I don't like to give only three stars but the dinner we ordered tonight was nothing like the reviews. I know it's hard now with only take out as an only option but I was far from impressed. We ordered 5 build your own burgers and cheesy Mac and bacon and a giant pretzel. One of the burgers was a bacon bacon burger. The burger came with not one piece of bacon! The cheese was almost invisible and the burger was extremely dry. All of our burgers were very dry. Some burgers were on pretzel buns. The buns were not fresh they were hard. Mac and cheese was ok. Nothing special and the pretzel was hard as a rock. French fries were good. Everyone enjoyed their fries. This place came recommended and I was very disappointed. Take out is tough but this was unacceptable. Maybe once you can actually sit and dine here things will be different but for now I'll pass. read more

Swift service, amazing food - strongly recommend the Drunken Goat burger

The food at this establishment is absolutely amazing 5 stars all the way. Now as to the guy Michaels review I happen to be regular at the restaurant and happen to be sitting near the older gentlemen and the jersey shore guy ( with full head of hair ) the older gentleman is a regular and one of the nicest guys who is absolutely harmless he is funny guy who doesn't mean anything he says and has a great relationship with the bartender working at that time. Talk about someone like that is absolutely disgusting because especially if you heard the whole thing like you claim you would of saw they know each other and it's nothing personal. Please get a life posting about an older mans behavior ( who also has a full head of hair ) is totally uncalled for. read more

It was delicious!! Seating was quick - service was excellent. I'm a bit of a pain - want my burger between med and medwell and it was perfect as was my wife's medium. More than I could eat and the bacon was awesome read more

Tried Prime Burger Bar for the first time tonight. Started with chicken wing appetizers. Asked for them crispy, when they arrived they were not what we asked for. Jess the bartender who happened to be attentive, recognized we were not happy. Immediately ran over to us and asked if everything was ok? We said we don't want the wings. She went in the back and then the manager JP came over and rectified the problem immediately. They came out better and were perfect. I ordered the tex mex salad with grilled chicken, my friend ordered kobe beef burger on a pretzel bun. We both loved our entrees. Jess & JP saved the day. I give 5 stars for both of them going above & beyond! We'll be back. read more

Everyone here is super nice, helpful, and accommodating. I've been here a few times and the food and drinks do not disappoint. Try the classic wings, burgers, and don't forget the onion rings! Super crispy- fire! Awesome owners are always here and the experience is great- read more

Had lunch today at Prime Burger Bar in Commack. Great experience. Charming place that was crowded for lunch. Service was top notch and the burgers were as advertised - "super!" Recommend this place for families, or just causal dining. Looking forward to a return visit. read more

Went for lunch and had a great Proprietary burger with my choice of toppings. Great service. Waitress was very pleasant and helpful. Will definitely go back. read more

Had a great burger from here. The short rib poutine fries were delicious!! Definitely going again..

First off, their Classic Milkshakes are amazing!!! Then, the Super Duper Milkshakes are even better!! They give you so much on it and it is the perfect dessert. Can't wait to try more Super Duper Milkshakes! read more

Our waitress Izzy was 10 stars, she was amazing. The burgers were good but I was expecting great. Pretty much same as Burger Fi but better atmosphere. I will try again and update soon. read more

Hit this place for a quick bite after reading about it in Newsday. Cool little place, met Ed, one of the owners who welcomed us in and told us to let him know if we needed anything. Seated right away, waitress was very nice. Burgers were great (I had Bacon on Bacon, wife had Mac and Cheese burger) and fries were outstanding (love the garlic aioli). Also grabbed a chocolate milkshake which was also really good. Ed asked us what we thought on way out, stopped and talked for a few minutes. New favorite burger place, we'll definitely be back! read more

Went to this establishment on 11/12/19 and had great time with the bartender Nick, who is definitely a good guy to chat with and makes one hell of a Moscow Mule. The staff was really friendly compared to Bleachers and Bantry Bay. I was too full to have any food but would return to try it soon. But kudos for the friendly environment and good luck on having a successful time in Commack because we sure as hell need a good bar here with some tasty eats read more

Best burger in town. Delicious drinks. Great vibe! Highly suggest the turkey burger and the french martini.

I had won a $25 gift card from a Facebook group for this place... I took my mom here for Mother's Day. The server was very friendly but maybe a little pushy when it came to add on ordering (ie desserts/shakes). My mom & I are used to ordering French fries well done. All I can advise is DO NOT ORDER YOUR FRIES WELL DONE HERE. The fries were literally so burnt, when I first saw them, I thought we were given sweet potato fries. There's a difference between well done & literally hard/burnt fries bc what were given, they were inedible which was extremely disappointing bc whatever white sauce came with them was good. We should've sent the fries back, but didn't. The breakfast burger itself was good, nothing special imo. What was really strange is that the last 4-6 bites of the burger all of a sudden got very salty (I didn't add any salt or pepper). Would I return? Maybe, but I wouldn't be rushing back. read more

Hi, Im back! The Covid has kept us in lock down but the promise of good food and accommodations can't keep us away. We visited the PBB after seeing the joint showcased on News 12. Let me preface my comments by saying the "Covid" restrictions placed on bars and restaurants may be the blame for methods or procedures followed by the businesses, not the normal way they do things. We entered a dimly lit bar area and was seated at a (low) table opposite the bar itself. The view of other people's asses sitting at the bar was not going to compliment anything we would order. High top tables would be a better choice. The room was dark with tables spread out to allow for distancing and the 33% rule. It was rather loud, speakers were ubiquitous throughout the room, making it difficult to hear each other across the table as well as the staff. Two waitresses came to the table to take our drink order, then realized we did get a drink menu. They both ran to get one, only to return to explain "there out of them", so we just ordered drinks. Our appetizer order was taken quickly, along with our entree order. Apps returned quickly. The large pretzel was "large" ,very good. I had soup, it was hot and just okay ( no oystereetts or crackers were offered). While in the mist of conversation and our appetizers the entrees arrived...now the table was covered in plates " tins" and now we felt rushed to get thru our apps or the entrees would get cold. The waitresses returned as we began with the burgers to take our dessert order. I asked her to slow down...lets get thru the burgers first. The burgers were very good, nice size, seemed fresh. However, the fries sucked! The "house cut" fries sounded good...but they kitchen staff killed them. We asked for well done fries, crispy fries. They were soggy and dripping with oil. Not sure if they were in fact house cut or not, appears the came from a frozen bag. So on to desert...we ordered the "chipwhich" sunday/shake. It took awhile for it to arrive, which was fine considering its lager and needs to be made...plus the rush thru apps and entrees. The pause was needed. The desert lady approached with what appeared to be our order and continued past us to another table placing the order down. The patrons at that table waved off the desert indicating its not their order....they had just sat for dinner. The order was then removed and delivered to us. Never in my years have I seen food delivered in error to one table removed and taken to another. THAT JUST NOT DONE IN THE RESTAURANT INDUSTRY. While we social distance, our food is past around. The desert lady laughed while saying she can't find her way around the numbered tables..I think there were 6 tables in the room. As we ate we saw her do it again...she took and order to the bar, meant for a table. We could hear the table guests question her about the mistake...they were not pleased. I've rambled on more they planned so in closing let me say more, this is a BAR, not a restaurant. The burgers are very good, the sides need tweaking. Someone in the kitchen knows what their doing! The fault in this joint in the front if the house...no one seems to understand what they do...they seemed very busy but busy at just looking busy. Training is the most important in the service industry, this place needs it, that is, if they want to a food establishment. As a bar....they're fine. A beer and a burger at the bar they can most likely pull off. Other reviews reference and bartender with a crappie attitude...if the guy on last night was the "guy", the reviews were correct. This guy didn't want to be there and couldn't be bothered. I could see that from the low table. Thats bad! I'll end this by repeating, the burgers were good...the staff was trying but appear to lack training. The front of the house is hurting the "BAR" You decide! read more