Got a coffee ice cream with whipped cream, fudge and chocolate sprinkles. The ice cream itself was…read moreway too sweet and tasted like a latte more than anything. Not strong on the coffee flavor and not what I was hoping for.

4.7 stars. Tried magic fountain the other night and was definitely the best ice cream i've had in…read moreYEARS. Got salted caramel pretzel and peanut butter cup. Both flavors were amazing. Only downside to this place is there's no where to sit inside which i didn't expect. However summer months won't matter. Also ONLY cash or venmo options. Which is fine but good to know ahead of time. Overall, will definitely be coming back !

This is one of my favorite spots for homemade ice cream. There's at least 2 dozen flavors to choose…read morefrom and everything I've had has been delicious. The staff is very friendly and even will let you sample flavors. They have classic flavors, as well as more interesting ones like Smurf! I tried it and it tastes like blue cotton candy. Apparently it's one of their most popular flavors, but I love their cherry vanilla. Either way, they have something for everyone. Also, there's ample indoor and outdoor seating, as well as a nicely sized parking lot.

Worst milkshake I've ever had McDonald's shake is better and they suck. More milk than ice…read morecream a watery weak mess.

Ben was very helpful! He was a delight to be served by!! He made it so cozy!!! Awsome service and…read morewould come again just for Ben! Poor service? I think not!

Ralphs was a delight, Ben the worker was a lighthearted darling he was very good at scooping my…read moreyummy ice cream. The atmosphere was perfect with the smell of sweet treats.

Nasty counter help multiple times. My daughter dropped her cone and was super upset and the woman…read morewho always helps us told my husband my daughter was at fault and was hostile. My daughter was embarrassed and cleaning it up. She has always loved the ice cream and she is a nice although energetic kid. Avoid. They also never have soft serve, sundaes or dip. Even with a line, Zita s is always lovely. Hospitable and kind unlike this place. Which is a shame because we go to Stirling Hotel pretty frequently. Zita s and Magic Fountain are way better experiences.

Their ice cream is AMAZING and service is spot on. Nice atmosphere and feels like an old time ice…read morecream parlor. I'm a fan of mint chocolate chip and theirs has the largest chips I have ever eaten. A+ from me!

Stopped by 1 pm for lunch…read more No wait for a table AC was working Fast, friendly service Food was great Same for ice cream to go

I came across this place and decided to try it out. This place is very adorable inside. I love all…read moreof the decor. They have a lot of parking and seating indoors and outdoors. There was a bit of a mix up during our dinner with meals and the system going down but it was quickly fixed and not a problem overall. We started with 'Gabe's Street Corn' which was fresh char grilled NJ corn on the cob smothered in buttery brown sugar sriracha sauce, house chipotle aioli, smoked paprika, parmesan & fresh cilantro. I would come back just for this ... this was SO delicious. I am a Street Corn lover but this was some of the best I've ever had. For our entrees, my husband got the 'Root Beer BBQ Burger' which was char grilled angus burger, swiss, provolone, hardwood smoked bacon, house sarsaparilla root beer BBQ, lettuce, tomato, frizzled onions & cheese crusted brioche. This burger was BIG and he said it was one of the best he's ever had. I ordered the 'Grilled Watermelon & Basil Salad' which was mixed greens, toasted almonds, feta cheese, hardwood smoked bacon, charred juicy watermelon, fresh chopped basil, sliced cucumbers & house buttery garlic croutons; Served with balsamic vinaigrette. There was definitely not enough watermelon, but the salad was huge and quite good; very fresh. That is one thing I can say for sure; the portions are big. The prices are a bit high but you get a good portion. For my dessert, we got the ice cream flight which is 4 flavors of your choosing. We tried the 'Peanut Butter Cup' (very light on flavor, not in your face peanut butter but still good), 'Strawberry Buttermilk' (this was my favorite! So creamy and flavorful), 'Black Raspberry Truffle' (another favorite. HUGE chocolate chunks!) and 'Watermelon Garden Mint Mojito' (Light flavor, but not my favorite. I would not get this again. I tasted mostly mint, not too much watermelon). I would 100% come back if I was in the area and I would recommend. I love any place that has unique ice cream flavors and not just the typical flavors. Service was friendly and felt very welcoming.

I love Beenie's ice cream! I have been visiting the ice cream shop for several years now…read more Beenie's is located near the Deloitte office building in downtown Morristown. Parking is tricky but there is a paid public lot across the street. Inside, there is a cute little seating area with picnic benches and some Adirondack chairs. Near the seating, there is a water cooler and plastic cups. Being located in the heart of Morristown, the prices are a bit on the higher side, but the ice cream is 100% homemade and sourced with local, seasonal ingredients. I love seeing all of the creative flavors and there are always so many different options to choose from. In the refrigerated section, there are pints and cakes available to take to-go. Monthly/seasonal flavors are offered as well. You can even create a custom ice cream flavor for a special occasion. Service is also very friendly and happy to help, even when they are very busy. They are very involved in the local community and source ingredients from surrounding local businesses. I am part of a local running club in town and each year they collaborate on a special flavor called "Neon Swirl". I can't wait for my next trip back to Beenie's to try more amazing flavor creations. Dr. Darkness: 5/5 Lavender Honey: 4/5 Neon Swirl: 5/5

Love Beenie's! The interior is colorful and well-lit, with a smart design to keep the line moving…read more A large and creative list of ice cream flavors await you! I went for the vanilla ice cream with cherries. It was a generous portion for a single scoop and more than enough. I assume that their ice cream is homemade, it tastes that good! Vegans - don't despair. There are numerous non-dairy options to choose from. The service was efficient and friendly. Overall, this is a very well-run and welcoming ice cream establishment owned and operated by caring small business owners. I highly recommend it!

it has amazing ice cream flavors with many different options to choose from! The workers are super…read morenice and work very hard all day. Penguins ice cream is truly an incredible place with all of the kids artwork!

Super cute ice cream shop! This was my first time going. You have to do street parking there isn't…read morea designated lot. Inside there are so many flavors to choose from. I got the wild blueberry ice cream. It was so good and fresh. There were maybe 3 other people there besides us and the staff took my order, scooped the ice cream, and gave it to me pretty fast. There isn't a ton of space to sit but they do have benches outside. Definitely more of a grab and go shop if you're walking around in the area. I love the theme of this place and the Swedish fish added to each ice cream is so so cute. Would definitely come back to try other flavors, it's always nice to support a local shop when you can!

The black raspberry cookie ice cream was creamy, sweet, and fresh. I liked the contrast of…read morechocolate cookie with the black raspberry flavor. Their single scoop was large enough for me! They have a chill ambience and service is usually friendly and efficient. This night they had fun pop music from the 90s-2000s.

We've been here 2-3 times this summer and overall we like their ice cream. Service is pretty quick…read moretoo. My daughter loved her strawberry ice cream. I tried the Chocolate Brownie and really liked the rich dark chocolate taste. We also tried the Amaretto Fig & Almond, which was different but really good. I was a little disappointed that they didn't have Key Lime Pie because I was looking forward to trying it. Maybe next time! The main downside for us is the seating. There's no outdoor seating, and every time we've gone this summer, the inside seating has been closed too. I really wish they had somewhere to sit and enjoy the ice cream, especially when you're there with family. On a hot summer day, it would be nice to just sit, relax, enjoy the ice cream and spend some family time instead of getting it and leaving. Good ice cream and we'll probably be back, but having seating available would make the experience so much better.