Good pizza, pricey but good Also has deserts that are great also Delivery person very friendly and nice. Arrived hot. read more

Gluten free and super cheesy!! I really liked this place. I'll go pick up next time bc door dash was way too much. read more

Glass Nickel never disappoints. We had not been to this location before; we stopped because it is very conveniently located near our destination for the evening, the Barrymore Theater. This location is in an older building, it's a bit rustic, but nicely decorated and clean. We ordered the pizza of the month, the "Italian Stallion", and it was very good. Server... well, I really liked her. So it was the usual Glass Nickel job. Two thumbs up. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Digging in to the Italian Stallion pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Always a great choice! I love the variety of unique specialty pizzas, and everything I've tried has been delicious. The feta is my favorite! The staff are always super friendly, and online ordering is quick and easy. Definitely my go-to pizza spot in Madison. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Feta-licious Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Have eaten here numerous times as a single eater. Was told by the hostess upon my arrival, 5:10, she could not seat me at a table for one and I would have to sit at the bar. I can understand if they were overwhelmingly busy but they were not and several 2-person tables were available. In fact, there was a gentleman sitting by himself at a table for two just getting ready to leave. Again, if they had been busy I could understand but they were not. So, someplace else is getting my business tonight. read more

Went to the Atwood location to grab a pizza for takeout on a Monday night. They had a steady stream of people coming in to eat there and pick up to go orders. Apparently there is also trivia on Mondays, so that may have been part of it. We ordered the portabella lugosi specialty pizza and the spinach cheese bread, since there was a deal going on. They were super quick with the turnaround as it was maximum a 15 minute wait. Staff was very friendly and gave us extra packets if red pepper flakes and parmesan for the road. Pizza overall was tasty. The kids liked the sausage on it so much that they picked it off to eat and just left the rest of us with the mushrooms on our pizza slices. Given the lack of sausage on my slices, i added some honey and red pepper to amp the flavor. Highly recommend! The spinach cheese bread was a surprise with how much people liked it. Paired nicely with the marinara sauce and had a nice crunch to the crust with a pillowy inside. Overall good as always! read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Portobella lugosi - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Ordered online to be delivered at hotel, passing through town. Got the gluten free crust with vegan toppings. Flavor was great! Crust was good but very crispy edges, which I don't mind:) Hubs got the build your pasta- cavatappi noodles, Alfredo sauce, added chicken, garlic, broccoli, mushroom, black olives and he devoured it! Delivery was about an hour but it does say busy times are Friday and Saturday night. Delivery gal was very nice and polite and food arrived nice and warm! read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Cavapatti Mix N Match Pasta, Alfredo, chicken, broccoli, mushrooms, garlic and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Becca was so amazing with her customer services skills and kindness I will always come back to this spot because of her. she was amazing

This place is absolutely amazing. I ordered this place for pick up as I was coming home and stopped in town for one of the specialty pizzas and a pep pizza. I have to say it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had everything about it just came together so nice. read more

I've been to Glass Nickel three times, and each experience has been better than the last. The service was iffy the first time I went, but this time it was great. For an appetizer, I highly recommend the toasted ravioli. It's hot and crispy and cheesy and delicious. I've done both a build-your-own pizza and the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm pizza and they were yummy! But the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm is really amazing. It's got both Alfredo and traditional red sauce on it. Truly an exceptional combo. In terms of ambiance, Glass Nickel is a great date night spot. The vibes are just right -- not too loud, and you can find a cozy booth to occupy. I'll definitely be returning to this restaurant in the future. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Toasted Cheese Ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Ordered pizzas and salads. Pizzas were great but we ordered chicken Caesar salads. Received the salads to find out that there was no chicken, so we paid extra for something we didn't receive. Huge disappointment read more

I have no words for this, but, DELICIOUS!!! Their pizza gives me happiness and I love it. Excellent ingredients and tops for delivery and temperature!! This pizza is what I dream of, A must have!!! read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - 14 - Deluxe pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Shocking to see this place rated any less than 4.5 stars! The pizza is ordered from them last night was the first proper American pizza I've had since I moved to the Midwest from New Emgland. The crust is properly cooked and has its own flavor, and they follow the instructions they're given. I ordered a New Haven style pizza purely by selecting options on grubhub. I didn't even get to use my own words. They still nailed it. It's exactly like the pizza I used to eat when I was going to college in Connecticut and they didn't even know that's what I wanted. I bet if I called my order in and described it with my own words, they could make it EVEN BETTER! Very satisfied with the overall quality but also the flawless competency of their chefs even when preparing a doordash order near closing.​ read more

Love the variety of specialty pizzas, plus new ones as pizza of the month. Can't beat their delivery, on point staff.

Have had their pizza several times, very good! Even better is their pasta w/meat sauce and chefs salad (I got 2 meals out of the portion size). read more

Pizza crust is a little doughy for us. Specialty pizzas aren't anything extraordinary. Got it delivered and when we opened the pizza box half the cheese had come off the pizza and stuck to the side of the box. Instead of getting refunded we got store credit for pizzas we don't even like. read more

We ordered delivery from Glass Nickel last night. The online ordering process is straightforward and easy. Our pizza arrived piping hot and about an hour before their estimated delivery time which was awesome. The sausage was very good- nice pieces and not spicy, which is important to my sausage loving toddler. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

We are picky about good food and service and you will not be disappointed if you eat here!

I have had a 75% success rate with my orders being correct here, but the pizza is really good, order comes out on time, and the appetizers not bad so I keep coming back. Tried a new pizza for Pi Day and tried the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm. Wanted it to be thin crust but it came out regular. Oh well, maybe next time it will be correct. Good amount of sauce and the chicken fried up nicely on the cheesy topping. I usually order The Carnivore --that is a top notch pizza. And the Mac and Cheese Pizza isn't bad either but I don't come here for that one. The mac and cheese bites I also tried were good, but not my top choice (the ravioli bites are better). Overall, I will keep coming because I love their pizza sauce, they use good ingredients, and the staff is friendly. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Chicky chicky parm parm, 10 inches. Was supposed to be on a thin crust but came out as regular crust. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

The pizza here is fire. Good crust, great cheese pull, tasty toppings. Their beer selection is good with plenty of eclectic options and a smattering of mainstream boring beers to keep the pleebs happy too. Service is friendly and accommodating. Ambiance is dark woods and a little divey. Every time I've come here I've had a good time. You probably will too. read more

See all

I haven't had pizza this good in ages! The ingredients were incredibly fresh, and the crust was perfect. This place brought back so many good memories. It's like stepping back in time! read more

Don't go on Trivia Night. Can't get a table. Never ate the food. Could be awesome,... I wouldn't know. read more

Had Glass Nickel while traveling. Good pizza. Very much a college-town type pizza but good nonetheless. Will order from them again.

Mid This was just mid, the pizza was extremely mid. The cheese sticks were disappointing. I've had better pizza at chuckie cheese. The service was great, don't get me wrong. Great people great atmosphere But the food is like a slap in the face, this place was highly recommended to me. I was left blue balled read more

We ordered delivery as we were in town for the night, and the pizza was mediocre. The crust was chewy and almost seemed undercooked. There was plenty of cheese on the pizza. The breadsticks were dry but had good flavor. Our delivery was quick and friendly. read more

Grabbing pizza here was worth the windy rainy drive through downtown Madison. Ok. I was the reason for the windy drive because I wanted to see more of the city. But the joint is in a historic area that is too cute for words. And the pizza is crispy and tasty and different. Sometimes that's exactly what you want and need. 10/10 would come here again. read more

See all

I sat at the bar waiting for my pizza. I waited on a bartender who seems to be doing the work of two people. I felt sorry for her. She seemed overwhelmed. I asked for two shots and a beer and got them accordingly. The bar has interesting decor. Nickels and dime decorate the bar. It honestly feels like a dive bar. No complaints on the pizza and waiting on the bartender. My pizza was delicious and I plan on coming back. read more

Bartender was accommodating and friendly. Manager was also there and came out to make recommendations for pizza. Both were constantly prepping for the evening rush, while still taking care of customers. Nice to see a professional operation, pizza and cleanliness were both excellent!! read more

We stopped here because almost everything else was closed(Sunday after 9pm) and I am so happy we did. The pizza was amazing as well as the cheese bread. The beer selection was really good. Service was fantastic and fast(server 65). Prices were really good as well. We went back this week and were just as happy with the lasagna and huge side salad(enough for all 3 of us). We will definitely be back. read more

Perfectly cooked pizza and downright delectable cinna nuggets! My son and I ordered to our hotel, and while there was a slight delay in the delivery, we would definitely order again! read more

Stopped in late on a Friday evening and were seated immediately. This was our first time here and it will not be the last since it is so close to our house. Also we had a $10 off coupon which was nice. Our friendly waitress was very helpful and also explained why there was uproarious laughter from the basement (improv on the weekend which we will need to check-out). Liked that they had a Mai Tai on the menu and it was very good especially at $7 ($5 on Mondays!) There were many good choices on the menu including some tempting apps but we settled on the Boarish Karloff pizza which was very good with lots of meat. The only knock was that the crust, while thin and tasty, was not as paper thin as we like. We are still getting used to large pizzas being $23 - seems to be standard pricing in Madison - at least $4 more than we were used to back East. We will be back. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - First time here! Got a Mai Tai for a bit of warmth on this cold night! Looking forward to our pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Cool place but a VERY boring pizza. I mean, it's not bad it's just really boring. REALLY BORING!

The garlic bread nuggets!!! Amazing!!! The pizza was good as well but the Garlic Bread Nuggets are a must when ordering from here! I recommend Glass Nickel Pizza. read more

I was told the salads were good. It was equivalent to a fast food salad like at McDonald's. Pizza was mediocre at best read more

Glass Nickel is an old-style pizza establishment akin to Pizza Hut. Greasy, doughy pizza make this place a must for lovers of heartier pizza. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Cardiac Arrest Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Absolutely delicious gluten free pizza and cheese sticks! You'd never know they are GF. Yum!!! Would definitely go there again.

i come all the time but I decided to order a dude came up asked for the exact change which it's cool but was mad about the wait then he tried setting my food on the ground which was weird because I asked for delivery then pay but still my pizza was cold and I live few minutes away read more

Beer was cold and delicious pizza was on point. Breadsticks were well interesting but delicious. Cool place and delicious pizza.

Good tasting pizza, when you don't want to cook. We ordered 2 pizzas: a sausage, onion and green pepper pizza that was Delish. The second pizza: a gluten-free, Boris Karloff Pizza. We were a little disappointed in the GF size as they only have a 10 inch gluten-free. We really would like a larger, gluten free pie again very good flavors and cooked well. read more

Great Place!!! I love pizza. I was skeptical to try this place after reading the reviews but it was great! I ordered a half Cardiac Arrest half Chicken Alfredo on thin crust! The pizza was hot, fresh and very favorable. The rep mentioned it would be 45min to an hour which is why I ordered while heading home. The pizza was delivered on time. Good customer service! I will definitely recommend this place to others who are also visiting from out of town. read more

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Madison East - Half Chicken Alfredo and half Cardiac Arrest - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin