We were searching for a good sub place that wasn't a chain, and I'm SO glad we found this! The owner was working by himself and was incredibly friendly and personable, which made the experience even better. The subs were absolutely delicious, and the bread was so soft and fresh. We also decided to grab a cheese pizza to go with our meal, and that definitely didn't disappoint either! We're not from the area, but one thing is for sure--next time we're in Madison, we WILL be back! Highly recommend checking this place out if you're looking for great food and a friendly, local spot. read more

Good crust and sauce. Delivered fast and hot. No cheese. Toppings are visible, as thin as air-brushed images. They don't have any content, flavor or value. Spent $40 on a sauce and bread. Complete waste of money. North Shore is a disgrace to non-franchise neighborhood pizza joints. read more

We always enjoy North Shore. Everything is always good. The salads, pizza and sandwiches. Very authentic East Coast! read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

Food always good subs are huge Only thing is tough time when school is open. Lunch time is impossible to go then. read more

All fantastic couldn't decide which was best - meatball sub or Green Monster pizza! Both fantastic flavor!

My boos bestie has been raving about this place so we finally tried it. This review is food only, we've only done takeout. So far we've had pizza, salad, and a couple pasta dishes. The pizza was VERY good, definitely in my top three for the area now. Salad was a little bit plain but honestly, still good. No wilted lettuces or anything like that, all very fresh. But what made me want to write a review was the Sausage Parm and the Eggplant Parm--omg both so good! Literally obsessed with both. Never had a sausage parm before & it slaaaaaps. And the eggplant parm was one of the best I've had in my life, ever, anywhere. Not too oily, not too chewy. This chef was like, "what like it's hard?" When it seems like it is for so many others. Bravo, baby! We love it. The whole place has a bit of an east coast vibe going on which we are INTO...no garlic knots on the menu though & that's a shame. Thanks for the recommendation, H. read more

It's been a while since I've been so absolutly disappointed by a pizza place that I just throw the whole thing rite in the trash..... pizza wasn't even cooked . Was covered in an ungodly amount of tomato sauce, almost no cheese at all. Old hard and crusty chicken and not an ounce of buffalo anything on the pizza..... which is kinda the entire point in ordering a buffalo chicken pizza but I guess no one here knows what that actually means or even how to make a decent pizza read more

We decided to give this place a try, had heard enough buzz about it to peak our curiosity. It's a clean, brightly lit place, ample seating and an arcade in the back. The person taking our order was polite and quick, informed us it would be about 30 minutes until our pizzas were ready and she was right. We ordered 2-16" pizzas, sausage and black olives. The crust is really good, just the right balance of chew and crispness. There definitely could have been more sauce on both pizzas. The sausage pizza was a bit greasy, but good. Sausage itself was good, but a little sparse. Black olive pizza was good, less greasy. Pizza is obviously a saltier food in general, but these seemed a bit saltier than most. There is room for improvement, in my opinion. But don't rule them out, definitely give them a try. read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - Sausage Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

Probably my favorite east coast style pizza and sandwich place. They literally never miss. We usually get the Italian and the Steak Special, but you also can't go wrong with the pizza. It's the best of its kind in the city. It's got a cute arcade attached to it, although we didn't partake the last time we went. Typical pizza place ambiance, nothing fancy but quite nostalgic. Only 4 stars because FOH staff seemed a bit off their game yesterday - maybe because of the busy weekend or long week with school. We all have our bad days, but try to not show it, especially as you're front-facing with guests. I will still be back, though. read more

Stopped by to support some good friends--and left totally impressed. The pizza was amazing. The crust had that perfect golden edge and just the right bite--honestly unforgettable. We got half "The House" (their signature pizza) and half mozzarella with sausage. My grandson couldn't stop raving about it--kid-approved and grandparent-approved! This is one of those places built with heart, hustle, and a whole lot of love--every detail reflects the dream behind it. Cozy, welcoming, and full of flavor. We'll absolutely be back! read more

My boyfriend and I just moved here from the east coast (NJ and CT) and we knew we needed to find a pizza place out here that compares with quality and taste of east coast pizzerias. Safe to say that North Shore Pizza is one of the best if not THE best pizzerias in Wisconsin. Food was good, and everything about it truly reminded me of my little hometown pizzeria. We will definitely be back! read more

First time trying north shore pizza. The lady helping us was very nice and luckily we they were not to busy while we decided what we wanted. Pizza had a lot of good toppings ect for the price read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - Pizza lots of toppings - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

See all

First time at this small joint. Called ahead for pickup and ordered the Steak Special (cheese, mushrooms, onions n pepper) and opted in for the 'large' 12in. They definitely packed the full 12"! I wish there would've been more cheese otherwise every bite contained all the special. Also got a side of fries, not sure if it was already packed n waiting but it was soggy. Saved the second half for lunch the next day. I'd definitely be back! read more

Will be back to have another sub here. Cold Italian was my first try, and it has me piqued in what other tasty food I can devour. This is some quality sammich materials being used here. Bread is perfectly soft, yet bitable. The salami and bologna were fatty and salty. All the fixings (I recommend) bring this up to be an above average experience at a wonderful price. Literally, the large is a 16 inch sub for like $11!? Fantastic. Looking forward to coming back for something else. read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - 1/2 Large Italian Submarine Sammich with and order of fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

Great sauce! Good people and good prices! Yummy!! Meatball Hero is my go to but I love the pizza, too. read more

Hands down best pizza in the Madison area. Got a classic cheese pie, definitely authentic New York style. Sauce was fresh, from scratch and delicious. Crust was light, had the perfect chew and some nice crunchy spots. Cheese melty, bubbly, and not greasy. Accidentally inhaled 4 slices on the way home . In addition, it felt like a nice and chill neighborhood spot. Plus, it has a dope arcade! Would highly recommend for anyone looking for that NY style. read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - Large cheese pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

Give them a little time. That was the general sentiment from the 14/16 year old employees that were working tonight. They were sweet and knowledgeable but unprepared for a steady stream of customers on a Friday night. No fountain machine. You can purchase bottled sodas for $2.50 each. They don't have an alcohol license yet so no beer and no BYOB. No water dispenser, the staff (half) filled plastic cups from a bartender's sink. You can't bring drinks in the arcade area, which felt like it was 90 degrees in a tightly packed nook past the dining area. We ordered the grilled chicken salad, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, a large fajita pizza. The salad arrived as torn pieces of iceberg lettuce, shaved carrots, onions, tomatoes and blackened chicken chunks in a plastic takeaway box. The mozzarella sticks and onion rings were unremarkable with the latter served without a dipping sauce, likely from the folks at SYSCO. The pizza was the star here with generous toppings sprinkled throughout the large pie, but the middle portion appeared undercooked and mushy. The arcade is on the pricier side with most of the games costing a dollar to play. It is my understanding they have only been open for 2 months so maybe give them some time to work out the kinks and we will return. read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - Hot Wheels pin ball! - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

Tastes like the east coast to us, so if that's what you are looking for then this is a place to try.

Chicken finger Alfredo had almost no sauce and was missing a lot of flavor but the Pastrami Special Sub was fantastic. One of the best sandwiches I have had in Madison read more

Best sub in town. Been here twice and can't recommend enough. Loved the turkey with everything and extra oil and vinegar.

We are Monona residents so wanted to try the new local place. I want to try the pizza, but we got 2 sandwiches instead- the veal and the chicken bomb. There are no online descriptions of what is in them, or what size the small vs large is, but I guess one can figure it out. The sandwiches are large and filling and tasty! We also got a side of fries (delicious) and jalapeño poppers (lackluster & need a sauce). But because of the arcade, we'll be back. I would assume if they sold beer, North Shore would do a bit more business but as of now, they do not. read more

Their pizza is delicious and super affordable. We have gotten sausage and sausage with mushroom. Also tried one of their steak sandwiches which was also yummy, but could use a little extra something for more flavor. Either way, I'd still eat it again because the ingredients were quality. Definitely recommend checking this place out. Also fun to take the kids to since they have an arcade! read more

Ok, hubby heard about this place on a Facebook ad. Figured we would try it since there is very little aside from chain pizza, burger & fries which we were definitely sick of. First time, and I say first time because we can't quit going there! We ordered a 16"cheese pizza and wings. Lemme tell ya, I have recently been to New York for the 1st time in my life and had true NY Pizza.....there is just no way to explain all the differences between what they call pizza out here in the Midwest and what NY makes. North Shore Pizza & Subs is owned by a man from Boston and lemme tell you.....HE KNOWS HOW TO MAKE A DAMN GOOD NY PIZZA!!! Like the crust was the chewy crunch you want with a nice sauce and just the right amount of cheese. PERFECTION! So the following weekend hubby and I got another pizza just cause it was that good. You don't need to ruin it with toppings folks. Just get the pie the way the good Lord intended. Cheese alone. Again, was awesome! The next time we went, I wasn't able to eat but hubby ordered the meatball sub which comes small or large. The small is an easy 6" and more than enough for an adult man. But if you really want a foot long....it'll only cost you a couple bucks more. But this sub was stuffed full of wonderful meatballs a marinara and cheese. So very tasty. Daughter ordered chicken Alfredo pasta dinner that night and was very pleased. I didn't try any but she wasn't sharing anyways. LOL So last night we had to order again because the menu is so big we gotta try all the stuff. So last night I ordered a small Steak Special Sub, hubby got the meatball Sub again and daughter ordered the Chicken Parm Sub. In our house we pass our food around so everyone can taste everything. I was very impressed with all of it. But my Steak Special was out of this world! When I say sub sammich around here you get a giant piece of bread with hardly any sammich in it. Not with North Shore! Here you get far more meat than bread and it's so tender and seasoned beautifully. There's a melted cheese in there along with onions, bell peppers and mushrooms with the steak and cheese sauce. The only complaint I can even think of here is that the cheese was so good I wish it were in more of the sammich instead of the inside 1/3rd. Orders have always been taken by the same man that seems to own the place. He always says it'll be ready in 15-20 minutes and it has been every time. Hubby is from Long Island so they chat a bit and I'm sure this guy knows my husband by now. LOL There is a small seating area if you want to stay and eat. The place is clean enough and has an arcade! I think the place is the old arcade that was always across the street from Monona Grove High School. It's the same building. Y'all need to check this place out! You will be glad you did. To the owner.....please don't change, you are our go to dinner spot! read more

Not a super inviting environment and the menu could add a little more description of what's on the subs. The sign had me thinking this was a skater vibe and it would be really chill with lots of bright, fun art murals inside. Chill was right, but very gray and cold. Pretty pleased with the amount of food I got for $8, though! Not sure how they're pulling it off, but if you're hungry, bring a $10 bill down here and get a small Italian sub. Can't imagine what the large is like! I'll for sure come back and maybe offer to paint some graffiti murals inside to bump up the vibe a notch! read more

See all

Food is really good. Subs are huge. Small or large, you can't go away hungry. Pizza is good Service us good and friendly. The twins are always fun to chat with. I would recommend them to anyone who likes a variety of subs and Pizza, etc Plus they have ice cream and video games. How can you go wrong. Nice seating area. Nice clean place to eat. Love you guys. Glad your here. read more

Love this place. Really tasty old school pizza. Calzones are excellent. Great prices and you can play a few retro arcade games while you're waiting for your food. read more

Hands down; Simply the BEST, Dangerously Delicious Pizza we've had in years. Has the perfect crust texture/chew, sauce and everything about is/was Beyond Fantastic. Who knew a heavenly pizza establishment existed here on Earth, right in our midst- in Monona, WI? Had never heard of them; had a taste for Pizza establishments from years ago that no longer exist (googled & had to find out more about them). North Shore Pizza remedied that at first bite! It's better than Ian's. We also tried the Garlic Bread that comes with a generous side of savory sauce (the type that brings out an animal instinct to want to lick the container clean!), PHENOMENAL - taste similar to Portabella & we highly, H~i~g~h~l~y~ Recommend an order or "more" of it. Was unaware it comes topped with cheese (though we thought would be just regular garlic bread) - I warn you however it is HIGHLY ADDICTIVE! We will be ordering this repeatedly. Tada-ahh, finished it off by trying an order of their fried dough. A magical concoction that kicks your tastebuds into happy dance -overdrive (though prefer less powdered sugar). The texture of it is amazing, as well as the taste. Have never tasted or had anything remotely close to this dessert. Different then a funnel cake, far better than any dessert pizza... Addictive & may cause a major feeding frenzy even though already stuffed from eating previous items. There is an inexplicable ever-so satisfying spongy-chewy pizza crust chew of theirs that has to be experienced, to fully understand. Highly Recommend all three out of three items ordered. There was no choice but to go back day 2 to try a sub and pasta with marinara. The pasta was good (however pizza is our preference, then again prefer pizza over pasta 9 out of 10 times). To be fair, only tried the vegetarian sub; the bread & sub was good, and an OK for us. We recommend ordering their Pizza, Garlic Bread & Fried Dough - from the menu items we've tried thus far. We will be back to check out other menu items, but pizza, garlic bread, fried pizza dough cravings are on auto-forecast. thus far. We will be back to check out other menu items, but pizza, garlic bread, fried pizza dough cravings are on auto-forecast. Super kind, caring, unbeatable people oriented establishment read more

Their pizza is good. But I dock a star for two reasons : 1) their green bell pepper is cut so thin it's basically a display pepper only. No green pepper taste or crunch. Only the appearance of a pepper on your pizza that crumples to nothing when you take a bite. So just don't order peppers on your pizza bc it doesn't really count as a topping but you'll still get charged for it 2) the gyro was pretty disappointing. Kind of feels like one of those grocery store gyro kits made to order. Would be better if they narrowed down their menu to things they just did well read more

Very clean dining area. Lots of options. I had a pastrami and cheese sub (small = about 6"). The pastrami was nice and warm. The cheese was nicely melted. The bread was soft and fresh. My wife and I are visiting from Texas. If we were local, we'd be back for sure. read more

These guys make a really good pizza and are on the steep part of the learning curve, when it comes to running a restaurant as a business. Give them a chance and a piece of advice, if you have one to share. Mine - Fill your salad dressing "go containers" during down time, so you don't have to do it when you're very busy. read more

Pizza is out of this world. Great sauce and crust. Need to try the subs. Hope they get a liquor license soon. Would love to eat at restaurant with a glass of wine. Some of counter service is a little curt, but I chalk that up to inexperience and youth of some of employees. But don't miss this place! I think I would cry if it ever closed. read more

We were skeptical about another pizza joint in the neighborhood, but this is our new favorite place! It's the perfect New York style pizza with crewy crust that you actually want to eat. Such delicious flavor. Don't sleep on this place. read more

They have a large selection My friend loved the pastrami and we shared seasoned crispy fries that were great I had a hot roast beef with grilled peppers and onions that was moist and flavorful They are friendly and responsive and had much more seating than expected Very reasonable prices too I will be going back for sure read more

North Shore Pizza and Subs is awesome!! The pizza is REALLY GOOD and the dining room has been remodeled. It's very clean, bright, and welcoming. The arcade is still there but is also brighter and cleaner than before. You have to try this place!! read more

Man I love their pizza so much and I've only had it once. They have such a big menu too I want to try it all. But the pizza is some thing you can't find no where else. The prices are great too. Interior is a nice place to chill with friends and family. The staff was polite and chill. Very understanding when I'm staring at the menu on what to order lol. read more

Thought I'd give this new place a try on my lunch hour and it was great! Walked in and 10-15 minutes later I was walking out with a great New York Style 10" pizza pie, enough for two lunches at a very reasonable price. Almost seemed more like a 12". There's certain cheese that's my favorite on pizza (think Buck's) and they use it! By the time I got back to the office (about 3 miles) it was still piping hot and delicious! I'll definitely be going back to try their subs. My only suggestion to them would be selling smaller bottles of soda, when I was there, they only had 2 liters available. There was a sign that said the Arcade was closed, I hope they are just remodeling because my granddaughters used to love going there when it was Rossi's. The environment was clean and fresh, but I really missed all the memorabilia that used to be in there, it was super fun to look at to pass the time while you waited for your order. They do have some artwork up on the walls that are for sale so that was cool. The pic I'm posting is my pizza the next day, cold from the fridge, it looked a lot prettier when it was hot, but it was still great cold (I couldn't wait..haha), and after re-heating. read more

North Shore Pizza And Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Monona, Wisconsin

Food was very good and a great price. Called ahead and food was ready when promised. I am impressed and will definitely be back.

Great newer (I think) spot for pizza in Monona, took over the old Rossi's location and they've kept the arcade intact which is great as long as you're not creeped out by that type of thing. Jersey style pizza, which I'm not sure what that exactly is, but I e joy theirs very much! They have a nice chewy delicious crust flavorful sauce/cheese and for me personally they've all been cooked very well. I've never dined in and I don't, my only complaint is the service has just never been friendly. Thank yous unanswered, hello how are yous ignored. Not everyone is here to make friends, but I only want to surround myself with people who extend common simple courteousys of conversation..... so I take mine to go! read more

Enjoyed the pizza (for take out). The crust has a nice chew & toppings generous. Sauce was a very small chunky tomato base rather than the usual pizza sauce, it was very tasty & made the pizza taste fresh. Will be back & try their other items. read more