Want to give this local place a try. For lunch, I ended up grabbing a cold brew, a meatball sub and a cookie. The coffee was the unexpected star of the show. Even with how much crème I put in, it was a quite strong coffee which I prefer. And 3.75 isn't overly pricy for good coffee. The meatball sub was decent. The cheese and bread were great. The meatballs or rather the "meatball" was seasoned well but was a bit messy but no complaints otherwise. Dessert wise, the cookie was pretty good. Haven't tried any of the pizza pies but the photos and from what folks ordered it looked great. The actual place seating wise and atmosphere wise was a nice mix of comfort and modern. My only real major complaint was 25$ (22$ without tip) was a bit pricy given the portions aren't super massive but personally I like to pay more if I know quality is going to be amazing. read more

We ordered a pizza for pickup. Yum! The crust was so soft despite the beautiful char on the rest of the pizza. Great flavor. My only criticism is that it's a bit pricey. Not crazy, but a little on the high side for a pizza that size. I would also prefer it sliced. Maybe you can request that? I'll be back though. read more

We loved all of the pizzas we got, but they legit make the best blue cheese I've ever had haha all their food is amazing

This place is hands down the best pizza and sandwiches in the area! Everything is so fresh, the pizzas are either Detroit, bar, or new haven style. I love the new haven and bar. The sandwiches are SO big and amazing ingredients Jess behind the counter is honestly one of the most happy genuine happy humans to roam the earth! Love her. Run don't walk, to get your pizza, sammys and pasta (yet to try, but hear nothing but awesome!) read more

Only did take out! We live pretty close and I just wanted to shove pizza in my mouth like a rat in private. I got a pepperoni Detroit and a meatball New Haven style. They were both really good but the Detroit is why you come here. The pepperoni are those little ones that curl up with the grease inside which is the best. They didn't cut it, which is a little annoying cuz they do advertise it as 1-2 people so it should be cut. The New Haven is also great, really thin but not burnt. Price wise it's the same as any other local place so why not get artisan?!?! read more

Rehoboth Baking - So good, but would appreciate it cut - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

See all

Really good pizza! Definitely some of the best in this area. Look forward to trying more in the future. read more

Rehoboth Baking - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

First time we visited in November 2024: amazing, amazing, amazing. Second visit in March 2025: not great. My overall review is good, because the inconsistency could've been a fluke, a different cook, anything really. Not sure. But I'll share both experiences! In November, we tried the mama ash, the Parma, and the Caesar salad. Both pizzas were New Haven style (which I recommend getting). We also got a cowboy cookie, a chocolate chip cookie, a brownie, and a pb chocolate bar. All of the bakery items were insanely good. Like, heavenly. And the cookies are giant. We also took a pepperoni bar pie to go, just to try, and I wouldn't recommend that style as it's not really bar pizza (for the south shore aficionados). The pizzas we ordered in-house were delicious. Great topping dispersion, amazing flavor, all the good stuff. The Caesar salad was huge and lemony and featured house-made croutons. Yum! The girl at the register was a gem. So nice. So kind. I just had a baby two months prior (she came along with us!) and the cashier gave us like 3 extra treats to take for free. She said, "mom needs these!" Super sweet. The second time we visited, we brought my parents. I had talked this place up, so they were excited- as were my husband and I! However, we felt it was only okay this time. Same great service, but the pizzas were kind of sad. We tried the shroomin' which was loaded with mushrooms and maybe a little too much truffle flavoring, but the Maui was sadly really sparse with the toppings. All 4 of us said the same thing. It was only ok. We also got a Detroit style pepperoni and ricotta with hot honey and the pie was nearly raw in the middle. Super disappointing! We did get the Caesar salad again and it was delicious but also much smaller than the first time. We took two cookies to-go and they were nowhere near as good as they were when we tried them last time. Really bland and overly buttery? If that makes sense. Tasted oily. I took home a pack of sourdough English muffins both times and those are incredible. Yum! I really want to give it another try since there's such a contrast between visits, but time will tell! read more

Rehoboth Baking - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

See all

Really disappointed in my visit today. I ordered the Meat Sweats Detroit-style pizza, the Melty Mozzarella, and a PB brownie. The Meat Sweats pizza was such a disappointment. Detroit-style pizza should have cheese to the edges and crispy. The pizza dough was soft and chewy, with no crispiness and not enough cheese. The pizza was also not even cut into slices. It had so much grease on it, and I do love some grease on my pizza. I cut it into slices and all the toppings slid off. The melty mozz I ordered without pesto and marina, so just some melted Mozzarella. It was so thin and burnt. The PB brownie was very good. read more

See all

I've been following Rehoboth Baking on Instagram for a while and finally made my way there and am kicking myself for not getting there sooner. Sort of tucked away in a rural town in southeastern Massachusetts, Rehoboth baking offers a remarkable menu and a cool, little atmosphere that makes any drive worth it. You order your food at the counter and the restaurant has sandwiches, pizzas, baked goods and more. The worst part about the place is picking what you want to eat because everything sounds absolutely amazing. I opted for a pizza cooked in Detroit style with roasted chicken, pesto and ricotta. The pizza had the great, doughy Detroit feel complete with crispy sides. You can order pizza in either Detroit, New Haven or bar pizza styles. Really good stuff. My dining friends each had a different chicken sandwich, one a chicken parm and the other with lettuce, tomato and pickles, and both sandwiches were served on an amazingly fresh made roll. Rave reviews on all the food. We took home some sourdough English muffins and blueberry muffins for breakfast tomorrow and the focaccia and loaves of bread all looked incredible. Definitely will be back to try more from this place soon enough and would recommend you check them out, too! read more

Rehoboth Baking - Flaky Bird - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

See all

Tried a white chocolate and cherry cookie while I waited for my chicken parmesan sub. Both were excellent. The chicken parms sub really seems homemade... You know because it is! I also got some more of those homemade English muffins. I like this place even though it's a little pricey for me. If they ever expand I hope they'll consider Fall River! It takes me quite a while to get here. read more

Great overall spot, looks to be an awesome place to sit down and grab a bite. Got a pepperoni new haven pizza, Detroit style with just cheese, and buffalo wings. Buffalo wings weren't great if I'm being honest, not enough sauce and they weren't the largest of wings. Also I asked for blue cheese... I think they gave me ranch. The pizzas were both great. Pepperoni was great and the dough was awesome. Cooked well. The Detroit style pizza was by far the best thing. Great chz to sauce ratio and cooked extremely well... altho they didn't cut the Detroit pizza Only thing keeping this from 5 stars is the couple of mistakes. The ranch cup and not cutting the Detroit pizza. They had pastries and cakes in a display case up front, they looked awesome. Definitely going to try them next time I'm in the area. read more

See all

We had an amazing time at this bakery/cafe! We were looking for a lunch place while in the area and found this place on yelp. It's a little hard to find because the entrance is in the corner of a plaza, but it is well worth it! The staff was super attentive and brought my kids coloring pages and crayons as well as balloons. I also watched them bring out water for the customer's dogs that were sitting in the back patio area. The food was amazing! All the wraps and bread dough is fresh made and delicious. The atmosphere was super cute, funky and fun! They had a connect four game in the back that my kids could play. We don't live super close by, but would be willing to make the drive out here again because we loved it so much! read more

See all

Highly recommend stopping in here. Delicious food. I will be coming back in the Summer to enjoy the patio and pizza.

Excellent pizza and sandwiches! Pastries are great! Always consistent...Always good! read more

I have to say this is my first time going there, and I am quite disappointed. I ordered the 3 little pigs pizza with extra pulled pork. And this was not good. It look like this was just thrown together. Maybe it was getting late for them being I ordered at 6:45. they close at 7 , but give me a break they are cheep on the meat. It didn't even cover the whole pie. Luckily I ordered extra but there was not enough to cover every slice. I could've got more meat at dominoes. Also why is the crust so sweet. I really would like to give them another shot. I might have wait a bit before I give them a chance again. read more

See all

Pizza is unbelievable!!!!3 different crusts to pick from at least 12 different pizzas to pick from

We stopped by and immediately was excited to try this place! We got the pepperoni pizza and a brownie. Both were yummy and fresh.

Perfect Detroit style pizza! A hidden gem in southern massachusetts. I wish I lived closer. I would highly recommend this spot if you're in the area. read more

Rehoboth Baking - Detroit style veggie pizza. - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

I got the Baller and Roni pizza (Detroit Style). It was phenomenal definitely worth the price. My wife and I ordered it for take out and when I arrived my wife wanted a dessert/ snack. So I grabbed her a cinnamon bun and I grabbed Boston Cream Puff both were great. Definitely will make the trip again from Rhode Island. read more

Rehoboth Baking - Baller Detroit Style Pizza - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

See all

Waited several days to write this review, looking at my previous reviews, you can see I was a big fan. I hope the owner takes this as constructive criticism from a once loyal customer. Quality Control! The last two orders, four pizzas in all, we were able to salvage a couple slices and discarded the rest. The last two were so burnt there is no way the oven person didn't know, more likely, didn't care. read more

I absolutely love the Rehoboth Baking Co! The pizza and food is amazing! The service is quick and the workers are nice, the food comes out quick. The interior is small but cozy and cute. I definitely recommend going to the RBC!!! read more

Great pizza!! Very friendly staff! I love the Detroit style! Very nice and clean interior 5 stars!

Great food and delicious sweets- cute outdoor eating area with picnic tables. Great service. Every time.

I've been following this shop's Facebook page for a while and finally stopped in. My intention was to get a thick crust pizza (they have three crust styles), but was swayed by the ABCLT (BLT with avocado and cheddar). It was delicious and served on a fresh store baked roll. My husband got the Cubano and he was super happy with his as well. We both only ate half of our sandwiches, they were a good size! We needed something sweet afterwards and split a gigantic cookie. Really like the vibe in this place, kind of rustic and industrial. They have a cute looking outdoor area as well. Their menu is extensive - all kinds of bread and rolls, breakfast foods, salads, many pizza toppings, desserts, and dinner offerings as well. I will definitely go back, hopefully for that pizza! read more

Rehoboth Baking - The remaining half of my ACBLT - BLT with avocado and cheddar. So good! - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

See all

Really great experience called a couple of days ago because it wasn't gonna be open till 2 o'clock on Easter and they said seating was first come first serve and they did not have reservations which is fine because it ended up being a beautiful day out. We could have just sat outside at their outside seating area. Girls at the counter very friendly They explained what the different. I were in the dessert case we ended up ordering a piece of funnel cake for dessert after breakfast and a cream puff to take home. That's the hubby's favorite dessert. I had to honestly say that the sandwiches were out of this world. They were both made with two eggs, cheese, and the meat I got the special today which was chorizo. It was fantastic as we can see from the pictures. It was loaded with meat. The hubby got the sausage, egg and cheese on the grilled English. The English English muffins are homemade as well as the croissants are made fresh in the morning the sausage, egg, and cheese he had had sausage on it and two eggs and cheese and he couldn't even even finish the sandwich with both taking home half of the sandwiches for later. We also had a large coffee because they don't have fruit flavored but we did share it and it was very on the stronger end even though it was the regular blend it was delicious. The chef in the kitchen. Was very friendly. He actually wore a cowboy hat in the kitchen which I thought was kind of cool. Definitely look forward to coming back here again trying something else lunch was not available due the fact they were closing at 2 o'clock today but that's perfectly fine. Gives us a reason to come back. Also, thinking of posting this to my bike group and seeing if they would like to do this either one weekend for breakfast or come here one evening for dinner since they're open till eight. read more

See all

We were so pumped to find this awesome little gem! We had tried their specialty pizza at a local event a few months back. It was really cool to have coal fired pizza from their food caravan! We originally wanted to try a restaurant next door but the wait was very long so we went to check out the menu here and boy were we pleased with the meal. They have the best bread so you can't go wrong! We had their specialty carbonara pizza done New Haven style but you can have a thicker crust if you wish. It was great and very crispy. It was hand rolled and all the ingredients were fresh. We also had the Mexican street corn app with their homemade soft tortilla rounds. Our favorite was the bbq chicken quesadilla; which was made with succulent chicken, bbq sauce, avocados, and the quesadilla was coal fried to perfection. The location is small but they do have outdoor seating for the warmer months. It has counter service, but everyone was friendly and so welcoming! They had take out boxes ready so you didn't have to ask. They also served beer and wine so I had a local IPA and some sangria with homemade peach and blackberry mix. We took some cookie dough home for dessert to make some cookies and they even have meals to grab and go! Check it out! read more

If you want stale English muffins, a pork Sandwich NOT made according to the menu description and a chicken salad sandwich that looks like it was made by an angry teenager forced to get a job.... Then this is the place for you! also the owner, while talented, is the kind of guy who thinks it's perfectly ok to be rude to staff when things get busy in the kitchen... there is no need for this... but that clearly explains why he is constantly advertising for help.. no normal person would work hard for someone who would belittle them because HE can't handle the pressure.... Go to a Guy and His Pie in Pawtucket , awesome folks, awesome food, awesome prices and wicked cool vibe there! read more

Went here Saturday night w some friends. Had the Meat Sweats Detroit style, friends had the grilled chicken New Haven. Both pizzas were delicious and the toppings tasted fresh (as opposed to frozen) and the sauce had a nice flavor. My only gripe was that their Detroit pizza was not very thick at all. It was also smaller than I was expecting for the price. Staff wicked helpful and some good beer options read more

Rehoboth Baking - Grilled Chicken Pizza - Bakeries Near Me - Rehoboth, Massachusetts

See all

This is horrible, horrible pizza. Seriously , some of the worst I've ever ordered. I struggle to even classify them as pizzas. They're closer to flatbreads. In addition to the outrageous prices, the biggest crime here is their description of their 3 different pizza types based on varying crust thickness. I assure you, their "Detroit Style" pizza has no resemblance of Detroit style pizza - more like a poorly made Sicilian. Similar story for their bar pizza. The price of the three pizzas I ordered amounted to over $60. Each pizza has 1-2 servings - insanely expensive. Never order pizza from a restaurant set up like a cafe. read more

My partner likes to joke that there is no good pizza in Massachusetts until she found this place. This is our second time here and it did not disappoint. We had the Roni with New Haven Crust and the Yard Bird with Detroit style crust and both were delicious. My 9 year old ate 5 pieces. Plus, we shared a whoopie pie which was just the perfect amount of sweetness. Not too rich -- just perfect. We'll definitely be back! read more

We went there when they were in there house it was nice they were very friendly we loved the food

I've been a customer since they were at the country store. At first it was great, and I'd come very often and promoted it to friends and online. But I've noticed the quality keeps going down hill. First it would something small like the cookie or cream puff being so overcooked it would be hard as a rock. Then the pizza would be almost burnt or barely any sauce despite a request for heavy sauce. Tonight, I figured I'd bring some friends as I wanted to sit outside. I was very specific about no peppers on my sandwich. Can't do them. Got part way through the sandwich & saw the peppers... and a pepper seed. Really have to avoid them. So I gave the rest to the friends.I hate to do this to a place I once loved and went to every other week but that's where we are at. read more

We were in the area at lunch time and decided to see if Rehoboth had any interesting dining options. Rehoboth Baking was a delightful discovery. My daughter is celiac thus gluten free so that dictates where we can and can't go so despite being a gluten-forward bakery they had quite sufficient lunch options for her. She really liked the rice bowl with a southwestern flair. My husband and I had a New Haven style pizza, one of their FOUR unique pizza styles. We look forward to trying every one of them as everything we had was truly delicious. We felt guilty about splitting one of their generously-sized cherry white chocolate chip cookies in front of my daughter, but promises were made and fulfilled for acquiring a future sweet treat. My only recommendation would be to add a gluten free dessert to the bakery offerings. This isn't super close to our home but it's definitely worth the travel and I see us becoming regular patrons. The patio will be a nice place to dine and play yard games in warmer months. read more

Amazing food I get the number 4 scramble eggs black coffee with a cookie awesome atmosphere. Cooked to perfection every time.

Everything was delicious! I had the pulled pork with eggs and it was delicious! Will definitely go back!

I just found my new favorite pizza place. First time going there I ordered the New Haven style cheese pizza. The crust was crispy. The sauce was on the sweet side with great flavor. The cheese has a dusting of Parmesan that's not overpowering and gives the taste of depth. I can't wait to back and try the other pizza styles. And sandwiches. read more

Very nice place. I went with friends for lunch, they had some great choices. Meatballs and ricotta pizza were so good! Their coffee was smooth and delicious. You can't leave without trying the baked goods... Cookies and Brownies were so good!! Definitely will be back!! read more

We've only gotten the pizza here. Both times were absolutely incredible. If you're looking for a nice freshly baked dough, yummy sauce and delicious cheese this is definitely the place to go! Also, the people that work there are super duper nice. Highly recommend! read more

Good food! Bad service. They're very fancy with their size of pizzas and was inconsiderate while explaining it. Felt like i was ordering a fancy coffee order venti/trente- whatever the sizes are, which is fine but for people who are learning patience is needed when sizes aren't self explanatory. Very rude while explaining something new to people read more

Amazing spot! Great breakfast sandwiches, baked goods, and coffee! Love it. Service is friendly also.