I absolutely love Sarah's Bagel Cafe in Nampa! I've been here four times since I've been in town, and that alone should tell you how good it is! Every single time I come, I order the New York Supreme Bagel, and it NEVER disappoints. It's packed with flavor, fresh, filling, and so good that I honestly don't even want to try anything else because I already know what I came for! There's just something about walking in, smelling the fresh bagels baking, and grabbing a warm, perfectly made order that instantly makes the whole experience feel cozy and comforting. And the white mocha iced coffee? SO GOOD! It's made perfectly every time and pairs so well with my bagel. Sipping it while sitting in that relaxed, welcoming café atmosphere just makes it even better. On top of the great food and coffee, everyone is always polite, friendly, and welcoming. The service has been consistent every single visit, which is a big deal for me. If you're in Nampa and looking for a good bagel and coffee spot, Sarah's Bagel Cafe is definitely worth a visit. Four visits later, and I'm still coming back! Way better than Starbucks ! I will update my review Coffee was so good I forgot to get a picture read more

See all

Great fresh bagels here. I stopped at Sarah's Bagel early this week and bought three bagels. One plain one poppyseed and one jalapeño cheddar. My wife is a fan of plain bagels and absolutely loved hers. It was soft in the middle. Go on the outside and cooked up crunchy just about perfect. I had the poppyseed bagel which tasted very good, but the poppy seeds had a funny taste to them. It was just an off taste and they were much smaller than most poppyseeds I've seen. Hard to describe the flavor. The jalapeño bagel was great. It could've used more cheddar and jalapeño like Albertsons down the street, but the bagel was excellent. Just little chopped up pieces of jalapeño resident slices. I toasted it with just butter and was very happy with it. Sarah's bagels are a bit less money than Panera Bread and a little more than a grocery stores but if you want to splurge on a bagel, I recommend them Not a fancy place, but there are some tables and it looks like groups get together and have bagels and coffee there in the morning I was in and out quickly and got my bagels to go. There were also bags of day old bagels, five dollars for six. Roughly half price. If you're not gonna use them for a day or two might as well get the older ones. read more

Stopped in on Sunday after church for bagel sandwiches, and will say they had a huge menu and the bagels were nice and fresh. We all got breakfast bagels, and honestly, it's a solid little place to grab a quick breakfast or lunch. The price point was good, the service was quick and friendly, and the place itself had plenty of seating and is nice. They also offer a ton of drink options, which is nice as well. We would definitely go back again. read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - Salt bagel breakfast sandwich - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

Great service, big variety to choose from, food is fresh and delicious Boba is fresh and tasty also. Definitely will be coming often. Also great space to study nice ambiance. read more

See all

And they are back . I am glad to see that the owners daughter is working there and I gotta say the amount of cream cheese on there is perfect. It's just starting to squeeze out. Thank you very much for making me want to come here again. I'm happy to put 5 stars back on the review . read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - Cinnamon Sugar Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

We were driving through Nampa and stopped in for a quick breakfast. The bagels were good! I kept it simple with a plain bagel toasted with plain cream cheese. Our bagels were nice and warm even when we got back on the road. I'd definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the area. read more

Just wow! Amazing. I had the breakfast croissant and it was so good. The bags of bagels are a great buy. Throw in the frozen soup to take home and it's a home run. read more

Good Bagel, sandwich was not the same experience! I will say this place seems to have a lot of locals coming in for breakfast, parents with kids, workers, people on their way to work. Good for the parents that choose this over a donut spot, but to each their own. Now I was less than thrilled, maybe just a bad stop. It wasn't that busy and the wait was pretty long for a simple breakfast sandwich . Worst of all was seeing the avocado that they used on my sandwich , so many bad spots. Now I get controlling cost but I know I would never put something like this on a sandwich...if it's spoiled I know I don't want to eat it! So many other choices and places that don't use spoiled ingredients! KT read more

I enjoy Sarah's sandwiches, but the problem I have is watching the eggs get microwaved in a plastic bowl. With all we know about plastic these days I would think they would get with the times and use glass or something. read more

Just stopped in for a late breakfast/early lunch.. great choice I had the pastrami bagel I think it was #9... it wasn't anything fancy it was just a straight forward lunch bagel... Service was quick for how busy the place was, seemed clean.. when in the area I will try again! Seems like a great local bagel shop! read more

Hadn't been here an awhile, but have never gotten a breakfast bagel. I got bacon egg and cheese on an onion bagel. There was literally no flavor in the bacon and cheese. All I could taste was burnt onion on the top of the bagel. Sadly disappointing read more

I'll give them a 3 based on the breakfast sandwich because I didn't really like it. It's a microwaved egg and American cheese and it tastes like it. I did like the bagel it was on though. read more

This place is amazing. Some of the best bagel sandwiches you will find and their frozen soups they sell also, out of this world. We go here often and will continue to go read more

We placed our order online, and thankfully my sister checked it before leaving--they had added cheese to my bagel even though I didn't order it. Glad we caught that mistake, as I'm dairy-free, and there's nothing worse than driving all the way home only to find out your order is wrong. That said, the bagel itself was super fresh and soft, which I appreciated. An okay experience overall, but attention to order details could be better. read more

I ordered deliver from UberEats from here and probably wouldn't again... the chicken noodle soup has a funky base or under flavor going on that I can't quite figure out. But it is hot and for my sore throat that's what I was after. I got their Parmesan bagel with jalapeño cream cheese and it's really good but I asked for the bagel to be toasted and it's not. I also got their jasmine green tea that had add ins of extra boba which I was fine with normal boba but it actually came with no boba whatttt the heck? My daughter liked her mango boba tea though and maybe because we selected extra boba in the add on's is why it actually came with it? Will never know. Also our order didn't come with any napkins which is always a bummer when you're counting on having everything you need to enjoy a meal. read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - Parmesan bagel with Jalapeno cream cheese - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

See all

Our son took us there for breakfast and the bagels were excellent. A very popular spot for locals and college kids. We will definitely visit again. read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE this place! Great drink menu, delicious food, quick and easy service. Definitely gets packed on the weekend and is NOT a fancy sit down eat restaurant. It's more like a nice quick deli stop. Once you start adding to your basic order it can get pricy. read more

Haven't been in person, which I look forward to because these bagels make fantastic breakfast, and sandwiches even a few days after they were purchased. The everything bagel and jalapeño cheddar bagels are my go to! read more

Worst experience ever ordered 10 bagels for delivery in Nampa only one showed up wasn't even the right one wasted time and money

Be careful, this place is addicting. We had a job in the area and was stopping in almost every morning. I'm pretty sure I've tried everything on the menu. Can I pick a favorite? Ehhhh that's really hard, everything was so delicious and brought their own unique flavor. This is a menu that requires taking turns; I had that one last time so I'll pick this one this time, and that one next time. The sandwiches are a great way to start the work day. So yummy and such a mood booster. I also appreciate how affordable they are. It made coming often easy and doable. read more

Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Ambiance 3/5 Water 4/5 Man this place gets packed on the weekends. Even though this place is packed the wait is pretty quick. They make great boba and coffees but the bagels are soft and they don't hurt your mouth like some other places. I recommend the jalapeño bagel to go with any of your choices. read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - 15. Mexican Fiesta Sandwich - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

Been coming here for a long time now but this time just was frustrating. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a PLAIN bagel and they gave me a onion bagel. When I went back in to get my order fixed the lady at the front was VERY rude and had an attitude. "Well is it still a bacon egg and cheese" I said yes and she proceeded to scrape off the insides to the plain bagel, i've never seen a restaurant do that. It seems super unhygienic in my opinion. The tables were dirty and there was a whole bunch of freight out on the floor which was ruining the atmosphere of the restaurant. read more

Tried it for the first time..had a breakfast bagel sandwich. It was very good...I'll be back!

We love Sarah's bagel cafe! The nampa location is always really quick service, very friendly staff, and they are always really kind to our kiddos. Their pricing is fair and the food is always delicious! We love all their different bagels, their herb cream cheese is a favorite. Their coffees lean on the sweet side so make sure you ask for less if you don't like it too sweet! read more

Food was good, but there was glass or plastic in my drink. I called the restaurant and asked to speak to a manager to warn them that I found glass in my drink and the response was "It was probably an accident. Come in and we'll make you another." read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - Boba covered in glass. - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

See all

Ok- it's a bagel right? You're thinking "Can't be that hard to make a good bagel." And you'd be wrong. Even at 1pm on a Sunday afternoon- these were fresh, hot and some of the best bagel sandwiches I've had in a long time. Forget the other local spots. Find a Sarah's. It's worth it. read more

Manly come here for their smoothies / boba drinks. They always are a hit and flavorful!

Best bagels in Idaho! And they make their own cream cheese and a dozen different flavors of soups. Love this place!!

Just moved to the area and have already found myself here twice. I love the amount of options they provide for bagel sandwiches and drinks. My favorite drink so far is the Vietnamese coffee, which I recommend to anyone that needs a pick me up. I am excited to try more of their menu options as all of their food has been extremely fresh and well made so far. read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - 22. California Dream with Bacon and Sausage Sandwich 11. Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

See all

Oh my, the best honeydew smoothie ever!!!!! Amazing staff and comfy chairs. Will be back for sure.

Very rude, I asked for salt and pepper packets after paying and it was like I was bothering them. I complained to the manager about the young ladies demeanor and he just shrugged his shoulders and proceeded to look at other orders. I am glad I tipped them and still got terrible service. My wife was looking forward to trying this place since we love the one in Boise, needless to say we won't be coming back and I will make sure I tell people how terrible your guys service is. read more

Sarah's Bagels is consistently delicious! The Sarah's special is great with bacon for breakfast and the lunch options are equally as yummy! Highly recommend!! read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - Sarah's Special with bacon - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

The bagels and drinks (my friends and I always get their boba tea) are very good, but where they lack almost entirely is the service. Every single time we've gone, the person taking our order is short and seems annoyed to be there. And then the one at the register always has an AirPod in and is short as well. She always seems annoyed to be there. I had asked for a vanilla chai with boba and they charged it as that, then when I confronted her about the drink not having boba in it she charged me an extra 75¢?? And she acted like it was a big issue. I totally get if someone is having an off day or a rough time, but this is a consistent thing there. The other problem is the general atmosphere. There are boxes and packages of stuff lined up against the walls and it makes the place feel very cramped and dingy. The owner is nice but the other staff are always fairly annoyed and seem like they don't wanna be there. The food is really the only good thing about this place read more

Went here for the first time today. The food was excellent and so was the service. The bagels were super soft and fresh and the sandwiches comes with all the goodies, including avocado and sprouts. They even made a special chocolate peanut butter smoothie just for my daughter since they didn't have one on the menu. I will definitely be coming here again. (Turkey sandwich on pesto cheese bagel ) read more

Sarah's Bagel Cafe - Turkey sandwich on pesto cheese bagel. - Cafes Near Me - Nampa, Idaho

We are so happy to find this bakery, great food, great service. They definitely have great sandwiches and bakery items. Trying their soup, they look great. read more

Excellent bagel- first time visiting and highly recommend. We were there visiting Idaho and found this bagel shop! Can't wait to go back.

Delish ... bagels are always fresh and not super dense . Boba is also yum always fresh

Friendly staff and they do a good job. A lot of choices of bagels and cream cheese They have delicious soups also read more

Worth the wait! My husband and I were craving a bagel sandwich and Sarah's Bagel Cafe did not disappoint!! Fluffy bagels, amazing jalapeño cream cheese and generous portions of avocado! Next I would pass on a Mocha and probably get a fruit smoothie instead but over great experience! read more

Bagels are good, but service is super slow. A little spendy in my opinion. Also the building is old and needs alot of love.