We used Premier Pastry 2 years ago for a unicorn cake for my daughter's birthday. The cake was delicious and beautiful. We used them again for my daughters birthday this year (2021) and I emailed them a pretty crazy description verbatim what my 7 year old told me she wanted for her nature themed party. I told them my price range and did not know what to expect. When I got to the bakery to pick it up I almost cried when I saw the cake for the first time. Gorgeous doesn't even describe it. It was truly PHENOMENAL. They captured each element we asked for and kept in within my price range and the cake was DELICIOUS. The interior layers were rainbow which made it very fun when we cut into it (although the cake was so beautiful it was almost an injustice to cut into it). Every person at the party was amazed and I could not have asked for a better cake. The baker even brought the cake to my car and made sure it was secure for the drive. Definitely will be using Premier Pastry again and again and again. 10/10 recommend. read more

See all

I regularly go to the Flag Store at the Veterans Outreach Center once a week on Thursday. It was a beautiful day and I decided to take a stroll up South Avenue. I happened upon pastry shop adequately named Premier. It had some beautiful wedding cakes on display. To my pleasant surprise I spotted some wonderful pastrie tarts for sale and walked in. I'm sure glad I did because I purchased the most delicious apple tart I ever had. Simply amazing. It's certainly not a small portion, actually it was quite large for 5 dollars, clearly enough for two people. But I polished off the whole thing. I couldn't help myself. :) It simply was the best I ever have tasted. Now it is a regular stop for me. I was there today and purchased 3. One apple another pecan raspberry and the 3rd will say bourbon something or other I can't remember but it certainly looked delicious. This is my first Yelp review and I have a very busy schedule so that should tell you how pleased I was with not only the people there but the delicious pastries that they make. I will most certainly try the cakes in the future I could only imagine how good they are. read more

Ordered a cake for my daughters bridal shower. It was absolutely delicious and beautiful! Thank you Premier Pasty. read more

Premier Pastry - Premier Pastry made this cake for my daughters bridal shower. It was perfect! - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Great customer service! On top of that they made the most beautiful wedding cake for my wedding. I brought in flowers the day before the wedding and a cake stand. They were able to add the flowers into the design no problem and the woman I met with that day said she had extra greenery she could add to the final design. This thrilled me because I was running around like a crazy person and forgot to get the proper flowers etc for the cake. My homemade cake stand was too small for my cake but the woman I spoke to said to leave it at the venue and they could place the cake on top of it regardless but putting a round base (that was bigger than my stand) on top of it. It ended up looking so good. All of my guests loved my cake. Delicious buttercream frosting! My favorite was the red velvet top tier, so delicious with the cream cheese frosting filling. I was so pleased with the overall experience. read more

Premier Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Five years after our wedding, guests are still talking about how amazing the cake was! I highly recommend premier pastry! Each year we reorder the top layer of our wedding cake. Great staff-- amazing cakes! read more

They did a FABULOUS job on our cake for our wedding!!! It was SOOOOO tasty omg! We got so many compliments on it. We chose 4 flavors-- Raspberry Almond, Apple, Chocolate Hazelnut and Chocolate Raspberry). The fondant was absolutely MOUTH WATERING! I was afraid of that part but it melted in your mouth... tasted like marshmallow, it wasn't hard at all! They delivered the cake on time, no problems there. Everything was perfect! I loved them even before the wedding. My Husband got me a Peach Melba cake from there for my birthday. We plan on ordering the Raspberry Almond again for our anniversary (because the one slice we have in the freezer will NOT be enough! lol). Trust me... these guys are AWESOME! You won't regret it!! read more

Giving this place one star because the design of the cake was beautiful and the people were friendly. However the cake we had was beyond dry. Pretty upset because I heard great reviews from friends and even the one cupcake we bought from the display case was good. We asked for a strawberry filling in the cake and I didn't think it was a strawberry cream they were going to put in there. The two dozen cupcakes we also got were so dry and tasted like cornbread with frosting on top. I had high expectations seeing as how friendly the staff was. The $135 we spent was not worth it at all. Sadly, I will not be returning here. read more

I was so pleased when I ordered my sons baby shower cake from here, and thought it would be nice to continue on getting our cakes from premier pastry. I called to set up a consultation for his baptism cake which is in about three weeks. The man that answered the phone was extremely short and came off to not care if he got our business. He told me he had no openings in the next 3 weeks to meet with me but l could email him a picture. When I informed him I dont have an idea hense the consulation. Well he told me theres nothing He could do but "maybe" send me a picture on email, but he didnt know if he could do it. I guess I was confused he "maybe" could do his job. I will get my over priced, dry cake else where since one indivuduals request for a small cake wasnt enough for Premier Pastry read more

Premier created the cake for my daughters 16th birthday! It was beautiful, exactly what she described. The cake was delicious as well. I am not sure what the negative reviews were about, our cake was perfect. Delivery was on a Sunday with no problem. They were on time, professional from the consultation to the cake. My daughter stated they were just like "Cake Doctor" on TV. Great Experience. Would recommend them to anyone. read more

Premier Pastry - Birthday Cake 10.11.15 - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

5 daughters - 4 wedding cakes - multiple Birthdays - MANY bridal and baby showers. We have 25 year history with Paula and Phillip. Now we live in Florida and I continue to order Christmas treats from them. This is by far the best - most consistent and creative pastry establishment I have ever worked with. Their designs are as gorgeous as they are delicious. read more

Best cake and customer service! I live in Texas and ordered a birthday cake to be delivered to my sister who lives in Fairport. Paula was very helpful taking my phone order and was able to have it delivered on a Sunday at the time I requested. The cake was beautiful, delicious and according to my sister "the best cake ever"! Thank you Paula, Premier and delivery man! read more

We really enjoyed our wedding cake, the customer service was excellent and they were very accommodating when we decided to change our minds a few times. The design was exactly as we described and the flavors were great! We had a 5 tier cake with chocolate raspberry, mocha and a buttercream with raspberry almond - they were so sweet and seemed to just melt in your mouth! The samples were not nearly as good as the actual cake. The prices were reasonable compared to other locations as well. read more

I ordered my wedding cake from Premier Pastry and was very dissapointed. The cake was dry and the layers of butter icing was too thick. The layers of icing was thicker than the actual cake. I got feedback from my guests that they did not enjoy it either. Customer service is not too great either. read more

I had such a horrible experience with this bakery. I ordered my cake from them for my wedding and upon trying to schedule my cake tasting and arrange final details they were so rude to me. I don't live in Rochester so the only time I could come in was a Saturday. They refused to meet with me on a saturday and told me that it was ridiculous of me to even ask for such a thing. The woman on the phone (who I believe is the owner) was so inceredibly rude to me. I cannot believe that they run a business this way. There cakes are so over priced and taste horrible!!!!! Brides beware!!!!! Do not use them!!!!! read more

I ordered a Minnie Mouse cake for my baby shower. Everything turned out great. I then ordered a Doc McStuffins cake for my daughters 2nd birthday party. They forgot to put my daughters name on the cake. I paid $150 dollars for that cake. The stupid ass bitch had the nerve to cut me short of speaking and hung the phone up on me. When I called back, they offered to give me only $10 off of the cake...Seriously? They will never get my business again and I will never recommend anyone to them. Poor customer service when they screw up. read more

Fantastic baked goods and service! Most beautiful wedding cakes in Rochester!

Premier Pastries did a fantastic job for my daughter's wedding October 19,2013. We chose the Mocha Walnut Torte, and Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Torte plus traditional wedding cake, and assorted miniature pastries and cookies. It all looked beautiful and tasted even better. Thank you for fabulous desserts at great event. Plus you were a pleasure to work with!! read more

Ordered some of the pastries for a dinner I was hosting and they were very good. Think because I ordered this a head of time and they were very fresh. The apricot almond petit fours were the biggest hit, even with everyone who thought almond/apricot would not be good. The swan cream puffs were the prettiest and great for a presentation. Little cappuccino cups were adorable and tasty too. Would def order from them again. I would like to order a cake from them too soon, because they are beautiful. Prob most upscale bakery in Rochester area and if I needed a wedding cake I would order from here. read more

We got our daughters first birthday cake from here. Philip was amazing to work with, very responsive and even gave me his cell number to contact him on the weekend with any questions. We got the Raspberry Almond Torte, which was delicious and had our guests raving about it. When we went to pick up the cake, it looked exactly as requested and he surprised us with a bonus smash cake for our daughter!! They were both done so beautifully! I highly recommend this place and we plan to continue using them for our cakes in the future. I was so impressed with my overall experience, I created an account just to rate them! read more

I am shocked that anyone gave this place less than 5 stars. I am a baker & this is the only place that I will order a cake. Yes, it is expensive, but well worth it. After all, what good is a special occasion cake if your guests take just one bite and leave the rest? read more