I had Italian sausage Bolognese, and halfway through traded it for my friends wild mushroom pasta…read more Both were fantastic, and had rich creamy sauces. The sausage was pretty killer, a tad spicy. The mushroom pasta had a tinge of lemony zest to it. Morels were deliciously panfried in butter. My favorite was the to go order for a third person though: pistachio Alfredo, a similar sauce to the wild mushroom pasta but a bit nuttier. Zero complaints with the food, and i look forward to the owners new location (pizza Lotties) that will be opening soon i hear. This place is dangerously close to five star perfection, if only it were not so crowded (locals know whats up) and it's also a bit loud. The open air kitchen is a nice touch but probably doesn't help with the noise. Imo good food for decent value and would be worth the wait (you can enter into the waitlist online which i will certainly do next time and probably opt for patio seating if possible) All in all very satisfied. This place has a cool menu that seems to evolve and explore the culinary arts. (I love that someone thought to make a sausage/pasta dish with Korean gochujang) I look forward to partaking in many future gourmand adventures here made possible made by such creative kitchen-bound artists

Great food, abismal service. I genuinely can't even put it into words. I understand waiting a while…read morefor seats, what I don't understand is how takes 30 minutes to get us water. Couldn't tell you the servers name, but I can tell you I won't be back for that. Edit: To address your response, after waiting that long for water, I did go up and tell the person at the front desk. At which point, our server did come and check on us. She said that you all ran out of clean cups and got us water, but did not ask if we wanted other drinks, my brother had to quickly ask her to grab him a soda before she ran off, then she asked my sister and I if we wanted anything else. We put in our food order as well because we did not know how long it'd take her to come back. Thank God we did because it took forever for her to come check on us. We didn't get one refill, didn't get one "do you need anything." We watched her talk to who I assume was the manager about pre-closing, and watch her take phone orders. I get that she might be new, but there seemed to be no interest in taking our order or serving us. After we finished our food, we stacked our plates and waited for it another 30 minutes for the check. When we finally received it, I just walked up to the counter to get checked out because I was not going to give her my card and wait for another God knows how long. Appreciate the advice, but I did express frustration and was met with more frustration. Work on your training practices.

We were looking for old school NY style pizza and at a good price. Gunny's nailed it. The price is…read moreUNBEATABLE for the quality. Toppings are fresh and the dough/crust was nice and chewy. It was easy to order on Door Dash and ready promptly. Pick up was easy.

The food was good, the experience was absolutely awful. I ordered a carry out order online at…read more5:53pm. I paid with Apple Pay and was able to track the order online, with a time of 6:15 given as the time it would be completed. I drove there and arrived on time, and waited behind 6 cars in the drive thru. The line moved really slow, with a couple of cars sitting there for 5-6 minutes before moving. When it was my turn I told them my name, and they asked what I ordered. I repeated what I had ordered and paid for, and the person left and came back a couple of times, then told me to pull around tot he front of the building where someone would bring the order out to me. I waited another 5 minutes before I got my food. The whole experience took 45 minutes from the time I arrived. So my question is this: What is the point of a drive thru if you can't just get your food there long after the web page said it was ready? At least the food was good but it wasn't worth it.

I've wanted to try this place for a while. It was a rain delay and the place was packed. We waited…read moreabout 40 minutes to get a seat, but were promptly served. We ordered a few different pies for the table. They were all good. I will definitely be back.

Came here for a birthday and we'll return because it was a great environment with great food…read more Unique toppings on the pizzas made it fun.

Very tasty pizza. Great service at front desk and we spent a hour with 3 pizza. There is no large…read morepizza and so we need to order one each. Good ambiance with board games to play with your kids and family

Me and my wife went here several weeks ago. Soon after they opened and it was great. Service was…read moregreat super clean. Food was good. Wall of drinks was amazing. We went back this Friday for a date night. Service was nonexistent. Bathrooms were gross all the tables were nasty trash was overflowing over half the taps on the walls were not working. I don't know if they have changed management or what has occurred, but it is definitely gone downhill very very rapidly.

All the things- food, service, ambiance, and THE BEER! Came…read moreto try a new Hazy IPA release... not a fan of IPAs but this one is great! (Ask for an orange) I had Claire as my server and she was perfect. I caught Happy Hour so yay but the deals are great. I tried the wings (BBQ), fries, and house made chips. Yummmmm - also ranch was excellent. Other than the IPA I tried my go to choice here is always Bluewing

First off, killer food and beer offerings. Being a native Arkie that grew up waterfowling, this…read moreplace really does it for me. There's great game-style dishes like duck that take me right back home. The servers were timely but didn't bug me or my guest when we were hard at work in a meeting. The dining room is nice, spacious, and clean, though there are a lot of TVs, if you're into that. I look forward to taking more lunch meetings there in the future!

Pizza is perfect everytime ! Service is great as well…read more Wish the bar area was bigger but def live the pizza and that's all that matters !!!!!

Pizza wasn't very saucy or flavorful. I got food poisoning after eating here. Safe to say I will…read morenot be returning or recommending this place. With all that said our Server was very sweet and did a good job!

Great bartenders, beer, pizza, atmosphere, drinks and service!…read moreChill vibe. Good bourbon selection.

Small quaint beer and pizza place. A friend celebrated her…read moreboyfriend's birthday here, really enjoyed it.

We've tried lots of pizza joints and found that Mellow Mushroom is the best. The crust is very good…read moreand the underlaying sauce was very tasty. We ordered the small pizza. It came to the table piping hot. It was loaded with lots of toppings. We were only able to eat just one piece and we were full. Just give a try. You won't be disappointed.

Friends brought me and my two little boys here. They are vegan so they like the vegan options…read more I had a different pizza than I would have typically ordered d/t splitting with my friend. The service would have been negative stars. So many mistakes and food took forever. Kids were going crazy. Pizza was good but nothing spectacular. We had the veggie pizza and cheese bread. I did enjoy the cheese bread

Delicious handmade wood-fired pizza at a fun, laidback neighborhood bar on full blast!…read more Good food and reasonably priced at their great location on Poplar in Fayetteville. Definitely recommend

Had the pleasure of tasting their wood fired pizza at Orthodox Brewing today. It was one of the…read morebest pies I've had in years! Thin crust veggie pizza was cooked to perfection. Will definitely catch up with their truck again in the near future!

Came for a work dinner - outside of the usual, but the vibes were fun, so thought this would fit…read morethe bill. Group of 7, looking to have a few drinks, apps, and dinner. Service was terrible; our requests to have the food come out at once were ignored, drinks were very slow to come out and some were forgotten. Water cooler ran out of water and was not refilled. One food order was totally forgotten. We were told that they ran out of plates when I went to ask for some additional silverware for the entrees served. The plus - drinks were decent. The falafel platter was fantastic; some of the best I've had in Fayetteville. I'd be back maybe for a drink and the falafel, but it is expensive for such poor service and generally crappy attitude from the waitstaff.

This place is just so good! I normally find myself at the Bentonville location, but I found myself…read morealso loving the Fayetteville one. Their happy hour is too good to beat! The staff was helpful in recommending wine for me on their rotating wine menu. I always love their pepperoni pizza and the interior here is great. It was a perfect quick dinner before a show!