Unmaintained bikes and slow service…read more It took 45 min to pick up 2 bikes and a trailer. The person helping us forgot to give us the second bike. Then, their bikes are unmaintained. The first bike had a broken gear shifter. The second bike they served us had a broken seat, to which they replaced the seat with a seat that had the cover cracked. Finally the trailer had a flat tire which we didn't discover until after we bikes a few miles. The guy also "cleaned" the trailer with a leaf blower. Kind of genius but not really the clean we were looking for. Also note the sign says "Martha's Vineyard bikes" so you may miss it if looking for Pedago

There were very few workers. They gave us a broken bike that stopped working when we were a city…read moreover from the shop. The workers were rude and would not give us any assistance with the broken bike; they give no maps or directions so we got lost on some back road for cars. Would not recommend for anyone. And they only gave us half our refund. 0/5 stars for sure; take your business elsewhere.

Highly recommend! We rented e-bikes and this shop had the best prices. The location is perfect and…read morecentral. The staff were very friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful! We will definitely be back

Will was great, charge just a little more to bring the bikes back in the morning. That was such a…read morenice touch.

Wish I could give this a 6-star rating! This was the highlight of my trip to MV. The owner was not…read moreonly kind, but extremely knowledgeable. He got our party on the exact right bicycle for our needs. We used these bikes to explore the island and rode easily 20 plus miles over the next few days. We even road all the way to Oak Bluffs for lunch and shopping. The bikes held our bags on the way back with no issue. We got the premium bicycles with gears, which suited our needs just fine, but E-bikes were also available. Hourly, multi day and weekly rentals with fair prices. Can't ask for a better bike shop!

They were lovely here-it could not have been easier to rent bikes. The entire transaction took no…read moremore than ten minutes. Highly recommend.

Very easy to rent from here. Bikes were in great condition,…read morethey add a basket for ease of shopping. Very friendly, and good price.

The staff were amazingly friendly and helpful. We rented two e-bikes for the day we found it to be…read morea such an easy process. They gave us all the information and quality e-bikes we needed to have a fantastic day in the island. I can't recommend All Star Bike Rentals enough.

Delivered right to the dock, amazing communication - couldn't have been nicer. The e bikes are the…read moreway to go!

Great service - had a bike assembled in less than 24 hours and am very happy with result. Thanks…read moreEasy Riders!

We have come to the Falmouth area 5 times in the past 9 summers and this is our go to bike rental…read morespot The location at the start of the Shining Sea bikeway is perfect The staff are super friendly and helpful Price for bike rentals are very reasonable especially if you're looking at keeping your bike for more than a few days. We usually rent bikes for 7 days. The bikes are great. We definitely can highly recommend these great guys and their bikes.

My wife and I rented bikes to ride the Shining Sea trail. Great service. We had an awesome…read moreconversation with Ken before and after we rode. He's a great guy! We will be back!

this place is dope (which means good). to the young woman at the front desk, your name escapes us…read morebut you were as hilarious as helpful as was everyone we encountered at Cook's. we rented a couple of e-bikes which stand for electric or maybe electronic (both can be true) and got to see much more of the island than if we had just walked around. *side note - to the cobblestone streets of the downtown Nantucket area. my tender backside (from the opening at the end of the alimentary canal to just past the prostrate) gives you 1 star. while you are charming, riding a bike over you is like pedaling over a dried-up river bed. But that's my fault. I veered from the map and after years of therapy am ready to take responsibility for my own actions. I am growing. we checked out some beaches...Madaket where we hit up MIllies Market, getting a couple of waters as my tummy was still full from breakfast. Then made our way to Cisco where on the way back happened upon 167 RAW. had the best fish tacos ever. the ceviche was also top notch as was the 167 lager. A lady with a dog named Linda (might be Lisa) told us to go to Island KItchen the next morning for breakfast which we did. solid recommendation. 167raw.com/nantucket/ we saw a Brant Point Lighthouse. anybody see that movie The Lighthouse? heard they eat the same plate of slop every night. anyways the brant point lighthouse has 4.7 stars which I'm not sure how you review a lighthouse but so be it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brant_Point_Light, we used them to ride to dinner one night at Proprietors where everything on the menu is amazing and the inside of the restaurant is really cool. riding at night is tricky so bring a torch. www.proprietorsnantucket.com/ Lastly, we stopped by the Whalers museum before returning the bikes and flying out. I purchased a Bo'sun Whistle which should be called a sea flute, either way, my family hates it. my point is we were able to get out and explore this beautiful island alongside old yet still active people not dragging rolling bags off a ferry over the rolling brick sidewalks of Nantucket. they are beautiful but a death sentence to anyone with weak ankles. how were we able to do all of this you ask? the good people of Cook's swapped out our batteries when they were getting low. use this business if you can. we got a shirt and hat also.

I don't get the poor reviews. We were able to rent cruisers no problem. And drop off was quick and…read moreeasy. I don't know what else you need.

This is a FANTASTIC bike shop. It's a few doors down from the new* Nantucket Bake Shop (which we…read moreturned into first by happy accident and of course took advantage of our mistake) and the Nantucket Meat and Seafood Market -- so it's a little ways outside of town, about halfway between town and the airport. * OK, new as in it moved sometime in the past 20 years. Island time elongates. Perhaps the slightly out-of-the-way location explains why (1) prices are so reasonable; (2) there's such a great selection of bikes for rent and for sale; and (3) the owner, who was on site helping customers, and staff are so friendly and helpful. Bikes seem to be well maintained. Staff were hard at work tuning bikes on our visit. We are not "real" cyclists -- we can remain upright on two wheels and that's about it -- but we have many family members who are extremely hardcore about the sport. All our hardcore cyclists rent from Island Bike when they don't bring their own bikes across on the ferry, and stop there for supplies or parts. So glad we bought our little one a bike here rather than from the bike shop much closer to our house where the used bikes they tried to sell us were badly rusted with loose bike chains -- AND literally cost twice as much. Yeesh. As of June/July 2023, helmets are half off. Get there now, friends.

The service we received from Island Bike during our recent trip to Nantucket was top notch. Lia…read morefollowed up on our online reservation to ensure we would have everything necessary for our bike rentals. She and the team were also quick to respond when I hit a nail and had a flat. I highly recommend Island Bike for their service, bikes, price and convenience of the free delivery and pickup.