Rays New York Pizza

I've stopped here a couple of times. The pizza was pretty good. Nothing outstanding but worth…read morerevisiting. However we ordered one night late apparently right before closing. The person on the phone was kind of rude, but it seemed like she just wasn't hearing us so we really didn't think anything of it. When we got there to pick it up, she was very rude and said she told us she was closing and basically walked out the door, handing us our food. It was unbelievable.

We stopped in at Anthony's on a day trip to Beach Haven. We have found that pizza on the beach is a…read morewonderfully easy way to enjoy the day. Anthony's was easy on and off of 72, we ordered ahead and our onion and sausage pie was cooked to perfection. It was ready when we arrived and it made for a wonderful day.

Menu 1 of 2

See all

Old school pizza parlor.

Pietro's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria

3.1(108 reviews)

0.4 mi

We have been coming to Pietro's for over 30 years. Last night by far was our worst experience…read more Salads were small. The Calamari, which used to be excellent was terrible. Over cooked, rubbery with a small amount and almost zero rings. It tasted frozen. The waitress was sweet and said Nick was not there, she did not take it off the bill, and we left more than half. The chicken cacciatore was over cooked with enormous amounts of green peppers. Giving this place a rest as this was the second poor meal in the past two trips.

Picked up a margherita and a cheese pizza from Pietro's last weekend since most places in LBI were…read moreclosed. It was extremely good. The takeout area was very busy but the staff were hustling.

Sign that I loved and laughed at

Another view of the grandma pie

See all

Shrimp scampi

Fusaro Pizza

3.3(117 reviews)

1.1 mi

Great food and they do so much for the community . They rescued the 6th grade Fun Day celebration…read morea few years ago and I'll never forget them for that

Had a half mushroom/ half plain pie delivered to Manafirkin Brewery! Delivered nice and hot! This…read morewas during boozy bingo and they found us inside the crowded room. The mushroom appeared and tasted so fresh and I'm sorry i didn't get the other side with sausage The crust was a meal by itself. I'm actually planning my next meal from them as I'm eating this on lol They also remembered the plates and forks .(And the craft beers at Manafirkin Brewery are all so good too)

Buffalo chicken & Hawaiian

2 locations

See all

Corner piece Lucy special.

Andi's Pizza & Grill

3.8(8 reviews)

1.1 mi

I enjoy the pizza here but my favorite sandwich has to be the cheesesteak panini! Awesome! Owner is…read moresuch a nice guy. Service is always good and food always tastes fresh. Give them a shot if you're in the area.

I ordered 2 pies and they weren't delivered. No wonder they charge upfront, once paid, they don't…read morecare about customer...not even an apology.

Most Recent Menu

See all

Most Recent Menu

Brazzi Wood Fired Trattoria & Pizza

2.8(236 reviews)

0.3 mi

The atmosphere was good. Our only problem was that the outside seating obstructed the handicapped…read moreramp. Service was very good. Our Italian wedding soup was good but not remarkable. Sandwiches were ok. The godfather could have used more meat. It arrived without oil and vinegar and when it was requested, Italian dressing was delivered rather than olive oil. ‍The meatball parm had tasty meatballs but also could have used another meatball. I've had pizza here previously which was excellent so we will return and just skip the sandwiches.

Run far away from this place. My friend and I ate there. She couldn't finish her meal. My chicken…read morepiccata and the chef never put capers in it!! When waitress asked- he put a total of 5 capers in the huge dish. They have a Spanish cook who never uses garlic in anything!! Everything tastes blah. My friend got spaghetti squash with chicken. The squash stuck together and there was too much butter. Nothing had flavor. Even the bread was tasteless! Zero garlic on anything!!!!!! They took the squash off the bill but they should've taken everything off! Horrible! Tasteless, zero garlic in an Italian restaurant!!! What happened to this restaurant it used to be so good!!!!it's beyond horrible!! Run far away. It should get zero stars! We were both really sick after we left

Half the dining area

Grandma pie and a sausage and broccoli rhab pie

See all

Homemade everything from scratch with incredible ingredients

Joey's Pizza & Pasta

2.7(103 reviews)

3.7 mi

Nice little spot on 72W ,,, my wife and I have eaten there the last 2 summers while staying on LBI…read more... recommended to us by a year round resident a I was inquiring about places with whole wheat pasta .. excellent vodka sauce .. good service and value

The Pizza is excellent! This location and ship bottom. Ive been coming here for past 30 years.read more

Complimentary garlic bread

See all

Seafood lasagna

Mama Maria's Pizza

4.1(39 reviews)

2.4 mi

Mama Maria's pizza was pretty fast fulfilling our online order, so service was quick. That pleased…read moreus the most. The price point is fair. The interior is kind of small, and has a few booths to sit in. When I came inside I noticed they also have pizza by the slice, which is good if you need a little something to keep you going. The taste of our pizzas was okay: not bad, but not glorious. Crust was on more of the flat side, not ready. The sauce was a tad sweet for my preference.

Best pizza around. Staff is always friendly. Love the "local" feel. Very prompt response to…read morecustomers. Clean. Casual. You can buy uncooked pizza balls to make your own at home.

Mama Maria's cheese pizza with a little bit of added Parmesan cheese. Yummmmm!

See all

Pizza in the car. There's no better way to ride!

ManaFirkin Brewing Company

4.4(63 reviews)

0.2 mi

Everything you could possibly want in a brewery. Ample parking. Plenty of seating inside and out…read more Food trucks and live music. Nice merchandise and lots of canned beer to go. Friendly staff. Most importantly, the beer is solid. I failed to get a full headcount but there must have been about twenty on tap when we visited on a Sunday afternoon in May. Stouts, tripels, IPA's, lagers, Kölsch, cream ales, seltzers, etc. Something for everyone and all of it very good. It was crowded but not overwhelmingly packed so it was a nice atmosphere. If we didn't live over an hour away we would come a lot more regularly, but for now we bought a few beers to bring home and look forward to tucking into them this summer.

Great variety of beers of course. I had a couple flights more good than bad. We really enjoyed the…read moreatmosphere food truck with pizza on. It was very good friendly service. Plenty of seating.

See all

Calloway's Restaurant & Bar

3.6(165 reviews)

2.8 mi

The overall layout of this place was pretty nice. They had high top tables, large bar area, seating…read moreand standard seating. The decor was pretty cool a lot of older stuff. The menu looked pretty good, but I was only there for a quick stop in. So I only had an order of wings. The wings were very good. I would recommend them. I look forward to coming back to this place and trying a lot more stuff. The service was very pleasant. It is located in the same parking lot as a driving range and a miniature golf so it has a lot to offer overall if you're looking for something to do and then stopping in for something to eat or a drink. I will be trying this again for sure. Looking forward to making a new review with much more detail on the food

I want to warn others that Calloway's is charging a 3% "processing fee" on debit card transactions…read more It is important for customers to know that in New Jersey, surcharging debit cards is not permitted under the law. Check for yourself, a quick search on Gemini or Grok yields the same response "No, it is generally not legal for a NJ restaurant to charge a 3% fee on a debit card transaction, even if they label it as a "credit card" fee." When I questioned the manager about this, I was met with excuses rather than a resolution. Point is that management can help prevent this by adding the debit card fee everywhere the rule is posted. It is clear this practice is about padding the restaurant's bottom line rather than covering costs. While our server was wonderful and not at fault, the management's lack of transparency is unacceptable. I like Callaway's but don't like their management who take no responsibility in rectifying this simple problem.

Bartender Sign!

Fried Crabcake sandwich with sweet potato fries.

See all

Interior

39° North

3.7(73 reviews)

1.0 mi

I don't often rate a place this low. I don't know if I ever have. Let's just start with. It's a…read morediner, which is simple. The seating is typical. It appears to be reasonably newly remodeled, but the air conditioning was nonexistent. Sweating in my seat was not comfortable. The server seemed to have a bit of a chip on her shoulder. It took a extended period of time for her to return just to place our initial order setting that aside we figured we are good to go 45 minutes later we finally got our two eggs over easy with sides couldn't be much more simple than that 45 minutes. Wait was insane. They were not busy either. So to the most important part of the food we waited 45 mns for. 2 eggs over easy came out over hard. The sausage was sitting on the grill too long clearly potato's just ok. Sour dough toast was pretty good but at this point we are already sour on this location. I have noticed a lot of people complain about the pricing but I didn't see it as too crazy until we ended up sitting in a diner for over an hour. With the above avg prices at least do a good job. The table next to us ordered an eggs Benedict and there were no eggs on it! I thought they were kidding but nope. Table across from us left prob 35mns before us and the table was still not clear. Terrible. Maybe just an unfortunate day and things happen but this had so many levels of bad I will not be giving it another shot sorry.

Decor reminds me of spots we hit up in Key West, Fla., very tropical and bright…read more The menu is vast and caters to all palates. The Kosher breakfast was delicious and the Not So Kosher breakfast was also delicious. Nonna's Cure was a new item which was a must have and I will be ordering when I return. Good place to hit before hanging at LBI.

Blueberry pancakes

See all

Queso birria braised short rib quesadilla & Mediterranean mushroom tacos

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Christy M.

10 years ago

Having been in the pizza business for many years, I have not tried the pizza locally, but now that I am I have to say Rays is my favorite. Good crust and cheese, sauce is not too sweet and the crust is thin and the pizza is not undercooked..... yay!!! Wings are really great and I love the variety of flavors for the wings so you never have to get bored. read more

Jane K.

10 years ago

Your review helps others learn about great local businesses. I was so happy to have a really good gluten free pizza! Please don't review this business if you received a freebie for writing this review, or if you're connected in any way to the owner or employees. read more

Andrew B.

3 years ago

Best food I had in a long time. Cheese steak was on point and huge. Fries were crispy. My Cesar salad with chicken was the absolute best in a very long time. I'll be going back every week for it. read more

Michael K.

11 years ago

Always great food! Pizza is second to none. The specialty pies are phenomenal! Haven't had a dinner I wouldn't have again!

Brian C.

3 years ago

Always perfect everytime we go never lets us down yet !!! Food service always excellent

Ray V.

15 years ago

Timely delivery and great sicilian pizza!

Sam R.

11 years ago

great pizza and great service!!!!

Kurt B.

14 years ago

Good thin crust NY pie!

Vincent F.

11 years ago

Great place good food

UN D.

11 years ago

Great pizza

Rays New York Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Restaurants near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Coffee near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Things to Do near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Desserts near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Parking near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Breakfast near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Dinner near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Burgers near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Shopping near Rays New York Pizza

BEST of Manahawkin, New Jersey Movie Theatre near Rays New York Pizza

Best of Manahawkin

Things to do in Manahawkin

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Rays New York Pizza also viewed

Joeys Pizza & Pasta

3.2

(65 reviews)

Great to call ahead for take out or be prepared for a wait. Our pepperoni mushroom large pizza was…read moredelicious. Great crust, cheese, and toppings were good. Twenty eight bucks so I'm sure they're making a good profit- so hopefully they'll be around a long time.

beware if you have food allergies or restrictions - they…read morecan't see the comments in the slice app.

Surf City Pizza

3.5

(108 reviews)

Great pizza HORRIBLE service…read more Came this evening and ordered 6 slice and a pie. Everything was ordered together. Slices came out in 5 minutes. The pizza after 20 minutes of waiting asked where it was we told still on the way there were tickets in front. Asked to at a minimum get a slice for our 1 year old and 6 year old and was ignored. Threw tickets in my face showing me other pizza that were put in at 6:27 and ours was at 6:31. I explained how he further proved my point as those came out of the oven 5 minutes earlier. He continued to not care and decide to open the public trash is as customers and how wrong we were. A shameful respect for customers.

Solid take out large cheese pizza, reasonably priced, lots of cheese good crust…read more Friendly takeout counter help

Lorenzo's Pizza at The Chegg

3.0

(24 reviews)

We ordered this pizza last weekend and unfortunately it is not very good. They had a lot of oregano…read moreunder the cheese and the overall flavor was really lacking. The order was ready for pickup at the estimated time though.

Ordered a Cranberry Feta salad after bringing it home I discovered it was missing the feta cheese…read more Went back and spoke to an employee about my order she said she wasn't working the night my salad was made. I asked to speak with a manager and was told he was very busy. I never leave bad reviews but this place actually deserves one.

Bay Village Pizza

3.7

(105 reviews)

If you want a quick and delicious slice of pizza this is the place to go! The location is great for…read morea place like this.

THE FOOD ----------------…read more+ Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage and Mushrooms slices were HUGEEEE! Some of the biggest pizza slices I've seen, anywhere. Quality of the pizza was average - typical boardwalk/beach pizza, but it hit the spot if you're just looking for decent pizza. - Cheese Fries were overly salty and, unfortunately, the cheese was on the side instead of smothered all over the top. + Menu was simple with 4 types of slices (cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom) and extra toppings listed for $4 each. They also sold 5 different 18" pies as well (tomato, cheese, clams, works and white). THE SERVICE ------------------- + No frills, quick ordering through a window. THE SURROUNDINGS ------------------------------- + Outdoor picnic table seating available right next to the pizzeria in an outdoor shed and also some bar seats to the left of the ordering window. - No private parking lot. Parking is strictly on the street. RANDOM OBSERVATIONS -------------------------------------- = Was busy EVERYTIME we passed by, irrespective of what time of the day it was. We came by at 12:45 PM on the Sunday of Labor Day weekend and there was a consistent short line. At some points, the outdoor seating in the shed got full too and some folks had to wait. = When picking up slices, a gentleman will just yell your name out and slide the heated slices on a long pizza peel over to the pickup window, so be ready when they call you! = Red pepper flake and garlic powder shakers are located by the pickup window.

Panzone's Pizza

3.1

(80 reviews)