We have been long time customers and always have been very satisfied. Tonight was a whole different experience. Our food was as delicious as always. The service and the atmosphere in the restaurant was another thing. We waited 15 minutes before a server came to our table, this was even asking for a waitress after waiting about 10minutes. We were not the only table that were experiencing frustrations with the waitresses. The servers with food were also walking around with no idea where they were to be going. This went on the entire time we were dining. This was not the Prohibitions Bistro experience that I would recommend to anyone. read more

Apparently news of coronavirus hasn't reached Prohibition Bistro. We immediately left upon arrival. No 6ft distancing between tables. No masks. No concern for anyone's wellbeing. read more

Food was good, but none of the wait staff or patrons are wearing masks. Kind of insane in the middle of a pandemic.... we had our masks on and it felt like one of the movies where the record scratches, it becomes silent and everyone stares at you upon entering. read more

What a fun place! Great sunset, wine, pizza and antipasti. Waitress Mary Berry was out of this world! Home made lemoncello and nocino to close out a delightful evening! read more

The food tastes magnificent for a reasonable price. The service is pretty nice and the orders are pretty fast. The looks changed it from a 4.5 to a 5. It looks like a very professional place and it just looks extremely nice. I would recommend this place. read more

Nope, you just can't go wrong with Harry's. We've been twice in the past two weeks, and both times were spot-on awesome. First, we took my friend Peter from NYC on Friday over Memorial Day weekend. We started with the 'Pomodoro' - Cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese, olive oil and garlic, drizzled with balsamic glaze served on bread like bruschetta. This is fantastic. Something about their cherry tomatoes just gets me! Next up, we ordered the corn pizza (with extra everything, as I always do) and then debated over which second pizza we'd get. Finally we decided to give the hot sopressata another try. I am so glad we did!! It played well against the creaminess of the corn and creme fraiche on the other pizza! The spice level on the hot sopressata was perfect also! Harry came by and had a convo with our NYC-based buddy, and gave us interesting digestif drinks made out of walnuts called nocciono. This past Sunday, I was shocked to see they were opened. Apparently they open for Sundays over the summer! What a wonderful surprise! My husband and I mosied over and sat outside for a small bit before the rain storm hit. Harry's brother was the manager this day, and immediately brought out the fantastic Burrata appetizer for us. He said, "If Harry were here, he'd do this, so I thought I should keep it going." Awesome! Also awesome? That burrata appetizer. I'd never ordered it before, but will definitely be doing so in the future. It is mozzarella stuffed with mozzarella curds and cream, which alone is like eating a cloud and ascending to heaven. It's served with an excellent salad (with those beloved cherry tomatoes) and the most scrumptious bread ever! Definitely from their pizza-dough recipe, this bread is addictive. We ordered the Frutti di Mare - a special with mussels, fried soft shell crab, under which were shrimp, and cheese-stuffed gnocci. This was good, but I wouldn't get it again. I think I might have just been musseled-out though as I've been eating them a ton lately. So of course we got the hot sopressata again, and downed most of it like piglets! The last piece I had to work hard to finish, but no way I was going to let it go to waste! Harry's is just fantastic, from customer service (Thanks Al and Vanessa!) to the food, to the decor. This is my happy place. read more

See all

The Prohibition Bistro offers an amazing menu, but a strange mix of restaurant themes. On the way hand, there are a number of terrific pasta dishes -- and the pizza is top notch. (It's one of only four VPN "True Naples Pizza" certified restaurants in the state!) But I just don't get the "prohibition" theme. The waitstaff (most are pretty young) were black shirts and bright red fedoras. The interior of the restaurant has a classic, 30s-era feeling. But the theme really cheapens the experience. It makes it feel like a cheesy theme restaurant instead of a top-notch Italian-style trattoria. That said, the pastas have a wonderful chew, and the sauces are perfectly seasoned. Flavorful without being overly garlicked or spicy. Salads and breads are excellent. And the wood-fired pizza is made to the same Naples standards as the excellent Il Ritrovo across the river. The restaurant also offers an intentionally limited bar. Don't look for a lot of hipster drinks. Cocktails are of the classic variety -- martinis and mixers from the Mad Men era. Kind of refreshing in this age of over-priced designer drinks. So it's a terrific restaurant. I just don't get the decision to cute it up with the red fedoras. read more

If you are looking for a family friendly, reasonably priced Italian dining experience, I highly recommend that you give HPBP a try. We visited on a Sunday night just as they opened, and I'm glad we got there early, because the place was packed by the time we left. We got a friendly greeting and were seated immediately. The wait staff are all decked out in suspenders and red fedoras, to resemble gangsters of the Prohibition era...pretty cool. Our server Jessica was friendly and knowledgable on the menu items. They have decent beer selection, so I started with a 3 Sheeps Rebel Kent, a malty (not too) sweet delight. My entree was linguine with marinara and Italian sausage. The marinara was as rich and flavorful as the best I've ever eaten and the sausage was savory and not overly spicy. Our pizza choices were Margherita, and the other, sausage. The toppings were just right, the sauce with a light tomato flavor and the thin crust was tasty. Another point I would like to make is that during our week in Sheboygan, we visited a number of restaurants, and Harry's was the ONLY restaurant at which (I'm assuming he was) the owner walked from table to table asking if patrons were enjoying their meal, and then thanked us on the way out...so kudos to them! Next time we are vacationing in Sheboygan, Harry's will be our first choice for Italian dining. read more

See all

Visiting from out of town. Heard this place had decent wood fire pizza. Arrived for early dinner. Host suggested the patio; Pleasantly surprised how warm it was with the heaters even with the wind billowing the shades. Watched some of the sky clear for a sunset over the harbor, channel side. Overall, a decent experience but don't need to go back. Wish I could give it 3.5/5. General thoughts: - Goat cheese ball salad - overdressed (!!!) super wet and saturated spinach and greens, and a laughably small cheese ball crusted with nuts for $8 - Ordered the margarita pizza. Four slices of a 12 inch pie. Excellent crust (edge). But topping covered crust was too wet. The flavor was nice, but skimpy on basil IMO. Would have preferred more. I love a table-side shredding of Parmesan cheese - and they offer that. - Nicely priced beers. - Server never refilled my water, or even offered it. Service friendly and helpful otherwise. - Why they make the waitstaff wear those red fedora-like hats is beyond me. That made the place feel gimmicky in a way. I guess the Mobster-Bennigan's vibe works for the owners. - Seems seating-friendly for larger parties and families with kids. read more

We were driving north a few hours and past dinner time-realizing only fast food chains were open when I saw Prohibition Bistro on Google Maps. We got off the freeway-not knowing what to expect when we pulled into the scenic lakefront area of Sheboygan.. only after walking into this unique restaurant with children in tow-we realized this was going to be a great experience. The food cemented that feeling as the pizza and all bread-based handmade food was excellent. Highly recommended-even though the price was steep--but not out of line.. if your stopping for drinks-the me I for adulting looked excellent.. we would gladly come back again. Many thanks to the kind and smiling wait staff. read more

Oh my goodness, the food here is heavenly that we went two nights in a row. The pizzas and the pastas were out of this world. We have been to stefanos and il ritrovo in the past and I have to see, prohibition bistro was even better. It's too bad that they are not open for lunch time, but service is very fast and the patio is just lovely in the summer. If you're visiting in from out of town, I highly recommend dining here. read more

My husband and I came to the area for golf from Houston, and we chose this restaurant based on the pictures. The pomodoro was my favorite part of the meal, and the arugula on the prosciutto pizza enhanced the flavor. The alcohol menu was quite exhaustive but of no use to me being six-months pregnant. Luckily they had a bottled root beer to make me feel special! read more

See all

Disregard any review that involves the servers and their masks. If they're so upset about it just leave. You shouldn't even be going out to eat if you are worried about it. I went there about a week ago with my significant other and It was the greatest experience of my life. As soon as we walked in we immediately felt so welcome. Everyone there acknowledged our presence which is very important with customer service. Our server was awesome, answered every question with a smile! Our food was phenomenal and I cannot wait to go back again. The owner walked around to each table and asked how they are liking their food which is great. As we were leaving the servers and hostesses all bid us a farewell. The greatest restaurant experience I've had ever! read more

Prohibition Bistro - Wine and beer flights! - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Quality pizza if a bit pricey. Enjoyed the half pizza half calzone type pizza! Spicy sausage and ricotta was great as was margarita.

My family and I came here for their corn pizza. My coworker was raving about it. I ended up getting Beef Marsala pasta, it was fantastic! Everyone LOVED the food and the owner even came and greeted us and made sure everything tasted great. I definitely would recommend this place! read more

This place is the bee's knees, far from being a hash house you can get quality hooch if you choose to come down and see their blind pig.:) 1920s lingo aside, I have been to this place numerous times and have never left disappointed. Their brick oven fire grilled pizzas are wonderful. I chose the prosciutto pizza and it was large enough to share with a wonderful blend of salted prosciutto and cheese. Perfect flavors to go with any wine or beer of your choice. If the food doesn't convince you to go visit this place, the ambiance might. It is tailored to have a 1920s Italian feel with a prohibition theme mixed in. The staff are happy to serve you and they are dressed to fit the part. The owner is also in the mix and visits the tables to make sure you are happy with your service. I rate this restaurant at a 5 because it's appeal and food have been exceptional the 6 times (over a period of three years) I've stopped in. I highly recommend this place. My little disclaimer for those of you who rated this restaurant so poorly because you had a family with kids and were turned away. The sign outside in big white letters on the building reads "Wine Bar" and "Prohibition". So the question you have to ask yourself is, does it speak poorly on the owner for not wanting kids in an blatantly obvious drinking arena, or does it speak more to you for wanting to bring your kids there in the first place? read more

Good food, also good beers. Pretty popular, so a bit of a wait, but nice little space by the water to wait outside.

What can I expect when the website says now you have a virus.... Umm fix that. I cannot believe that this is unknown to the business.

THE COVID19 restaurant shutdown occurred yesterday. Stuck in a hotel whose restaurant is closed, we walked to the harbor area and found we could at least order pizza to go, from here. We lucked out immensely! Turns out they make authentic Roma Pizza on tuesday nights only! The dough is started the saturday night before. The best flavor and finest ingredients I've ever had! 5 stars Prohibition pizza.! Mos def be back highly recommended! read more

Very disappointing. Didn't even get to go into this restaurant. For background, we decided to take our kids to Blue Harbor for fun. This restaurant literally is located across the street from a water park that promotes families to Sheboygan. I was with my extended family which accounts for about 6 adults and 5 kids. We walk up to this restaurant and are greeted to a sign that basically says families with children are not welcomed. My wife walks in to secure a table for our family and is shut down. Very rude staff and ownership. We have traveled all over the world with our children and have never been treated as bad as this place. What a joke. Please boycott this place. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Zero stars! We went here last year with the family and it was ok. This year? We were created with 5 signs telling us how unwelcome we were. Then the manager came outside to tell us that they don't have kids menus... We didn't want kids menus! They won't be in business long across from a family resort! read more

See all

I absolutely love this place and their out of this world pesto!!! It's just as good as my mom's which is really saying something. I thoroughly enjoy their pizza even though I'm not a big fan of that style of pizza usually and I love the ambiance. I always look forward to coming here when we can. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Sat on the deck last night overlooking the lake. There were numerous heating lamps that kept the area warm and comfortable! We had an app, 2 pizzas and drinks and everything was great. Service was excellent. Loved it here! read more

Staying at Blue Harbor and visited Prohibition Bistro on a Monday evening. They were very welcoming to the kids and staff was very friendly. We ordered the bread and pesto and the pomodoro (like bruschetta) - both had great flavor and fresh ingredients. The server even brought us extra bread to polish off the pesto; and it was worth it - the bread was warm and soft. If you are visiting with kids, here are two tips. The pizza on the kids menu is massive!! It's the same size as the pizzas on the main menu. So, tip one: the kids pizza can easily feed 2 kids, especially if you are ordering appetizers. Tip two: the kids pasta is standard size, so it broke my heart to pay $14 for noodles that likely cost less than $1. If your child is adventurous, order some appetizers and then for dinner, give them a little from your entree. Should definitely be enough, as the entrees are good sized. Overall, a little pricey, but great flavors. You know what they say...You get what you pay for (unless it's off the kids menu). read more

A wonderful experience that is comprised of great food, service and environment. The layout of the space and the ambiance is intimate as soon as you walk in. Perfect for a date or a dinner between friends looking to enjoy great food and company. We were offered the patio by the hostess; a bit skeptical, she reassured us that it was covered and heated. "A patio in March?!" was my first reaction, but boy did it end up being a gorgeous evening on the lakeside. We ordered two beer flights (they have an extensive wine and beer list) and split their Truffle pasta and Boardwalk Salad (which is served atop a pizza crust!). Everything was fantastic. The truffle pappardelle pasta had huge slices of portabella mushrooms; perfect for any mushroom lover and the salad was dressed appropriately given that bleu cheese can easily overpower any dish. The salad was crisp to the forks touch; well prepared. I would ask for dressing on the side next time just so I could take it home and save the perfection for later! The portions given the quality of ingredients and price are unbeatable! This restaurant is perfect for both those looking for a gratifying and unique experience for their taste buds as well as those who prefer to stick to well-received Italian classics. As someone who cooks often and is a firm believer in that Italian food is more often than not a miss around the US, I would come here time and time again. read more

The largest portion of this rating goes to the quality of the staff and owner. They are incredibly kind and respectful. My girlfriend left her purse the other day. Her parents and us came back to pick it up and the owner had it in his office. He returned it and offered us all samples of wine on the house. This is just an example of the kindness he and his staff showed. A good portion of this rating goes to the quality of the food and wine. Amazing taste and variety with the choice of familiar flavors or something different from the ordinary. Another small portion of this rating goes to the ambiance. This is a comfortable and relaxed environment for most occasions. This is the kind of place that has good quality to their products while also being a business someone feels good to support in their community. read more

Great bartender and amazing pizza. Was traveling for work and wanted food. Glad I picked this place. It was amazing.

Sheboygan has always had a wonderful foodie scene, so it was no surprise when Harry's popped up on the South Pier with a creative menu and excellent wine selection. The pizza, antipasti and other menu offerings always deliver, and the vegetarian options are just as thoughtfully crafted as their meaty counterparts. In addition to the basics like margherita and marinara, many other options including flavorful cheeses and well prepared veggies grace the menu. I do think that they could stand to let the prohibition theme chill out a little- I've always felt that the costumed staff is a cheap gimmick that feels mismatched compared to the quality of the food and beverages. read more

Went here tonight for Dinner, its was very good! Alex was our waiter & he was great!i liked the vibe & music. Will be back next time we are visiting from Chicago. read more

Excellent pizza. Brought me back to London 1985. I have not had that delicious, tasty, most dynamic pizza until today. Bravo! We normally each half a 12" pizza and today we are it all! Great service, ambiance, and a gracious host made it a great place to eat, and relax. read more

Had the steamed mussels and was pleasantly surprised. The butter, wine and garlic sauce was perfect! I actually had the sauce as a delicious soup. Highly recommended. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Had the steamed mussels. They were exquisite!! Highly recommended. - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Never made it brought the door because when I called the girl "behind the bar" was so rude. I asked about accommodating a large table, they can't accommodate over 8. I asked for the wait time for two separate tables, and she said she couldn't give me that. I said I'm across the street, at the hotel, and I can be there right away I just want to know if there is a wait. She told me to, "walk across the street and check the time in the restaurant." WHAT?! read more

I'll be honest; I wasn't sure if it deserves 3 or 4 stars. The food: There are, unfortunatly, a lot of eurpean style pizza places in town, and this one is right down the middle. It was tasty, quick, and fresh. It wasn't bad, however it didn't jump out. The Staff: They were attentive, polite, and quick. Our waitress knew the menu, could answer all the questions, and was happy to joke around. It was appreciated. The atmosphere: This is where I think it deserved 3 stars. The actual building is in a great location, with views of the river and lake, and the inside had nice decor. The downside is the overly-cheesy and "we tried to hard" prohibition outfits. It's hard to determine exactly the clientele they are trying to focus on. It's not really aimed to the hip our younger crowd, it isn't aimed at families - it truly is a style all their own. The takeaway - I would recommend it. It's not terribly pricey, the food and drinks were good, and the service was excellent. If you can see past the weird suspenders and hats, you're golden. read more

We love this place. The owner, Harry, is kind and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. I always get the 4 seasons. It is a fun mix. You must try the nocciono, a walnut liquor. It is the perfect end to your dinner! read more

Never had a bad meal, and I've been here over 30 times! Service is professional and great. Have tried everything on the menu and would recommend it all! My favorite dessert is the campfire pizza! read more

Loved everything about this restaurant! Our waitress was so nice and helpful. She made great menu suggestions. Ambience was delightful. I wanted to stay all night! And food was superb! Can't wait to go here again when in town. read more

This place is by far one of the best restaurants for Italian Food and we are from Chicago . The owner and staff are so polite . Food was outstanding !!!! Braised beef was so good and tender. My wife and kids all enjoyed their meals . All of the ingredients are fresh!!!! Must get a pizza they are to die for read more

Prohibition Bistro - Tonight's special pizza with roasted veggies and balsamic dressing - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

We just ate at Harry's Bistro and it was fantastic:) We ate outside on their patio and it was awesome! It was heated the sun was setting and it was picture perfect. Our server was great and the food was excellent. We will be back with friends! The owner was attentive and it just gave us a wonderful feeling of being important. read more

Maybe we didn't order the right things but not blown away by the food. The atmosphere is nice and it seems like they want to be a nice fancy restaurant, but they are just missing something to take it to the next level, I'm not sure what that is.. will definitely be back this summer for drinks outside. read more

One of our favorite places in Sheboygan whether it's to dine or just sit for a glass of wine. Our meals have only been excellent, the menu offers ample options for vegetarians, the wine list is awesome, the atmosphere warm and interesting, and the staff always fun and responsive. Great place for a date (especially if you don't mind the music of Frank Sinatra)! read more