in a little strip mall. There is no…read moredrive thru, but you can preorder and pick up. You order up at the counter and the sandwich is prepared fresh. The menu is up on the wall with a nice assortment of sandwiches and salads. I ordered the Classic Italian medium sub. The sandwich was prepared amazingly quickly and double wrapped in deli paper. The ingredients were fresh and the bread was soft. There was a little dressing on the sandwich. The cheese and tomato were cut so thin, they were translucent. But there was plenty of meat on the sub and it was filling. The sub was good, but didn't leave me craving another soon. The servers are friendly and efficient. They have 5-6 tables to eat inside and the dining area is clean.

    Photos
    Naked Fries Regular- fairly certain my dasher skimmed off the top but that's for another day! :)
    Naked Fries Regular- fairly certain my dasher skimmed off the top but that's for another day! :)
    Vegetarian Cole Turkey
    Vegetarian Cole Turkey
    Medium Impossible Cheese Steak + Lettuce, Tomato

    See all

    Medium Impossible Cheese Steak + Lettuce, Tomato
    Tipsy Mermaid

    Tipsy Mermaid

    4.6
    (173 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $$

    Finally visited this spot and it did not disappoint! I recently met a friend here for dinner, and…read morewe happened to come during the districts sip, stroll and shop event. It was insanely busy at the restaurant, but we were able to get seats at the bar top - which I think made our experience even better. I'm not sure how it is usually, but the bar was extremely lively and upbeat. I have to say, the bartenders were fantastic and brought awesome energy. I love when it's obvious the fish and chips and was super pleased with the dish. It comes with fries and a small side of slaw. I'm not a big fan of coleslaw, so next time I'll probably try to substitute it for something else if possible. 21+ inside and family friendly outside!

    Tried the Happy hour for the first time today and I truly loved every second of it! The happy hour…read moremenu is good for all of Tuesday and there's some pretty good options on there. My friend and I got the crispy chicken sliders and the Cuban cigars from the menu. We also got the lobster and shrimp dip which was not part of the HH menu but my fave dish from the evening. The drink variety is also great! All around the service was fabulous. We sat at the bar and it seemed like a lot of regulars were coming in which made for a nice ambiance. Pretty casual and it's nice to find a space that gives coastal vibes all around. I would love to return to try their full menu and some other cocktails!

    Photos
    Seating
    Seating
    B Cafe Steak & Eggs
    B Cafe Steak & Eggs
    Bagel sandwich

    See all

    Bagel sandwich
    Panera Bread

    Panera Bread

    2.4
    (61 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    I like the way this Panera is laid out. The counter is up front and tables and chairs are on the…read moreside. I advise using the kiosk to order as the front counter is painfully slow. There was only one person in front of me in line that ordered only coffee, but it took 10 minutes to finish ordering. There is a board to tell you when your order is ready, but it's kind of behind a wall so it's difficult to see. Anyway the dining area is nice, almost upscale with art on the walls. There are high chairs for the kids and wheelchair accessible tables. I had an Italian Sandwich which came with a cup of soup for a dollar. I am obsessed the warm Italian sandwich on their fresh in-house-made, chewy bread. The sandwich is huge and shareable. The creamy Broccoli Cheddar soup is tasty and warmed my bones on a cold day. Panera food is consistently good. This Panera is close to US 65 exit. There is plenty of parking. The restrooms are clean.

    Did a quick stop for their Dragonfruit refresher and to try the Dubai cookie! The stars are for the…read moredrink and cookies but I had a weird experience with the worker that took my order she literally just starred at me like I was ghost lol then proceed to take my cash with gloves on then she started to grab my cookies. I politely asked if she would change her gloves since she just took my money with those gloves. Being a food service extraordinaire I just noticed. She did change the gloves but only per my request. This makes me nervous for the others ordering.

    Photos
    Hearty Fireside Chili & Rustic Baked Potato Soup
    Hearty Fireside Chili & Rustic Baked Potato Soup
    Kickin' Grilled Cheese & Creamy Tomato Soup Value Duet
    Kickin' Grilled Cheese & Creamy Tomato Soup Value Duet
    New Sandwiches

    See all

    New Sandwiches

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop - salad - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...