Great staff. I was concerned the breakfast/lunch would be more incidental, but equal care is given to both parts of the business. The baked goods look amazing, with a wide variety of options. I tried two, a ginger bomb cookie and a Lady Lock vanilla and they were rich without being overly sweet. The cookie had a great texture and nice ginger chunks, and the pastry shell of the Lady Lock was great. Both could have used a touch more sweet to my taste. My vibe was more French pastry than American taste. I would try different things next time, which is okay as there as so much to choose from. Breakfast was a mushroom/egg/mozz/spinach on a biscuit. Great and full of flavor. Lasted me a long while. Cafe au lait was perfect. Friend and I sat and chatted in the somewhat uncomfortable cafe chairs. Atmosphere was lovely, quiet conversations and delicious smells. Will definitely try to return. read more

The best cake in town!! We LOVED our wedding cake, and the strawberry jam with the lemon mousse frosting was so delicious. The decorators did a great job with a colorful, vintage style for our cutting cake. read more

Rolling Pin Bake Shop - Wedding cutting cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

Great bakery, luncheons, staff! Nothing more needs to be said! It's great! Yelp say I need at least 85 characters n this review but from my perspective all I need to tell you is that THE ROLLING PIN IS GREAT! read more

Out of this world. Best quiche ever. Muffalatta sandwich was on outstanding foccacia bread and had fresh carved ham. Great service. Adorable space. Decent prices. How could this get a 3.5?? Its the best read more

I recognized a product as a common bake from frozen product. when I asked if everything was made in house. I was told yes. when I pointed out the common distributed product. his response was he didn't actually know and just sold them. no checking or anything of the like. seemed like he didn't care and was just there for a paycheck. can't say this gave me confidence in purchasing read more

I was there to order cup cakes. I got some vanilla and strawberry cup cake without the fillings. Strawberry cupcake was my favorite. Each cup cake was $4, which I thought was slightly expensive. Next time I will order only handful of cupcakes from here. Also I think I should go for the filled cup cakes which are $5. Fresh fruit tart ($7.57) was the favorite item I had here. I also tried almond horn ($3.12) and cronut($10.20). Both where really good and filling. Everything in the display looked beautiful. read more

See all

Tasty cookies! Festive holiday options. Great stop for host gifts, parties, etc. Nice bread selection.

Great food , great atmosphere, great to sit and relax with a friend . Never go when in a hurry ,always slow or a person. In front of you buys $80 worth of pastry read more

Rolling Pin Bake Shop - This is 16 0z. This is why the place is not 5 stars , - Bakeries Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

We came here on a Wednesday morning, around 10 am, for breakfast. We split the Eggs Benedict and the Pastrami Hash. The Eggs Benedict was nicely balanced with perfectly cooked eggs (runny yolk, cooked whites), some ham, medium thick cut, and a cheddar herb biscuit. We both agreed on it's delicious-ness. The Pastrami Hash was pretty good. Great Pastrami, nice amount of veggies, but would have liked a bit more potatoes. We also got some baked goodies, yet to try them! read more

See all

Everything they do is fantastic. Tanya, the owner, has a new bread oven and is making the best sourdough combinations ive ever had. The crust is perfectly crunchy while the interior is soft and delicate with just the right "tooth." Their pies a delight and pastries so rich. Her restaurant is also great. Their daily breakfast and lunch menus with homemade soups are so flavorful. The muffaletta is perfec! read more

Just went here for breakfast. They recently expanded which gave the crew much more space and opened up more dining tables. the food was exceptional! Very warm welcoming feel, great staff, and the baked goods are outstanding. Had the Make My Day breakfast and it was just enough. Will be back, for sure! read more

Rolling Pin Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

Just recently I had two cakes made from the Rolling Pin. The cakes were incredibly delicious, everyone raved over them. I don't usually write reviews, but I was so impressed overall, that I needed to write a review. I took them a picture of the invitation for the party, they said they could re-create a birthday cake that looked similar to the invitation. They said they could do this with buttercream, I was honestly a bit hesitant, but thought whether it turned out or not it would be a conversation piece. To my complete surprise and amazement, not only did they make it look like the invitation, but they far exceeded any expectation I could've had. The other cake was a white cake that they made fancy and I added flowers to it. Both cakes were beautifully done. The sheet cake was red velvet with cherry filling, and the round cake was a lemon cake with lemon filling between two layer and raspberry filling between the other two layers. I would have to say the lemon was my favorite of the two cakes, but both were very good. The lemon/raspberry cake is now my new favorite cake and I believe we will be having this every year on my birthday from here on out. Rolling Pin is definitely worth every penny!! These were definitely my favorite purchased cakes in recent years! read more

See all

The pastries, breads, and sandwiches are sooo goood!! It's easy to become a regular here. It's a great place to spend a cold wintry afternoon. read more

See all

Rolling Pin Bake Shop has become a fixture in the Fitchburg community. I've been a patron since they first opened, spent many birthdays celebrating with cakes, and see them at local farmer's markets. Their cakes are DELICIOUS (here's looking at you, strawberry shortcake) and they are actually a pretty decent spot for lunch! My husband and I have stopped in a few times to grab a quick bite. I definitely can't leave without a baked good, however, and I'm sure I'm not the only one. The owner is a total sweetheart, and very accommodating when it comes to envisioning your perfect cake. read more

Rolling Pin Bake Shop - a person holding a cup of cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

We bought 4 éclairs. They were awful. The pastry cream was clotted and grainy the pastry Doug was tough and flavorless. Really disappointed

Got the Eastern European Rye and Herb & Cheese Biscuits. The rye is okay. The biscuits....YUM YUM YUM YUM YUUUUUUM. Incredibly delicious. Perfect amounts of herbs and cheese, the smell, the taste, the density; a whole experience. read more

The new remodel is terrific. The staff has more room to work, and the dining area is spacious and well lit. The whole place feels homey and "put together." The food is tasty as ever. I ordered the quiche lorraine and it was very good. I recommend it, though I wish they offered the option of a side of some kind (I always like a side salad when I have quiche). They now distinguish which bakery items are day old--a complaint I had made in my previous review--which I appreciate. Speaking of their bakery items, they continue to be outstanding. Can't go wrong with the pastries--donuts, croissants, cookies, etc. read more

I try to support them as much as I can, seeing as how I live just up the road. However, every time I have gotten bakery items or lunch there, I've just been left feeling buyers remorse that I didn't drive further to go somewhere else. They're a bakery, which is suppose to be known for their breads and pastries, but most recently, I got the Challah and it was dry and did not have the typical pillow-soft interior. The taste is suppose to resemble a brioche bread, a bread that is as much a pleasure to look at as it is to eat and simultaneously rich and slightly sweet. This tasted nothing like a true Challah and instead was a dense breaded, dry, loaf of bread. I also got the mixed berry tart, maybe something that was four inches in circumference, and the total was ~$14 before tip. Another time I went, I ordered the Muffuletta and again the bread was just too dense and heavy, it overshadowed the fillings to the point where I couldn't really differentiate the ingredients. All I could taste was bread. read more

See all

They closed the door on my face at 3:58. They were suppose to be open till 6pm (stated on Yelp) but the door said 4pm. They saw me, a girl shook her head no at me and shut off the lights. I drove 30 minutes just to try this bakery. Will never try them again what horrible business. I decided to try their cupcakes which were sold at Brennans and was so disappointed. No flavor at all such a waste of time and money. Never ever again!! read more

Purchased an assortment of donuts/pastries for an event and while not cheap they were gone fast, super yummy and people wanted to know where I bought them. Service was pleasant, friendly, easy and overall will definately return for more sweet treats! read more

Their peach/raspberry pie is the best pie I have had in a long time. Great sandwiches too.

Tried to stop In here since the girl at FedEx next door said they're goodies are excellent! But they had lights on & a locked door & no one answered their phone even though right now YELP says open M-F until 6pm! Sat til 4pm MAKE UP YOUR MIND RPBS!! Are you open or not??!! No extended holiday hours? BOOOOO!!! Oh well .... read more

We ordered an 8" white cake, frosted and decorated beautifully. And it was absolutely delicious. The raspberry filling was generous. Much thicker than any other raspberry filled cake I have purchased. The cake was moist and the frosting tasted like a cross between butter cream and whipped cream. I don't think it was, but it was so fluffy and sweet. I'm a definite fan. read more

Wife won't stop asking about more from this place. I couldn't remember where I got something that she loved and she went on a search to find this place again. Will be back read more

I have only been here once, so my review is solely based on that. I was at the UPS store, and Rolling Pin Bake Shop is conveniently next door. I have a major sweet tooth, so I rarely turn down baked goods. I walked in and saw an assortment of cupcakes. I mostly walked in because there was a sign for "doughnuts" on the door. I am always down to try new doughnut places in Madison. I used to live in Chicago, so I miss those fancy huge donuts. When I walked in, all I could smell was that overwhelming smell of old fried oil. It is not favorite. I hate when my hair smells like it after I leave a store like that. I was surprised to see beignets. I've never had a beignet, but I hear they're great. The one I had as pretty good. Though, it's kind of hard for me to hate fried dough with sugar on it. For donuts, I got the coconut cream one and a chocolate caramel one. Both tasted great, I'll give them that, but the dough was stale and dry. Granted, I did come around noon, but I feel like I should still be getting a decent donut at that hour. Perhaps I am too picky. read more

I was a fun of this neighborhood bakery store, however I'm very surprised that their bread is previously frozen. I always thought it's fresh made, straight out of the oven daily. read more

Rolling Pin Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin

waited at bakery case to be serviced/waited on. waited for 5 minutes and no one came to take my order. shop was not that busy & there were plenty of staff around. one big day "day old" cookie was $3.25 Prices are up with new remodel read more

Lots of donut and cookie options - both classic and more modern alternatives. The raised donut with vanilla icing was so fresh and tasty. Really cute iced cookies in different shapes - got a chicken for my kid and it was SO fresh and soft. Often these types of cookies are hard so I was so happy. Lots of cakes and other types of desserts. Staff was very friendly. We'll be back in the future to try more and they even have breakfast/lunch options beyond bakery. read more

I love coming here for breakfast and to get some cookies for a friend. The quality of the food and bakery items is excellent! Staff are friendly as well. Highly recommended! Check it out! read more

Rolling Pin is UNDERRATED! When looking for breakfast in the area, Rolling Pin isn't usually at the top of the list, but their breakfast sandwiches are sooooo good. The sausage, egg, and cheese is my favorite - consistently good every time, delicious and fresh ingredients. And the bread! They give you super thick delicious slices for the sandwiches. My favorite is the rosemary olive oil. I've actually been getting it from the Fitchburg farmer's market for months without knowing it was from here. Now that I know it's from Rolling Pin, they have a new loyal customer for sure! read more

We had fantastic breakfast pastries with coffee at the shop and a couple of cookies to go. Everything tasted great. Service was excellent. Ambiance was pleasant. read more

If you are looking for a nice wedding cake you can go to almost any bakery. If you are looking for 'CAKE!!!!!', then go to Rolling Pin. They sit down with you, ask lots of questions (so you know what you really want), and offer suggestions based on what you describe. Delivery was perfect, the cake was perfect. After the wedding we discovered the "anniversary" cake had not been taken care of correctly and was trashed. I called Rolling Pin to see what could be done, and they said they would make a fresh cake on the first anniversary, for free. The disaster wasn't their fault. We will be back, and many wedding attendees will be first time customers. Thank you! read more

My fiancé and I are hiring the rolling pin in Fitchburg as the bakery for our wedding cake. Customer service is great to go to the counter and someone is always happy to help you! We tried a champagne cupcake as a sample and the cake was moist and very appetizing. The environment is friendly and splendor. Can't wait to do our cake tasting in May 2023 for our April 2024 wedding!!! read more

This place has a lot of potential, but the last three times I've gone here I've been disappointed. The items were a weird dump cake in a to go box (not good AT ALL), an overpriced and not that good chocolate mousse and brownie concoction that came in a plastic cup (meh...bland,boring, dry) and some past their prime sale cupcakes that should have been tossed and not sold at all. So three strikes.....this should not be happening at an upscale bakery. Some quality control is needed here. The items that have been good here include the millionaire's bar (which they never have), frosted brownies, specialty cake slices, lemon bars and FRESH cupcakes, especially the hostess themed one. read more

I was in the UPS store next door and saw a sign that said "Gourmet Donuts". Dont threaten me with a good time. Unfortunately they were out that day. The young lady working the counter was very friendly and helpful in picking out alternatives to try, The chocolate drizzled peanut butter cookie was a GREAT peanut butter cookie, but I dont know if it was so great as to be better than buying an entire package of similar peanut butter cookies from a grocery store bakery. It was chewy and had great peanut butter flavor. I could have used more chocolate. The raspberry and cheese danish was surprising. I was expecting gooey cheese but the cheese was hard and baked in, the raspberry filling was the gooey part. The flavor combination was good. The iced coffee was good but not exceptional. I am trying to remember now if the total bill was $9 or $13. $9 is more than reasonable for 2 baked items and an iced coffee. $13 is not. I'll probably give them another shot. read more

Super cute! The breakfast banh mi was delicious. I would get that again. And, they have lots of options for dessert too.

This is one of the best bakeries in the Madison area!!! Definitely better quality than many others. Give it a try!

My husband ordered cupcakes and a carrot cake for my birthday party from here. It was beyond delicious! The carrot cake was so damn good!!! No words to describe the cupcakes that my friends still rave about! Sea salt caramel and sundae are a few of the flavors we got and YUM!! Order ahead for a party and if you love carrot cake this is the only shop to get it from!!! read more

Great selection of cookies and other pastries. Russian Tea Cakes are soooo delicious! Cookies are decorated for all holidays. They also have food(sandwiches, salads, etc.); I have not tried the food. read more

We ordered a tiramisu cake from there for a birthday. I went to pick it up and it wasn't ready when I got there so I had to wait for that. The wait wasn't very long, but still. Something should be ready when they say it will be. The cake was beautiful on the outside, but the inside was a different story. It was supposed to be a three layer cake, I think. The bottom two layers were very thin (about 1/2 inch), and the top layer was three times as thick (about 1.5 inch). The top layer was also a weird shape. It was not a full circle cake like one would expect. It was missing a corner all the way around. They used their frosting all around to fill in where the cake was missing. Super weird and almost comical. As for coffee flavor there was next to none. And the cake itself was also very dry. For a $35 cake I definitely got jipped on the cake part. I will not being going back here again. read more

Rolling Pin Bake Shop - This is what our tiramisu cake looked like inside. Super disappointed in the unprofessional quality. There's also next to no coffee flavor. - Bakeries Near Me - Fitchburg, Wisconsin