Rustic fire is located off the 101 near the 46 Its a small but also large seating area for all types of groups. Parking is a bit limited but should be doable Overall great American vibes Servers were super nice and helpful and looked like they were hustling and locked in Their cheesy breadsticks were def worth the hype We got their large asian chicken salad and my parents loved it alot And finally their chicken white sauce pizza was definitely the highlight of the meal 10/10 would come again read more

See all

This is easily one of the best pizza experiences you can find , honestly The quality and flavor closely resemble authentic New York-style pizza, with a perfectly crisp crust, well-balanced sauce, and high-quality ingredients throughout. The establishment maintains a high standard of cleanliness, creating a comfortable and inviting environment for guests. Equally impressive is the level of service staff are attentive, professional, and efficient, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable dining experience from start to finish. read more

The pizza is so bomb. This was our first time near our hotel & the customer service was amazing. Super helpful & would definitely come back. read more

Rustic Fire - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

After some wine tasting we decided to stop at one of our favorite pizza spots. We ordered the combo and the breadsticks. The service here was fast and they always checked on us. Plenty of indoor seating. read more

See all

It always goes well at RUSTIC FIRE! Rustic is my go to meal when passing through Paso Robles. Service is always good and the place is always clean. Anytime I know a friend is passing through I have them grab a pizza to bring to me in Bakersfield. So yeah I do enjoy RUSTIC FIRE PIZZA! read more

We ordered this to-go, so I can't comment much on the service or ambiance inside the restaurant, but the service for delivery was great and timely. We ordered: - 11" Medium Margherita Pizza - The Margherita pizza was solid. With the mozzarella cheese, basil leaves and tomato slices, it was delicious. - Italian Breadsticks (No Mozzarella) - Not a fan. I found these to be a bit on the drier side and not very flavorful. I wish we have gotten the Cheesy Italian Breadsticks with the mozzerella. They came with the option to choose two dips, which we chose the marinara sauce and ranch. One thing I liked was that if you don't like any of the pizza options, you can build your own pizza pretty easily. Overall, I would definitely be back in the future to try other items from the menu. read more

Rustic Fire - Italian Breadsticks (No Mozzarella) - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Their food is so good!! Rerouted our road trip to get a cauliflower crust pepperoni pizza. Delicious thin crust. The caesar salad was delicious too and loaded with chicken. Everyone is so welcoming and nice and they have a lot of selections. They even have gelato and sorbet. Wish they had a location by me. read more

Service is friendly. You bring your number to your table after you order. Pizzas were amazing. Wonderful crust, sauce, and toppings. I really enjoyed the breadsticks with buffalo chicken. They brought us extra ranch as well. read more

See all

What a find this place was! First time here and will definitely be back again! A group of four of us came on in on a Thursday, early evening, found a spot to sit, and ordered at the counter. Really great vibes inside with multiple seating options...loved the decor too! We opted for a comfy booth with a TV built in the wall area. Ordered was a delish bbq chicken pizza, fantastic breadsticks with dipping sauces, a tasty flatbread wrap, and the biggest medium sized salad ever! It was plenty for us all, and we took a lot home. Also ordered was a kids one- topping pizza that came with a scoop of gelato, and a drink- super cool! The servers, cashiers, and Manager were all friendly, attentive, and accommodating. This was a perfect stop on the way home from the coast, and we were all super satisfied! read more

See all

Great food, great service and wonderful atmosphere. They must have gone through a complete makeover ever since I was here last time. New delicious menu, great beer and wine selections, and they have gelato!!! Many customers gone for gelato after they're done with dinner, including myself. It is a perfect setting! I really enjoyed my chocolate cookie with cafe latte gelato. Pizza and flatbread sandwich were delicious, super tasty with tons of flavors. I was already contemplating what to order when we come back next, like tomorrow. Hope you'll get to try Rustic Fire too! read more

Rustic Fire - Greek Salad & Italian breadsticks (1/2 order) - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

Came in before the crowds arrived. Service was great and the food was excellent. Salid was fresh and plentiful. Got a medium thick crust pizza, plenty for two. Food was great and the staff was friendly. A nice find. read more

Rustic Fire - seating - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

$50 for a cracker thin pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. I'll never go to this Highway robbery outfit again. It took over 25 minutes to get our order and there was no other person in the place. Like we do not know what cheese and pepperoni cost? Go to Marv's, while it's not inexpensive, it's the best pizza in Paso Robles. I'll never ever get ripped off again from this place. read more

Stayed across the street at Adelaide Inn and came across this pizza place that was so good! The service was fast and they were very helpful with suggestions. Definitely recommend the buffalo chicken cheese bread (you have to ask, not on menu). The pizza was good and we ended with their gelato. read more

See all

Nice pit stop on our way to Pismo. Clean and spacious inside. The parking lot is shared with several neighboring business. Ordered a medium pepperoni and fresh jalapeño pizza. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Great pizza sauce flavor. A great selection of local wines and beers along with tasty treats like cookies and gelato. The customer service was on point. Very nice and helpful. Will definitely stop by again soon. read more

See all

Great place, great value. Popped in here for dinner, not expecting much, but were hugely surprised by all the food options plus types of wine & beer, they have packed into this place, all while retaining a great neighborhood pizza pub atmosphere. We ordered small salads and they were excellent. Also very nice that the manager came out to ask us if we were satisfied with everything. All the staff were impressively friendly and attentive. Most surprising aspect was their wine and beer selection at nearly half the price of downtown Paso restaurants (they even had non-alcohol Athletic Brewing products - my favorite). read more

We went for dinner and what an amazing experience. The food was so delicious we had the bread sticks and pizza. Cooked perfect with great taste. The staff was so friendly especially Krystal. We can't wait to go back. read more

Pizza was very good lots of interesting choices. Get a gelato while you're there. A few tables are outside so you are able to bring your fur babies. Great place to stop while traveling. read more

Delicious. Will be coming back. Obviously not Michelin style pizza but there's some flavor combos (eg. Meat lovers) that hit better than I expected so bravo. The arugula prosciutto with balsamic glaze sounded good but the arugula was not prepped it was just dryly placed on so it overpowered the taste or balsamic glaze and prosciutto. You could probably not put balsamic glaze and you'd hardly taste the difference . Yet if you don't put it on it does feel like the pizza is missing something. I would suggest pairing the pizza with something that balances well but can still stand out amongst the untempered arugula read more

Quick and easy service, really good food and drink options. We did pizza and the crust was perfect and ingredients were fresh and delicious! read more

Rustic Fire - 11" Medium Rustic Fire Works Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

We Came in on Friday night We just squeezed in before the crowd arrived. The line can get very long, but the staff goes quick. I like that you get a number to place on your table, and they bring the food, so there is no yelling out names--so I give them bonus points for that! Food-We ordered personal pizzas, and Cesar salad to share. There's lots of crust (GF, thin, cauliflower, etc) options. The salad is very fresh. Pizza toppings are on point. Desserts.. if that's your thing, they have brownies, cookies, gelato! We have tried & they are delish!! Drink options- all local offerings, wine & craft beer, plus fresh tea & standard fountain drinks. Prices are decent. Vibes- It's a sports bar theme with tons of TVs, high top tables & booths. I don't love the parking lot, but The husband loves this place, we visit every time we come to Paso read more

Craved for pizza and salad while driving into town and saw this place off the 46, so we decided to stop and give it a try! It was a Thursday evening around 6pm and the line was out the door. We almost didn't stay, but the line moved so quickly that before we knew it, we were already inside (yay!). We checked out their menu, knew what we wanted, placed and paid for our order at the counter, and found a table for two. Cool seeing all the beer kegs up top, ample table seating and some booths inside. Order up: Roasted Garlic Chicken with Bacon Greek Salad Our food came out hot and fresh! The medium pizza was decent in size, savory, flavorful, and the crust was just right! The delicious Greek salad (also medium) was more than enough for two people, thank you for having pitted olives in there...effortless eating! Glad we stayed and gave them a try! This place did not disappoint! CHEERS and happy eating till next time! read more

See all

This place is amazinggg and the food is to die for!! I am so bummed I didn't try this place sooner. Ordered a pepperoni pizza with the original crust and it was cooked to perfection - a crispy crust, with just the right amount of cheese, sauce and pepperonis! Their Italian cheesesticks are also phenomenal. Finished the entire meal and wished we had ordered more! I can't wait to come back here again asap! read more

Rustic Fire - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

We were starving after leaving the beer festival and then hanging out at the pool. Luckily this place was right across the street and open late. They were busy but it only took a few minutes to put in our order at the counter and grab a seat. We ordered the cheesy garlic bread and a pepperoni pizza. Both arrived at the table hot and fresh and everything tasted great. read more

Rustic Fire - Italian Cheese Breadsticks Full Order (For 2-4) - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

Great little spot with plenty of indoor seating and parking out front ( does get busy around lunch and dinner) Order and pay at the bar for food and drinks to be delivered to your table , alcohol , craft beers and wine all available, Pizzas are thin crust, topped with with fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked We had a Greek salad which was great but a bit heavy in the dressing, order that on the side otherwise delicious Great atmosphere and friendly helpful staff Looking forward to our next visit read more

Rustic Fire - 14" Large Rustic Fire Works Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

See all

The pizza just seems to be subpar. No taste and pricy. Would be nice if the prices were on the menus

Kids took off a half a star - food too HOT on presentation. Everyone (46 YO, 45 YO, 10 YO, 7 YO) loved the meatballs, bread, burrata salad, pizza and gelato. Adults enjoyed the beer. All commented on the friendly and welcoming service. read more

The chicken used for the salads and flatbread was horrible! The texture was awful, it looked like Tyson precooked chicken. I think for their prices the quality of the chicken should be a lot better. Quality of chicken can improve! Pizza was good. Ambiance was good. Service was good. read more

They are an excellent choice. We were traveling through and stopped here for food. We looked at a couple of food places around the area before choosing RF, as we never had tried them. The hospitality was excellent, very friendly and welcoming, and the food was. Delicious! We had club salad, Greek salad, mushroom pizza and kids cheese pizza. I highly recommend them. read more

Excellent pizza and salad! My friend and I each got our own build-your-own pizzas and we thought they were delicious. We also shared the Italian salad which was big enough for 2 even though it was only a Medium. The salad had the right ratio of lettuce to meat to veggies to cheese. The gentleman who took our order was super patient and very kind since we took a bit to decide and were a little high maintenance asking him to see the size differences for the pizzas. The rest of the staff was equally pleasant saying hello and smiling at us whenever they passed our table. I highly recommend this restaurant and would definitely go back the next time I'm in Paso Robles. read more

Best pizza in Paso ... fresh ingredients and friendly service! We go there often and it doesn't disappoint!

I am a legit NYC pizza snob who hates most of what he finds in California. What a surprise this place was! Fantastic, crisp, flavorful. I will for sure return whenever I pass through. Highly recommend! read more

We came here to eat instead of eating at Sensorio. It was a good choice, but we really wanted it to be a great choice, but it fell just short. It is a pizza restaurant with numerous choices for your pizza in terms of toppings. We ordered the Works pizza and the prosciutto, mushroom and arugula pizza, along with some cheesy breadsticks. The works pizza was good, but the prosciutto pizza was too salty. It made it almost inedible. However, the cheesy breadsticks were the best. Lots of cheese and the ranch and marinara sauces were really good. Definitely would come back for the breadsticks. read more

Staff is really friendly and easy to see and understand the menu layout as well as great wine offerings.... Sticking point the cashier messed up our order so we had to take the receipt up to get correction. Was corrected without issue just an inconvenience. Ordered Cesar salad (All core of the salad) and an Italian Sausage & Peppers Deep dish pizza ... their deep dish thickness is the thickness a butter knife and the pizza was very very dry... I don't recommend this pizza ! read more

Rustic Fire - Dry deep dish pizza (possibly Costco microwaveable? - Pizza Near Me - Paso Robles, California

Absolutely abysmal service. Wait times are long, but we were happy to wait as the food is good. We enjoyed the pizzas and salad and felt that the portions were fair. Ambience inside the restaurant was lively. However, we took home leftovers and later that night, my sister had a slice and she found an ACRYLIC NAIL in her pizza. We do not wear acrylic nails. We returned to the restaurant the next day hoping for at least a refund, given that she had chewed an employee's acrylic nail. The manager of the store first interrogated us about whether we wear acrylic nails and then stated that there was "nothing he could do about it." The entire time, he seemed to be questioning our experience. He did not offer a refund because he stated the system did not allow him to pull up past transactions. I wonder what kind of system that is. He did offer one free pizza, but we did not want to eat their pizzas after that. Do NOT recommend. Customer service is KEY in the food business and Rustic Fire failed miserably. Will not be returning ever. read more

See all

Yum! This modest strip mall eatery is pretty hip within. It has a double store front with lots of TVs and an impressive selection of wine, beer and other beverages. Parking is relatively easy but the lot can be crowded. The service is warm, knowledgeable and welcoming. It is easy to order at the counter and have food brought to the table. The food is VERY pricey but it is EXCELLENT. A large, cauliflower crust gourmet pizza is about $50, but well made and delicious (but I prefer triangle slices over squares). The large Caesar salad was super fresh and generous. I would definitely come again. read more

Ate here twice while in town. Both times very good food and service even while it was busy. Don't forget some gelato for dessert. They have a great wine selection too! read more

Just ordered 2 pizzas for my staff up the street at in bloom...for family meal, and let me tell you, I've been to Italy and they have nothing on your pies!! Thank you so much!! read more

Today was the first time we ate at Rustic Fire and I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! The pizza was delicious, the salad was cool and crisp, but what stood out most was the service. Each of the servers were extremely helpful and pleasant and so willing to make our experience there the best! The owner was also very kind and helpful... honestly 10 stars from start to finish!! read more

From the street, it's part of a small strip of shops, and really doesn't appear to be much. However, it's really nice inside, and very much a cool restaurant and bar. I went for lunch, and the gf, pooch, and I (the "Big 3") ordered 2 pizzas. Albeit a little pricey, but the za was really really good -- great cheese, toppings, sauces, and crust. I'll definitely be back, and want to come back soon for dinner and wine. read more

You know a place is good when you walk in and can already anticipate it's going to be amazing just by the smell. We ordered carry out pizzas - rustic fire works and a bbq chicke. They were a quick 20 minutes until pick up and I'm so glad we chose here. The large were plenty big to feed 7 people and the crust was thin, but not crispy which was good. They're loaded with toppings and great all around. Would recommend! read more