Reye&#x27;s Pizza

Our first visit to this 'Icon' pizzeria and Bakery in Bradley Beach. The warm…read moreGoat salad and pizza was awesome. The ambiance is a real cool Pizzeria look and feel. The server was very warm and friendly offering some popular suggestions. The bakery next door will also knock your socks off. A grand slam all the way around. We highly recommend this pizzeria and bakery in the heart of Jersey Shore!

Food was amazing! Tasted fresh and flavorful! My favorite was the eggplant tower. The breaded…read moreeggplant was fried to perfection with great herbs like garlic and tomatoes. The margarita pizza felt light yet fulfilling. The service was great! The Ambiance was great as we sat outside.

Counter

Balsamic Pizza

See all

Margarita pizza

Vic's Italian Restaurant

3.8(516 reviews)

1.8 mi

Had a delicious meal on 8/25/26. Monika was an outstanding waitress who made you feel welcome and…read moretaken care of. Very attentive and a terrific personality! Looking forward to our next visit and seeing her again!

- Large restaurant with two dining rooms and classic old-school tavern vibes, featuring mahogany…read morewalls, booths along the walls, plenty of tables, and bar seating - Service was warm, friendly, and very attentive throughout our meal - Food was very good: the thin-crust pizza held together well and had a tangy tomato sauce; the salad was fresh, with large, flavorful tomato chunks and just the right amount of dressing; calamari was nicely fried, though the portion could have been bigger - Private parking lot with plenty of spaces

Inside

Cheese pie close-up

See all

Entry/waiting area

Brooklyn Square Pizza

3.9(37 reviews)

2.2 mi

Drove down from Nutley for my favorite post-run ritual: a solid 5-miler on the boards followed by…read morethe best pizza around. Even with an hour's drive, this spot is always worth the trip! I placed an order with Anthony for the Peter's Special Square Pizza. It's a perfectly thin square pie topped with a bright peeled tomato sauce and a fresh mozzarella blend, all finished with a sharp hit of Pecorino Romano. The sauce absolutely pops! Anthony provides awesome service, and this has officially become my go-to reward after a long run. Keep it up, Anthony--truly delicious

A bit out of the way but worth the drive. Dinner with my son's family. He did the ordering. Salads…read morewere fresh and well portioned. The pizza a pepperoni with hot honey glaze delicious. Service spot on. Everything that came out of the kitchen looked delicious.

Pepperoni Pie

2 plain, white/broccoli, margherita and mushroom.

See all

Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria

3.6(780 reviews)

1.7 mi

What a legendary spot! After researching this place and while in the area, we knew someone in our…read moreparty had to take on the whole pie/pizza eating challenge. We came, we saw, and my husband conquered :) A few things to note about Pete & Elda's..they don't take reservations. This is an incredibly popular spot, especially in the summer months, so if this is on your Jersey summer list..block out some time for this experience. They do offer to-go if time isn't of the essence, but I do feel like if you have the opportunity to have the full experience, take it. We've never done a food challenge before, but essentially the challenge is for (1) person, 30minute time frame, conquer a full pie, receive a t-shirt and of course, bragging rights. As we were seated, we noticed several other tables had at least one or more people taking the challenge, which was super fun to see and root on. Also in the parking lot there were people taking pictures with the iconic Pete & Elda's sign with their t-shirt and friends. The pizza is like a cracker-thin crust, super yummy and shareable for large groups. We had the cheese, and others at the table ordered sausage/onions, and pepperoni. We also ordered breaded mushrooms (an NJ shore classic) and zucchini sticks for the table, a Caesar salad, and macaroni and cheese for the kiddo. FYI, the macaroni and cheese was pretty fire! I've been eating a lot of kiddo meal leftovers on this trip, and this was a standout. I love the bar atmosphere of this place too, and learned you can actually also order "bar pies" at the (bar only). Great beer selection! There are other food classics on the menu as well if pizza isn't your thing like chicken parm, stuffed shells, veal, seafood, chowder soup(s), burgers, cheesesteaks, and more. All in all, my husband got the t-shirt, finished the challenge in 19 minutes, took the picture, and we all have fun memories of this day. This seems like a spot that holds a lot of memories for families coming to the Shore, and spending summers eating pie and enjoying tradition and celebration. Can't wait to do the same next summer :)

A shore legend when it comes to pizza spots. Old school charm and decore with paper thin pizza…read morecooked to the perfect level of crispy crust. We came in a busy Saturday night this time so did have to wait, but the hostess was spot on with the quoted wait time. This time my husband tackled (and suceeded) the pie challenge by eating a full XXL pizza himself on just 30-minutes! Wow! Meanwhile my dad and I split and XL Special Pie with peppers and mushrooms.

Interior

See all

Can't beat Carmen's Pizza!

Tino’s Artisan Pizza

4.2(178 reviews)

2.8 mi

Redemption is possible! We ate at Tino's -- Greek and Caesar salad topped with thinly sliced…read moreseared ahi tuna. Delicious. And the service could not have been nicer. Second verse, even more pleasant. We returned today with our niece and the food was once again on target: GF eggplant pizza, ahi tuna, eggplant rollatini. As delicious as places with much more hauteur. But the best food gets diminished if the service is haphazard or by rote. We were extremely fortunate both recent visits because LAURA helped us. She is efficient without being mechanical, friendly without a hint of professional tip-increasing fakery, and she made us feel welcome while dealing with equal art with several other tables. A delight, and she deserves her name in caps. And for any skeptics, we're not locals and we're not related.

Absolutely delicious sandwiches!! Everything is so fresh and they don't use any preservatives /…read moreadditives which I love. Definitely will be coming back and trying their pizza as well! Service is fine, and they have a good amount of both outdoor and indoor seating. Food also came out very fast.

Strawberry nutella pie

See all

Chicken Parm Sandwich

Pagano's Uva Restaurant

3.6(185 reviews)

2.2 mi

•$$$

Service from Toni was 5 star (and Nonna warmly greeted and sat us). Lovely restaurant but a few of…read morethe dishes were not great. The salad and Pasta alla Norma were the best of what we tried. Creme brulee was good also - desserts are all $10. Wish the lasagna were better - too acidic. Tasted sour. Could not eat it.

Our waiter was excellent. He recommended the homemade gnocchi and it didn't disappoint. He served…read moreme a gnocchi made with ricotta cheese. I've never had a better gnocchi in my life and I will definitely recommend to my gnocchi loving friends. Everyone at the table enjoyed their meals. Highly recommend this place

Lava cake with ice cream

See all

Del Ponte's Bakery

4.2(206 reviews)

2.1 mi

Excellent biscotti - I recommend the Almond and Chocolate Pistachio. I take them w me when I visit…read morefriends & family and always a big hit. Better hostess gift than a bottle of wine.

What a great bakery - the Willy Wonka of bakeries. We were kids in a candy store in awe of all the…read moredelicious choices available. So many choices of all kinds of everything Available -Everything was delicious. My personal favorite was the crumb cheesecake. We will definitely be back again soon.

See all

Il Posto

3.3(154 reviews)

2.0 mi

Prices are very good, Food is delicious and the portions are more than enough. We now go regularly…read more Friendly atmosphere and live music most nights. Lively bar with plenty of TV's to catch all the games.

I've been meaning to leave a review for this place for a long time. My wife and I eat here two or…read morethree times a month--sometimes more--and always love it. It's truly one of the "last of the Mohicans"--a classic, old-school Italian joint that you just don't see much anymore. I'm not knocking the new, modern restaurants and their creative concepts, but if you're looking for a really good, affordable Italian dinner in a great atmosphere, this is your spot. The moment you walk in, it feels timeless, which only adds to the charm. They have great live music most nights, the owners and staff are incredibly friendly, and the wine bottles are very reasonably priced. It's tucked into a unique, up-and-coming neighborhood that's a mix of industrial and residential (with some really nice new condos being built). If you want a great night out with good music, good people, and delicious food without breaking the bank, you need to check this place out.

Pinot Grigio & the Prosciutto & Arugula Pie with added Mushrooms.

See all

Sitting out on a beautiful night having dinner date , With delicious food while we listen to a band played inside!

The Elbow Room

4.0(149 reviews)

1.9 mi

Great locals bar and restaurant Solid food and bar…read moreexperience Excellent service Street parking can be difficult

Went for the music and ended up eating dinner. The Elbow Room is a cute beachy venue. Our service…read morewas excellent. The spicy vodka rigatoni was delicious. Will be back for both the food AND entertainment.

Dining area - opposite bar area

Tater Tachos

See all

D'Arcy's Tavern

3.8(135 reviews)

1.9 mi

I came here during the World Cup after seeing this spot online for so long, and it's safe to say it…read moredid not disappoint! If you're a soccer fan, this is the place to watch the games. The atmosphere is unmatched, with an energetic and welcoming crowd and nice friendly service. They have super cool decor, with team flags and scarves lining the walls and ceiling. The food is great classic pub food, we ordered wings and fries, and they were great. The wings were perfectly crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and they offer a ton of sauce flavors. Plus, they always have different events going on, which makes it even more fun.

It's been a while, but always nice to come back to a local tavern in the area. It seems a lot of…read moretheir TVs are pointed to soccer matches, just an opinion. Food was excellent, and the service was even better. What I don't like is minimal : there's a partition between the sit-down tables and the bar seats. Must be the way the building was built. There's an upstairs private room for parties with an airy view.

Amazing key lime pie!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Brian O.

4 years ago

Great place to pick up delicious meals to go when you don't feel like cooking. Gets very busy at times on the weekends around dinner time so call in your order early. read more

Mike J.

7 years ago

If you want good NY/Jersey Pizza Stay away. The sauce is way to sweet, very greasy, you can tell they use cheap cheese. Stay Away!

Chris T.

214

7 years ago

Great food for great price. Have ordered from this place many times and it is always an excellent meal.

Dominic Z.

177

2 years ago

Belmar and Lake Como's Late-Late night delivery crutch... otherwise pop into Federico/Fedirici's.

Sabrina C.

330

11 years ago

really good. great people working. locals fav for sure.

Glenn C.

10 years ago

Good, informal and reasonably price pizza.

Keith P.

12 years ago

good food great pizza best in Belmar!!!!

Reye's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Reye's Pizza also viewed

Pasquale's Pizzeria

4.3

(44 reviews)

Never get salad dressing correct. Getting annoyed. Everything else is great. I put in notes but…read moreseems to be ignored. Delivery's also prompt and polite food always good. Just can't get salad dressing right for online orders Also no sauce for chicken fingers today also forgot canola twice!!!

Such yummy pizza I love the variation…read more Really good crust and you can customize it as Much as you want . Their cheese is always fresh

Federico's Pizza & Restaurant

4.2

(195 reviews)

Literally the worst food I've had in a while. Ordered delivery - the sub was cold, the meat was…read morestale. Took 3 bites and threw the rest out it was so disgusting. And the cheesy garlic bread? I can easily make better at home.

A staple in town - very popular. Quite warm inside from the…read moreovens and body heat. Pizza is standard NY style and classic Italian entrees that are nice in portion size and flavored well. Great white pizza, garlicky flavor. The cheesesteak however (although stuffed) was a little flavorless and very messy--the oil seeping through the bread, bag, and onto my clothes. No bueno. I will say the half size was more than enough though for the average person. Have not found service to be overly friendly here. Would still return for some classic, old school fare.

Qua Pizza

4.5

(88 reviews)

I live nearby. I love their pizza but after seeing their chicken parm hero go viral, I had to stop…read moreby and try it. The service was friendly and the sandwich lived up to the hype. The toasted roll was the star but the chicken cutlet with buffalo sauced topped with caesar salad and lots of fresh parmesan cheese was great. I will be back for more.

Broccoli Rabe Pesto was criminal. It's a pasta dish but it was served as a flavorless soup.read more

Santino's Pizza

3.9

(52 reviews)

My wife and I have ordered pizza here many times and usually we pick it up. This is the second or…read morethird time we've gotten a delivery. The pizza was late over an hour and 20 minutes late. Pizza was cold. We will never order another pizza from this place again.

Food and service was very good, definitely going back, we went to Belmar board walk on our way home…read morestop for a bite at Santinos, everything was outstanding.

Anthony's Pizza

4.0

(49 reviews)

Came here for a late lunch after VCF East wrapped up. Anthony's is a nice little joint tucked away…read morein the corner which gives it a local charm. Anyone visiting InfoAge should pop by here. The large pizza was pretty big and had the right amount of crisp to it. Service was great. The pie was brought out after it was done and we had to get a go-to box at the end of it all anyway.

First time there looks like they have a nice variety of pizza that you can take out in slices…read more Can't wait to try them all. Also love the garlic bread.

Michaels Pizzeria

4.7

(7 reviews)

Everyone who lives at the shore knows they are surrounded by an abundance of Pizza parlors. And…read moreeveryone thinks their Pizza joint is the best. So they can have their opinion. But I'm willing to put Michael's pies up against anyones. If you like thin crust pizza with delicious sauce you have to give Michael's a try. You won't be disappointed. You may even have found a new favorite.

Great local pizza. Crisp all the thru Fresh sauce and tasty pepperoni Ice cream next door !read more

TJ's

3.9

(63 reviews)

I'm writing this review mainly to clarify that there IS indoor seating here - enough booths and…read moretables for about 24 people. Very informal, of course. But my point is that you don't have to take your pizza to go. I had three(!) slices here last week. Very affordable. The plain cheese was just OK - a little dry - it might have been left over from the night before (only one slice was available and I was there at the beginning of lunch). The veggie slice (broccoli and sliced tomato, no sauce) was solid. The "Grandma" slice was FANTASTIC, saucy and flavorful, and that's what I'll be ordering next time.

This is how pizza was delivered. Way undercooked and all toppings literally slid off in…read morecorner...and boxed soaked in grease....its sad they even packed this thinking good to go....

Spring Lake Pizza & Bistro

3.4

(61 reviews)

Best chicken parm sandwich I've had in a long time I am not used to having chicken parm this good…read more Been disappointed many times by places that make parm that is dry, rubbery, and gray with greasy breading and scorched tomato sauce. I usually like my parm to be a little thick. I went two days ago with my wife and I had a chicken parm sandwich. The chicken was thin, but very fresh, perfectly cooked and delicious. The sauce was excellent, and the chicken was lightly breaded, slightly crisp, and not greasy at all. The bread was slightly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, like it was freshly baked, high quality Italian bread. There is nothing that could have made this sandwich any better than it already was, and now I am going to be comparing every other chicken parm sandwich I order to this one. Great job!

A GREAT place for pizza and other stuff too. I had a personal pizza today while I was out on an…read moreappointment. It was just perfect! I recommend them to Everyone!

Pizzeria Lucci

4.1

(77 reviews)

The staff was attentive, the atmosphere was great, and best of all the food was the best! It was…read morethe best pizza I had in a long time! Definitely must go if you're in the Belmar area!

The pizza is light with a nice yeast flavor. The toppings are flavorful and cooked perfection…read more Unfortunately, I live in California so I can't go as often as I would like, but I was a true delight to eat there.

Little Mia's II

4.1

(33 reviews)