New to the area and we've been looking for a new pizza spot...WE FOUND IT!! Pizza was AMAZINGread more

Stopped by Colosseo Pizza recently and it felt like stepping right back into my childhood. I used…read moreto come here all the time as a kid, and even though it's been years, that same no-frills, neighborhood pizza place energy is still very much alive. We started by sharing a salad and WOW. Do not skip it. It's one of those simple Italian salads that somehow just hits perfectly, and adding the mozzarella is an absolute must. Fresh, generous portions, and way better than you'd expect from a classic pizza joint. I could've eaten the whole thing myself and been happy. We each grabbed a slice and shared some garlic knots, which were warm, soft, and loaded with garlic flavor (aka exactly what you want). The slices were classic New York-style, nothing overdone, just solid, comforting pizza that reminds you why these spots never go out of style. The menu keeps things simple in the best way. Pizza, slices, and, salads. All the staples you expect, no unnecessary extras. It makes ordering easy and keeps the focus on what they do well. You're not here for trendy toppings or experimental flavors, you're here for reliable, satisfying food. The vibe inside is super casual and welcoming. It feels like a true local spot where regulars come in, families stop by, and no one's trying too hard. The staff were friendly and easygoing, which just adds to the comfort factor. I'm already looking forward to coming back, and next time, I might just order that salad for myself.

Had lunch at Pasta Pasta today, a little gem in Port Jefferson. Food was delicious and service was…read moregreat!!!

Good food nice place . Located near the boat terminal. Small but the service and food were greatread more

This place lives up the New York Pizza ! The Chicken tenders…read moreand fries were way above average! The next day leftover pizza was like fresh bread

The people who work here couldn't care less. Went to pick up need to go order and the awkwardness…read morethat ensued was un parallel. The high schooler behind the counter maybe said three words while being confused before handing me my order. Very little seating. Food was very sub par. Will not go again.

Decided to order takeout on this day and another reason why I love Port Jefferson, NY, is because…read moreof close proximity available from the Danfords Hotel. Last year, I was in Port Jefferson and had dinner at Joey Z's. Classic and traditional style Italian food. The pizza had a thin, crispy crust and texture

Best spot we enjoyed the breakfast and Taylor made the best Bloody Mary we have ever had. The…read moreplace is clean and the food was top notch. My hubby had the omelette and I had a crepe both delicious. We are excited to come back for the fondue and a dinner before we leave town 5 stars service was also excellent

I'm really disappointed with my experience with Renzo's Pizzeria. I called to place an order and,…read moreyes, I may have confused the order for a moment -- but I was actively correcting myself and trying to fix it. I clearly said to forget the two eggplant parms and instead do one eggplant parm or one chicken parm. Instead of helping clarify, the person on the phone repeatedly said, "You're confusing me and I'm busy, can we hurry this up." I'm sorry, but that's not how you speak to customers. If you're busy, simply put me on hold -- I would have gladly waited. I also work at a pizzeria, and I would never speak to a customer that way. A little patience and basic manners go a long way. Very unprofessional and disappointing customer service.

The pizza is tasty. Thin crust with a flavorful sauce. We were disappointed with the amount of…read moretopping especially since it cost almost 10 bucks. The value is not there this pizza was 30 bucks and they should do better. We also had garlic knows they were overly firm, dry and flavorless.

Friendly staff, and great food. What more can you ask for, highly recommend. Also has a relaxing…read moredinning room, and sit down area for pizza.

We visited on a busy (early) Friday night without a reservation because we were told you can't make…read moreone for 4 at this place. Surprisingly, one last table was immediately available, so that's good! The rest... not great. First off, we were given food menus, but no drink menu. Our waitress was busy, so after about 10 mins we were able to flag down a busser and ask them if they could kindly hand us a drink menu, which they did even though that's not their job. Another 20 mins go by until our waitress finally showed up to take our orders. Complimentary rolls and olive oil to dip came, which was good. Then, 3 drinks came, the fourth one (a soda, no fancy cocktail) we waited 10 mins for and then had to remind the waitress about it. We were all done with our first round of drinks way before the food came, so ordered another round. Then, the food came. BUT! Not for everyone, only for 2 out of 4. We waited a couple of mins so we could all start at the same time, but after a while decided to just start because the food was getting cold. A whole 15 minutes later, the third person got their food, followed by the fourth person, as the first two people were already done eating. Super awkward. At one point the waitress put a drink on our table with the words "I know you didn't order this, but I can't find the person who did so you get an extra, enjoy!" At first I was happy about that free drink, but a couple mins later she came back and took it away again! Gave it to the table next to us. I guess the look on my face wasn't very happy after being teased like that, so she did end up grabbing me a free drink. The food itself received mixed results. The salad was ok, $16 for green leaves, some beets and some cheese. Dressing was good, but served in plastic to-go containers? Added chicken for an extra $4.50 was good. Brick-oven pizza looked good but tasted like cardboard. I fully expected the bill to be wrong, with all the back and forth with forgotten drinks, extra drinks etc., but it was correct, yay! Probably won't be back though.

Our waitress was patient and very friendly. We love when our server does not rush us. The chicken…read moresandwich was fresh and crispy and the cucumber salad with falafel was fresh and delicious! Next time I want to get the giant pretzel. It looks so good on the table next to us. We went for a late Saturday lunch and there were people there, but it wasn't too noisy so we were able to have a conversation. They were decorated for Valentine's Day and it's just a really cute and cozy place to go.

The service here is great, The staff is wonderful. The food is awful I would not recommend coming…read morehere to eat. This would be a perfect spot for happy hour for some drinks! There are way better options for food

My friends and I get takeout from here almost once a week and really enjoy their eclectic selection…read moreof unique pizza choices. Although I do not dine in often, the ambience is reminiscence of a typical pizza joint with takeout seating as well as sit down dinner experiences. One of my favorites slices is definitely there buffalo chicken slice, and their garlic knots are the best around here.

Great pizza, fresh flavors, friendly staff, fast service, worth every visit! again!!!read more