Cancel

Open app

Search

Proof Pizza

4.0 (100 reviews)
Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Proof Pizza Photos

PROOF PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Trendy
Good for kids

Recommended Reviews - Proof Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Build your own pizza
Dina E.

Super fresh ingredients, and a build your own pizza option, made this brick oven-style pizza a restaurant I would visit on the regular! What made this extra special, is you can eat in the adjacent Saint Kate Hotel lounge, while people watching and listening to live music! After your meal, enjoy a stroll the art gallery (free of charge). Takeout is also available and parking spots are located directly in front of the restaurant.

Michelle E.

After seeing a musical at the Marcus Center, my husband and I stopped at Proof Pizza for a quick bite. This was our first time dining here, and we were impressed by the vibrant atmosphere of the Saint Kate - The Arts Hotel, where the restaurant is located. The hotel's bustling lobby and bar add to the experience, making it a great spot to grab a meal. Proof Pizza offers a casual dining experience. While there isn't seating inside the restaurant itself, you can either order to-go or dine in at the seating area within the hotel. The service was quick, and the Neapolitan-style pizza was good. I ordered the Proof Special and it had a great balance of sweet and spicy flavors. The combination of peppadew, sausage, and giardiniera was tasty, and the crust was chewy. I found the pizza to be somewhat greasy though and I should've ordered it well-done. If you're looking for a fast, casual, and flavorful meal downtown, Proof Pizza is worth a stop.

a pesto pizza with mushrooms, sausage, pickled veggies.... they forgot the arugula but i honestly didn't notice ha
Courtney C.

Another Yelp find win! We got pizza for dinner from this place to go and wow it was delicious!! the crust was on point- the staff were super friendly at proof and also at the hotel because we were told to order at the bar. we chose to do the build your own pizza since it's only $1 more than their pizzas and had more toppings options- we made one with the pesto sauce and one with the special tomato sauce. We loved both of the pizzas- the toppings are super fresh and there's a good variety- some toppings like the pickled veggies i had never heard of the same but it was a yummy addition to the pizza. I would recommend getting 2 pizzas for 2 people unless you have something else like a salad to go with. We "almost" finished both pizzas as two adults with only 1 slice left. The drizzle options on top are great too! We highly recommend this find!!

Caes F.

Located near the Hotel of Saint Kate, Proof Pizza is a true stone fire oven pizza. For $18 dollars and some change, the pizza was not amazing but tasted solid. The bread was really nice and I appreciate the sauce flavor. I was the only customer so it took 5 minutes. The Proof Special Pizza was a mix of sausage, garlic, and bell peppers. Overall, the pizza was decent.

Prosciutto & Mozzarella pizza, at the bar!
Lydia B.

This pizza was so good. Fresh and chewy crust, plus they let us eat it at the art hotel bar. Mom and I split a pizza and it was perfect for us before the Nutcracker! Highly recommend.

Yummmmm
Ashley H.

The best pizza I've ever had a hotel and you can do 50/50 on a pie. On one side we did mushroom, broccolini, pesto and mikes hot honey and the other side was cheese My husband and I split this while having some drinks at the bar before DMB show at summer fest! And i think you can get this as late night pizza from room service! Definitely recommend this place.

Build your own pizza! (Marinara, Pepperoni, Bacon, Garlic, chili oil, chili flakes, Parmesan)
Nia S.

Proof pizza serves perfectly crisp, flavorful pies with the option to build your own. The casual atmosphere makes it ideal for a laid-back meal. A must-visit for pizza lovers.

Ron D.

Posh Pizzaria inside modern elegant artsy hotel . Their specialty here is Pizza Margarita - original recipe nothing twisted nor modified. It was good, texture and flavor were there , crust is a little chewy bu tracking of crispiness. Why 5 stars, hotel showcase local MKE artist their work and support their work. Donates 1% of hotel revenue to support Artist. Great hotel, good pizza , awesome artworks.

Genoa Pizza
Haley J.

A great addition inside/attached to the Saint Kate Hotel! I stayed at the hotel for 8 nights and got this twice. The second time I was dying to get it again! You can also order this through the bar inside the Saint Kate lobby. Delicious, I'm not a huge pizza crust girl but I found myself finishing this pizza crust!

Four Cheese pizza
Brady R.

It's a good pizza spot, especially for those that stay in St. Kate hotel. I wouldn't suggest going out of your way if you aren't a hotel guest, though. As for veggie options - you really only have 2 total options, which was a bummer. I think they were a multi-cheese and then a margarita option. They also catered pizza for a work event we had at the hotel, and those pizza options weren't on the menu, but they were much, much better. Good pizza spot, a little overpriced, but tasty and gets the job done.

Eva G.

I LOVE Neapolitan pizza. The success in me loving the pizza is toppings and how it's baked. Extra crispy, right here!! Service was friendly and welcoming. Why not 5 points? There was only a bar seating along the wall and if someone came in the wind blew in and it was not pleasant. Wish they had tables to sit at.

Genoa pizza
Krizelle G.

By far the best pizza in Milwaukee and probably in the entire state of Wisconsin. This review is years overdue. Since moving to WI from NJ we have tried pizzas from all over including the popular Lou Malnati's and Giordano's of from WI and IL locations. We tried dine in and take out options for days we don't want to cook. I just keep coming back to this place and at one point had proof pizza every single week! Menu is straightforward, ingredients aren't complicated and they don't put things in the pizza that aren't necessary or muddle the flavors. Their white pizza is also very good but the genoa pizza is my favorite. They use very fresh mozzarella and never overcook it. The tomatoes are fresh and sweet. And lets talk about the dough itself, it's thin enough to not taste bready but it's never thin enough to be crispy or taste like salt crackers. It's just absolutely perfect. Sometimes we would order ahead and it would take 25mins or less for pick up. Dont really mind waiting for it inside the St Kates hotel lobby because of the terrific elegant artsy ambiance inside the hotel, next to the lobby bar. There's metered parking right in front of the proof pizza entrance but this is limited. We've also dined in and had cocktails at the hotel bar with the pizza. They also had wings and other items on the menu but we really come here for the pizza. This is my go to pizza place and even though I live outside the city i still don't mind driving in to pick up pizza from here.

Margherita
Christina R.

We had a hankering for some pizza before we left Milwaukee but didn't want to get a huge one. We saw Proof Pizza did smaller pizzas so we decided to head over. It's inside of a hotel and honestly, at first, this made me not want to eat there. Hotel restaurants are usually pricey and not very good. Turns out, it was good and not completely overpriced. The menu items are interesting and if you don't like how any of them look, you can always build your own. We decided on the Proof Special and the Margherita. Both incredibly good. The Special may not be for everyone but I love sour/pickled flavors on my pizza. The pizza came out quick and perfectly cooked. With a can of Spotted Cow, was a lovely meal.

The box is unique instead of run-of-the-mill. Nice!

See all

5 years ago

Some of the best pizza in Milwaukee and very reasonably priced. The margarita is a go to

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Dawn E.
241
3
0

7 years ago

Great topping options, great crust and super yummy. Reasonably priced as well, loved the vibe.

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Roy Z.
0
92
0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Outstanding pizza. Perfect crust. High quality ingredients. Fast preparation. Great lunch spot!

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Mushy, cold overcooked Brussels sprouts and prepackaged salads? So many better options in Milwaukee.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Guest Relations M.

Guest Relations M.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Proof Pizza

How big is the pizza? Big enough to split between two people?

Hi Vikki, yes the pizzas are big enough to split 3-4 slices of pizza between two people.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 9,432 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Riley's Social House & Sandwich

Riley's Social House & Sandwich

4.7(129 reviews)
0.8 miHistoric Third Ward
$$

Riley's is a great place to bring your canine companion (or borrow a friend's) and enjoy great…read moredrinks (cocktail and beer selection is hard to beat) and solid sandwiches. Service and patrons are friendly here. In addition, there is a great "dog coding" system that helps accommodate a safe setting for the social spectrum of dogs. Recommend whether you have a dog in tow or not. Pro tip: it's a great place to pregame before hitting the Summerfest grounds.

I've been meaning to try Riley's for a long time so finally made it to this location! My friend's…read moreold coworker is one of the owners so I remember her telling me about it when they opened. I'm happy they are doing so well and have multiple locations now! We just wanted a drink and a quick bite to eat and being during a baseball game, lots of places in the area were busy. There was a good crowd there watching the game as well. It's an interesting setup, reminds me almost of a living room (with dining tables) and then the small bar area is to the side. To order food, you do it through two wall kiosks which I like because you can look at options and not feel rushed unless there's a line. Outside they have tables and a tv as well. I choose a veggie sandwich which had a good kick to it! The smaller size was good enough for me. It was a bit confusing how to get your food, from what we understood, you have to go through a door to get to the kitchen window (bathrooms are that way too) but no one calls your order number or anything. I'd suggest an improvement on that way you know your food is ready or maybe we missed something. Overall, I would return and would like to try other items on the menu!

Photos
Riley's Social House & Sandwich - Inside

Inside

Riley's Social House & Sandwich
Riley's Social House & Sandwich - Espresso martini

See all

Espresso martini

Bavette La Boucherie - Previously retired 80-yr old butcher

Bavette La Boucherie

4.5(463 reviews)
0.6 miHistoric Third Ward
$$

I was excited to be in Milwaukee today, given the many restaurants that have earned recognition…read morefrom the James Beard Awards. Most of those spots only open for dinner, so I was thrilled to find that Bavette La Boucherie now serves lunch. My friend, a local, told me the restaurant originally began as a butcher shop. While that's no longer the case, the space still pays tribute to its roots -- shelves lined with kitchen knick-knacks, butcher-block counters, and a display of local provisions that hint at its past. Chef-owner Karen Bell leads the way here, and you can feel her touch throughout -- from the creative menu to the casual-elegant vibe. The décor blends exposed brick and warm wood with soft light and a friendly hum from the open kitchen. Our server, Matthew R., had only been with Bavette a couple of weeks, but his background in restaurant management showed. He was knowledgeable, attentive, and offered great suggestions. Before our sandwiches arrived, we shared a cup of pork and tomatillo pozole topped with cabbage slaw and a dollop of sour cream. It was piping hot, bright, and deeply flavorful -- the kind of starter that makes you stop talking for a minute just to enjoy the next spoonful. Having read rave reviews of the Korean steak au jus, I nearly ordered it, but Matthew suggested the roast-beef with cheddar since I'm not a big lunch eater. Excellent call. The sandwich was divine -- tender, flavorful beef layered with melted cheddar on a crisp, perfectly toasted roll. The beef-fat fries had great depth of flavor, though I'd love them even more if they were twice-cooked for that extra crunch. Being more of a gin or vodka drinker, I couldn't resist the Gin Old Fashioned on the cocktail list. It was delicious -- smooth, aromatic, and balanced enough that I happily ordered a second. Great food, warm service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Bavette La Boucherie is a gem I can't wait to revisit.

Was in town for the weekend and TikTok said the only things I should do in Milwaukee were Discourse…read moreCoffee and Bavette. LISTEN... The only crime here is that this place isn't a chain and it's miles away from me. Our waitress was amazing, the vibes were perfect, everything felt intentional in the best way. The heirloom tomato salad was so fresh and delightful. A full 5 out of 5. And those beef tallow fries were unreal. I am still thinking about them and genuinely wish I could figure out how to recreate them at home. TikTok actually delivered on this one. Very happy we ended up going.

Photos
Bavette La Boucherie - Fresh-cut roast beef w/pickled veggies and brown mustard

Fresh-cut roast beef w/pickled veggies and brown mustard

Bavette La Boucherie - Everything here is SO delicious!

Everything here is SO delicious!

Bavette La Boucherie - Charcuterie Plate

See all

Charcuterie Plate

Swingin' Door Exchange - Carrots and Grilled Beets!! Delicious

Swingin' Door Exchange

4.5(1.2k reviews)
0.3 miDowntown, East Town
$$

Went in late after a ballgame close to the kitchen closing. Nice full place with a locals feel…read morethat was very hospitable to travelers. Had a great Rubin and blackened carrots, excellent quality and quantity for the price. The type of spot you hope to find late while trying to avoid the chain hotel bar/restaurant

I was heading to the Downer Theater after work for a movie on Friday night and of course wanted a…read morefish fry beforehand. I surprisingly don't have many options in my "MKE - Fish Fry" collection that are near downtown, but Swinging Door Exchange was one of them. I was pressed for time, so I placed a to go order rather than dining in. I got the combo fish fry (two pieces of cod, two pieces of perch, and three fried shrimp) with potato pancakes. I was also very easily talked into the half rack rib appetizer. The ribs were good, even though I prefer sauce that's more sweet and smokey. Their sauce was on the tangy side with a tease of spice that really only became noticeable when the majority of the half rack was gone. If I were in the mood for ribs as my main meal, I'd consider getting theirs as an entree. The two potato pancakes weren't homemade; instead, they were premade hash brown patties that some other restaurants also serve with their fish frys. These were perfectly acceptable in lieu of homemade pancakes. The cod tasted great, but the breading didn't hold up very well. Either the fish itself was too wet or the two block walk back to my car allowed for condensation to wreck it or possibly both. The perch was not yellow lake perch but probably something like pike perch. Even though both kinds of fish and the shrimp were all good sized portions, $29 feels like a lot. I wouldn't say no to it, though, if I were dining in next time and avoid the extra cost of their takeout fee. Shout-out to the bartenders working that night. The bar area was absolutely packed, but both of the ones I talked to about placing my order were friendly and helpful even with being super busy.

Photos
Swingin' Door Exchange - Hometown old school bar and restaurant. Has a Cheers feel to it

Hometown old school bar and restaurant. Has a Cheers feel to it

Swingin' Door Exchange - Ahi Tuna Steak

Ahi Tuna Steak

Swingin' Door Exchange - Historic Mackie Building, once the site of the Grain Exchange. Swingin Door is bottom right

See all

Historic Mackie Building, once the site of the Grain Exchange. Swingin Door is bottom right

Proof Pizza - pizza - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...