For context, I rate products and businesses on a simple scale: 5 stars means I love it, 4 stars means I like it, 3 stars is okay, 2 stars means I didn't like it, and 1 star means I hated it or think it's unsafe. 5 stars. I've been coming to Raindancer for years and I honestly can't remember ever having a bad meal here. It's one of those dependable restaurants where you know you're going to leave happy. Back before COVID they had a legendary salad bar and I REALLY wish they would bring it back. I'm not even a huge salad person and I still looked forward to it every time I came here. It was fresh, loaded with options, and honestly one of the best restaurant salad bars around. Raindancer, if you're reading this, bring back the salad bar!!! The ribs here are excellent. Always tender, flavorful, and they give you a very good sized portion. I've brought several friends here over the years and everyone has always enjoyed their meals. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant has a nice rustic feel to it that fits the atmosphere perfectly.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The food is consistently great and the staff has always been friendly and attentive whenever I've visited. Small negative is there are no free refills on soft drinks. I believe it's always been the case here atleast as far back as I can recall. For me it should be a big deal because I live sodas it's an integral part of my dinner. But yet i like it here a lot so I forgive it. That says something. Keeping my soda filled is one was I rate servers. If they do it without me asking they are ontop of their game to me. But Ike I said that's not applicable here. Just keep it in mind. But for me, the crown jewel here is the chocolate mousse pie. It is fantastic. Light, fluffy, rich without being too heavy, topped with whipped cream and little chocolate morsels. It's absolute heaven. They also have a peanut butter mousse pie that I keep telling myself I'm going to try someday, but every time I come here I can't bring myself to pass on the chocolate mousse pie. Maybe one day... although probably not. It's just too good. They have a take out window. Sometimes if I'm in the area I quickly pick some up for desert. It's so worth it. read more

Pros: very friendly staff Cons: [[HIGHLIGHT]]this is an old restaurant and it feels tired. Matted carpet, sticky floors, old decor. It does look like they may have tried to spruce it up at some point but not well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Prices are up there, and the food inconsistent. I had the French onion soup and it was delicious, I followed that with the copped chicken salad and it was awful. Cold pre frozen chicken and absolutely no taste whatsoever to the salad base. Even slapping on salad dressing didn't help. We also ordered the prime rib, now this dish came out perfectly, hot and just as described. It had great flavor. The drinks, soda and ice tea were a ridiculous price, nearly $4 each with no refills. All in all a disappointing meal for almost $100 and nope, no return visit, I believe they are just resting in their laurels of past days. read more

Been here many times over the years. Seems like back in the late 1990's when we first visited the restaurant. Back then it was recognized as a more seafood restaurant but we soon realized that it also was a meat restaurant. Have never been disappointed in the quality of our food or the service throughout our time at this restaurant. For us it's a drive to eat here but we currently drive up to 3 hours to eat at various restaurants in the upstate areas and to lower Hudson places also. Depends on the various food choices we are interested in eating. read more

I am in town visiting family and friends and of course I had to stop at the Raindancer! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It hasn't changed in appearance one bit and has that amazing vibe![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Our server was superb and very attentive. When I shared my food allergies, not only did she share it with the chef, the chef, Steve, came out to introduce himself. I felt very well taken care of throughout this experience. I had a bacon cheeseburger with smashed potatoes. It was delicious! I am actually returning tonight with more friends. I highly recommend you checking out The Raindancer when you are in the area. read more

See all

This place is great!!! No idea how anyone has a bad review here. Host was accommodating, server was outstanding, food was really really good. Price point was right on. We literally drove 2 hours for this meal and the delicious coconut creme pie, with a macaroon type crust! Maybe the best desert I've ever had. I had the filet and my partner had the prime rib. Both were cooked exactly to our liking. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The decor is also perfect for a steakhouse.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Loved it. I would highly suggest making a reservation beforehand. Other than that, Everything was outstanding read more

Went to Raindancer with my husband for my birthday, this is the lobster I was served. Clearly old with a hard shell and appearing freezer burnt not fresh. We asked the waitress to get Walter to address the matter. The claws were so tough the claw crackers broke while trying to use them. Walter came over to the table and screamed "Put it on YELP, leave a bad review I don't care you are paying". I had not even mentioned leaving a review, we just wanted a new lobster. He then told a male waiter to go stand by the table and make sure we paid for the lobster. We will not be going back there again. Just remember this is the food quality you can expect from them the next time you want to go out for dinner. read more

used to be a fantastic restaurant. Been told by more than one reputable source that the son is running the once popular restaurant into the ground. Apparently more coke in the kitchen than in the soda machine! We stopped going. Sad how bad it is from what was in its heyday read more

First - our server Kim was amazing! She was so personable and patient! It's been a while since we've been and I was surprised to see the menu has changed completely. I was disappointed to see the salad bar is gone - that was always one of my favorites. However, I understand that Covid did away with a lot of these options. Okay - prices are definitely very different as well. I guess I don't understand a salad being $15-$16. So I passed on that. Of course hubby went for the tried and true, prime rib. I opted for the seafood trio. Hubby said the prime rib was as good as he remembered. Sadly, my seafood trio fell a little flat. The shrimp and scallops were nice sized but swimming in a pool of grease rendering them soggy. The romaine leaf on the bottom did nothing to help. Four scallops- two were undercooked, two were overdone. Four shrimp were cooked nicely but could have been better had there not been so much oil on the plate. The haddock was okay. I did also enjoy a glass of white sangria. I wish they bottled it - very crisp and delicious! If we go back, I'll definitely get the prime rib because the seafood doesn't seem to be prepared the way it used to be. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant was decorated beautifully for Christmas complete with carols playing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It was a nice evening - and the service was excellent. read more

See all

We drove a half hour to get there because they were having some great food specials. We went mid afternoon because we knew it would be busy, we were amazed that it wasn't but there was a note on the door saying their "reservations" were full and no walk ins. Their ad said nothing about reservations being needed. Luckily they let us sit at the bar to eat. We felt very sorry for the over worked bartender "Marybeth" as she was by herself and they dumped this on her. She is the only reason we gave 4 stars. She was kind and very accommodating. We gave her a great tip because we felt very bad for what management had done to her with all the extra work. They obviously didn't count on the popularity of thier 2 day midweek half price sale. Hopefully better planning next time as we heard many unhappy people as we were leaving. Marybeth should get a raise! read more

I have been dining at raindancer since 1988 having both lunch and dinner numerous times. I have never had a bad meal there and service has always been wonderful and fast. As far as I am concerned this is the only place to get a prime rib, always done perfectly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Love the privacy of a booth.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I do miss the salad bar. read more

Attended a catered event where I had pre-selected prime rib from the options. Others got the chicken parm or seafood lasagna. Crisp veggies, a variety of cheeses, and very large shrimp were at cocktail hour. Everyone was very pleased with their food and most the service. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The room with all the windows was very cold and it was awkward wearing a coat to eat like that.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I've eaten here before for late lunch/early dinners. It's okay. Really the only "restaurant" around. Not my vibe but nice for the area and food is always good.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

We had reservations for my bf birthday, because the last time we were there it was awesome. This time was totally NOT WORTH THE MONEY Normally you get soup or salad with your dinner NOW you had to pay extra - my bf got the strip steak which came with a little bowl of rice and I mean little bowl no other sides just rice - he ordered Roasted Red Pepper soup and we paid extra and for roaster red pepper soup it was more of a chili looking soup - not sure on that one - we also had the lemon pepper chicken - you couldn't taste the chicken there was so much lemon pepper on it I couldn't eat it and I order the soup as a side which was creamy chicken vegetable - there was more veggies than chicken and the only veggies I saw was peas and carrots - we were VERY DISAPPOINTED in our meal and have wished we chosen elsewhere to go Our server was very nice, that was the only pleasant thing we can say read more

food was good, and service was lovely! [[HIGHLIGHT]]it's a nice little place to get a bite[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. [[HIGHLIGHT]]we even had a little fireplace by our table[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]! read more

Raindancer Restaurant - one of their cocktails, i forget what it's called though - American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

Service and menu selection were great. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant itself is excellent in its decor and comfortable dining options.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We had a pork chop and stuffed haddock, both were great. read more

It was my 77th birthday and my wife asked me where I'd like to go for dinner. I chose the Raindancer because of the extensive menu. They had a Summer Special starting and I used that menu starting with 25 steamed little neck clams, then snow crab claws. My wife had the Prime Rib which was perfectly cooked. Our waitress was Amber and she was fantastic! She was very helpful with the menu, explaining any questions we might have. [[HIGHLIGHT]]If you are looking for a very neat, clean and nicely decorated restaurant, this is the place.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Over priced ...long long wait for our food and ultimately minimal portions for the price ...out waitress was in denial about how long we waited while other much large parties came and went...this was our third time trying Raindancer hoping our previous disappointing experiences were isolated.....not to be ... We live locally but will not be going back. ... read more

I recently had an excellent lunch here with a group of friends. We were a bit of a handful and the server was unfazed by our numerous questions regarding the menu, add-ons, rounds of coffee and drinks, etc. He got our orders down to a T. The grilled salmon salad was excellent, as was the chocolate mousse and Mexican coffee. I would return! read more

Raindancer Restaurant - Mexican coffee with a rock sugar stirrer - American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

Came for my birthday dinner with some family from Tennessee that was visiting and this has always been one of my favorite places, unfortunately I won't be going back, the manager is rude, condescending and is not willing to accommodate when someone is unhappy with their meal. We ordered three filets, one delmomico and one prime rib not one of the steaks were cooked properly, they were charred on the outside and raw in the middle, we each had about four bites that was cooked properly. We sent the delmonico back but decided to just deal with the others, it came out just as bad as the first. The manager came out and immediately I could tell that he wasn't going to help us, he came up to the table and stood between myself and my cousin at the table, he was so close that I could smell him and feel his body heat coming off of him, this made me very uncomfortable. He argued that it was only the center of the steak that gets cooked properly there. When one person in our group expressed that they didn't care for the prime rib and it was too salty his response was "well have you ever had prime rib before" in a VERY rude tone, I have never been made to feel this way before and I was embarrassed that I brought my family to someplace that would treat their customers this way. The waitress was wonderful and she seemed scared when we weren't happy with our food which is a huge red flag for me, how mean are you to your employees that they're scared when someone's food isn't cooked properly. Bottom line, DO NOT go here unless you want every temperature in one steak, it will go from well done to raw and you'll have just a few bites the way you like it and you just have to deal with it because the manager doesn't care about anything except his bottom line. I will let the rest of my friends and family know not to support this business. read more

The food here has been good with good portions in the past. It has never been inexpensive but the value was within reason. The menu recently changed and we couldn't believe the prices. The salad options range from $16 to $24, that's right, for salad! A hamburger is $20. In addition to prices increasing, we found the portions were smaller, even on the French onion soup. Good luck getting out of there for lunch for less than $25 - $30 per person, before tips. We won't be back. read more

Raindancer has gone so down hill it's not even funny. From the quality of food to the quality of service. Such a disappointment, as this used to be a nice spot for a good meal (not any more) We were offered the early bird special for an extra $5 each. This included salad, dessert, and coffee or tea. We decided to do this and when coming to desert we were told our options. Made selection and instead of it being included we were charged for both full price. When notifying the waitress she said we ordered the wrong options (she told us our options). You'd think they credit this mistake but nope, they took 2 sodas "off" (we never drank them). $100 meal for 2 ppl and a 3 year old.... Ridiculous. Such a shame and the food was really subpar for a place that used to be above those around. Don't go here, go down the road to The Rustic Loft, much better service, atmosphere, and food! read more

Raindancer Restaurant - Our bill for 2 adults and a 3 year old... - American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

Their Early, Sunset Menu, 3 courses for $29, cannot be beat. Choose a Caesar or garden salad. An entree of fish, steak, or chicken dishes. A choice of desserts. My favorite is filet mignon tips au poivre with a baked potato (you can decide how peppery you want your sauce). So easy to get to just off Okeechobee Blvd on Palm Beach Lakes Blvd. Plenty of easy parking right around the restaurant. Give it a try. You'll get great service (ask for Ted) and delicious food at a great price during these high price times. read more

Walked in with my wife and my mother to have a nice lunch. Parking lot had MAYBE five cars in it. Waited to be seated by the hostess who was VERY condescending and rude.Turned around and walked right back out. Will never even think about going back. read more

We used to LOVE this place. We haven't been in quite a while. We ordered for pick up last night and no one had anything positive to say. I see they are cutting corners and no longer concerned with quality. I ordered the filet salad and it was all the bottom of the lettuce chunks of iceberg, and nothing really in it besides the lettuce other than very fatty meat and same with the bacon. The portions and quality of everyone else's meals were awful. Over priced for poor quality meals. We will not be back. read more

Great fresh food und friendly service . I had the steak and blue salad and it was excellent

The food was not prepared correctly and I asked for a new fillet. They wanted to try to fix the fillet by cooking it more. It was charred outside and raw inside. There was no fixing it. The manager came over to be sure they could not just cook the fillet more. No apology. The impression was they did not want to cook the additional steak. Really? What about taking some pride in the meal you serve? The waiter kept backing away from the table while we were still asking questions. He did not know the specials. He argued with us about a dessert item. Bottom line I left a review on their website ending with this, "waiter, manager and owner should all be ashamed." read more

Everything we had was delicious from the French onion soup being cheesy and warming your insides , to the buffalo quesadillas with blue cheese . Penne à la vodka great choice as well pasta was cooked perfectly. Service good waiter was attentive. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance very nice fire place music but at a low volume nice bar all around great place for a late dinner .[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Raindancer Restaurant - French onion soup - American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

Our family had made reservations for a bereavement luncheon and was given a menu with prices. After the event it was noticed that the prices were much higher than what was on our menu. After talking to the owner (Walt) he said it was more expensive because of the time of day. He knew the time of the reservation but never said it would be more expensive for that time. It was on a Monday their slowest day. We were finished way before dinner time so it was a stupid excuse for marking up the prices. VERY DISHONEST person. Not worth the money. read more

Good food. Hit or miss with customer service Haven't had a good dessert yet.. won't try again read more

We were treated poorly by the waiter he didnt want to b bothered. Didn't like or want to answer ?'s about food or dessert items when taking order or possibly didnt know the answers after asking him how long he has worked there, him stating over 5+yrs walked away from table several times while talking to him. Guest we were with wasn't pleased with the way her steak was cooked charred on outside raw & cold inside & he kept insisting to just warm it up again when she was asking for another one to b cooked properly med well & hot. He seemed disgusted. Took over 45 mins for her order to be done correctly while unfortunately we sat & ate. He also suggested to another guest would u like sauce for your steak & never mentioned there was an additional charge. We were addressed by a manger also about the order which he also did not want to comply to the customer to cook another. We expected for the price of our meals better & more polite service & respect from the manger!! read more

I want to first start by saying that the staff at Raindancer is extremely attentive and friendly. They are constantly checking on you, you never have to wait around for someone to refill your glass or wonder if they are going to ever come back with the extra sauce you requested. They always seem to anticipate your needs. Five stars for the staff, every time I have visited! The atmosphere is also relaxing and welcoming. That being said, they last 3-4 times that we visited, the food was mediocre at best. On one visit I ordered a "chowder" that was just a mixture of water and flour. It was inedible. On another visit, I ordered the seafood casserole. I've ordered it several times in the past and really enjoyed it. But on this occasion, it again resembled the chowder in that it was just a flour and water mixture, lacking flavor and cheese. It seemed like maybe they ran out of the proper ingredients and tried just thickening up the sauce by adding more flour. It was certainly not the same delicious dish I had ordered in the past. Again inedible. My husband is a creature of habit and orders the West Coast Salad every single time and he absolutely loves it. However on our most recent visit, he said it just didn't taste right and couldn't eat it. Very disappointing. We continue to frequent this establishment because of the staff and the atmosphere, but unfortunately the food appears to be going downhill. I hope that it improves, because it really was a good place to get a delicious meal previously. read more

Wow has this place gone down down hill. Haven't been here in 20 years and will not be back. Waitress was great but probably a little too honest. Wife had scallops that were not cooked completely , actually cold in the center ( almost 40.00 cost ) , I don't usually agree with her but I said send them back immediately after I tasted them . The waitress came back and said " well the cook says we haven't had any complaints tonite !!!! Ok they were cooked trust me ... when she brought the scallops back the plate was extremely hot , what an insult they threw them in microwave and over cooked them ... we left the whole plate of scallops on the table and left. And yes we paid for them . This place isn't cheap for being in Amsterdam NY it's kinda of pricey actually ... I don't recommend. Over priced and food below average. read more

It's tough to give Raindancer a 2 star rating given how good the service was and that my personal experience was worthy of a 5 star review. However, some of the other people I came with had experiences that were just too bad to not bring up. Three of them ordered burgers - two mediums and one well done. The burgers took forever to come out and were burnt to the point that all they could taste was the char on the outsides of the burgers. Do better. read more

Always excellent food, ambiance is great. Staff is competent and helpful. Never have had a bad experience read more

Sadly disappointed in this establishment. If you don't have a reservation, even on a week night such as a Tuesday, well don't expect to be getting a table. We were told the wait without a reservation would be an hour long. Meanwhile, as we were at the hostess stand, the group ahead and behind us was told it would be 20 minutes. (They each had 3 people in their group and we had 6). When I questioned the wait time, we were told it was because they were under staffed. This seems to be every time we try to have dinner at this place without a reservation even. We left and went down the road to Nicolino's where a reservation was not needed, the service was one of the best and the food was amazing; which is not the first time we have done this. The other times we were turned away for not having a reservation, we weren't even given a wait time. I don't think we will be trying to go to this restaurant again. read more

Omg I ate here the other day, and it was awful . I'll be honest. I never ever had anything bad from here before, but this was horrible. I ordered a burger, and it was nasty. idk what they did differently. It was disgusting tasting. I dont think I'll be back any time soon. read more

Son and I were down for his General Motors training and decided to stop and try this place since The Pizza Place next door was closed. Food and service was great. Left a great tip on our bill, 40% and loved that the waitress thought it was a mistake and at least came and asked us. Top Notch! read more

I came into this restaurant blind sighted and I was not impressed to say the least. I got the New York strip steak, a caesar salad, and a side of mashed potatoes. The steak was absolutely horrible, there was no seasoning on the steak and most of all the steak was full of fat, so much fat that more than half of the steak was uneatable. The mashed potatoes were actually not terrible and had a good amount of seasoning, the Caesar salad was average. The service was good, and the ambiance of the restaurant looked like a 1980s garage. Many flies were flying around the restaurant. All I have to say is please do not come to this place! It's very overpriced and what your paying for isn't even worth it. read more

Great food. Timely service. Servers were attentive. Always a go to when we are in town.

Old school restaurant with a huge salad bar and generous portions. Very crowded during the track season, but friendly service. The salad bar features traditional vegetables, coleslaw, potato salad, but they also have fresh made bread and huge blocks of good cheese you can cut for yourself. The entrees we had were solid; my scallops were a bit over cooked but it's hard to pan sear scallops in a huge industrial kitchen. Pro-tip, no free refills on soda; they charge by the glass. read more

Raindancer Restaurant - Scallops ($20). Big portion. - American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

We don't live far from Raindancer but I have yet to be disappointed with anything I've ordered from there. The Creamy Garlic Parmesan Pasta is amazing if you like garlic. I definitely added shrimp to mine and they're decent sized shrimp. The Prime Rib also perfectly cooked and tasty. Service is hit or miss just like any restaurant. The booths definitely need to be refreshed. read more