Was a perfect day to have lunch here. One of my favorite restaurants here in the neighborhood. The place wasn't crowded and I sat at the bar. Blake, the bartender, was very friendly and asked me for a glass of water, since it was a hot day here. 5 minutes later I ordered a hard cider which hit the spot. They have spots and music videos playing on the TV. Then I ordered chicken quesadillas was so yummy. Had a great lunch here and I will be back read more

Replay Andersonville - Hard Cider - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

The chocolate chip cookie skillet was so good oh my goodness!!!! My overall rating of this spot is 4 stars, but I rate the skillet 5 stars read more

Replay Andersonville - Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

If u like food and nostalgic arcade games, this is it ! From KISS pinball machine to Pac man; this will bring back good times ! read more

See all

I love this place. The energy is good. The outdoor seating area is large and you get to soak in the Andersonville vibe. Prices are very reasonable and the portions are generous. I could. It finish my chicken and waffles with eggs. Service was friendly and fun. I can't wait to go back with my wife. I'll need to find a quieter spot so I can hear her better. Bottom line is, check out Replay on your next visit to Andersonville. read more

Replay Andersonville - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I had just finished having dinner and decided I wanted to have a drink. My friend and I went down to replay for a nightcap. We decided to sit at the bar. It was nice and clean and service was pretty good. My bartender was very attentive making sure my drink never went dry. They played really good music throughout the night so I was able to vibe out. I did not have anything to eat, but looking around people were ordering food and it looked pretty good. There are old school games that you can play, games from the 90s, which is great. However, I did not get a chance to play any. Next time I go back, I plan to do so. read more

See all

We went on a pretty slow day but waited way too before having to ask if we had been assigned a server. Very slow service, especially anything coming from the bar. The food was good but not worth returning for the warm drinks and poor service. read more

The servers and the bartenders are truly wonderful. They make you feel like family. The owner made a terrible mistake and removed the chicken pesto wrap, my and my partner's favorite. They took it off the menu so we won't be back. It's a damn shame as the rest of the menu is lackluster at best. read more

Bartenders and management are extremely rude dismissive and condescending they don't realize they're in the hospitality business service was terrible read more

Replay in Andersonville has become a staple spot for my friends and me. When you walk in, you're greeted with good, friendly service. One of the things I love most about Replay is the retro games. Whether you're waiting for your food or just feel like splurging on some nostalgic fun, the games add a great vibe to the place. The menu is always evolving, which keeps things fresh. Some of my favorite dishes have to be the Cubano sandwich, which is a different style since it's not pressed but super tasty with its smoky pulled pork. The nachos are a delight too - I usually get the salsa on the side to keep them from getting soggy. And let's not forget the wings! I love getting them naked so I can dip and try all of their tasty sauces. To top it all off, I usually wash everything down with a refreshing Aperol Spritz. It's to aid the digestion :) Will I be back? Absolutely - I've been coming since they opened! Welp! Into the next! read more

See all

Really enjoyed this chill bar and grill with 26 draft beers. Whether your preference is local or further away, there's something on the draft list to appeal to any beer lover. The special - a bowl of tomato bisque with a half grilled cheese sandwich - tasted delicious and was reasonably priced. Cheese curds were as light and airy as cheese curds can be, but were still satisfying. Friendly and efficient service. read more

See all

I came up to Andersonville for the first time for the craft fair and the day was so lovely that it was only right to find a patio and an Aperol spritz nearby - Replay was the perfect setting! The patio was casual with plenty of tables and a good amount of shade. I was really impressed by the food too! For a pretty well rounded American menu, the food was delicious. I got a chicken Caesar wrap and it was HUGE, perfectly seasoned and the right amount of dressing. The tater tots were also perfect. I kept looking at all the food that was brought out to different tables and it all looked amazing. It was easy to just pop in on a whim for dinner on Saturday which was great compared to other restaurants nearby that had long wait times. I really enjoyed the food and the setting for a casual dinner! read more

Replay Andersonville - Chicken Caesar Wrap & tater tots - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Upon arrival we had to wait three minutes to be seated even though there was someone at the bar (who didn't acknowledge me) so that kinda got the night off to a bad start. Three minutes doesn't seem long but time it, it's a while. Anyway, things got better from there. The person who seated us let us pick whatever we wanted outside since there weren't really that many folks there at the time (we were there around 4:30 sine I had my two month old with me). We started with the fried pickles which were yummy as usual, though next time I'd grab the salt to season a bit. I ordered the jalapeño bacon burger and my companion got the curry wurst (September is Oktoberfest--servus!). Both were really good. I had never had currwurst before (neither had he) but tried a bit and it was good. The burger was really tasty, although not as spicy as I thought it might be--it really wasn't spicy at all. But it was good, and perfectly cooked, which sometimes is hard to get because I order burgers well done only. I'm happy to report it was perfectly well done. To finish we ordered the skillet chocolate chip cookie. It was my birthday so we had to get dessert! It was delicious. It came out HOT (I uploaded a video--you can see the edges bubbling!) and diving in too quick resulted in too hot a bite so be patient. And also make sure you have a bit of ice cream in your bite to cool it down. The outside seating was great. It was very comfortable seating and most or all of the tables have umbrellas for when the sun's in the air. For all but the hottest of days, you may want to bring a jacket or something; a few days before fall it was pretty cool, but luckily not so cold that I couldn't enjoy myself, having forgotten to bring a cover-up (a couple degrees cooler and it may have been, though). The patio is dog friendly as well as kid friendly, and they have special "kid-friendly hours" as well. Parking is probably a pain most of the time, but we got lucky and there was a couple spots right across the street from the outdoor seating, on Balmoral. But there may be paid parking along Clark as well and the surrounding streets. It's taken me years to finally make a stop at Replay but hopefully it won't be another few years before we come back. read more

See all

Our experience was very good!! Ricky and Adrian were our bartenders and were so nice and responsive. So friendly!! We had the seasonal salad and it was delicious! Love coming here, everyone is so friendly! read more

I was seated fast by the hostess. Outside on a beautiful evening. It took a while before the server showed up but he straight from the beginning said sorry for the wait. The menu is a modern American menu with dinner stable appetizers like wings and fried pickles they offer salads, wraps and burger. The burger can be substituted by an house made turkey patty or an impossible burger. So a lot of choices. I was craving a burger and when I read home made turkey that's so rare I'll had to go for it. Side salad some extra cheese and that's it. As starter I ordered the fried pickkes. The starter came after the mail lol. But that did not matter since they have been nothing special. Nothing to complain about either. But the burger. It felt like the size of three regular paddies. Wet delicious add one like the pickles pepper and crispy bacon. A very good burger! I will come back anytime. read more

Replay Andersonville - Fried Breaded Fried Dill Pickles - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Great venue but for the snotty arrogant condescending bar tender. Friends asked for a vodka with Red Bull and snotty bartender in the most condescending tone said "you mean Red Bull with vodka" I asked what their lightest beer was and again bar tender arrogantly said Bud Lite. He must really hate his very complicated job of being a bar tender. Needs to lose the attitude he might get way more tips!! read more

Mediocre bar with terrible service. Waited over 20 minutes for a beer. Not busy. Also order fried pickles. Wish I hadn't.

Everything was very good: Service, pacing of our meal and the staff. The atmosphere was good, not too loud, but you could tell that the people around us were enjoying themselves. read more

Hanging out in Andersonville? Stop by Replay for food, drinks, games, and good vibes! A friend and I were meeting up for drinks with friends to celebrate a birthday, but we wanted to eat first. A quick walk down Clark had us stumble upon Replay. Free retro arcade games? Yes, please! Good bar food? Yummy! The fried pickles were thick and heavily battered (which I rather enjoyed). The buffalo chicken eggrolls were yummy, though the blue cheese dressing was a bit...sweet? Definitely a different taste to it, but still good. Our server was the perfect mix of great conversation, helpful recommendations, and friendly banter. And, what's even better? I had left my cell phone on the table and had to return to get it...which was safe behind the bar for me to retrieve it! Thank goodness! read more

See all

A sunny afternoon in Andersonville calls for a late lunch and drinks on the patio. Apparently, I was so hungry I failed to get a photo of the nachos. It was the perfect snack to have before joining friends for dinner. The patio was great and servers were accommodating as we added some chairs to our table so friends could join us for drinks. Great patio, great service and a wonderful spot on a sunny afternoon! read more

Replay Andersonville - Beer - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Right in the middle of Andersonville, this place is great for a casual lunch or brunch! They have old school video games you can play while you wait for a table. Lots of food options to choose from that all taste good! read more

Amazing atmosphere and the jalapeño burger was to die for!! Service was excellent as well

Service was a little slow for the amount of people there, but the chicken cesar wrap with brussel sprouts were amazing :)

I was visiting the area and when I was waiting for an appointment in Andersonville, I looked up outdoor lunch spots because I had my dogs with me. It is also raining and some of these places with patios had closed their patios, so I give them props for accomodating during the rain and during the pandemic. They had hard canopies out and also had space heaters. The food was good and the service was pretty responsive. I'm not sure when I might next be in the Chicago area, but I had a good experience here. read more

See all

Solid drinks and vibes. Used to come here for trivia which was fun. Their frozen fruity drink behind the bar is really good, not too boozy!

Had brunch at Replay to celebrate Father's Day. First time at Replay and had an incredible tie. My wife and I enjoyed the Bubbly Happy Hour (champagne with pineapple juice). I had the Smash Burger and I can honestly say that might be in the top 5 best burgers in the city!! Two quarter pound patties, cheese, fried pickles, caramelized onions, and mixed greens. Ridiculously good burger!!!! Service was very friendly and attentive. Always fun to find another great place to go to for brunch. Can't wait to go back!! read more

Replay Andersonville - Double Smashed Burger - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Food is okay, most recent time I went service was terrible. I have been to replay probably 50 times in my life. We have spent many a summer night on the patio, but this most recent experience was horrible. I came in with a craving for a Burger, Mac and Cheese, and drinks. I ordered a Moscow Mule and it tasted flat. I asked the server Adrian, if the bar could remake it, and he took it as a personal slight. Ignoring me was pretty much my punishment for the rest of the night. He also was giving me dirty looks from across the restaurant near the bar. This mule tasted the same as the other one just topped off with fresh soda. It was not good at all. We had already ordered our food so Adrian made sure to avoid us the rest of our meal. He passed me about 20 times without asking how the food or the drink was. The drink had not been touched and was on the edge of the table. He moved it to bring food but did not ask how it was. Guilty conscience maybe? He also did not ask if we wanted any additional drinks or food the entire meal. I guess no dessert or any other drinks could be ordered. As we are wrapping up our meal and he finally comes to the table and asks if he can take anything off the table. I told him that he could take the drink because it's disgusting and it has not been touched. He said, "oh, it went from being waterdowned and flat to now disgusting." He then started to laugh and grabbed the drink and walked away. Adrian, I'm glad that you found the situation so funny. By avoiding us the entire meal you missed the opportunity to build the sale as we had plans for dessert and more drinks. Customer isn't always right but it would've cost you nothing to be kind and ask how our food and drinks were. It seemed like Adrian didn't want us to be served to begin with. I want to be clear that Adrian never checked in with us once from the time we got our food to the time he asked if he could take something off the table. Guess water refills and no other requests would be honored simply because I gave feedback on a drink. I vote with my dollar and won't spend money where I'm clearly not wanted. Replay is not cheap by any means. So how about treating paying customers with just a bit of respect. read more

OK! Replay Andersonville is consistent! They consistently deliver on bar style food! I have only been disappointed once with the spicy chicken egg roll. Then only time! Otherwise, keep it up y'all! Drinks are there! Huge beer list. They keep it fun and the workers are busy but they will get to you! They nailed with the outdoor seating when Covid-19 hit and the additional outdoor space during the summer is perfect! read more

See all

Replay is my neighborhood restaurant bar.. I love to support my local restaurants so stop by as often as possible. Service makes ALL the difference in wanting to stop by. Today I came in about 330 in the afternoon for quick bite. Blake was working and he was the epitome of friendly professional service. Not only was he pleasant and efficient with me...but he was like this with everyone he interacted with...from other customers, to the guy who walked in passing out biz cards for window washing or whatever...point being, was consistently friendly and polite to all. It motivated me to leave this review because service is NOT always to this level and he should be acknowledged. It's what makes aville so amazing. I've left replay before after less than stellar service and thought....hmmm no need to return for a bit but after watching Blake be so kind to everyone...ill def come back for mid day lunch. Thank you replay and thx Blake. It makes a difference. read more

Bad vibes and broken games :( This place used to be a gem and one of my favorite spots in Andersonville, but I'd have to be dragged back after how lame this last visit was. Go spend your money at a real arcade (or even just a different bar where the staff might actually make you feel welcome). read more

Such an enjoyable spot, they've got great food and matching prices. It's a great spot to watch a game, meet with friend or just enjoy yourself and grab lunch and a drink. Everyone seemed to enjoy helping one another as a team for service which I appreciated. And the host was so sweet and wonderful. Also shout out to Orlando, you kept a smile throughout my entire visit and spoke to every guest it was a pleasure to see such genuine hospitality in the service industry. read more

Replay Andersonville - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Went here the other day trying to get drinks. Was ignored for 20 minutes by bartender. Tried going up to bartender politely saying "hey I'm trying to order drinks been trying to get your attention" and was immediately cut off by him saying "can't you see I'm helping my guests right now. I'll get to you in a minute" waited an additional 15 minutes and was still not greeted by him no words or nothing. I ended up leaving this establishment. I also posted about this incident on my instagram where I got NO RESPONSE by the marketing team. This is disappointing to me as there's literally no sense of care towards guests. read more

Replay Andersonville - DM sent 2 days ago - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Went here for a quick bite and some drinks, and it was great! The drinks are delicious, the staff is friendly, and the tater tots and chicken fingers are OUT OF THIS WORLD. I've never gone on a super crowded night, but it does get busy! Lots of fun events and activities to do! read more

Just like that, my opinion of this place improved! In these trying pandemic times, we turn to libations. Enter Replay, with their social-distancing "Lemonade Stand" serving frosty beverages of several varieties. Offered up by adorable, dishy bartenders. This is a a fantastic idea to stay in business. You get your drink in front, there's plenty of area to spread out and stay away from everyone. Very little contact necessary to pay. And the drinks are GREAT. Well done, Replay! Thanks for keeping Andersonville healthy and sliiiiiigtly tipsy. read more

Not really sure, but I was expecting a little more from this place. Our server wasn't the most friendliest, and while I kind of like the layout of this place, I realized how much I prefer Replay in Boystown. We asked the server if there were any Sunday night specials or something and all we got was a "no". Just seemed a little sassy. I do like that Replay has juke boxes that allow you to digitally change the music from your phone, but I feel like the music was a bit too low in volume here. Like, come on... you can turn it up a bit louder I feel like! I'd still come back here to try more of the drinks and feel the vibe on a Friday or Saturday night, but my first experience here was a bit disappointing. We'll see for next time! read more

I came here with a friend and it was my first time coming here. The place seemed nice until we sat down at the bar. The male Bartender with the tattoo on his arm needs to learn how to be nice to everybody. If he's not capable of being nice, he needs to learn how to FAKE being nice. I was watching the way that he spoke to my friend and his body language, his tone of voice will look on his face was ALL wrong. I tried so hard to justify any reason that he was treating my friend that way, but I COULD NOT FIND ANY LEGIT REASON. He wasn't so busy (he spent a lot of time chatting with other employee at other end of the bar). Maybe he was having a bad day?!!! Well that can't be it bc he was friendly and smiled to the people on both sides of us. Food came we ate it and never once did he ask how the food was or offered to get us another drink.. The fact he was nice to the other people made me feel even worse. I was in a good mood when I went in there and I left feeling terrible.. sometimes when I go to Popeyes, I feel kind of like I'm being discriminated against but other than that, I don't really know what the effects of racism feels like, but just the way that this bartender looked at me compared to my friend. I just felt dirty and bad. Needless to say, I probably won't ever be going back to this place. The food was good though. The Pac-Man game was fun Haven't played that game in so many years i did enjoy that at least......... read more

Do not eat at this place if you want to use the bathroom. They only have gender neutral stalls with urinals in them. Took my little girl into the bathroom and walked out to a grown man peeing right next to her washing her hands. It's completely inappropriate and unacceptable. I could understand allowing people to choose men, women, or gender neutral but they give you only one completely ridiculous option. Additionally, food is mediocre over priced bar food. read more

I'm going to give it four stars although I feel like we didn't stay long enough to really be able to judge. I'll say this, Chicago still has pretty strict Covid policies, in terms of going out and clubbing. And in comparison to Wisconsin/Milwaukee. There's really no point in going out right now in chicago other than to help keep businesses going. The place seemed clean and although temperature checks are no longer a thing, they seemed to follow COVID guidelines. The whole point of the bar is to play old school video games but playing the video games is still not an option. I found the music not to be the vibes we were looking for. It was more alternative. My biggest qualm was that both the bathrooms are gender neutral. Meaning men can go in the bathroom with women and while women are in there. I don't like that. I'm not comfortable with it; gay, straight, yellow, black, blue or handicapped. I'm all for inclusion but I just did not like the bathroom situation. I guess if there was an option for gender neutral but also a place for someone who is not comfortable with that, I'd feel differently. Other than that, Our server was really friendly! read more

I was given a completely flat Diet Coke and my friend was charged $4 for a "Sprite" when she ordered and received a soda water.

We were pleasantly surprised by this location! After frequenting Replay Lincoln Park, we didn't have hugely high expectations for the food from an arcade bar. We were very wrong! We got the steak sandwich and a build your own turkey burger, both of which were large, filling, and very delicious! The space itself is clean and nicely distanced and they have options for both indoor and outdoor seating right now. Keep in mind that they don't have any games available to play right now, but the drinks and food make up for that! read more

Replay Andersonville - Build - a - Burger - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Absolutely love dining here in the summer at their outdoor area. It's dog friendly which is a huge plus. Great menu, delicious cocktails, terrific service read more