New to Randy's Pizza after recently passing through the area to Durham. My 12 y/o granddaughter was happy I stopped after we both found the NY style pepperoni pizza to be great tasting. She loved the plain-by-request side salad with fresh crisp greens & a few julienne-cut carrots. A more "grownup" side salad was the best I had at any restaurant, in a very long time. I also ordered a Stromboli for myself which turned out to be huge enough for 2. That was a good thing, because the Stromboli tasted so good my granddaughter helped finish it off. The marinara was so on point I regret not having ordered an extra serving. The staff was friendly and accommodating to customers as lunch time business started to pickup shortly after 11:00 am open. I usually read Yelp reviews before I visit a restaurant. And sometimes I have to discern whether to chance victory. Randy's Pizza at TJ Alexander was a victory! Thank you for a very satisfying lunch. read more

Last time I will order pizza from this location. I have patronized this location several times and usually just eat the pizza and be done. But I'm so tired of wasting my money at this place. Pizza crust is so yucky!! I can't even find the words to describe it. Pizza is tasteless. The one I purchased on yesterday was not good. I just chalked it up as a lesson learned and will stick with the Randy's location on Miami Blvd. read more

Everything I've tried was delicious!! I recommend the white pizza. It takes a few minutes to get your order because it's made to order. Well worth it!!! read more

Pizza was Excellent you can't deny that. Nice thin plenty of ingredients. What I could do without are the antics of the less than funny staff that spent most of their time sliding across the floor on a towel, hugging, high fiving, and uttering nonsense. Except for the little guy making pizzas it was more like watching an idiots version of "whose line is it". At one point "bearded guy" dropped back and shot a rolled up napkin into the sauce pan that little guy was using to make pizzas. Seriously ?????? I saw it happen. Red shirt guy uttered " what's your f$$&@ problem" and they laughed it off. That was it. Seriously folks. Someone relies on you to run their business with professionalism and most likely the welfare of them and their family is relying on you. Grow up. Yes, despite it all, I will be back. read more

Easily the best Pizza in Durham. According to my partner, who is from the Bronx, this is NY Pizza at its finest in Durham. Love the thin slices and the subs are also delicious. No other pizza in town can compete . There's nothing like a date night over pizza slices. The side salad was really good too. read more

Delivery order: 12" grilled chicken sandwich with onion rings. Had to order $10 to get that delivery. Food took about 40 minutes to arrive at my hotel door. I opened up the sandwich to see that it had tons of mayonnaise and cheese. I asked for easy on the mayo and no cheese. I open up the sandwich and see very little pieces of chicken. I didn't eat more than a few bites. The onion rings were delicious. Los Angeles native stuck in North Carolina read more

Not a fan. This is my 2nd time at Randy's. I thought the first time was okay but I had tried white pizza and it was bland. Today I had the deluxe and I was seriously very disappointed. The pizza had zero flavor and a flimsy crust. I won't try again. Maybe fresher mozzarella would help. read more

I used to love this place, but lately they're the gang that can't shoot straight--I order my usual pizza and get some indeterminate pie with a gluten-free crust. I order pepperoni and get plain cheese. And then they want the mistake pizzas back which only makes me hungrier. I'll order somewhere else from now on. read more

Very disappointed. Placed an order for delivery. 14in. Kickin Hawaiian price on menu was $16.95. I was charged $17.50. I was charged a 2.00 delivery fee even though it clearly states FREE DELIVERY($15.00 min.) When I asked the person on the phone her response was, " Oh,I don't know anything about that." Delivery time stated was 45min to a hour. Actual delivery time was one hour 10min. After all that I really just wanted a salad. There wasn't even a fork with my delivered order. So I couldn't even eat that. I won't be ordering from them again. Again disappointed. read more

This location of Randy's is disgusting. People eating while they are preparing food, right in front of you. Rude service. Tables are dirty right after opening. They are always out of some toppings. Water dripping from the ceiling. The ricotta in the center of my calzone was actually cold. The marinara is watered down. The kitchen I in serious need of a deep clean. I don't know how this one stays in business. The only location of Randy's that is well run anymore is the one in RTP on Miami Blvd. read more

Don't go here the white male cashier is very rude. He is not polite when taking the order. My pizza was not cooked all the way and and then when to tell him. He was going to redo my order and he threw the box with the undone pizza to the side angry. He is very rude to his coworkers too. I use to be a manager and Id fire him if I had to put up with his attitude read more

9/24/16: I ordered two Randy's strombolis at 8.07 p.m. it was not delivered until 9.22 p.m. I noted when I called to make sure all sauces were put in the box when delivered. NO sauces in the box so I called the manager on duty and demanded the driver re-deliver the sauces. The manager said he fixed my order and that he put the sauces ontop of the box...but the driver might have taken the sauces off ... he confirmed he would call the delivery driver and have him re-deliver. ..well 9.45 NO driver and we ended up eating the DRY A** strombolis. Waisted 27.00 which included a nice tip.. This really turned me off from buying anything else from Randy's Pizza. read more

I needed a slice not a whole pie. I found Randy's Pizza. The young lady preparing the orders was on the phone and with no gloves put my slice in the oven to heat up. I kindly asked her if she can wear gloves when handling my food please. The young lady caught an attitude half heated my pizza and the throw the slice in a box without paper. The guy preparing the sandwiches was picking his nose without gloves then took the same hand he had in his nostrils and put the bread in the oven to preheat. Never again! Thank you Randy's for the experience as I will not be visiting your establishment for a second time nor would I recommend it to friends and family. read more

I absolutely adore this place. I usually eat in (cause, you know, beer and pizza) or carry out, but I just got delivery for the first time. Driver was super nice, even offered to take it inside for me since I had a twisted ankle. They also have the only pizza box that can go into my fridge -- zabox, a local company. It does take a little more time than the chain pizza places because they do it in a real pizza oven, fresh made, rather than run something from the freezer down a conveyor belt. Sandwiches and chicken are great too. Not slap your grandmother good, but very tasty and super good for the price point. Usually at least a couple of good beers on tap. All in all, for the price, you can't beat this place! read more

I love the salads here! Believe it or not, the best Greek salad around is at a spot famous for pizzas! The pricing is great and The staff is so friendly. Love it! read more

Their cheese steak is great! Definitely in the top 5 maybe top 3 that I've had and I eat them at every Italian restaurants go to.

Generally the best I've found in my immediate area. Customer service isn't particularly great, and they've overcooked it a few times, but still compares well to a lot of the other chains. read more

I got a sausage and mushroom pizza. Wow this place is by far one of the best pizza places I have ever been and good prices. Nice people in the store too. read more

I did not like my $26 Elias pizza. I love to support local but this was a terrible pizza. I should has stuck to Red Barron.

This place has gone totally down hill in the past year. So much so that we will NEVER order from them again. We can let a couple of late deliveries go but not when they are an hour late, the pizza was basically raw with hardly any ingredients and they forgot part of our order. The person on the phone who ended up being the manager, did not offer any apologies or refund. They do not know what they are doing any more! read more

I've been to Randy's several times and enjoy their pizza ands subs. I was a little disappointed with my last visit though. When we got to the counter there were several people behind the counter working and cooking. Th person who took out order seemed distracted. The service was not great when the food was ready either. This was not typical of what I've experienced on the past I had a calzone and my husband had wings. The calzone was slightly undercooked and a little watery but was okay overall. The chicks wings were meaty and hot. The health rating was 98 and the place wa pretty neat and orderly. I hope this was just a one time experience. This place has potential so we will try it again soon. read more

Stopped by for a quick bite for lunch. Had never been there before. Had the two slices and a drink. Very good pizza! Crust was perfect. Just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. Would have been 5 stars had it had just a touch more sauce. Highly recommended if you are in the area. read more

Randy's is one of the best local chains around. The pizza is thin crust, and always perfectly cooked. When I lived in the area, I ordered from this Randy's all the time. The staff was friendly, and the prices are really, really cheap for the quality and quantity of food they serve. Randy's, could you please open a Washington, D.C. branch? read more

We are done with this place. The pizza is terrible, the amount of cheese on the pizza was very small ( we ordered extra cheese, never get it) we have complained a couple of times, no one is listening, we taking our hard earned money somewhere else. read more

Excellent pizza reminds me of Montreal style we go at least once a week. Fairly priced I have been going here now for a few years...They must have changed ownership the place is going downhill... still love the crust but they are getting cheap on the toppings ... had given them 5 stars going to drop it down to three read more

After reading some positive reviews I decided to give Randy's Pizza on T.W. Alexander a try. Got 2 large pizzas Thursday. They were the largest pizzas I've encountered in a very long time. BUT the skimpiest amount of cheese I've ever seen. I'll be trying elsewhere. read more

My family and I love love love this pizza. We can't find another pizza (place) we all agree on but this one. They have delivered to our place in apex before and did it with a little persuasion. Not sure if they do it regularly. I could eat their pizza everyday. But I'd be hitting the 200lb mark quick. read more

The best pizza in town, i definitely recommend the steak and cheese sub. The pizza has an amazing taste, they are very friendly and just the food in general it's tasty. read more

Wife out of town. Tried Randy's for the first time. Three days later and I've faced two 14" supremes. Yah take your five stars.

Great customer service! Food good and price friendly! Definitely would recommend. Plenty of choices and delivery option available!

Boy Randy's, you guys sure know how to sh** on your customers. This is the second time we received our order two hours late and the pizza was cold. The first time you guys delivered only half of our order and this time had to be reminded to deliver the pizza. Busy or not, you can kick orders out as they come in and maybe your drivers would get a better tip. Pizza Hut tastes better, is cheaper, and at least they deliver on time. That's the last you'll get from us. read more

First of all the customer service here is non existent and the menu is overpriced for the quality of the food. The pizza is huge but very thin and really greasy. It wasn't awful, but what was really disappointing was size and price of their hot wings. They also don't offer and family meal combos such as pizza and wings. I'm sure we'll eat here again but not too often. read more

Hector is the best pizza maker. I always order the fresh mozzarella with cheese and basil. Perfect when he makes it! Thanks!

The customer service here is garbage, quality of food has went to crap, pizza so greasy it falls to pieces. Tried to order via phone an several occasions and was placed on hold immediately every time for over 10-15 minutes. The last time I was placed on hold for 25 mins so I hung up and drove there and they weren't busy at all, staff just f-ing off and playing loud rap music, looked like a hangout not a pizza place. read more

The best Hawaiian Pizza I have tried! Canadian bacon, bacon, pineapple, chicken and the kicker Jalapenos! Yummm, so flavorful! Beautiful crust done right! We will be back! read more

Well, I must say after recently moving down here I'm a bit picky with my pizza since I'm from NY. Went in here for a quick bite for dinner since we were in a rush. Some people in there but nobody in line. Took 10 minutes just to get somebody to start talking to us. Then they told us it would be another 15-20 minutes for our food (sub and two slices). Needless to say we ended up leaving because we were in a bit of a time crunch, but I was just kind of ticked off by the customer service. Oh, and the prices were pretty steep. Won't be going back. read more

I had lunch at this new location on Saturday, Dec. 31, 2011. The food was every bit as good as the other locations, and the atmosphere is even better. Same great giant slices. As far as thin crust pizza goes, this is as close to New York City pizza as it gets. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that these guys are importing the water or something. :o) read more

Lazy when there's no manager there. I called and spoke with a young woman who asked to place me on hold. I then proceed to wait for ten minutes, but but no one came back to the phone. I thought, "okay, maybe they were busy"? I drove down there...still on hold mind you. Fifteen minutes had passed and when I walked in, there was no one in line. I tell the woman I had spoken with on the phone I had been on hold all this time and she said, "I didn't know you were on hold". How the heck did you NOT know when you were the one who PUT me on hold! She acted like she had no idea I called and the other guys just all shook their heads like they didn't have a clue. I was so angry after that, I went to Subway. Sorry Randy's, but your adults can't leave the store in the care of the kids apparently, because all they were interested in was closing shop. Very poor customer service. read more

Don't waste your time or money here. Employees are nasty and the restaurant is not clean. Order your pizza from Slice of NY. I can't say enough to avoid this restaurant. read more

This is my local pizza joint and I couldn't be more satisfied for NC pizza. It's some of the best I've had down here, NY style of course. Staff is really friendly, and they have some good lunch specials! Definitely a must try if you are in the area. read more