It is NY COLD outside today. We had a Margherita and a Vodka sauce pizza delivered today. My first experience with a vodka sauce pizza was a great one! Delivery was fast and the order was hot and ready upon arrival. Yes! I am now a new fan of vodka sauce pizza! read more

Prospect Pizza - The box says it all. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Nona's pizza was awash with red sauce and clearly not homemade. Pizza did not enough mozzarella or basil, and they do not offer garlic as topping. Small pizza was 16 inches and overpriced. Way too big for 1 person. Broccoli was overcooked and watery. Skip this place. read more

Great Pizza! Fast delivery and great other food also. The prices are affordable . Good neighborhood spot that stays open late and has a wide variety of stuff read more

Simply delicious! Wide variety. Not over priced. Check them out. You won't be disappointed.

I wish I could give them zero stars. Called in to order pizza, gave them our CC #, and the lady on the phone said she would call us back to confirm order. She never called back so we called back - she proceeds to let us know that we need to send a picture of our ID to her boss's number. We thought this was strange, but seeing that it was a legitimate pizzeria with okay reviews, we text messaged him the ID. Then the lady on the phone says, because the ID is a Florida ID, he wanted us to text him a picture of our actual credit card. Insane. This place is running a scam. It's also racist. My brother-in-law is black - you saw a picture of him and now you are questioning him? So many wrong things with this. DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM. read more

Whatever you do, DO NOT order for delivery. Ordered a large pizza and was given a 50 minute estimated arrival time. Requested an update through the Uber Eats Apps after the 50 minutes and no update. Finally called the store 8 times and every time they picked up and put the phone down. I understand orders taking longer than estimated but DO NOT continue to put the phone down as soon as you pick it up and carry on about your day. Customer Service is horrible. Save your time and your last nerve. read more

I was pleasantly surprised by the large margarita pie I ordered from Prospect Pizza last week. They aren't a household name or a buzzy restaurant written up by all the food blogs. They're just your local pizzeria operating mostly on delivery orders and single slice takeaways. My pie was made fresh from the time I ordered it for pickup and was ready about 30-40 minutes later. It carried well through some distance and tasted absolutely phenomenal when I got home. The sauce was tart and tomatoey, there was plenty of fresh garlic and basil in the sauce, and the cheese to sauce to bread ratio was perfect. Even more telling is that I finished every last bite of the crust-- the crispy and fresh edges of each slice were irresistible. I was tempted to chalk up the tastiness of their margarita pie to me being hungry, but eating it heated up the next day I found myself planning my next Prospect Pizza pie order, stat. Okay, random pizzeria with an okay Yelp rating, your pizza hits differently these days. read more

Prospect Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Free delivery, quality pizza! Sides are sometimes a bit too greasy for me, but overall good food!

It was all right little dry crust hard andWhen it was delivered the pizza was warm because very late. With the delivery, shouldn't even accepted pizza . Got my money back. read more

Quarantine Review: We needed some pizza and wings and fries and dessert and Prospect was open. Delivery: It was quick and efficient. Perfect. No complaints here. 5/5 Philly Steak Pizza: I love a good cheesesteak pizza but this was just okay. The yellow triangle cheese slices were not a good look, too much peppers and not enough seasoning. It was almost what envisioned but missed the mark. 3/5 Margherita Pizza: They refer time it as "Grandma's Pizza" ... it was unexpectedly a rectangle and it was really good. Basil, mozzarella and sauce. Delicious. 5/5 Wings: These were classic buffalo wings. I asked for blue cheese dressing and for 9 wings they gave me one cup. If you really like blue cheese with your wings ask for two. Fries: Fries are admittedly tough to pull off in delivery. These were just meh. They were lukewarm and not really seasoned. 2/5 Cheesecake. Solid for what I'd expect from a pizza joint and yet for $4.50 I would have liked an option for a strawberry or pineapple topping. 4/5 read more

See all

I went in 5min before closing to get what I knew would be the last old slices of pizza. Fine. I asked if he could put pepperoni on a slice and I would warm it up at home. After using a spatula to take the slice i requested from the tray, he proceeds to use his BARE HANDS TO GRAB PEPPERONI FROM THE FRIDGE AND PLACE ON THE PIZZA. I immediately call him on it - flag that it is so unfair that he is doing this, he is aware it's unsafe and illegal and that i just came from the train and I would never put my bare hands on something now without gloves and that he is well aware he needs to use them. He points the other slice and says he will give me that one, but why would I trust him about that slice? Sorry, I'm out - and never ever to return to this filthy establishment. read more

Also named Millennium Pizza as the listing on Uber did not like their pizza or mozzarella sticks the garlic bread was made well but I'm just not a fan of fresh raw chopped garlic spread on bread As they completely ignored my request for powdered garlic and butter just another mediocre pizza spot read more

Horrible! Never do delivery this is what they well send you. If you can't get ac delivery g right why wild I out in the effort to come in and place my order when business can't be consistent across the board. read more

Prospect Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

If they sent you burnt food they will not make it right. Avoid businesses that can't handle their own mistakes.

I come in and order a ham-and-cheese sub sandwich which is supposed to come with lettuce, tomato, onion, salt, pepper, olive oil and vinegar - standard. Or at the very least, a customary query - which didn't happen. Not only is the sandwich literally just ham and what appears to be Kraft slices, but when calling back and asking them how they could forget so many key ingredients, they ask "how to make it right" - by trying to charge me for another sub sandwich, assuming I'd already consumed their failure. When asserting that I had not eaten said failure, they actually asked for the sandwich back - likely to be resold. Not only is this atrocious customer service, but just plain gross. read more

I love Prospect Pizza! It's the best neighborhood pizza spot. They're quick and efficient and the pizza is great! Had 6 pies catered for a party and all my guests enjoyed the pizza! Got compliments from quite a few of them as well about the pizza. Got 2 cheese, 2 pepperoni, and 2 buffalo chicken pies. They had it ready for me within hours at an affordable price. All of my friends love Prospect Pizza too. This is your spot if you're looking to grab a slice! read more

I've ordered twice from here through the new Slice app. Very easy. Quick delivery. Grandma pizza is excellent. I was very surprised tonight though to find that the sausage onions and peppers pizza has NO tomato sauce! The pizza is good, but for me it needs to be really clear in the description that this pizza doesn't have sauce! If I ordered sausages peppers and onions on a pie anywhere else, sauce would be a given. Interesting choice PP. Thanks for the speedy service. read more

Prospect Pizza - SAUSAGE PEPPERS & ONION PIZZA PIE - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered pizzas from here for four years and they always delivered the truly ideal, classic cheese pizza. (Their vodka pizza is also excellent.) read more

Prospect Pizza definitely is hitting a sweet spot for the area. This part of Brooklyn doesn't have dollar slices, and it does have some fantastic sit-down places popping up (looking at you Zurilee, Parkside, etc.), but it most certainly lacks something in the middle (and no, don't even get me started on Gino's). Prospect Pizza is the place you want to order from, or walk over to, to grab a pie last minute just because you feel like it. The prices seem pretty even keel for the most part, and the grandma pie I ordered was pretty good. It was pretty thin for a slice of that style, which wasn't bad, but definitely thinner than most of the usual ones I've had. Seasoning was good, cheese and sauce were solid A-. Good enough that I'll definitely be coming back to try some more options. Their daily specials are a nice way to mix things up, and while I haven't tried their other Italian dishes yet, I'm willing to take a chance. They had our pizza ready in about 30 minutes for a take-out order, as promised. Nice to see a new place that isn't trying too hard, but is just doing their own thing. read more

See all

A new place that popped up in the neighborhood. I've ate here twice and each time I'm moved almost to tears at how good the pizza is. I will definitely be back. read more

Prospect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I dont really love pizza and I dont eat it often. But I know a good slice when I see one and the Sicilian thin crust at Prospect Pizza is damn good. Crispy crust gooey cheese, slightly sweet tomato sauce it was really good. I usually opt for a grandma slice but this was as close as I could get on this particular day. The slice was $3 so about par for the course. They have a pretty extensive menu and since they are new they have frequent specials. If Im ever in the pizza mood again and looking to stay in PLG/Flatbush Im coming back here. read more

See all

In store purchase is better than delivery wings are alright pizza is pizza, you know read more

Love this place for my neighborhood speciality slices! I like their ceasar salad too. The staff are really nice and friendly. During COVID, they always had the door open to increase circulation and ensure safety. read more

Solid pizza, and other options. The ziti sometimes has huge globs of cheese in random spots which I do not mind, but some might. They always bake a fresh pie, and your order is always delivered by the estimated time. read more

Prospect Pizza - Yay personal pies! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I went to Italy once and said to an Italian person 'You should come to NYC, we have the best pizza in the world'. Yes, I am that person. And had zero regrets since then. I live in Queens, but periodically visit other boroughs for good food. Again zero regrets. Prospect Pizza is one of the places I make sure I visit when in Brooklyn. I tried a few pizza slices there and oh my!! The vegetables are super fresh, the ratio between cheese and tomato sauce is on point and the dough is dreamy. I truly want to try every flavor there and then decide what's my favorite. I mean, its Brooklyn and it's pizza, what can go wrong there. I secretly wish, I lived in the neighborhood. Mind you, I never go back to the same restaurant/café twice, but this place stole my heart. Do yourself a favor and pay a visit to Prospect Pizza. I highly recommend. read more

I can guarantee you that no nonna or nonno was involved in the development or execution of this pizza. The pizza did not even resemble Italian food. Yes, there was crust, some kind of cheese, minimal, bland sauce, and some random, also bland, oily vegetables on it, but it really tasted like "pizza" you'd get in a strip mall in the Midwest somewhere. As a Brooklyn pizzeria, they should be ashamed of themselves :(. Nice delivery guy, though. read more

You have to specify that your pizza should have tomato sauce otherwise you get an open face round hot cheese sandwich thing. So livid. read more

See all

My favorite pizza in all of nyc. Sauce is perfect, crust is perfect,, always delicious! Ive had it so many times and it never disappoints !!

Okay...I've had enough with these people. Lived on the block for 20+ years and I've seen my fair share of pizza spots on that corner. Pizza has always been trash but when it's the last resort (I'll review the other two) you do what you gotta do. BUT 3 WHOLE DOLLARS AND FIFTY CENTS FOR A PLAIN SLICE IS ABSURD. The dough is hard. The cheese/sauce/grease ratio is trash. Mind you- I ordered a pepperoni slice so I didn't mind but when I saw that sad plain slice being handed over to me for $3.50...I knew my time with them has run out. I literally just got a slice from the spot on Court St by the movie theater (IYKYK) A pepperoni slice with a medium fruit punch for $4.25. They've never let me down. Go there or to Pinos in the slope or Antonio's on Flatbush if you're really desperate for a slice. Prospect Pizza won't see my hard earned money in 2022 read more

Ordered a pepperoni pie through Grubhub. Delicious pizza, fast delivery, reasonable prices. What else do I need to say? read more

mmm this was actually the best pizza i had on the whole trip. lil pizza shop that i passed every day & there were always people sitting outside eating it & it always looked so good so i had to try it before i left the city. soooooooo mf goood i wanna fly back judt to get it again read more

Prospect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Had a slice of cheese. It was amazing. Real good taste. Authentic. Glad I stumbled on this place.

Doing some work in New York and wanted a slice of pizza this place came up and I wasn't disappointed awesome variety staff was real friendly pizza was delicious and the price is so great that we were stopping in area read more

Prospect Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Was delivered quick and in great condition! I ordered a white pizza pie with pepperoni also ordered a meatball parm sub (was ok :/) read more

Prospect Pizza - White Pizza Pie with Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza is good. Recently ordered lasagna unfortunately was not impressed. Barely any meat and was poorly layered and mostly flat Update: just ordered the baked ziti w chicken. Missing chicken and the Shit is just disgusting. Do not order pasta from here read more

We got a grandma pizza; it was delicious. This will def be my go-to place to order pizza from. Delivery was decent 30m. Since my last review we have been ordering from prospect pizza at least every other week. Sometimes it's hard to understand the guy on the phone and he seems to have trouble understanding us at times, but just be patient! The buffalo wings are THE TINEST little chick wings I've ever had. They taste like they're frozen and heated up (which is prob what they are). I tried them more than once hoping it was just a bad day-- nope! Never add garlic to your pizza, they will just put small mountains of chopped garlic all over it instead of spreading out tiny pieces of garlic. We had to scrape ALL of it off it was disgusting! Still love the grandma the best! Spinach pizza was bland. read more

We're absolutely ecstatic that we've found our pizza delivery!!!! It only took 3 years of living in PLG. We weren't sure what we were getting into when we ordered the eponymous Prospect Pizza (absolutely no description of the toppings) from Prospect Pizza, but based on the great reviews and nice looking photos, we decided to take a chance. It was delicious! We liked it so much that we ordered it again later that week. Prospect Pizza is very generous with their toppings. The pizza was loaded with broccoli, peppers, black olives, sliced sausages, pepperoni, and onions. The delivery is always fast. We love Prospect Pizza. read more

Best pizza in the area. Always friendly staff and great selection by the slice. Lunch deal two plain slices with a soda for 5 bucks, can't beat it! read more

One of the longest wait time for a pizza and wings I've ever experienced. It took 2 hours for them to walk 8 blocks and deliver this pizza which is an obscene amount of time. We called multiple times and each time they said 10-15 minutes which we then waited another 30 mins. Upon arrival the wing sauce was spilled all over the bag. The pizza was cold! They blocked both my number and my friends number after the call and that was when we just asked for an ETA. Overall really shitty delivery even though the pizza was good, after heating it back up in the oven, but who knows, we were starving so it could have been dollar pizza and we wouldn't have known. read more

Prospect Pizza - Wings busted open and sauce spilled - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I order by phone a calzone and first it was 13.50 and the today it was 15 this is ok but the way the guy that I spoke to was rude and i pay for this calzone 20 dollars and i call them back in a nice way telling them that I didn't want a refund I was just complaining about my food That came Burned and he answer me in a bad way that my calzone wasn't burned that he look at it before sending me and I ask him if I could speak to the manager and told me this is no the manager this the owner the owner and he told me that maybe somebody before make good calzone but not know and that the next time they wouldn't do anything for me. I'm so upset. read more

Prospect Pizza - Burned calzone - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York