This place was such a vibe- I had SO MUCH fun here!!! Me and my dad sat at the bar for a drink and some apps.... We were having so much fun we stayed for dinner!!! We first ordered (obviously) some oysters !!! My first time trying and they were good - not what I was expecting but the sauces were good! We also ordered the spicy ahi tuna nachos... pretty big plate and they were delicious!!!!!!! While we were enjoying those- we noticed you could buy the kitchen a beer... so we had to!!!!! It was so fun, you ring a bell and the kitchen gets so excited!! We even got the meet the "Mary" (very sweet women by the way) We, like I said, had so much fun we had to order dinner!! I got the chicken schnitzel and my father got the walleye sandwich.... We ended up splitting both plates because both were so delicious!!! Both are big portions and made perfectly! I cannot wait to come back and try more and hang with this fun staff again!! read more

See all

I've been craving oysters and I have been eyeballing this place for a long time. We finally got around to coming here and I am happy we did. I got the Chesapeake oysters (they were huge!), Bloody Mary and their clam chowder. All of it was good. The clam chowder tasted exactly what I was hoping for, nothing fancy just normal chowder that tastes like home. We also ordered the deviled eggs to share but they were a bit salty. Our waitress Brandi was very nice and attentive. She made the experience great! read more

Salty Mary's - Chesapeake oysters - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

Service: server was delightful unfortunately she didn't bring out our appetizer and did not come back around for a while when we finished eating. Food: Very disappointing. We ate here about 2 years ago and the fish and chips were great. This time the fish was greasy and the fries tasted like they were from a freezer bag. The fries used to be soooo good. Flat wedge fries. Unsweetened tea was from a fountain and not fresh brewed. Appetizer was ok but the dipping sauce was not great. Seems like they reduced the cost and quality of their ingredients. Price: Outrageous. My wife and I split the $25 fish and chips. $25! For the quality that is nuts. I'd recommend Kitchen Social. Fish and chips there is better and only about $18. Overall I was disappointed and won't be returning. The only reason I gave it 2 stars was the server. read more

I returned to dine in after a positive experience dining there before. Unfortunately, this time I ordered only an entree salad. I asked for the dressing on the side. The salad arrived soaked in dressing.The salad was small and I was not impressed at all for the price. Disappointed. read more

Great Sunday brunch with standout service--friendly, attentive, and very knowledgeable. The place was lively and the atmosphere pleasant. Food was decent but not exceptional. The $3.50 oysters were okay, though not especially fresh and poorly shucked (shell fragments left in the liquor). Most dishes were heavy on Cajun seasoning, which overwhelmed the seafood rather than complementing it. read more

Salty Mary's - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

The service was really good .... Had the fried and raw oysters was basic to me. Was a nice spacious place. read more

Salty Mary's - Broiled Oysters - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

I ordered the crab cakes, they were the size of a fifty cent piece! They were the smallest crab cakes I've ever laid eyes on! For $ 37.00 thought it was kind of a rip off. We had both east and west coast oysters I'd say at best they were ok, really small for $ 21 a half dozen. Doubt I'll go back. read more

Visited from out of town 2 years ago and came back again! Super cute inside and was sat immediately. Tasty lobster roll and shishito peppers ! Aside from my broiled oysters being slightly overcooked, I recommend this place. read more

Salty Mary's - Oysters and Blistered Shishito Peppers - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

My son and I had a pleasant dinner on the patio a few weeks ago. I had the fish and chips and he had the chicken sandwich (fried). Both meals were delicious. The server was both pleasant and efficient; I'm not sure what her name was. Sorry I think we'll go again. read more

I'm not normally a "fish" person, but my wife loves it. Over the years, we've dined her and I'm amazed to say, this is one of the few spots where I actually eat fish. The Cod is deep fried, but you'd never know it. Not a molecule of oil. Nice tasting fries too! In a real twist, my fish-loving wife can't get past the Shrimp with Grits. It's a topsey-turvey world at Salt Mary's. We can't pass the Bread Pudding dessert, either. Give it a try. The menu is full of great food. read more

Salty Mary's - Salty Mary's - BBQ Shrimp with Grits - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

The food was fantastic and the service was personable and prompt will definitely go again I loved it. read more

See all

Well, goodness me -- this place is just lusciously delicious! First off -- fun atmosphere, with a cozy fireplace, original decor (including oyster shell chandeliers!) and clever signage. Jeremy was our server, and was friendly, knowledgeable, and handled my gluten allergy without batting an eye. The food? Our selections were off the chain. We started with the deviled eggs - extremely creamy; a little kick; topped with a crisp cornichon. We had 4 different varieties of oysters -- all perfectly chilled and served with both cocktail and a green sauce mignonette, with plenty of lemon. Now for the showstoppers -- I had the N'awklins shrimp and grits. Oh my! The shrimp were nestled on top of the silky cheddar grits, and blackened - seasoned beautifully and cooked just right - not mushy or chewy. But the star? The broth! Tomato based, the depth of flavor was unexpected, and so good, I could have eaten a bowl of just that. My husband had Cioppino, which I could not taste due to GF. His description -- the broth was rich and thick -- not like a typical cioppino broth. It was was chock full of seafood -- very hearty -- with mussels; shrimp; calamari; clams, and just a touch of heat. The bread was also a standout -- baked to order, and then charred. You may want an extra piece of bread, he wants me to tell you! Really -- go to Salty Mary's, ask for Jeremy, and stuff yourself silly. You won't regret it. read more

See all

Not too much good! Service was slow with lots of apologies. The meal took quite a while with apologies , and it was very bland. We both ordered fish and chips it was extremely tasteless. We used our lemon, the sauce and ketchup, and it was still tasteless. read more

Went for lunch (my 2nd time there), had clam chowder and cod sandwich! It was fantastic!! The server was above and beyond. I sat at the bar. Very rustic and old school. Will definitely be back! Great prices too!! read more

Salty Mary's - Cod sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

I started with the oyster shooter. A cup of clam chowder and an oyster PoBoy! Outstanding service and the food was top notch. I don't like flaccid fries. Theirs are so crisp the crack when you bed them. Delicious! read more

Salty Mary's - Oyster Po Boy and crisp fries. - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

Yummy The food was really good! Our server was lovely as well. We liked the oyster lamps read more

Salty Mary's - mac and cheese - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

Enjoy apps and cocktails with friends for happy hour and both didn't disappoint! They also had cute little patio. read more

See all

Birthday dinner Aug. 30th... Server Heather was great... Happy Hour oysters were great... Main meal not so great... I had the Cioppino which was my go-to there but not as good this time... Broth, instead of being like broth was a heavy tomato-based sauce overpowering the seafood... Definitely changed the recipe and not for the better... Partner had lobster mac 'n cheese which she has always loved but this time appeared to again, be a different recipe and not as good... Used to be a nice creamy mac 'n cheese with the lobster meat incorporated into the sauce but now was just a bowl of cheese macaroni with a little lobster sprinkled on top... Very disappointed in the meal... read more

A group of us went here for Sunday brunch and a book club discussion! I have to say that everyone from the girl I spoke with on the phone, to the hostess to our server were sooooo extremely kind and helpful. Some of us did the brunch menu and some did lunch- all did not disappoint! I ordered the New England clam chowder which was delicious and the wedge salad. That was big and very tasty. They have a great seafood menu and it's decorated really cute inside. I did not order but they had a honey bread on the menu that I saw on another diner's table and it looked delicious! I really enjoyed my dining experience here and really want to try for dinner. It's hard finding good seafood items in the Midwest, but this place is a "catch" ;) Oh, one more thing- the shrimp tacos looked amazing and one of my friends ordered them and said she could have eaten 6- they were that yummy! You get 3 in an order, I believe! Check out Salty Mary's! We will be back! read more

The deviled eggs - as others have said - SO GOOD! Clam Chowder - AMAZING Our server/bartender (bc we had to sit at the bar) was amazing !! (Bree) This is in an old Friendlys restaurant BUT the ambiance is nice. They do have a few tvs and will put on whatever game you want read more

Salty Mary's - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

Really good seafood. Nice staff, nice place. We will be back. By the way, the oysters were good, probably the best thing on the menu. read more

See all

Best fried clams in Ohio! I have searched the state for this beloved delicacy! Charming casual feel, and very friendly service, we got to meet the chef! read more

Food was great. I got the fish n chips and my mom got the crab cakes and we both commented on the crispness and lack of oily-ness that sometimes you get with deep fried food. My wife got the crab legs and really enjoyed them, and at a great price. The hush puppy appetizer was very good as well. We'll be coming back. The only thing I'd improve is having a wider variety of beer on tap, but they do have a decent selection of bottles and cans. read more

The waitress suggested the seafood broil, either 1/2 pound or 1 lb, without naming the price. We ordered the pound of seafood broil. Lots of potatoes, small crab legs which required a lot of work for little meat, and four of the mussels were still closed (not boiled long enough to be safe to eat). The bill for one pound of seafood broil was $120! Suggest that if a pound of anything--caviar from the Black Sea, uranium, a first edition of a Dicken's novel--be sure to inform the customer! Again, lot's of potatoes, undercooked shell fish, and not a lot of other seafood: $120! Better off enjoying a good meal at another restaraunt. read more

Came for an early NYE dinner. The service was friendly & efficient. We started with calamari & split a chop salad which is huge! I was hoping for king crab, but they serve snow, so I decided on a blackened walleye sandwich with cheddar grits in place of fries. It was very tasty. My son ordered the lobster roll and really liked it. We ended our meal with a cherry vanilla bourbon bread pudding and it too was delicious. I love this place! Nice little seafood house close to home! Forgot to snap a pic of dessert :( read more

See all

Great V-Day meal with spouse at Salty Mary's in Westlake. 25 valentine's in the books. Holy cats. We had tropical shrimp ceviche, lobster roll, Blistered Shishito peppers, bloody-mary deviled-eggs, bourbon vanilla bean cherry bread pudding and a black cherry old-fashioned for her. Yum. Will return for the 8 other things on the menu we want to try. BTW : the building is an old Friendly's Ice Cream place. Great remodel and re-purposed space. read more

See all

Happy hour. Deviled eggs. Avoid. Seemingly from a bag of peeled, gave up flavor in whites and yolks long ago. Shudder to think what it would've resembled without a little cornichon crunch. Burger. Server: "How would you like it?" Me: "OMG...hand formed?" Server: "Alas, no." So it came medium (ordered medium well) and unseasoned. But best factory patty I've encountered. Rounded edges and likely a half-pound. Great bun. Oysters...substantial...large w liqueur and the mignonette wasn't just poured vinegar...it was chewy, and it bit back! Shrimp...delish, again substantial...'bay shrimp' fears unsubstantiated. Mussels and fries...fantastic. Service...not rated, tho they did forget us in the shift turnover. We'll be back for more and different! read more

Everyone in our family agrees that Salty Mary's has the most delicious food. We always take our out of town guests here! Seafood lovers- Salty Mary's will absolutely exceed your expectations. Delicious food, a calm atmosphere, and genuinely friendly staff will make the visit unforgettable. There are so many good choices - clam chowder, parmesan garlic butter broiled oysters, fish and chips, coldwater grilled salmon, plus the deviled eggs are delicious! Time and time again, we could not leave without trying the bread pudding dessert. We appreciate the hospitable hosts, amazing dishes, beautiful presentation, and nice wine list at Salty Mary's! I feel so lucky we can have fresh seafood locally! I would definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Food has gone downhill. Disappointing. Longtime chef no longer there. Items I have enjoyed previously are not what I expected

We just went to a Santa event and it was so well organized and festive. The Santa was perfect! The food is always good. Fresh and interesting. Service always amazing. Owner was there and you could feel the camaraderie. Well run place!!! read more

It's been a while. This is one of my favorite spots for oysters. New oyster variety every time I visit this gem! The Freshest oysters on the west side hands down. Carlos is still killing it in the kitchen. Lydia the bartender was fast and friendly, great service every visit. read more

See all

Tonight I had little time but a craving for some calamari and a fish sandwich. I've been meaning to stop in for awhile but decided to call in an order since I had plans later. Thank god I called in the order and I'll be eating inside soon Their calamari was great but the blackened walleye sandwich HIT THE SPOT! And did I mention this was take out?! The bun on the sandwich was perfect and I loved every peppery bite! The walleye was perfect and their thin cut fries complimented the entire meal ... nothing was left. And now when I have a little extra time, I'll be planning when I can head inside for a meal. Thanks Salty Mary's and see ya soon read more

We had Sunday brunch there and were very pleased with everything the service food and ambiance. I had the Crab cakes Benedict and it was excellent, the hollandaise sauce was very flavorful and tasted fresh, the crab cakes were very good too. My wife had the veggie omelette and it looked and tasted great also. Both came with breakfast potatoes that were chunks of potatoes seasoned perfectly. We'll be back. read more

My first time here, not terribly busy at 8pm on Saturday. Food was amazing and fresh. Service from our waitress was good but kitchen and bar was slow for being slow. Lobster roll and oysters were awesome. We had the trout dip and crostini appetizer. A bit pricey but delicious and tasty. read more

See all

Salty Mary's was so good! Yes, have the oysters and oyster shots but also have the crab!!!DH and I went today 5/7/2026 and Special thanks to Lydia who made our experience even better! read more

I was no where near being salty after leaving here! We came here after a recommendation and were really impressed! The menu has a lot of delicious items that don't break the bank and good quality! We started with the edamame, which was soooo yum. Also got the cornbread which was sweet and delicious it could've been a dessert. The honey butter on it is to die for. The oysters also were great. For entrees I go the Po Boy and love how it was just ever so slightly fried. Great casual atmosphere and great food!! Definitely sending the recommendation along! read more

Salty Mary's - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

Have wanted to come to this establishment for some time, finally did it. I did not take pics of all the food, but our group also got the cod sandwich, blackened walleye sandwich, some grilled oysters and Nawlins shrimo. All the food was very delicious, was very impressed. Our server was very friendly and overall great. Great vibe inside, I bet it's a great place to hang out in the summer. Can't wait to go back and try different items. read more

Salty Mary's - Deviled eggs - Seafood Near Me - Westlake, Ohio

See all

Our party was 11. Service was great and food was excellent! Thanks Joyce for the great service. read more

See all

Food was great, always is. Had a great experience with manager. Called to see if we could fit in one more, he put me on hold and I was on hold for a while. I figured they were very busy and hung up. The manager, Max, called back! It turned out they were too busy to accommodate, and that was fine. Great, great customer service!!! Love the food here, but will always remember the customer service! Great job Max! read more

This was a very nice stop along our journey out of Ohio. Nice quality seafood (oysters and shrimp). Definitely a solid dining experience.