I had the Great South Bay burger. Amazing! My wife made her own burger. Everything was seasoned well and delicious. We love the garlic aioli that came with the fries, and so did our five year old son. We can't wait to order from here again! So good! read more

Fantastic lobster roll! Also had some nice live entertainment in the Covid friendly parking lot. Staff was working hard and I could here some pretty rude customers complaining about ridiculous things during a pandemic. Great job Burger Bar!!! read more

I admit their burger was good. Confusing menu description is bad. Please be careful when you order burger. They don't put all things listed on the menu. I expected lettuce and tomatoes will come with the burger because it's written on the menu. I complained over the phone. The lady picked up the phone put her manager on the phone, but the manager didn't apologized me at all and spoke like I was wrong. read more

I was really excited to try out Prime Burger, however was disappointed to received burnt food. I ordered the reverse wings (blue cheese on the wings with wing sauce to dip), and was so surprised to see such dark wings.... I can't believe they would serve something like that, it was nearly impossible to eat. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Reverse Wings - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Obsessed with this place! The food is TOOO GOOD and the service is awesome. I used to always go to Babylon burger bar until I stepped foot into Prime Burger bar. All around, amazing ! read more

My second time here. First time was for dinner and i had a burger that was pretty good. Second time was for lunch and I had the steak sandwich. Both times i was happy that i had eaten here and very pleased with the food , beverages and the service. Really nice looking bar restaurant that has a nice classy look with a nice neighborhood crowd. One of my new favorite spots. read more

The burger here was delicious. Great bar area. A sprinkling of tables in the back. Started with the roasted wings with grilled onions. Excellent. Similar to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza wings. My blended burger was very tasty. The Cole slaw on the side was very good. We skipped the fries this time. Finished with a black and white shake which also was excellent. Definitely going back soon. read more

The burgers were really good everyone at the table had one. The front of the place is small for seating but I think there was additional seating. I would call ahead for big parties 6 and over. Need to go back to try the milkshakes they look huge. Was too full to try one that night. read more

Moved from South Shore to NS and was delighted to find out the "burger bar" I frequented also moved to Commack. The "Juicy Lucy" was exactly what hubby remembered from Massapequa location. The service, taste, food and price were all positive points. Kids even loved the special over the top milkshake for a great report card. We were sat in back but it was much better with younger children than sitting by the bar. Tip: go early cause the hype is all it lives up to and crowds stampede in. Amazing food and will be back really soon!! read more

Order screwed completely despite making person read order back. Items forgotten, burger overcooked. Never going back. Burgerology in Huntington, Babylon Burger Bar or even Zin are better choices. read more

First time and they said it would be a while, yet Candace sat us, and got our drinks so fast, also took our order. Seems like everything is Made in house so worth the price and wait. Def can't wait to go back. read more

Prime Burger Bar - a woman sitting at a table with a tray of food and a bottle of beer - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

We went there to dine in for the first time after ordering take-out a few times. The staff was fantastic. Brought our food timely and checked in on us regularly. Clarissa was a doll. The appetizers were outstanding. Loved the sauces that came with the wings and the cheese curds were outstanding. I really enjoyed the burgers that we had that were cooked perfectly. Great beer selection and they had live music which added to a pleasant outdoor eating event. read more

I had the Surf n Turf burger off their summer special menu. The burger was so greasy that I had a hard time eating it. While being greasy, it also was quite flavorless. I ate the lobster meat and about half the burger. Even ketchup couldn't help this. It was very disappointing for a $25 burger. The fries were good, but I won't be back. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Surf n turf burger mess - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Food is quite good, with the exception of the runner mixing up the rare and medium burgers. BUT don't get stuck in the back dining room. The acoustics are horrific and it was like being locked in a Chuck E Cheese aka a circle of hell. Some softer surfaces or acoustic panels would be welcomed by many patrons, as we weren't the only ones distressed by the fact that we couldn't hold a conversation at our table without raising our voices. We will probably return, but ask to not be seated in the back. read more

Looking for a burger that is Amazing? How about some Mac n cheese? Or a Samich?? This is da place. From the Bavarian pretzel that is HUGE to the waffle sweet potato fries with a delish marshmallow sauce- yes marshmallow.. the burgers are juicy, the roll choices are great and they also have gluten free!! I have eaten here more times then I can count and the food is always the best. Bring the kids, bring mom or just your bestie. It's worth it!!! read more

Looking for an awesome burger place?? Try this place out you will not be disappointed. Very calm feel to the place, relaxing atmosphere and super delicious burgers. The service os friendly and quick. The menu have a nice variety of burgers to choose from and the truffle fries are out of this world!! I took my wife's family from Colombia here and they absolutely loved the burgers and you will love it too!!! Bring the family or bring your friends!! read more

Awesome food! So excited to go this week for my bday! I recommend the big pretzel and the burrata burger!

So I haven't seen my brother in law in months. He suggests Prime Burger Bar. I stop in early before the slacker shows up. The bar was full and I took the last two seats. Guy walks in and I offer him slackers seat, we get to talking and have a great time. Good food, friendly people. read more

Well here it is Mother's Day. I called the restaurant to see how late they would be serving. I was told the last seat would be 8:45 PM. I told her that's great I'll be taking out but I'll make sure to place my order earlier. So I called at 8:20 to place my order only to be told the kitchen is closed. I said really? I called earlier to ask how late you'd be open so I would make sure I could get my order in before you closed. They said sorry but we weren't busy so we're closing earlier. I said that's wonderful, it's Mother's Day I called earlier to make sure I could place my order before you closed. I have eaten here before, the only reason I was ordering from here was because of the pastrami hamburger. I will certainly find other hamburger places because their hamburgers are not that big. It was just a craving of a different burger that I didn't get anywhere else. It's pretty sad when you call to make sure you're going to place your order before they close and they tell you they're going to close anyway. Lost my trust. read more

Great burgers, best in the area by far. I didn't try the ice cream but the pics look amazing.

This is a favorite of my friend who lives in the area, and I agree with her assessment. The burgers were juicy, meaty, and well put-together. There were a lot of options to choose from too. Bring your hearty appetite to this place. read more

Don't waste your time here..... Manager was a complete jerk.... Embarrassed my wife, friends and family.....Thought my wife was one of his staff members with his ignorance and attitude.... 43 years old I have never in 1,000 restaurants visited have had a problem....Everyone has an off day I understand... He was off alright.....He was definition on how not to manage a restaurant.....The place looked nice and other staff members were courteous... Not your fault......I figured we would give them some business and have a nice meal there... I know it's been hard due to Corona virus for businesses.... Went to Jackson's down the block and had a great meal WITH A COURTEOUS MANAGER THERE!!!! read more

Place is pretty good! Food is super fresh and it's just the right amount of bar to restaurant ratio. But the real reason I go is because of Scott the bartender. HE IS THE BEST! Always amazing service from from him amazing sense of humor and of course makes the best drinks! read more

Really loved this place, I've heard very mixed reviews about it and very impressed by everything. Me and my friend split the spinach and artichoke dip which was fantastic, different...but very good. We then both tried the BBQ burger, which was awesome as well. Cooked to liking and it wasn't too much stuffed in a bun. The waitress was amazing and she was running back and forth so coming from a person in the restaurant business, she did an amazing job and i hope this establishment see's what a great employee she is! We also got a HUGE fudge brownie shake. I hope this place remains open, they did an amazing job on everything. I wish nothing but the best for this establishment!! read more

They have the best burgers on Long Island bar none!!! The service is great and the wait time is short. read more

This place is the new "IT" spot. The menu is awesome and the ribeye Sammie is just delicious. You also can't go wrong with any of the Mac n cheese options. Each one is superb in its own unique way. I recommend stopping in even if it's just for a beer and some wings. The vibe is welcoming and fun. TRY IT! read more

Best burger I've had in a while. Overall it has a pretty good beer selection, ok service and great burgers that are cooked at a prefect temp

Fried chicken sandwich was advertised as 5.99 when I went to pick up sandwich I was charged double 12.00 they told me that price in ad was for eat on only not takeout??? Complete rip-off also FALSE ADVERTISING never again beware of being ripped off read more

We finally found it! Great food, friendly knowledgable service, comfortable setting, our new local fav. We were smart (lucky) to go slightly early when it was not really busy. I understand how the experience could be affected if the place is full. Burgers, fries, lobster bisque and beers were spot on. Was given the opportunity to sample several unfamiliar tap beers before ordering. Can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. read more

Great food! Full service bar with great drinks. This is not your typical "burger bar." The burgers are awesome and they have a huge variety to choose from or build your own, too. If you don't fancy a burger then they have a great menu of excellent appetizers, sandwiches, etc. Piping hot, excellent portions, and reasonably priced. One of our new favorites. Dine-in service was very slow, but we went on a busy Tuesday night and they seemed short staffed - our waitress was doubling as the bartender, but the food arrived hot and tasty! We will be back soon! read more

We visited the Prime Burger Bar on Saturday Jan 4 and arrived at peak time approximately 7pm we were happy to wait at the bar for our table and ordered drinks and apps which were received timely. We received great service at the bar. We realized we had given the wrong number to the hostess so went to provide a corrected phone number when we encountered an older hostess who we later were told was an owner she physically pushed us out of the way of the hostess stand and was incredibly rude. We waited for her to finish and she was clearly stressed and not equipped to handle the Saturday night crowd. We would have left if not for the courtesy of the remaining staff who recognizing her apparent rudeness to my party and other parties waiting cane to her rescue. When she came to call us for our table again she was put off and rude when she had to wait for us to close our tab at the bar and told us to hurry up! I would not expect this service from an owner who should set the example on how to service a customer. She was rude and condescending and I will certainly not return with my business to a restaurant that so clearly does not value it. Thank you to Candice our server who tried to come to the rescue of her errant bosses. read more

I'm not one to complain on social media but after this disturbing experience, I can't stay quiet. My family and I went out to dinner at Prime Burger in Commack. This was our second time at the restaurant since it was SOO delicious the first time we were there. The food tonight was nothing like last time. Four of us ordered the dry-age steak burger medium rare. All of them were regular burgers and cooked well-done. The vegan beyond burger was delicious. In my opinion, it seemed like no one with experience was working there. There was a very rowdy group of people at the bar who seemed like they were friends of the owners. After a heated argument, a knife was pulled by one of them. This whole meal was so uncomfortable and I would NOT recommend this place. read more

Atmosphere was nice and staff very pleasant. When food finally came everything was cold..Mac and cheese and burgers. French fries were are hard and dried out. Left pretty much everything on our plate. read more

Highly disappointed tonight. Went there after working an 11 hour day and was just looking for a night out with my girlfriend. After placing our dinner order it was like the waitress disappeared. We literally had to go up to the bar in order to get more to drink. The food came out finally and was cold, still no sign of the waitress. Meanwhile there was at least 9 employees in the place and only two tables going. Spoke to the manager and hopefully they rectify the service. read more

Add at least 30 minutes to the wait time they give you. And don't believe if they say you can call ahead. Can't comment on food because I never got seated. Would have liked to experience it. Zero stars not an option. read more

This place makes amazing burgers, their lamb burger was to die for, would definitely recommend

My husband and I saw a clip on Channel 12 for the Prime Burger Bar and even though we live in Greenport, we sojourned through Covid land on the hunt for a mind-blowing burger and were NOT disappointed! DANG!! I had the Bacon on Bacon burger ( bacon IN the proprietary meat), bacon JAM on top, and two strips of, you guessed it Applewood smoked bacon on top with American cheese. Juicy?!! Thank you for the napkins!! And the fries!! What did you do to those fries?!! They're so yummy!! We got a little cup of garlic aioli for the burger that, heck, we used to dib the fries and it was unreal!!! GREAT service!! We will definitely take the trip again and bring friends!!! WOW!!! read more

ive been here two times now in the span of a year and the second time was just as good as the first, if not better. the drunken goat burger has to be hands down the best burger ive ever had in my life. if you have not tried this place and you live in the area you MUST GO. 10/10 read more

Prime Burger Bar - Pastrami Burger - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Mmm. Great burgers, nice salads and relaxed atmosphere. My new go-to for a great burger. Would have given it 5 stars, but the tequila selection needed some sprucing up. read more

Burgers were great. My mom loved her salad and turkey burger. They forgot the avocado on two of the burgers but my dad went back and they were very apologetic. Good fries! read more