Love this place! Have been getting their pizza since I was a child and it's always consistent. For the past few years we've been going to the amazing bottleshop, enjoying pizza and/or cheese, fruit and cracker trays and also trying some awesome beer. They have a nice rotation so you can try different things weekly. Their bottleshop is huge. Definitely something there for everyone. They also sell different cheeses in the bottleshop area. For a while we weren't going too often bc we were in the Scranton area, but we now live within walking distance and try to go once a week. Dangerous! read more

Pizza is so good!!! But they DONT TAKE CREDIT CARD- they have ATM machine that charges $2

I've been going to Sabatini's since the 1980's and worked there for two years in the 1990's. The pizza has always been consistently good and remains so till this day. Not sure if I'd claim it as the best pizza in the Valley, but it's up there. Make sure to get the pepperoni. It's ground up, not sliced. The best pepperoni you'll ever have! read more

First time there and the service was bad. Saw my waiter one time and that was to order. Had to bother a different waiter just to get my water filled or just for anything else. The guy at the counter didn't seem to pleasant. Thinking the service there is just rough all around but, the food is excellent. Guess ya gotta get the good with the bad in this case. read more

One of the best places to get a slice in the Wyoming Valley. The service is average-to-good, while the pizza is excellent. Sabatini's also serves birch beer, which is pretty rare to see around here. Good selection of beer in-house, as well as six-packs and 12-packs available for takeout. Friendly staff, solid yet affordable prices (it's no bargain like Domino's) and great food. read more

Cardboard pizza and way too expensive beer. They have an extensive beer choice but most I tried were pretty bad and the pizza is thin crust with canned sauce and very chewy read more

Pizza's inconsistent. Staff is rude. Cash only is a joke. Years ago was a much more enjoyable experience. I'll go down the road from now on. read more

I love their pizza. And no place I know makes anything like it. Not a big fan of the diced pepperoni though.

Northeastern Pennsylvania is most famously known for it's Old Forge Style pizza, but Sabatini's pizza inhabits it's own catagory. There is simply no other pizza that looks, tastes, or smells like it. Imagine this: round crispy pie, thin crust- baked until almost blackened on the bottom- covered with a savory, slightly sweet sauce, and blistering hot cheese. You can taste the charred but not burnt crust, which makes an audible crunch with each bite. This is Sabatini's pizza at it's best. Sit in one of their old wooden booths, order a pitcher of root beer and enjoy! read more

If you like eating amongst the lord of the flies, this is the place for you! Service is terrible. The food was like left overs from another place...my old elementary school cafeteria in 1984. The lady serving it also reminded me of the lunch lady. Not the cute cuddly one either...the one with the mole who smoked and coughed lot. I paid $50 for a small pizza, a small cheese-steak w/ fries & flies, a bowl of OK pasta and sauce & 3 cokes w/ 3 flies! I also noticed the spider from Charlotte's Web hanging out right above our table. Be Aware. read more

One of my go-to pizza places. We love the new bar area and the beer selection is amazing! We always have had a good experience here. Just be careful with parking as spots are pretty narrow and hard to come by during peak hours. read more

My new favorite pizza!! The sauce is AMAZING and I'm not even a sauce person. Definitely get extra sauce. Also the cauliflower crust is pretty good!!! They have a great selection of beers as well. And the service is great! read more

I can't believe this place has gotten so many good reviews! I live within a mile of this place, and after trying their pizza about 5 years ago we never went back. We got their pepperoni pizza, and it was absolutely disgusting. Nobody at our table could eat more than a few bites, that's how bad it tasted. Nobody from our party of 4 has ever eaten there since. read more

I love the pizza but I only give them 3/5 because the wings were WAAY too small and too expensive for the size.

Went to sabatini's for dinner today at 5:30. Took my parents who still live in the area. I Haven't been there in years. My father always raved about the pizza. Well here is the scoop. First of all, the service was terrible. The waitress was a miserable human being who could not have cared less. She served my husband a beer with half of it spilled on the tray. The pizza that is supposed to be "better than anything around" had no taste. And we got several toppings on it. Oh I forgot to comment on the Caesar salad....like I'd like a bit of lettuce with my dressing! The poor lettuce was just drowning. I will never go back there again! Give me pizza lovin' any day of the week. They rock! read more

The service is good but the food gets a thumbs down. The thin crust pizza I ordered barely had any cheese or sauce and had a burnt smokey taste. It was also a bit soggy. The only redeeming quality is its selection of beer. read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

I'm updating my review and knocking it down a star because the last three times I've been there all has been less than stellar. I ordered a take-out pie and I arrived early for pickup. The pie was ready. When I got into the car I dug into the pie. Yes, I do that! It was only warm. Hummmm? Pie must have been pre-made or something, but it def. wasn't piping hot. Two other times I dined-in and the service was very sketchy. They took our order quick enough and brought our beverages quick enough but that was it ... the pie took a while, which was ok and worth the wait when it's piping hot, but after that the wait staff was nowhere to be found. She walked by plenty of times but never stopped to check-in on us. No refills on sodas and my beer glass went dry. WTF. We even had to stop her in order to request our check. read more

Wide selection of beer on tap plus shop onsite with hundreds of beers to choose from. We sat at the bar; too cold to sit at outdoor patio area. White thin crust pizza is thin and crispy; Could use more rosemary tho. Red with thick crust is different because it is a traditional round instead of Old Forge or Sicilian style. Asked for a sample of a beer that was on special and was told by bartender; he could not do that! We could purchase a 4oz instead!? Did not make sense to purchase that if the sale price was cheaper per ounce if we liked it?? Their was four of us and we spent $$ that night. Wow! I do not understand why no sample taste!! We all ordered Delirium Red on tap which is delicious. Served in a cute elephant print glass. read more

Absolutely the best pizza in the Valley, hands down. Can't beat it. I grew up eating here and it's always great. Some places are on and off but not here. It's consistently great and delicious! read more

Just visiting the area. Great find. Will definitely order another pizza when I'm back in town.

One of my favorite local pizza joints. Old Forge has nothing on Sabatini's. The sauce is unmatched and the beer selection is downright astounding. Also, little known fact: the cheese fries (with mozzarella cheese) compliment the pizza perfectly. Oh, did I mention cheap!? Best bang for your buck. read more

I love crispy crust pizza and this was perfect. The crust is thin and sufficiently topped to the edge, no dry crusts here. The sauce is sweeter than your average NY style but it's good. The mild wing sauce was thick and flavorful. The booths are a bit small but then again I'm a big guy. The big downside is the cash only status. But they have an ATM in the lobby so if you forget you'll be covered. Tons of craft beers here too! It was a nice deal. read more

a true family style pizzeria where you always get great service and some of the best tasting pizza i've ever had! the crust is nice and thin with a mildly sweet sauce and the perfect amount of cheese! the beer selection is one of the best in NEPA, which makes this place all the better! one of my top 5 places to eat in the wyoming valley. read more

Pizza is good... tends to be inconsistent... good beer selection... only domestic on tap is coors...

Sabatini's pizza is excellent! Their sauce is a bit sweet with a slight tang. Their crust is very thin, making for a crispy exterior. This isn't your typical cheese-over-sauce pizza; you'll get some bites that are just sauce and dough and some that are just cheese and dough. Beware, this place only takes cash. They have an ATM on site with a $1.75 service charge. Lots of beer, too, available for takeout. Plus, they're always quick- 15 mins from call in time to take out. My absolute favorite pizza in the area! I also love their Texas Chicken Cheesesteak! read more

Terrible. Terrible food. Terrible service. And they take cash only! Which for new timers is important info that isn't posted anywhere!! And the new building is a BAR ONLY! So stupid. Once and done. read more

Decent enough pizza, AMAZING beer selection - one of the best in the area, a must if you are only in town for a short while and need a quick fix for the family. Staff is rather knowledgeable, can steer you in the right direction as far as food & beer are concerned, table service is always just about average... I'll drop in when I am back in town. Take-out counter can be a bit confusing at times, especially when it's busy - it's busy. The place gets mobbed and the staff shows it. The earlier you get there, the better. read more

LOVED coming here as a child! Old family style environment! BIRCH BEER ON TAP!

I am obsessed with the new sabatinis beer place!!!! Amazing! The selection for beer is out of this world! Atmosphere is truly great and warm and cozy. Try the ROOT BEER BEER because it's to die for! read more

Honestly, not the greatest pizza I've ever eaten but it is good and not old forge style, so I love that. However, 5 stars for an impressive of beer store and honestly as nice as any LA bar I've ever seen. Major props to whoever designed it and the selection is intense and immense. I would come back to browse for sure. read more

I know I'm odd man out on this one. A lot of people at work recommended this place for good pizza and I was MORE than disappointed. Being from NY my expectations for pizza is always high and this place didn't even come close. I ordered a large pie peppers and meatballs and what I got was a small personal sized pizza with a few pieces of pepper and tiny specs of meatball throughout. I was splitting this pizza with someone else and needless to say we were still both starving after easily polishing off this "large" pizza. The quality wasn't even good enough to make the tiny size worth it. read more

Fantastic thin crust pizza. We were visiting from Philly and it's better here than at most places at home. Two large two topping pizzas, a chicken cheese steak, and drinks was only $50. read more

Not a fan...pizza had a very smokey taste to it. Dining room needs updating, has a 70s feel to. Booths were very small, had a handicapped person with me who could not fit in a booth. Had to go into a closed off,very closed area for a table. read more

I am from the south, but when we visited my wife's home in PA, she introduced me to this place. I really like the pizza they serve here. Every time we travel up to PA. we stop in here several times. We usually bring some back with us, but along the drive back it disappears. Just cannot say enough about it. Stop by and give them a try. I get the thin crust cheese with extra sauce. But order yours the way you enjoy it. Happy eating. read more

Great Cajun bites!!! For being a Friday night service is fast and great!!! They have a HUGE beer list to rival other places. If you are not sure what type of beer ypu like, yhey have tast testings to help you decide. Oh and the pizza is great :) read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Great cajun bites!!! - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

Amazing beer selection, pizza perfection, and great atmosphere. Great to see a place like this in NEPA, and we'll definitely come here each time we visit the valley. Cheers! read more

Good pizza, staff is key to quality here, only had take out, but word on the street this place is one of the best places in the area! Check it out. read more

Some of our favorite pizza. Bottle shop is amazing for those who love unique or craft beers. Children love the chicken fingers and spaghetti and meatballs. I have never had a bad dish here. One of the best. read more

Absolutely love it!! Large plain, hot wings, and their birch beer on draft...a must have.

My favorite pizza in the area! Bacon and banana peppers, well done. Great beer selection too! I love exploring the $2 bin.