There is a serious swing of reviews here. Either its love or hate with little in between. I'll be the middle guy. I've dropped by here a few times for a cold beer after a race on the boardwalk to cool down and relax in the sun. They have a small but decent enough beer list, from Coney Island pilsner to Bud, to Kona Big Wave and a few others all under $10. Also, some canned beers such as High Noon and Goose Island IPA. I skip eating here as most of the menu is unhealthy but they do have some healthy things such as a few salads and fruit bowls. I've found the service here to also be ok. read more

See all

Stopped for a couple of drinks as we walk down the boardwalk and we found the best drink ever. The Henny lota!!! This may be the best spin on a piña colada I've ever seen. Taste fantastic. It's must try. read more

The best on the boardwalk ! The food and drinks are great ! Service very accommodating... and the ambience is everywhere! read more

Salt & Sizzle - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Saturday during the afternoon it was a packed house. I was curious to see what the hype was about so I arrived later. Once I arrived one of the staff quickly informed us the kitchen was close. No food order only drinks. We order 2 margarita. It was delicious and flavorful. She wasn't cheap at all with the liquor. Lol read more

See all

I didn't expect their frozen drinks to be so good. Everything was pricey in my opinion. But I enjoyed my frozen drink. Service was straight forward and informative. Many seating available read more

See all

This was my first time here and they had similar choices to the rest of the boardwalk but also some unique items like the shrimp tacos I had. My friend ordered the chicken tenders and fries which were good and the fries were fresh cut and crispy. The food came out quickly and we were able to snag a table since people were leaving. I loved the shrimp tacos they were big and stuffed and the flavor was delicious just a bit messy as I ended up with sauce all over my hands! I also enjoyed the coleslaw that cane with it but it could have used a little pepper. Would definitely come again. read more

See all

I'm prefacing this review with sharing that all I got were frozen drinks. And they were GREAT. I ordered a frozen margarita and the frozen vodka and red bull. They were perfect. The perfect frozen smooth consistency, took a long time to melt even in the heat, and they were strong. This spot is located directly on the boardwalk and they offer food as well. See the photo for a menu reference. read more

See all

Absolutely awful. I get it. I was hungry. It was late. Yet the quality was still awful. I ordered a cheese omelette, which had zero cheese in it burnt and served over a bunch of undercooked potatoes ordered a side of curly fries under seasoned and overdone. $25 later it was disgusting. Do not order from this place. Absolutely horrible. read more

Super good tacos. The fish is crispy and extremely flavorful. It comes with a side of coleslaw, which was OK. Love all the fresh veggies of tomatoes and onions on top of the taco. No complaints! read more

Salt & Sizzle - Baja fish tacos - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They tried to add on a 6 buck tip just for taking an onion ring and two beers order! Watch out at the register!!! Will not return and I live here. The owner obviously knows they are ripping off tons of customers. Boycott this place. There are many other honest places! read more

The drinks definitely do hit. The customer service is decent; be watchful when you use card they automatically charge tip for themselves. Also, they do let you sample the drinks before you buy them. The food that steak and frites was bomb that sauce yesss read more

Complete waste of money. $17 fish taco which was basically a lot of lettuce and a bunch pico with a small piece of fish. I really wanted to go and get my money back. Then they try to rip you off at the register by adding automatically. If I was t paying attention they would have gotten me but I made them ring my order up again cause tip for what???? The line is very unorganized. Suffice to say I will not be going back. read more

Food was amazing and super quick service! I will be going back frequently!! Fresh taste' ! read more

Salt & Sizzle - Shrimp tacos ! - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Definitely the spot to go to. Amazing food amazing staff and great food choices. Good place read more

Salt & Sizzle - Front - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The location is great and that's about it. Fish and chips $16 with 2 over fried fish sticks. Two fish tacos for $16 with the same over fried fish in the tacos. The loaded fries were $10 but they came with A LOT of fries. The nachos were $11 but they were cold. You can grab a bite here if you're hungry but it's overpriced and poor quality. Most of the restaurants look like they have basic burgers, hot dogs, etc. that are overpriced. The drinks looked good but expensive. A small beer $8... It's a tourist trap and just expensive fast food. I'm a Brooklynite so this was outrageous for me. read more

Salt & Sizzle - Loaded fries and small Stella - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very small and weak frozen margaritas for the price paid. Very pushy for tips. I'd skip them.

We were hungry after watching the hot dog contest and decided with the crazy lines at Nathan's, we needed something different. We come to Coney island quite a bit and noticed that this place had reopened with a new name. Hey let's do it! We went inside and were greeted by the servers moving around at a feverish pace. The decor is simple, clean, nautical, shrimp shanty with its white tables with splashes of royal blue. You pretty much can sit anywhere, order from the table and pay in cash or you can walk up to the counter and pay with cards. Mixed drinks were a little pricier that I expected,, but beers were priced okay. We decided on a beer, a soda, and a order of fish and chips. Everything is cooked to order so it took about 15 minutes for the food to come out. The fries were actually really good it was cut potatoes! The fish was pretty decent but it needed to be in the fryer a little longer (there was a little residual wet batter) so I ended up taking half of the food home for the next day. All in all, this was great! Our whole bill including the tip was under $30. We know we can pick up something tasty when we come back over the warm months. Thanks guys! read more

Salt & Sizzle - Fish & chips $12 - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The cheesesteak was the worst thing we've ever been served at any "restaurant". The whole sandwich was cold, the bread was completely stale and the meat was clumpy and dry and cold. It tasted like it was made yesterday and just sitting around. This was a terrible excuse for a sandwich especially for $15. They also have the "suggested tip" set at 20% and tell you to sign, so if you're not paying attention you'll get robbed for a tip and no one is even serving you. read more

This is by far the BEST spot on the boardwalk in Coney Island. The quality and freshness of the food is excellent. I had a fresh salad (with mixed greens, not romaine or iceberg). My husband and son had chicken tenders and hand cut fries. We also had a watermelon/feta/mint salad. Everything was DELICIOUS. On a busy day, we were able to order quickly, and our food came right out. I wasn't able to partake, but they have creative mixed drinks and frozen drinks. When we're in Coney Island again, we'll be back! read more

I've been wanting to try out this place for a while now and I have been here twice (once just for soda) and recently for the steak tacos and the blue Hawaiian drink. In the two times I've come here, the staff has been rude. They are not friendly at all. The steak tacos were not very good. They have flavor but the steak was very rubbery and hard to chew. The blue Hawaiian was very good. My reason for wanting to try here was due to the fact it looked like such a relaxing place to visit. I recently had two deaths in my family and decided to come to coney to clear my mind. I will try here again but only for drinks. I don't think the food is worth it. The food and service could've been so much better. read more

Salt & Sizzle - Steak tacos and a Blue Hawaiian - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

In the boardwalk. They had a variety of great drinks on the menu. I ordered the Henny Colada which was cognac, coconut and pineapple. It was a bit pricey at $16, but that flavor was worth every penny. Wish the cup was bigger. read more

Being on the boardwalk, I just wanted something nice, and cold. There were no lines, and the drink was decent. Frozen drinks are $14. read more

Salt & Sizzle - Coney Rose - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Terrible service! Nachos with nothing but cheese and the meat I payed extra for. Fries were decent but no mayo. And when I asked for water the staff made a fuss about it. Terrible service choice another spot to eat in Coney Island! read more

Salt & Sizzle - Worst blue Hawaiian, told the bartender for an exchange he proceeded in wanting to charge me. He spoke to his boss and he still charged me. - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food is okay. Service is awful. Got drinks and came back for more. I was on the drink line to get frozen drinks. The girl with the sleeve tattoo asks me what I want just to tell me to go on a different line only to take the customer after me. Just walked away and will not be coming back. If you think I'm just going to go on a different line after waiting on one already you're hilarious. I will just go somewhere else, it's not that serious. read more

Great frozen drinks with equally nice inside seating a la breeze for a calmer cocktail. Or you can opt for casual sea view, where all the action is. Go have a drink at Salt & Sizzle. They are not shy on the liquor, and you can add an additional shot. read more

Salt & Sizzle - Mango frozen drink with an action packed view. - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love this place! There are no healthier food options on the boardwalk and this place has salads and tacos, so refreshing! Major upgrade. Also nice big space to sit in back with Adirondack chairs. Literally biggest and best onion rings I may have ever had. Support it! read more

Tried to have a large private event but the management refused to work with us on pricing for drink packages. Poor customer service. The group drink packages were overpriced and the food is mediocre at best. This is too bad. The location is great and our group previously held events there with the prior management that were a success. I would have liked to write a positive review based on past experiences but it not after our last event. Unless things change I recommend another location. read more

It has good aboutthe place..... do not say no. The staff was very friendly, the patio behind the takeout was a pleasant surprise!! Beer prices very fair and nice local selection! FOOD fries are great those potatoe cut with skins in and plentiful Now...fair...fish/chips.. fish was overcooked. Could have been that day. From the reviews it is either over or under... they need consistency. Bad...cheesesteak... never found any cheese in the extra cost Provolone. Onions only...they need green peppers, mushrooms.... call it a Cheesesteak. The meat... tasteless. I want them to succeed. Please take the reviews and get better read more

Although a bit expensive, this place has a great location and offers great fish and chips as well as other seafood items like fried shrimp. This place is more like fast food than a full service restaurant. But it does offer a great place to hang out on the boardwalk. Check it out! read more

Stopped here on my visit to Coney Island. Ordered a decent-sized cheesesteak and a draft beer, the Merman IPA from the nearby Coney Island Brewing Company. There is also beer in cans and cocktails on the menu. Service was friendly and quick, and it looks like they have multiple places to order to meet demand during busy times. read more

Salt & Sizzle - Draft Beer - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I had a terrible experience at this establishment. I visited on a quiet Tuesday afternoon and ordered a lemonade and a Philly cheesesteak. When I placed my order at the counter, the server tried to add his own 20% tip without my consent. I sat at a table but had to get up to grab some napkins. When I returned, a gust of wind blew my $16 sandwich off the table before I could even take a bite. I cleaned up the mess myself as the staff watched without offering any help. When I brought the incident to the attention of what seemed to be the manager, he callously informed me that I would have to pay for another sandwich. Given the circumstances and the fact that they are a new business, I expected better treatment. To many options on the boardwalk to return here. read more

Love the live bands, just walk in the back. Great drinks , awesome view , this is what Coney Island should be about ! read more

Salt & Sizzle - View from back of the bar - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Tacos and steak frites are excellent,people is caring and it's very clean too.we will come back!

Great place to hang out on the boardwalk and slam 8 dollar Coney island beers.there is also additional seating in the rear and restrooms. The staff is friendly and very efficient, lines do get long but what the hell Coney island is crowded. The food is dive fare, expected worse but not bad , the beer is cold and the ambiance is beach bum style, picnic tables and umbrellas, definitely will return. This is not a fancy place but it is absolutely worth a visit. read more

I went to this place yesterday and had a ball. good live music and better environment. the bartender Sean was awesome! made great drinks for myself and my mom. he was nice and patient with asking what's good and what should we get. I definitely will be looking for him next time I go back. read more

Incredibly greasy food. They need to figure out their fry oil temps because the food was like an oil soaked sponge.

Love their drinks! Service is extremely nice too! They opened on April 2021 and I sure they will be super busy when ppl discover them

had the cheesesteak with provolone- I thought it was really good. the bread was not the typical bread and was more of a ciabatta= pretty thick and hearty but worked really well with the meat and not soggy with the nice browned onions. fries were very good too- I would go back again before cyclones game read more

The bartender was horrible. There were only two people waiting ahead of me and he managed to take about 20 minutes with them. Flirted with the first customer (an older lady). Then for the 2nd customer he concocted an unsolicited, unnecessarily complicated drink that involved putting mini marshmallows on top and roasting them...except he aimed the flambe gun towards the customer and fired it. Thankfully the gun wouldn't light and he had to take it elsewhere to do it. Was rude and brusque when he got to me (probably because he was embarrassed about his ineptness). Repeatedly ignored my request for a plastic fork. This is not the only establishment on the boardwalk that serves cocktails - would highly recommend going somewhere else. For example Paul's Daughter had staff that were friendly and efficient. read more