I had the most delicious thin crust pizza here. Fairly priced. I was amazed at how good it was. The sauce was delicious and the cheese was delicious. I still find myself thinking about it. And they made it quickly! I wasn't waiting long. If I ever come back to the area I'm stopping here forsure read more

I ordered the individual pizza, thin crust, extra sauce, pepperoni and black olives. It was pretty good. It was filling, had good flavor and was a reasonable price. The service wasn't great, the woman taking out order was unpleasant, and not helpful. This place is open late, has beer, a tv, some old arcade games and decent seating. I wanted a salad but I was not about to pay $5.99 for a one trip to the salad bar. Consisting of lettuce, a few toppings and dressings. No thanks. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Get in my belly! - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

We ordered no contact delivery last night for the first time as well as for the first time from Rusty's. We got a large pizza with half having a select group of toppings and the other side having other ones. My husband and I don't agree on things such as pineapple on pizza. The pizza was perfect. It was exactly as ordered and delicious! We also ordered a thin crust bbq chicken pizza- I didn't have any but the guys said it was good. The garlic bread was on point. The website said it'd take an hour; we ordered at 6:00pm and it was too us by 7. The driver came up in gloves and a mask and knocked and then left it on the front door step. Overall, great food, easy to use website, and great no contact delivery. They have new customers in us! read more

I liked their pizza, their sprite was also very good. But they have bad cap quality. There floors were dirty but it was busy. So that's a cautiona when you go when it's busy. I think it's above average but not my favorite. read more

We had lunch there today. My husband ordered a full meatball sandwich. The lack of meatballs was pitiful. He opened the sandwich only to find one meatball per half sliced extremely thin with very little sauce even. I ordered a vegetarian that tasted like it was a frozen pizza from Costco at best. Don't waste your hard earned money at this so called restaurant. read more

This review is for the new Rustys in Summerland ca. The building is brand new, but Rusty obviously isn't new to pizza and sandwiches. The food is delicious and the service is great. I had the meatball sub and it was awesome. My wife had the bbq pizza, it was awesome also, I tried it as well. We recommend this place. TW read more

I have ordered from the Rusty's in SB for years and have always loved it. However this location just lacks in every department. Their customer service is mediocre at best and the pizza was like cardboard. Not to mention there were 5 small pieces of chicken on the whole pizza...it was a CHICKEN pizza. Step it up, dominos is better than this location. WAY overpriced. read more

When we arrived to pick up our dinner they did not have are order ... at all all good went down the street and had the best Thai Food ever! Thank you Rusty's Pizza Parlor read more

We stopped by Rusty's for dinner while on a road trip and it was THE BEST pizza!! Sadly they were out of Buffalo wings... we really wanted to try those! We've been talking about making a special road trip back here because it was so good. read more

Simply the best. We've tried every pizza place in this town and NO ONE beats Rusty's. Period. Bye.

My husband and I went to Rusty's Pizza for lunch today. We were extremely disappointed to where we won't be returning. Mind you I grew up in Carpinteria and visited Rusty's on a weekly basis. I also worked as a supervisor at one time in my life. The place smells horrible like dirty socks and urine. The salad bar had browned salad which we had to request fresh salad. The ice tea machine didn't have regular unsweetened tea which is all my husband drinks when out. Then our pizzas were so small. They use to fit the plate now they are much smaller than the plate served on. Same plate smaller pizza. But the worst part was the smell in the entire restaurant. Horrible just horrible. Not sure if Roger, Carol and Cindy Duncan own Rusty's anymore, but it definitely isn't up to par as a restaurant should be. Super disappointed. Looks like We will have to find pizza else where in Carp read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Quick Lunch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Working in Carp and drove by this place a few times. Decided to stop today. Glad I did the service and pizza was very good. Will definitely come back again. read more

A Rusty's uninsured delivery driver hit my friend Jill. Now they will not respond to her or her insurance company. Is this the kind of business you want to support? read more

After a long hike along the Carpenteria Bluffs and beyond, we were too pooped to go out, so we ordered in from Rusty's. The pizza was delivered sooner than they had estimated and was just what we wanted. We ordered and got a meat pizza on thin crust. I can't remember what it was called but it had chirizo on it. Yum. The price was fair for what we got. I don't think you can go wrong. read more

In town for the night stopped by for some pizza damn their pizza is the bomb! Definitely coming back again.

Big shout to my man Jessie and whoever else was working late Friday night March 19th! This place blew my god damn mind. Pizza, wings and the bottle of wine were all 10/10, customer service was great. I didn't think I could eat more when I left and on my way out they handed me a pizza they made that someone canceled, which was the best thing my drunk ass could hear at that time, more pizza?? Hell yeah! Only reason it's 4 stars is all the tables had crumbs on them. Rustys Pizza Parlor in Carpentaria, eat here! read more

I'm giving because mrder was a medium pizza, salad and barbecue chicken wings. The pizza and salad was excellent. However the chicken wings were terrible. The wings P. read more

Marc n I stayed in Carpenteria overnight due to he worked Sat pouring concrete for a store their building. Obviously only food available is takeout with COVID19. Giving them a 4 rating because the pizza may have tasted differently had we'd been able to dine in and wasnt as hot when we arrived back to the hotel. We ordered the Rustys Special with bell peppers and no anchovies. We got the thin pizza rather than pan which may have also tasted different. It wasnt a bad pizza. It was tasty, just not what were use to closer to Riverside at Dukes, Aloha Pizza or 4th n Mill. We would order again under other circumstances if we return and order a pan pizza instead. read more

Terrible pizza not very clean and overpriced. Salad bar was the best part and even that was just ok.

5.50 for a bowl of salad and you can't go back after your done. I have never been to a salad bar you can't go back for more. WTF! And the salad bar ain't even worth $2. Glad I don't have to come back here. Pizza is okay but nothing special. If you are traveling through no reason to stop here. Continue on to Ventura. Much more to do and eat there. People are nicer too. By the way you can see how small the salad bowl is on the attached photo, SMALL! read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Average overpriced pizza! Making money of off the people camping nearby, or on the beach for the day. I understand it's a small-ish business and support such businesses is important, but no need to be so ridiculous in their pricing. read more

Walked in and I ordered a medium thin crust pizza to go with black olives and green peppers & a coke. Total $19.82. Waited over 30 minutes. Walked about 3 blocks and it was still warm. The crust was tasty as sometimes a thin crust can be soggy. The pepper toppings were scarce and olives dominated the taste. Not sure if all locations are the same and maybe people flock here because there's few pizza options, but I've had great pizza that leaves you wanting more. Rusty's is a bit rusty with its presentation and overall pizza. read more

Bunch of fucken idiots, I'm always asking for extra Parmesan packets and always get extra PEPPER packets...

I've always liked Rusty's Pizza but when I picked up my Pizza today it was not cooked as I requested. The pizza was under cooked. I asked for a well done pizza. Next time I won't take it for granite. read more

If I could give less I would. I bought the (half) Rusty's sandwich and there was literally two pepperoni sized paper thin salami slices inside. Guess I got the bread and tomato sandwich, imagine if I bought a full sandwich!? Better off with a subway footlong for the price. I enjoyed the Rusty's in Santa Barbara after a concert at the bowl but they clearly are not the same. Pitiful. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Rusty's sandwich, where's the meat!? - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

See all

Service was terrible ! Pizza was not what we expected! We ordered thick crust and Got thin ! Will never go back ! The only reason why we went was because they had Dine In won't do that again ! read more

We ordered from the Rusty's pizza in Carpinteria on two separate occasions for delivery. Our first time the delivery guy said that you must request Parmesan cheese and chili flakes when placing your order. He could not provide anything, including napkins. The second occasion, we ordered a Large Combo pizza. When asked if we wanted anchovies or bell peppers we chose bell peppers. What we received was a bell pepper ONLY pizza. I wish I had taken a photo. The saddest pizza I have ever seen. We will never order from them again. read more

My granddaughters (age 8) favorite pizza in SB. Good price point. Consistently good. If I can't have Marty's Pizza this is our go to

Excellent crust, sauce, toppings! Yum! Got deep dish very good! Got the bacon, pepperoni, jalepano !

Two hours later NO pizza. They claimed they called and knocked on the door and that's impossible being I live in a commercial building that's is high security. I gave specific instructions to call when downstairs.... he "claimed he called and knocked" lies. They only returned $10 . 00 . Out of a 40$ pizza we never received. read more

This location does not serve potato wedges. I ordered my pizza well done, but when I received my pizza it wasn't even close. (It was undercooked even compared to a regular pizza NOT well done at the 3 other locations I've visited) I ordered medium wings and asked for the two containers of ranch they said I was allotted, (which still isn't enough considering how good their ranch is) but I only received one. When I asked for more ranch (holding a 5 dollar bill in my hand) I was handed an empty container without a lid and was told to go to the salad bar and serve it myself, even though I ordered my pizza to go. When I went back to the register to get a lid, I asked if I could pay for more ranch, and they didn't listen correctly and continued to tell me I was only allowed 2. (Still standing there with a 5 dollar bill in my hand) Also, there was a slice of pizza that had no sauce, cheese, or topping on more than half of it, but that didn't bother me, too much. It happens. I love Rusty's, the pizza still tasted great considering they use the same ingredients, but wasn't prepared properly. The restaurant itself was very clean and inviting. They just need more competent workers at the register. This was the first time a Bakersfield business was actually better than another location. read more

If you want pizza, go here. This place is better than PizzaMan Dan's. The service is above average at Rusty's, but the food here is better than PizzaMan Dan's. When a worker there spilled wine on a pizza, (The pizza was protected by a box) he said: "Oh No! the pizza will get drunk!" Which was funny. If you're in Carpinteria, GO HERE. read more

Tried Rusty's out while we were camping in Carpinteria. They delivered, it was fast & we enjoyed the pizza. Ordered the cheese bread (yum!), garden salad, and a traditional pepperoni pizza. Enjoyed all of it! I loved that they gave us extra plates, napkins, ranch dressing, & tons parm cheese & pepper flakes. I would order from them again. read more

Been here several times, ordered delivery several times-- this trip was a bust. The gal taking our order had a very limited command of the English language. My pizza was not what I ordered. It was useless to complain because they could not understand what I was talking about. They have always had good pizza, they just need to hire English speakers. read more

Me and my family went camping and walked here from the beach. We were so amazed at the friendly staff. But, the real adventure starts with the garlic cheesy bread. It's so good it'll blow your head off. The barbecue chicken pizza , pepperoni and cheese pizza was a refreshing example of creative cooking. You'll be amazed what a $15 pitcher gets you. Just want you to expect delicious and always served hot and fresh. This place deserves five for a pizza parlor. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Carpinteria, California

Called in for an order and may I say the staff is the most unenthusiastic staff I have ever had the nerve of speaking with.. Really lol?? You guys sound like a bunch of emo teenagers.. It's okay if you hate your life but don't be so obvious about it at work!! Keep business and bullshit completely separated!! Put a fake smile and be happy we are paying you for your over priced pizza. read more

Rusty's- Open late! Great if you're still hungry after eleven! ( they close at midnight... on the dot) I got a mini-mushroom thin crust pizza here. Just plain 'ole pizza, no goat cheese / truffle oil / organic veggies or anything like that. It's a small town Shakey's, but much cleaner and with a tad bit more character. An actual pizza parlour with maybe a little less flair. My mini-pizza was pretty tiny, like the size of my palm. It was cute that they cut it into six slices. I really could have folded it in half and eaten it like a quesadilla in 2 bites..and ordered another one. The best thing about this place is the old school arcade games...I played space invaders ( its technically called something else, but you know, pacman or _____ is always the choice) and got up to level 9 on the first try. I was killin' it! A few points- I don't know if they serve alcohol. My parmesan and hot pepper flakes came in little square packages. The cashier was really friendly. Great for a party! read more

Grew up having Rusty's pizza. It is amazing and no other pizza comes close to it! I've taken plenty of my buddies from other states and towns here and I've always been asked to take them again when they come visit. read more

This is a decent pizza place. We usually stop here on our way to Santa Barbara for a snack. The salad bar is always fresh and the tables are clean. I also like that my toddler can be loud and no one cares :) They also have TV's and video games. read more

Horrible customer service on the phone. The only thing saving this place is its thin crust pizza