Outstanding Key Lime Pie Wondering people working here on a Friday night, every seat taken and I'm at the bar waiting on an order of Key Lime Pie To Go. 25 minutes later they made my dream come true with a whole pie wrapped & real whipped cream in its own container to go. People applauded, customers & staff alike. I'd put in the wait time and a good tip. Yum Yum I'll be back when it's not Friday. read more

We stopped here for lunch with friends bc another place we were going to didn't have a spot to park and boy was it lucky for us. We were seated right away outside on the patio. My friends loved watching the iguanas roam around outside in the parking area while we waited in our food. I ordered the poke nachos and they were amazing. The flavors were great together and the presentation was upscale. Only thing I would have done to improve them was to add a bit more poke itself on them. Otherwise 10 out of 10. My husband order the conch fritters. They were good. They were served with several options for dipping sauce. Although they also touted the best key lime pie in the keys we didn't get it. Maybe next time. This is a place I would stop back at just for the poke nachos. As an army mom I also loved that they were a veteran owned restaurant. read more

See all

Today we had our worst meal in Florida. Husband ordered the Catch of the Day which was Grouper. $45. The fish was so overcooked it was inedible. My wings were undercooked and rubbery even though I asked for extra crispy and my Greek salad was equally pathetic. It was just bad food. Not one ounce of care went into the preparation. I'm searching for something nice to say about the food but cannot. Of course when most of our meals were left on our plates and we didn't want a box the server asked if the food was ok. We let her know it wasn't good. The cook took 20% off the check. Whatever. What we wanted was an edible meal. The service was good. The outside deck is fine. Please don't eat here. read more

We got there about 5:45 on a Wednesday, had to wait 20 minutes for a table. I was not impressed with the ice tea or the pinot gregio. Service was 5*. I ordered the Churrasco skirt steak medium rare. The taste was quite good. A few parts were very rare, a few parts were done medium well, but most of it was as ordered. The rice tasted good, but was not very warm at the time it was delivered to the table. The onion rings looked really good, but the taste was lacking. I give the rings 3*s. My wife has the Ahi Tuna dinner. She gave it 5*s. Large portion. Great taste. Very good sauces. The worst part of the experience was payment at the end. Yhey shove a screen in front of your face with the server standing over you as you are asked to pick a tip percentage. There is no breakdown of what the charges are or how the tip is calculated. There was an option for a printed receipt, which I selected, but never got a receipt. If my wife had not been so happy with the tuna, I would have given them 3*s. read more

Their service was great and the food was amazing! Went here multiple times and it was amazing each time!

We were here for Happy Hour. Monday-Friday 2-5 pm. Lots of $7 appetizers and drinks $3-7. Such a good deal! We also got $11 key lime pie. It was a generous portion with whipped cream on the side. A small, divey place with good food. read more

The service was amazing, gave us some great recommendations. I got steak and shrimp fajitas with rice and sweet potato fries, literally so good and so fresh. The key lime pie here, in my humble opinion, is the best on the island. Vibes are good, would dine again (or just come back for the pie ) read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - Key lime pie - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

The place for key lime pie. Recommended by a local, we stopped here while staying on Marathon Key. It was incredible. We tried key lime pies from several other places during our stay, but this one remained our favorite. read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

We just stopped in for an appetizer and pie. Service was excellent! We had a huge pile of onion rings with chili mayo. They were hot and perfect in every way! The key lime pie slice was big enough for 2 and best we've had so far in the keys. The outdoor seating was comfortable thanks to the fans and the shade. Saw some burgers come out as we were leaving. The looked and smelled so good!! read more

Great little bar and restaurant! We enjoyed a very stiff Caribbean Rum Runner before ordering our dinner. My lovely wife had their fish dip which she definitely had to share with me. OMG so delicious and smoky. Then she had their Coconut shrimp app. which I was told was fantastic. I had their 1/2 pound of cold shell on shrimp with horseradish sauce. The shrimp were fresh and so flavorful then I enjoyed the 1/2 pound mushroom and Swiss burger with fries. They ask how done you'd like it cooked and it was perfectly cooked how I asked. Rare and bloody MMMMM! The fries were seasoned perfectly and soft inside. Then the BEST part of our meal was their Key Lime pie. The best I'd say around! The whole place is warm and cozy and clean. The restroom was also clean and well stocked. We will be definitely coming back. read more

See all

This is a fun little roadside sports bar with great food. We ordered the club sandwich and the mahi BLT. Both very hearty portions and the fries were hot and delicious. The outside seating is fun with the thatch roof and highway decor, but there is quite a bit of road noise since you're right next to the highway. Worth a stop on your way through the Keys! read more

See all

The S.S. wreck has really, really good food. They don't have a water view but the food, relaxed vibe, and super friendly waitress made up for it. It was very clean and they had fans to keep it cool on the deck. I got the cheeseburger and it was very good. One in my party said they had one of the best fajitas they've ever had. The turkey club and shrimp dinner were very good as well. The key lime pie absolutely lives up to the hype of "best in the keys" it was the best we had all week. Rachel our waitress was the BEST! read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

After a morning at the Dolphin Research Center nextdoor, my family and I wanted lunch before leaving the Keys. Lucky for us, S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill was mere steps away and had something for everyone to eat. I got the catch of the day (mahi) grilled Key West style (includes lemon, garlic, and thyme) on a sandwich with fries, my wife had the club sandwich (no tomato) with fries, one kid had chicken strips with fries, and the other had grilled cheese with fries. Of course, for dessert we had key lime pie. The prices are higher than other restaurants, but all of the food tasted great and the portions are huge. In particular, my wife raved about her club sandwich and the bite I tried was excellent. They key lime pie could have been a little more tart, but was still the best non-chocolated dipped version we sampled on our trip. Matt was a fantastic server. Kudos to him. read more

See all

The SS wreak is a tourist destination, although there were some locals in there. The place was packed with people standing room. Only the service was not that great. The food was it passed for food. I know when I go back up to the keys I won't be going here. read more

We were driving down to Key West and needed a break. Checked Yelp for something near by that allowed dogs. This place allowed us to bring the dog, so we stopped. Glad we did! Super friendly server who recommended the prime rib. We ordered one large one and split it. Was very good. Not really a prime rib person, but it was good. We had lots left over. The dog enjoyed the leftovers for a couple days. We tried the key lime pie too. Excellent! Was plenty for two to share. Our server said it was award winning. I am sure it is. The restaurant had a nice island tropical vibe and I would absolutely stop here again! read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Fun place and great service! Nothing on the menu was something I would like personally but I'm a huge picky eater so that's okay. None of my friends had any complaints with their orders or our amazing server. Expect to pay about $30 for a meal here. read more

See all

Stopped in for dinner on a weekday night. Sat instantly. Service was great! Good music playing in the background. Ample seating for small and large parties. Menu has a large variety of options for all pallets. We started off with the Coconut Shrimp, which is served with a delicious sauce. Highly recommend! 10/10 appetizer. The Mahi BLT was fresh and battered to light perfection. I added chipotle sauce, which took it up a notch. Spouse claimed the buffalo chicken sandwich was a good choice. Saw others mentioned the Key Lime Pie so I took one to go since we were too full to eat one on site and it did not disappoint one bit!! It was phenomenal and a must have if you fancy key lime pie. read more

See all

A waiter sent us to SS Wreck when we mentioned our quest to find the best key lime pie in the keys. Out of the ones we had, this was my favorite in taste and texture. We ordered a piece to go, and I was bummed to see that it was in styrofoam. In addition to being landfill bound, Styrofoam becomes an endocrine disruptor when exposed to heat. This is not healthy... and can be dangerous to those who have a disease impacted by testosterone or estrogen. read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

We were party of 8 with my toddler and we had the best service. Our server was phenomenal I can't remember her name but amazing service. We ordered alottttt of food, drinks. Everything was brought out HOT and honestly really quick. It's a small place but we were able to snag a table outside and it was super windy but really nice. Perfect spot near our airbnb. Didn't take any pics because we had a long day and were just starving but the food was great. Thank you!! read more

Okay we are were wowed by this place as quick recommendation by Marjorie at the Dolphin Research Center of place to grab a bite... everyone at our table loved the food and cocktails! I had the burger that was easily the best burger I have had at a restaurant I have had in years. The beef they use is from Brasstown Beef, and we will be looking to get some beef from them too! And DEFINITELY get the Key Lime Pie here!!! Stacey our waitress was very helpful and made wonderful recommendations and treated us like family. And on an additional note they are supportive for veterans which I was very grateful!!! read more

Most amazing place so far. Our waitress was incredible not to mention beautiful and very helpful. Food was so good. Pie was to die for. We will be back read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - Nachos and pie - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

BEST KEY LIME PIE EVER. We came here just for the pie and ended up buying the whole thing. It was a little pricey at over thirty dollars, but after the first bite we knew it was worth it. The whipped cream is homemade and the balance of tart key lime with the cream was perfect. We tried a lot of pies in the Keys, and this one was hands down the best. read more

We just took fish that we had caught today to have them prepare it. The waitress messed up every single order for the sixth of us. She screwed up every side for all the six of us as well. Had a horrible attitude and then had the nerve to charge us 20% tip, which she did not deserve. Did not even get an apology. Don't visit this dump read more

What a great spot to hit up on your way in our out of the Key's. The food was great, service was friendly, and do t forget to try the Key Lime Pie. Best I've had all week. From the seafood to the hamburgers for the kids everything was enjoyed to the last bite. read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - Key Lime Pie - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Service was excellent!!! Food was delicious The peel and eat shrimp were so fresh! The catch of the day sandwich was excellent. Highly recommended! read more

Tonight had the Frog Legs again, still not as good as two years ago, Onion Rings are good, and the coleslaw, you could really taste the core of the cabbage. My wife had grilled (7) Shrimp (unseasoned), unfortunately the grill must of been seasoned, little specs of black was on the (7) shrimp (assume from the grill), coleslaw (a lot of core, not very favorable), and a baked potato (plain). The shrimp did not taste that fresh. I also had three beers that were very reasonably priced. Our waitress Iris was great with great service. And the music was perfect, not too loud or overwhelming. read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - Receipt - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida

The vibe was great. It was super nice to sit outside. The key lime pie was decent but nothing to write home about. The server was all over the place. read more

My wife and I live in Key Largo and we traveled to Marathon for the afternoon and upon a recommendation of a friend we went the S.S. Wreck and Gallery. Starting with our server Christina. She was one of the best servers we have had. She was informative, anticipatory, and pleasant. I would imagine that all the staff there is good at their jobs but she really went the extra mile. We had a late lunch the food came quickly and hot. Great quality and portions for the price. It has all the trappings of a Keys Bar/Restaurant and is not a tourist trap. It is in north Marathon definitely worth your time, ask for Christina. read more

Great food and excellent service. Loved the burger and the fries were some of the best I ever had. Fun place!!

We have been in Keys for several days. Ate at some good high end restaurants. Loved this place. Down home, full of locals, great and diverse menu, amazing service. Kylie was our waitress. She was outstanding. Staff kept table clean of clutter. We had frog legs (six full legs), potato skins (six large potato halves stuffed), tuna nachos, fresh catch snapper, pizza and the best key lime pie in the world. The portions were huge. The pricing was reasonable and the ambiance with service was great. Also veteran owned. What's not to like. Worth the trip! read more

SS Wreck is always a stop for us when in the Keys. We absolutely love their delicious food, cold drinks, Amazing Key Lime pie, and Kimberly~the super bartender. SSW has made our fresh fish that we have caught. So delicious. I have never had a beer that was not cold or a mixed drink that wasn't delicious. I'm a Vodka girl. Most of all we absolutely LOOOVE the Key Lime Pie. The crust is buttery and so delicious. The key lime pie is creamy with a taste of lime and the whipped cream has a hint of vanilla that is to die for. We share a piece of pie because it is so big and so yummy. Gotta share the love. Kimberly welcomes us each time we have come in, and we feel like a part of SS Wreck family. Thanks SS Wreck for all these things that do you wonderfully. We tell everyone about your amazing place and the pie. We will be back!! read more

See all

This is your typical casual Keys restaurant and bar. A mix of locals and tourists. The gregarious wait staff were fun and welcoming. Milly was our server. She made our experience fun and enjoyable. She guided us on the menu, which is always helpful. We started with a blackened ahi tuna filet seared rare and served with wasabi, seaweed salad and pickled ginger. When I asked Milly for chopsticks, she gave me a blank stare like she didn't know what I was talking about. I loved it. 'Never mind' I told her. Welcome to the Keys. We also started with the fire grilled oysters with butter and Parmesan cheese. They were a perfect grilled smokey and salty flavor. We should have ordered another half dozen oysters. We split a blackened grouper sandwich for our entree. I wouldn't order this again. Too light on the blackened seasoning and the filet was very small. I wouldn't get that again. Key lime pie dessert? Heck yeah I said. It was a very large slice. Could have had a stronger lime flavor but was very creamy and tasty. The graham cracker crust was perfect! We enjoyed our two cocktail lunch at SS Wreck. It's a solid choice. Milly said we should have gotten the ahi tuna nachos. Maybe if we had, this review would have been 5 stars. Ask for Milly if you go. She's worth the visit. read more

Had the Mahi Mahi BLT and a side salad the sandwich had a whole filet and I was concerned with it being on Texas Toast but it really made the sandwich. Finished lunch with the Key Lime Pie and I haven't had a key lime pie as good anywhere' read more

Stopped for happy hour, which I had to ask for the special menu. Appetizers were listed for $8.00 each. I asked for the shrimp tostadas. Oh we don't have them the waitress said. And she's looking down at the order machine. I thought she was joking. Never even looked up or explained. Ordered the pizza Listed for $8. My date ordered the peel and eat shrimp. they had absolutely no taste. No seasonings whatsoever. When the bill came, pizza was $9.00. Questioned the waitress. "They must have raised the price." "That's what came up on the computer." End of conversation again. Maybe a bad day? Especially reading other reviews? .. I won't be returning. read more

The food is always consistently good at the Wreck! I highly recommend their coconut mojitos! And, of course, leave room for their awesome key lime pie with its amazing thick graham cracker crust. read more

We loved it so much, we went back for dinner a second time on our trip. Enjoyed the live music. All of our food was amazing. It is the best key lime pie we've had in the keys! read more

Genuinely delicious. Pulled over for lunch and had some of the best food I've had in the keys. The atmosphere is like sitting out on your deck enjoying a home cooked meal. The Greek salad is massive and does not skimp on toppings. The BLT Mahi was just perfection, down to its crunch. The Mahi was deep fried perfectly and was a juicy bite. A bottle of tartar sauce accompanies, making it a complete home run. Also the potato salad was cool bite to snack on. A kick of heat came from the buffalo chicken sandwich was also fried up perfectly with plenty of sauce to spare. The best part was getting their slice of key lime pie. It was so smooth and is made in house. I still can't get over the graham cracker crust. Service was phenomenal, we got to kick back and enjoy a delicious lunch. read more

See all

A fun place....we were there 3 times. It was PACKED all three times. That tells you something. Service was great. Portions were almost-huge. food quality was very good. read more

*****Bug bites****** bring bug spay. No seeum Bugs biting the whole time, from waiting to order and waiting for food. I got ate up all over. We ended up bringing it home to finish it. Thank God for the lemon wedge that I got to rub on my legs. The food has one seasoning on everything you get. I got potato skins and blt. The blt has a whole lot of bacon. The staff is great!! The price is upper end. They are proud to work there. read more

Food was surprisingly good for a sports bar. Nice indoor/outdoor seating set up. Plenty of parking. Service was pleasant and timely. read more

S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill - Sign - American Near Me - Marathon, Florida