Bottom Line: The Shrimp impressed! We were having 6 for…read moredinner. My brother went in and ordered 6lbs. The guy behind the counter told him he did not need that much. He was right. These Shrimp were huge. The guy also cut the backs and deveined them but left the shell on. My brother told him we were going to BBQ them so he also gave some cooking hints. Everyone loved the shrimp. They were fresh, firm and did I mention HUGE! Bottom Line: if we are having another seafood dinner we will def head out to this place!

This is a nice place for fresh seafood next to a deli. They have an Italian twist on the seafood…read morepart with rice balls, risotto with shrimp which was really delicious. They are super friendly and like what they do.

Today I had lunch in Southhampton Village at Citarella's. The hot and cold buffet was a bargain at…read more$13.99. I purchased some fresh blueberries, ropa vieja, fried tilapia, and chicken with mushrooms. Gisele was my cashier, and I declined her offer to purchase a shopping bag because I was going to stay in the store and eat. I sat on a barstool by the window and people watched--no celebrity sightings though! WARNING: BAD INTERNET SERVICE! I had to check in AFTER I left the premises because I do not use public WiFi!!!

Love the Italian almond cookies. Prepare food and soups are excellent Been going to various…read morelocations for almost 20 years. High quality / outstanding service.

Way too windy cant eat- hair all over the place. My friend waited a very long time for salmon was…read morenot cooked as requested. We left before it arrived because it was a ridiculous wait. I have to say the service is very nice. Very good. The food is also very good. Just be prepared for the wind and possibly the wait.

It is the perfect clam bar/seafood market, and the location is perfect overlooking Shinnecock Bay.read more

Their warm lobster rolls are the best on L I ! Chowder is…read morefull of seafood and delicious. Lines may be long, but it's worth the wait.

Decided to visit this place with some friends during our trip due to the extensive gluten-free…read moreoptions available. I made a reservation on a Sunday night, which wasn't needed. I had no idea there was outdoor seating, or I would've requested that. The atmosphere was very casual with hits playing on the speakers and football reruns on the TVs, but none of that took away from the experience. Now onto the food... I ordered the hot lobster roll and a lobster bisque cup. The roll came with fries, but they gratuitously let me sub them out for sweet potato fries at no extra charge. They'll also throw in another roll if you notify the server you plan to split the hot lobster roll with somebody. I've never had one before, but I thought it was good! The roll could've been sliced better since it was difficult to pack the lobster on the sides, but that seemed to be a one-off since others in my party had a better sliced roll. The lobster bisque was thick and creamy. Thicker than what you'd expect, but still very good and they did not skimp out on the seafood. They came out quickly after ordering, which I guess is due to them just having to pour it into a cup in the back. I was expecting it to come with the rest of my meal, so I saved a little once my entree came. Overall, we had a fun experience, and I recommend this spot for a casual meal that can satisfy everyone, due to the plentiful menu options.

7/22/26 Yesterdays…read morelunch and sit out to Out of the Blue. Nice and casual where you walk up to the counter and place your order, take a seat and wait for it to be brought to the table. We ordered the fried clam strips/ fries in a basket and the fried shrimp/fries in a basket. Both orders were really delicious and nice portions. My wife had the shrimp, 7 jumbo shrimp fried nice and crispy served with tartar sauce and cocktail sauce. My clam strips were awesome. We first stopped at whalers, I was craving the clam strips. Whalers didn't offer that so we figured let's go to Out of the blue. Very glad we did. Enjoy the pics!

Came to this restaurant on an early Saturday evening. This is the type of place where you order…read morefirst then you grab a seat. We were told about the wait before we ordered however, we should've reconsidered. We waited almost 45-1hr for 3 entrees and some garlic bread! The food was decent however, the wait was not. The decor was casual with huge TVs playing sports and there is outside dining. Willing to give this spot another try but they need to do better with the food timing.

Absolutely amazing evening spent on a Southampton beach with a bonfire, steel drummer, and an…read moreimmense moonrise over the ocean under an otherwise starlit evening sky with the surf pounding just yards away. Thirty-five of us, enjoying lobsters, clams, mussels, and corn on the cob right off the grill. Two long tables were provided, perfectly set with rosé, white and red flowing. Such a special evening. East End did a superb job!

Capt. Phil and his team delivered an awesome beach party last night in Southampton. From appetizers…read moreto dessert everything was superb. Freshest clams ever, with Phill shucking non-stop for our guests. The lobster was good and the steak was excellent. Tables were beautifully set with lanterns and torches down the beach plus a giant bonfire! Best for me: they did EVERYTHING PERFECTLY, so we really got to socialize with our friends. Our guests were raving, (even our most jaded Hamptons friends). This was an event to remember and I will always be thankful to Capt. Phil and his extraordinary team!

After attending a practice round of the U.S. Open golf championship yesterday at Shinnecock Hills…read moreGolf Club in Southampton, New York, with my daughter, we planned to pick up lobster rolls at the Shinnecock Lobster Factory, which is located on the Shinnecock Indian Reservation and was on our way home. We stopped, were greeted cheerfully, and quickly found parking before heading to the window to order. My daughter had been there before, but this was my first visit, and we were both treated very well by the staff, including the Vice President of the Shinnecock Nation, who teased me for comparing their lobster rolls with ones I had tried previously at the original Lobster Roll in Montauk, Lunch in Southampton, and Cousins' Maine Lobster trucks back in Pennsylvania. He said theirs use fresh, not frozen lobster meat and are better. We both got the four ounce "Guppy" served Hamptons style - warm lobster topped with warm butter and chives over a bed of arugula served on a toasted brioche roll that came with a generous portion of classic shoestring fries and a pickle. Our sandwiches and fries were terrific, and I even got to try a Montauk iced tea, a local favorite that has half the sugar of Gold Peak sweet tea and came highly recommended by one of the private chefs in the Hamptons that I follow on social media. Overall, we had a great experience.

The reason why I gave a 4th star?…read more The Lobster Bisque was the best Lobster Bisque I had in my life! Seriously, huge chunks of lobster meat and was that a little heat as well? I was in heaven enjoying this soup. It was nice to have indoor seating. I didn't notice any picnic tables outside? I placed the order on the digital menu board and grabbed my cold beer on the side window. I waited for inside for our food, listening for our number to be called. First impression: Shinnecock Lobster Factory Lobster Roll Bread? Stale The Lobster Roll? I can never find the perfect Lobster Roll on Long Island. I don't get it, New England is kicking our tails (See what I did there?) Lobster: It wasn't coated in butter but a mayo-y mess I ordered the biggest, baddest Lobster Roll they offer. It was meaty but with filler meat like parts of the claw. After I ate the big chucks of cold lobster coated with mayo and was left with cheaper part of the lobster, IMHO the roll wasn't worth the expensive upcharge. My wife ordered a Fried Fish platter. It came with three large pieces of fresh fish. The fish was lightly coated in batter and fried gold brown. The french fries were good as well as the fish, no complaints. The potato chips, I'm assuming they were homemade but after a few minutes became cold and oily, it didn't want me craving more. The Shinnecock Lobster Factory got the lobster bisque down, if they can work on the lobster roll this place would be 5 stars hands down.

Best Clam Chowder I have ever had. A bit pricey on drinks,…read morebut that's due to location. Service was great.

Cozy atmosphere and great menu variety with several gluten free options! Very good service.read more