Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rosati's Pizza

    3.0 (46 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 11:30 pm

    Order Rosati's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Rosati's Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Rosati's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    I will tell you what isn't in this photo. $2 of mozzarella.

    We paid $2 for mozzarella. Where art thou? Check your cheese before you leave. This is WI after all. ​It could be there if you squint. Maybe dried out? The remnant of failed mozzarella dreams. It strived to be great but the universe took it's toll. RIP dried alfredo. Be one with the dessert that lacks moisture. You are free now. ​

    Deep dish with bacon
    Kolt K.

    We ordered a deep-dish pizza with bacon from Rosati's, and it did not disappoint! This thing was loaded with cheese--every bite was rich, gooey, and incredibly satisfying. Definitely a super filling meal! Service was great, and they were very respectful of the estimated pickup time, which we really appreciated. While they do have a nice little spot, this is more of a grab-and-go place, so calling ahead and picking up is the best way to go. If you're craving a deep dish that brings the cheese in a big way, Rosati's is absolutely worth it!

    Worst customer service I've had in a few years! We asked if we could have half Parmesan and half BBQ wings for the 6 piece wing appetizer. We requested this so my partner and I both could have our preferred wing sauce flavors. The cashier which whom was a middle aged male mocked my partner and said " no we can't do half Parmesan and half BBQ but we can do six Parmesan and six BBQ". Our modification request was not acknowledged but met with a rude response. I'm sorry but when did being sarcastic to a customer ever become acceptable? I grew up in the early 2010's in this neighborhood remembering countless days walking to Rosati's on Commercial Ave for a quick bite. Now I will remember how bad the customer service and food is in 2025. The chicken is dry, and the pizza has too much cheese and onions. I will NEVER give Rosati's my money. They need to work on a respectful atmosphere and being flexible with their food when a customers wants a modification's we shouldn't be talked down to.

    Italian Beef: a paltry amount of beef, with all ingredients it barely fills half the bread :(

    See all

    10 years ago

    LOVE the chief sandwich! Their pies are really good too! Both locations are solid and we usually order as take out.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Madison F.

    Madison F.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Bob N.
    18
    217
    373

    11 years ago

    My go to in this area. Thin crust is a winner. Sauce excellent. Call to pick up always right on time. Prices reasonable.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Madison F.

    Madison F.

    I am so glad you enjoy our food. We really do try to please.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    The huge thin crust supreme pizza we had was delicious! If we lived here, we would be returning.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Madison F.

    Madison F.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Rosati's pizzas are some of the best pizzas around. Hot and fresh ingredients. Hint: custom order how you like the doneness of the crust.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Madison F.

    Madison F.

    Ty for your high praise. I hope you continue to enjoy our food.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Rosati's Pizza

    Review Highlights - Rosati's Pizza

    This thing was loaded with cheese--every bite was rich, gooey, and incredibly satisfying.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Crostini Sandwiches - Philly Chicken Cheesesteak (it's MASSIVE)

    Crostini Sandwiches

    3.9(141 reviews)
    2.8 miEken Park
    $

    It had been so long since I went to Crostini, and it's still a lovely little local spot that now…read moreseems to have more seating (yay!). We were having a work "philly cheesesteak" dinner but needed a good spot to get takeout. We came to Crostini - ordering was super easy and our food was ready and waiting for us upon arrival. Staff was very friendly in our limited interaction. I don't love steak, so I got the philly chicken cheesesteak, and holy moly was this sandwich massive. I could barely even hold it together there was so much chicken going on there!! I ended up keeping all the chicken that naturally fell out of the sandwich as leftovers and put it over rice for a meal the next day. I loved that the sandwich had mushroom and peppers on it, having some veggie interaction made it feel healthy :) Especially considering I got a small french fry with it too (which was actually somewhat large). Ketchup was extra so I went without it and was perfectly happy eating my french fries without condiments. This place definitely still fills a void in the area and I highly recommend checking them out!

    We placed an order for pickup including a sub sandwich, a panini, and fries. Everything was ready…read morein advance of our pickup time which worked out great for us. The online ordering system is a little clunky but they were able to handle our requests (no tomato). And the ability to see your order status was very nice. Our food was still hot (that should be) when we picked up. The actual restaurant is a little awkward when you get inside. There's a small alcove to the left where you place your order. And you have to ring the bell for service. Everyone was super nice and the place looked vibey from what I could see. Not a ton to say since I just picked up. The food was excellent. The sub sandwich comes rolled kind of like a wrap which I wasn't expecting but didn't impact the flavor of experience. The panini was huge and easily 2 meals. Fries were soooo good. Like stadium quality. And don't skip the nacho cheese if you like a classic cheese fry. Overall I'm sad we haven't tried them sooner!

    Photos
    Crostini Sandwiches - The dining area

    The dining area

    Crostini Sandwiches - Philly Chicken Cheesesteak

    Philly Chicken Cheesesteak

    Crostini Sandwiches

    See all

    Hot Lunch - Classic 2.0

    Hot Lunch

    4.6(71 reviews)
    4.5 miTenney - Lapham

    5 stars because these sandwiches were stellar…read more I had the classic 2.0 with the addition of sweet pickled peppers and my SO had the turkey sandwich and we loved them both. The turkey was a hot sandwich while the classic was a cold. The location itself is small, feels like a hole in the wall bar with great cozy vibes. We were lucky enough to bike over on a nice day and so we sat in the outdoor space which is also small but got the job done before we were back on our bikes with happy bellies. We will definitely be revisiting so we can try more of the menu!

    I thoroughly enjoyed myself here, that being said, on par with some of the lower reviews - they did…read morerun out of the pork belly sando, they charge for everything extra, and service was pretty slow. But if you were open to just having a nice casual dinner in a retro easy place, this is it. My fiance and I went to meet up with some friends from out of town and from a list of places I wanted to try, they chose this one. Between the two of us, we spent about $60 for this meal, which I suppose now adays is on par with what you can get away with. We also left with half a sandwich because honestly, these guys are huge! -Hot Beef Sando with Cheese (extra): this was a massive sandwich, packed with flavor. The ah jus was on the side and needed for dunking. It hit the spot, was a messy affair, but was very good. The meat wasn't melt in your mouth, it was actually quite dry, but the mix of everything together and the dip made it good overall. - Chili Cup: well spiced, super small cup and charging a dollar for each addition of onion, cheese, and sour cream is murder. Pass on the fixings, the soup doesn't need it, but it's not something i'd get again as it wasn't knock out of the park good. -Homemade Orange Soda: this was great. I love the nostalgia of using Tang and it was more earthy because they put some spices in it. Overall, would get again. -Coleslaw was asian inspired and made well, especially with the mint on top. Be warned though, its the same slaw on the pulled chicken...which speaking of: -Pulled chicken sandwich: It's their meat americanized fusion version of a banh mi. I know they have a vegan one on their menu, but this one felt less like a sandwich. The spices weren't quite asian tho and was interesting with the slaw. I wouldn't say it was my favorite but I did eat a whole half. Happy nomming!

    Photos
    Hot Lunch
    Hot Lunch
    Hot Lunch

    See all

    Rosati's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...