I love their sourdough (even the day old) for sandwiches! They are a great option for your weekly bread needs. Although I haven't tried their Sammie's, they look delicious! Good quick option for a meal on the go. No seating inside. But you get fast service with a smile. And can place your order on the website ahead of time. read more

Stalzy's Deli - Day old sourdough loaves $5.50 each!!! - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Seems now they stopped serving breakfast. I picked up a half wheat bread. That was excellent. Bialys was flavorful. Butter bread was ok. I got a potato salad, but didn't like it at all. Taste was off. Overall I will return only to get more bread. read more

See all

Hands down the best corned beef and pastrami in Madison! Fabulous ham, too. Their Reuben is my favorite sandwich in town. I miss the restaurant, but at least Stalzy's is still around, and I can pick up a pound of meat whenever. read more

Finally visited and am thoroughly disappointed. I hate leaving bad reviews, but this is Not a deli. I ordered a "Rachel" sandwich, which is corned beef with Swiss, and coleslaw. First, I asked to taste the coleslaw because I dislike sweet ones. This counter person brought me a fork with 3! tiny slivers of cabbage on it. Huh??? The "sample" didn't even cover a quarter of the plastic fork. Anyway, it was nicely vinegared, so I ordered the sandwich. I specifically asked if they had deckel (fatty) corned beef. The counter person went in the back to ask; came back and said yes. Nowhere on the menu did this say the meat was grilled. If it had, I would have asked for it Not to be! They grilled all of the lovely and tasty fat fat right out of the deckel and chopped it finely!!! WTAF?!? Also, we were watching a baker working with a large batch of freshly made bread dough on a table about 10 feet behind the counter. I saw this guy touch his face 3 or 4 times while he was working the dough! Not only that, but he was called over to the register to change the receipt tape and, after handling the machine all over and inserting the new roll of paper, went Directly back to working the dough!! NEVER AGAIN. read more

During covid we got takeout from here but I wanted to try the dine-in experience. We stopped on a Friday evening and it was relatively quiet. The workers were all very helpful and friendly. We ordered the Reuben with pastrami and the smoked salmon sandwich. Both came with chips. And I got a Hamm's beer too! The sandwiches were both $15 which these days seems the new normal. The wait was not too long. Both sandwiches were very delicious with a good portion of the main ingredients. The bread was top notch. There were many other sandwiches on the menu that I would return to try. A very solid deli experience. read more

We arrived, by coincidence, on the night they announced the restaurant was closing. Though there was mention of the Deli part still open to walk-in customers. The staff was super friendly and kind as they turned away clients... turns out we were most likely the last to be seated that night. They told those arriving after us, that they had run out of food. Our meal did not live up to previous visits. Compared to previous visits, our sandwiches were very light on meat, I guess that parallels the running out of food situation. I'm not sure of the future plans for this location, but I'd go back and hope for the yummy Ruben I had on previous visits. read more

Tried them at a festival. The line was so long. They didn't hand out tickets, and people that went after me and paid totally cut and took sandwiches first before their turn. My only feedback going forward is get cheap numbers or tickets to make people be nice and wait their turn in line so there doesn't end up being a fistfight over a brisket sandwich. Lol But once I got the sandwich, WOW. I had their french onion braised brisket. Most tender and best flavored brisket I had ever had. The portion size was so generous you could've totally split this with someone else. I also had to eat part of it with a fork, so it's not some thing you can pick up with your hand but it is so delicious and worth it. Pretty good value also for 14 bucks. It was worth the wait. read more

Stalzy's Deli - a menu on a sign - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

This is a cool place! I just picked up a sandwich to go but there is a great dining area. I love the seating at the old school counter table. I ordered the BLT. There are lots of good looking sandwiches on the menu. It took about 15 minutes for them to make it. The BLT was great! I'm picky when it comes to bacon but I was impressed. The bacon was well cooked and tasty. They paired the sandwich with a pickle and amazing sea salt kettle chips. Overall a great atmosphere, friendly staff, and great BLTs. They also have a parking lot next door which makes it easy. I will be back! read more

See all

This spot was a great breakfast experience! I was so pleasantly surprised with my first impression! Staff was super friendly and helpful with menu items. I got nostalgic seeing the creamed pickled herring and red beets . My great grandma was Czechoslovakian and those memories came back with the quickness seeing some of their deli items. I will definitely be back!!! read more

Stalzy's Deli - Corned beef hash and a potato pancake - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Matt the awesome bartender at Fairchild gave us a recommendation to go here for hungover "brunch" while we were in town for the weekend. He did great - this was DELICIOUS. And geez, it smells good in here too. Such a satisfying sandwich and thick cut chips. read more

Stalzy's Deli - Combination pastrami and corned beef on rye. - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

We've been trying to stop back at Stalzy's for a few years now, we used to live in the neighborhood and come by all the time. They closed due to an unfortunate fire and then the pandemic hit. We finally made it back today for brunch. If this place isn't at the top of your brunch spots to visit, you need to add it to your list. Greeted by friendly staff members, you place your order at the counter and seat yourself. There are plenty of brunch and lunch options here, we had the brisket hash and Brooklyn breakfast sandwich, and two bloodies of course! The sandwich was hot, pastrami flavorful, and the egg runny, just how you want on a breakfast sand. Every sandwich here hits the mark with excellent baked bread and perfectly sliced deli meats. Stalzy's has new decor, but has the same classics that never fail to satisfy. We can wait to come back again, see you soon Stalzy's! read more

Stalzy's Deli - Bloody and a beer chaser - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Quality has gone downhill since the fire & pandemic seemingly in inverse relation to the price. People don't seem to mind though, it's always packed. Had a $17(!) corned beef sandwich today and it was chewy, the meat had the smell of old deli meat about to turn, & the bread was stale and crumbly. My wife had a club sandwich (also overpriced) that was merely OK. The meat used to be of a much higher quality when it first opened. We went there all the time. Now it's not worth it. Some of their other menu items are better (more ingredients mask the quality?) & I still enjoy their breakfast items. It's hard to mess up breakfast. Service is so-so. Staff seems annoyed to have to interact with the customers but they're not outright rude. read more

I wasn't that impressed, if you want different forms of a Reuben sandwich maybe you'd like it. I didn't think they were particularly friendly and the prices were not great. I hate to say so, but it wasn't what I hoped. Sandwich was just okay to me. read more

Worst takeout experience so far, and we have been doing a lot of takeout over the last year. In all honesty, this is the closest I have ever been to giving a one star review. They get two stars because I could tell that the staff felt really bad for how the whole process went. We ordered a turkey pastrami reuben for pickup on St. Patrick's Day. Now this was probably a mistake as they were experiencing very large numbers of orders, however this was not made known through their order system online. I scheduled my order for pickup at 5:05pm and when I arrived and called, they said that they were running a little behind. That wasn't a problem and I asked how long they thought the wait would be. I was told 30 minutes, so I said I would go pick up something else and come back. When I came back, I called again and told them where my car was parked and they said that they would bring the order out. So I waited, and waited, and waited. Finally I went into the deli to ask what was going on with my order. The whole street was also full of cars and their was a line outside the deli that went down the block. When I went inside my order seemed to be ready and sitting on the table, but no one had brought it out to me. I finally got my food at 6:40pm when my pickup time was 5:05pm. This seems like a little too long for just a sandwich and chips. As for the reuben itself, they get points for the amount of turkey pastrami that was on the sandwich and the meat itself was actually pretty good. However, overall the sandwich was quite greasy and wet. I understand the idea was to give a lot of meat, but the sandwich didn't balance flavors well. The bread just didn't seem to hold up to the moisture of the sandwich and so it was all kind of mushy texture, which I feel bad saying because I had high hopes. This combined with the price of the sandwich, $13 for the sandwich and some chips, didn't make this the most satisfying takeout experience. I really, really was wishing that the sandwich would have been better after the amount of time it took to get it, but who knows how long it was sitting on the table. I hope to give them another chance, but this was just a really bad experience. read more

Stalzy's Deli - Turkey pastrami Reuben with Slide chips - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Lack of Communication, care and leadership. While standing inside waiting for a pre-timed pickup and ordered 2 hours in advance for 2 sandwiches, I watched cooks and staff having fun. For 25 minutes past pickup time I was told "it's just going to be a couple minutes" while others who just ordered walking in got their food. Very disappointing from a company who once held it together. This is most likely the last time we will return. read more

I had the best sandwich of my life here! The owner is so nice and the food is incredible! Such a nice atmosphere in the restaurant as well! You can really tell that everything is homemade and good quality! Can't wait to come back read more

I've been looking for an East Coast deli in Madison ever since I moved back a couple of years ago. Stalzy's is the place! Atmosphere is very casual, place is clean. Not a ton of seating but people cycled in and out in a timely fashion. Food was wonderful. The broth in the matzoh ball soup was rich and exquisite. Had the Rachel with turkey pastrami-perfectly toasted and salty/creamy. My dining partner had the mushroom Reuben and loved it. Grabbed some bialies and chocolate chip cookies to go. Cookies were delicious and didn't last the day. read more

Butter buns are everything. Get a pack and salt the top and warm them. We love trying new things here- such a fun neighborhood place to grab breakfast or lunch. I'm here for all the bread read more

See all

Went to Stalzy's to pick up a sammie for lunch today for the first time. It will absolutely be the last. I ordered a pastrami Reuben to go. Get home (a couple blocks away), and unwrap it. Mushy bread. Open it up to see it, a ton of fat. Now, I'm not talking the silky, well cooked fat that you don't mind eating. This was undercooked rubber. Pull all of it off the meat, and there's not much meat left. Take a bite, and the whole piece of meat pulls out of the sandwich, because it's not correctly cooked. That was, without a doubt, the crappiest sammie I've ever had. Threw half of it away. And almost $15 for just the freaking sandwich! Save your money. You will be disappointed. read more

Weirdly no crowd on a Sunday at brunch time! A great place to get food without any wait to speak of, you can buy fresh loaves of bread and I've seen many people come in for picnic sandwich making supplies- This 5 star review is for the Challah French Toast! I am usually a strictly waffles person but this French toast rivals the best waffle in Madison, I almost don't want the secret to get out, the staff is friendly and quick. A solid experience each time we come for breakfast, lucky to have this reliable breakfast so close to home. read more

Great food all around. Homemade everything and can't beat that. Cubano sandwich was melt in your mouth pork. Reuben had delicious sour kraut and just EnouGH thousand island to get a taste not smothering. read more

My first time and last time ever for Stalzy's. I wanted a Reuben sandwich from a real deli. The corned beef was dry and so tough it was impossible to chew. I explained to the "waitress" the quality of the meat rendered the sandwich inedible. He response was "Well, that's what we have." Not "I'm sorry", "let me check with the cook", "what can I do for you". She had zero interest the quality of the food, or in my satisfaction. $16 lesson learned. Oh and the chips are drenched in grease. What an utter fail. read more

A great place to stop for breakfast or lunch! Lots of drink choices, sandwiches and breakfast stuff featuring corned beef. They have a nice bloody Mary or Hamm's on tap and you keep the neat glass!! In sight bike parking outside. read more

See all

The service was slow (for a non-busy visit), the kettle chips were cold and greasy, the burger was luke-warm. You are expected to bus your own table and yet they ask for a tip before you even get your food. At least the lettuce and tomatoes were fresh. read more

We stopped for lunch on Friday 4/26/24. Dad a delicious Ruben with Pastrami and cold slaw. We ask them to split it because we are elderly and can't eat large portions. They cheerfully did that. It was delicious. We will definitely be returning soon. There are so many choices. This is nice for Madison's east side. Great parking beside the restaurant. read more

I can't believe I've been sleeping on Stalzy's and already can't wait to return. I almost exclusively order a standard turkey or an Italian sandwich when out, but will likely eat my way through this entire menu. Had the turkey pastrami Rachel today. Comfortable inside, good counter service. Wasn't a huge fan of the chips, but know to order a deli side next time. Shocked this only has 3.5 stars, it's 10/10. read more

Saturday afternoon lunch to go: reuben, rachel, grilled cheese were all excellent! Curbside pickup. Call ahead and place your order, then they bring your order out when you call back to let them know you've arrived. Nearby parks make for a nice and socially distanced lunch. I also liked the German potato salad as a side. The best deli I've experienced in Madison! read more

The worst experience I've had with a deli Rubin sandwich was made with dried up corn beef that I wouldn't Feed my dog read more

Wonderful food and excellent fresh bread. Was not crazy about the matzoh ball soup also, since it was our first time there, was a little confused on if we should tip or not. They gave us a number at the counter after we paid and we sat down. I was unaware that they bring us our food but we clean up after ourselves. Now that we know that we know what to expect, but definitely will be going back for the food and fresh sliced bread. read more

Try the brat/egg/baked bean/toast breakfast - I felt like I was back in London again. You won't regret it.

First time with my friends. They had some type of Rachael. They said it was yummy but very messy. I had the Lox sandwich. Came with chips and a pickle. Sandwich was huge. I'm not used to having so much with a lox sandwich. Maybe it was just me and I am very familiar with salmon, husband owned a Japanese restaurant for many years. And I've had Lox at other different places but not only was there too much of it but also it tasted too fishy and I love fishy fish. I don't think I'll be ordering Lox from here again. I'll try other items. I'm not much of a root beer gal but I wanted to give it a try. It was very yummy root beer. read more

The food is good, but pretty bad service. When ordering online they give a pickup time (usually about a half hour for one or two sandwiches), and we consistently end up waiting at least 20 minutes over the estimated pickup time, just idling in our car outside. My partner loves their food, but for me it doesn't feel worth it. read more

I've lived in the area for a long time and outside of having their bread at other local establishments, I've never actually gone/eaten their other food. Recently though, I got take out and tried their Reuben, Curry/garlic chips, potato salad, and sourdough bread. All were very good. If possible, I would give them a 4.5 out of 5. Nothing absolutely wowed me to push this to a 5, but this was still better than just a normal 4. The Reuben had good flavor, but could have used a little more kraut and corned beef. The potato salad was light and delicious. The chips were unique and I liked them a lot. The sourdough was solid. Overall, I had a good experience and would definitely recommend Stalzy's. Not too sure why the other reviews on here are as low as they are, because I don't see how this place could be below a 4 at the lowest. I will be back. read more

Stalzy's Deli - Reuben sandwhich and potato salad. - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

You can't get much better when you are in the mood for a high-quality sandwich. I ordered the special hot roast beef sandwich with horseradish sauce. It was perfect. Tender, high quality roast beef with great sauce. The bun may have stolen the show, it was an incredible carraway roll. Hard to make a great sandwich without good bread, and Stalzy's always nails it on the bread. Only part of the meal I wasn't a fan of was the sweet & sour coleslaw on the side. But it probably wasn't their fauly, coleslaw in general just isn't really my cup of tea. Can't wait to come back to try their Friday fish fry or brunch! read more

Stalzy's Deli - Special hot roast beef sandwich on the best Caraway roll ever. - Delis Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Stalzy's fish fry is simply, the best. It's not the cheapest fish fry, but it's high quality and different than what you might get elsewhere - potato pancakes, German potato salad, and the best coleslaw in town. And after a bumpy start, Stalzy's has built a smooth system for curbside pick-up (and that's all you can ask and hope for in these strange times!). But, don't just come for the fish fry - the bread, meats, sides - everything is delicious. My personal favorite is their BLT, which...well, I can't think of a better one in town. Enjo read more

I will be back! I've had this place bookmarked for a while now. Came in on Sunday for a late lunch... We got such an entrance by a man behind the counter that was so excited to show us the menu. I asked for a suggestion from the man, and i order The Rachel (Turkey with slaw). It was super!! My boyfriend enjoyed his bloody and Tough Guy sandwich. They also have their own parking lot (major +++ in that neighborhood). read more

See all

I love Stalzy's sandwiches and am basically addicted to their chocolate/butterscotch bars, so I had been eager to try their Friday fish fry and it did not disappoint! You get a choice of walleye or beer battered perch (they used Hamm's when we were there, not sure if they switch it up) and a choice of potato pancakes or German potato salad. I went with the walleye, my husband the perch and both were perfectly cooked and battered. The batter on the perch was particularly excellent - I swear you could taste the beer. The potato pancakes were a nice change of pace instead of the usual fish fry potato options, but they are definitely filling! They also bring out a relish tray with assorted breads prior to the entrees. I thought the $16 price was very reasonable. The service, as usual, was awesome and I love the comfortable space of this deli. read more

See all

This is a quaint deli with a private parking lot. While there isn't a lot of seating they do have counter space if you don't get the chance to find a table after you order. However, this lovely deli is well worth a visit. Ordering is easy as the menu is displayed on a chalkboard above the counter. Everything is fresh. Bread is crispy on the outside, soft and doughy on the inside and then you add your meats. The smell of the rotisserie and smoked meats make your mouth water as you patiently wait (only a short time) for your food. There is a large cooler of lovely drinks to choose from, desserts as well. The decor is pleasant with beautiful original paintings from a local artist who painted in France. The staff is kind and the place has a calm, cheery vibe to it. Well worth a stop. read more

salty burger, no concern for bad experience from staff member. The place was clean...........

I love everything at Stalzy's! The bread and rolls are excellent, fish fry is delicious, the reuben with turkey pastrami or the Brooklyn breakfast sandwich are tied for favorite sandwiches, and don't even get me started on the bloody mary, pickled beets, German potato salad, and potato pancakes. My mouth is watering just thinking about all the delicious options! read more