Pluses: delicious picatta sauce and Marsala sauce. The Lemoncello cake was scrumptious Breadsticks were delicious , but only one per person. The Cesar salad with anchovies was delicious. Elderflower martini was delicious. Coffee was good. (Decaf was not available!) Service was prompt and the waiter was very personable. Now the negatives: furniture was in poor repair;; kitchen was noisy due to the sounds of crashing plates; the veal was tough; the server didn't come around to refill our water; the pasta, although good, was served without a large spoon.; and of course, as mentioned by others, 4% was added onto the bill for payment by credit card. read more

Really chill atmosphere, but sat quickly. I was worried Gorgonzola tortellini might be a strong Gorgonzola taste, but it was perfect and creamy. Also had the lemon cake dessert that was recommended... try it! Delicious! Fair prices too. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Tortellini Gorgonzola - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

If you haven't been to Serritella's yet, it's definitely worth a visit. I ordered the pesto pasta and it was delicious. I skipped adding protein (meat has just not been it for me lately), and honestly, it didn't even need it--the flavor carried on its own. My only tiny complaint? It said it came with sun-dried tomatoes... and I think I counted three. But even with that, the dish still hit. My wife ordered the chicken parmesan and said it was bomb. Of course I had to try a bite--and she wasn't lying. The flavors were all there, no notes, no "I wish it had this or that"--just solid. I also had the white sangria and let me tell you... that alone is worth coming back for. So good. We sat out on the patio, got greeted right away, and our waitress was attentive, kind, and just added to the whole experience. She even offered dessert, but we were so full we had to pass--and that's saying something because banana cream pie is one of my favorites. Bonus: she's the one who makes it. I love a good family-style spot like that. We'll definitely be back... and next time I might just order a salad so I can save room for that pie read more

See all

We have been coming to this Milagro Plaza for a long time but never tried this restaurant. We usually eat at Mesa Mercado but decided to try Italian food. Ordered a salad and tortellini and a small spaghetti with meatball. The salad was so simple, was not expecting a salad like that in a place like this. Even the dressing wasn't good. The tortellini was was presented so sloppy and couldn't taste the Gorgonzola. My spaghetti and meatballs was okay, it lacked salt and pepper and flavor overall. The spaghetti was overcooked. Service was okay but not memorable. This restaurant is in a great location has a look like a high end restaurant but without the great service, good food and is lacking that wow factor. In good faith I cannot recommend it. Giving it two stars with the hope the manager will see what needs fixing and make this place a star one day!!! read more

See all

Clam chowder Tuesdays and Fridays. The best in northern CA!! Fantastic happy hour values also!! LOVE this place! read more

Met some friends there for dinner. We hadn't been to Serritella's in many, many years and that was of course at the old location. It was always great food. Food was wonderful tonight. We had the delicious breadsticks (with peanut butter - by request now) and our friend ordered fried polenta with meat sauce for a starter for us all to share. Yummy. I had Chicken Parmesan with creamy polenta it was so good, and a large enough serving that I cut it in half and brought the rest home for dinner tomorrow. My husband had the combination with beef ravioli, cheese tortellini, and lasagna. He also brought half of his dish home too. Our friend had meatballs and spaghetti and boxed up half to take home before she even started to eat. Her husband ordered the veal piccata and ate every bit. We all loved our meals. The service was excellent from the minute we walked in the door. We were so well taken care of by everyone. It won't be long before we return. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Combination with cheese tortellini, beef ravioli, and lasagna. - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

Love it here! We come all the time because they are always fast and efficient with great service members who make you feel at home. I am leaving a review today specifically because we came to Milagro on a Monday for the Gelato place only to notice they were closed. We headed over to our favorite Serritella's as we know they have ice cream. They didn't hesitate to get us a to go order of ice cream with sprinkles!! We sat outside after with our to go cup and they even came out and handed us some waters since it was a warmer day. Safe to say they always go above and beyond and we will continue to come back for not only the great food but the incredible service! read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

The place is kind of hidden in the plaza in a way, we found this place driving by. As we entered, the staff was really friendly and seated us right away. The place was kind of empty. The booths were pretty outdated. The leather was pretty much scratched off the seats. It didn't seem very sanitary to sit on honestly. I hope they get that replaced soon! The food was great, especially for the price. The kids menu was super cheap and it was not noted on the menu that there was hidden vegetables in the macaroni cheese, which I liked! The calamari was seasoned well and had a really good dipping sauce. I'm not sure what it was, but it was delicious and addicting. Once I found on the menu that there was a smaller portion plate I went for it. The spaghetti was great. Just the meatball needed a little bit more seasoning. The waitress was super friendly and attentive. Overall, I would definitely come back! read more

See all

One of my favorite dinner spots! We recently moved to Fair Oaks and had been having a tough time finding good local Italian food. One day we tried Serritella's and it was that day I knew we had found our favorite local Italian food. The quality of the food here is outstanding. Everything from the salads, to entrees to the deserts are fantastic. Truly some of the best Italian food around. Our favorite server here is Ben, he's attentive, friendly and makes sure we always have an exceptional experience. Make sure to ask for him when you go in! read more

I been driving by this place for years but never stop or eat here before. A friend suggested it so we went cause she know I love pasta and OMG the food is good and our server, she awesome. Why did I waited so long to come here. read more

See all

Loudness: 80 decibels. Wednesday night and only about 50% full. 80 decibels is equal to being near a running lawnmower. As usual, the food was superb! I had the Half and Half: Beef Ravioli and Cheese Tortellini. My dining companion had Scaloppine Ala Marsala with chicken as his protein. The food was full of flavor and generous portion sizes. The bread sticks are my favorite here! Our server was attentive and very helpful. This was the first time dining here for my companion and the server was very helpful directing him through the menu. It's tough for a restaurant to control the ambience here, but Serritella's does a good job by keeping the lights a little low and building out booths with tall backs. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmesan - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

The online ordering is horrendous. Was given a confirmation of when the order would be ready. Arrived on time to pick it up and had to wait over 30 minutes. No apology, explanation or credit offered. read more

Pleasantly surprised by this place! First off, all of their pastas can be made gluten free and they confirmed whether it was an allergy or preference to address possible cross contamination. Huge win right there! We were a party of 4 and got 4 different dishes plus an appetizer to try a variety. We started with polenta appetizer. I thought it was just okay- but my mom ate the whole thing basically herself and proclaimed "I can't stop eating this!" Lasagna- huge rectangular serving. Spicey red sauce but usband demolished the whole thing. 1 meat/1 cheese Ravioli- again Spicey red sauce but my parents enjoyed it Primavera GF- delicious! I ate the entire serving. Very fresh veggies, wish there was a bit more lemon in the sauce. Good service with good communication from server. Ambiance is a little off since it is in milagro with other restaurants. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Giant lasagna - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

This is a nice restaurant with nice indoor decor, q nice bar, and clean bathroom. There is space to sit outside and there's plenty of parking. It's next to a sushi place, other restaurants and notably a gelato place. We came here for father's day, not 2ait time. However, it took about 30 + minutes to get our food. The waitress didn't check in with us at all during that time. We weren't impressed with the food. They serve small portions and weren't very tasty - it lacked salt and seasoning in general. We asked for table salt and pepper to help the taste. The bread we had in the beginning was good - nice and warm. We got the chicken Alfredo and pesto pastas. I had a glass of white wine - it was good. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Pesto pasta - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

Got the seafood combo sub angel hair noodles. Cooked perfectly, amazing flavor, perfect amount of sauce, clam and scallop. My only gripe is that I would love if there were two or three more shrimp. With that being said the sauce was amazing. The service was killer, everyone is so friendly and so accommodating! They let you make substitutions for different pasta, even gluten free. The breadsticks are also great and the butter ohhhh my lord the butter was addicting. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Linguine Seafood Combo sub angel hair noodles (half size split with my mom) - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

We've eaten at Seritella's at least 6-7 times and it's time for me to leave a review. I think they may have a new manager or supervisor because in the past the previous manager gave us a little attitude,... but this time around was different. The older gentleman was awesome and his service was 10+! He brought us breadsticks for free on the house and tended to us with water refills, ranch refills etc. Pizza was very delicious and bottom was perfectly cooked. From the Chicken Alfredo to the pepperoni & ham/pineapple they all tasted great! Noise and ambience level was perfect with not too much noise. If I was to leave a review 6-7 month ago I'ld of left 3 star review but based on my experience yesterday 2/16/25 it was a 5 star! I'll definitely be back soon. read more

See all

Delicious food, new chef, old school service, but with high prices and no proportionate appreciation for repeat clientele. This is one of those places where the longer you've been eating there, the greater the assumption that you'll be willing to wait. But wait... Bonnie revived Milagro Centre and brought the ambience to this venue. She's a wonderful human being, but if she's not there, the service can be inconsistent (understandable if it's busy). On a Friday evening, set aside some time to hang out or call ahead if you're ordering to go. Sometimes, it's not as packed, but the service remains slow. For the prices that are charged here, "hit or miss" isn't acceptable. Although the space is shared with a sushi restaurant, it's not okay to order sushi and sit at Serritella's. I have mixed opinions on this. On one hand, a "food court" concept does minimize the impact that a classy Italian eatery brings to the table. But why not collaborate with another restaurateur for an international experience? What if someone in the group isn't in the mood for pasta and could go for some sashimi? Isn't there a way to manage this when it's not too busy? Isn't cooperative marketing an option here? Hey, I don't own the place and it's tough to survive in this competitive world. This review is not intended to discourage anyone from sampling the Serritella's menu, particularly since there's a new chef in town with additions such as risotto arancini and specials like beef bourguignon with creamy polenta (yum!). If you haven't tried this restaurant, by all means, check it out. It's not as wonderful as it once was, and maybe that's the problem. However, parking is much more plentiful than at the old location across the street (now home to School of Rock). Also, Serritella's is willing to switch up the menu and break tradition to some extent. If I could give it another half star, I would. Bottom line...eat here, and decide for yourself. Why not? . read more

Serritella, yup that's Italian for to prune or trim down. Fits well, with such a large open space, the menu is quite concise with many traditional and contemporary Italian entrees. Perfect with a pairing wine list and garlic butter to flavor those breadsticks on the table. Give them a try for lunch or dinner, and while you're at it, peruse the gelato place next door for dessert. read more

We had our monthly women's group here. The atmosphere is open and lovely. Everyone liked their food. We tried the spinach and cheese tortellini with gorganzola sauce, which was light and delicious. A couple people had the eggplant Parmesan which they loved, and a polenta dish that had a ton of veggies. I would get that one next time. Both the server and bartender were attentive and friendly. They share a space with a sushi restaurant that has a robot delivering food. We want to go try that one too. read more

Unlike last weeks "salt forward" utterly ridiculous Carbonara experience at Sampino's on Broadway, last night's experience at Serritella's was great. Seven of us went there for my son's birthday. My wife accidentally ordered the wrong item on the menu, but started to eat it anyways and not complain since she ordered it wrong. The waitress was fantastic, she said no problem, and made up an order of eggplant Parmesan for her to take home, which is what she really wanted. Obviously at no additional charge. Now that's what's called service folks. read more

So came a few weeks later and my opinion has not changed much. Somehow food was not stellar. The appetizer was just warm but edible the pasta plate was cold and the noodles were raw. How does a chef put something like that out. It was just wrong. We sent the plates back and he recooked them and this time they came out warmer than the appetizer and the pasta was edible but not great. The service was better but when you come in at 4:30 pm, and it is mostly empty, I expect that service would be good. That said the staff does still congregate in one place chatting....at the host desk this time. The energy is off in this restaurant it's like they don't care one way or the other and management doesn't seem to mind. I won't be back for a very long time. read more

I ordered the seafood linguine. If it was advertised as shrimp linguine that's one thing, but "seafood" is a gross exaggeration... especially for $28! While there were several decent sized shrimp, there was one mussel and four very small bay scallops. If they were clams, I missed them. Very disappointed in this dish. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Seafood linguini - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

We arrived right when they opened 4pm only ones in restaurant for about 30 minutes. Large menu with lots of options. The restaurant is part of an open concept and attached to other restaurants and bar and community event center. The food was good we dined in a Tuesday. We ordered a bowl of their award winning Clam Chowda only served on Tuesdays & Fridays. We shared the fried polenta cakes we chose the spicy red sauce. We also had a glass a white wine, it was a generous pour! And an entree each, to go we got a 16" combo pizza and two slices of lemon cake. Apparently we were hungry! read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Vegetable lemon buttered angel hair pasta - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

My husband and I have been going to Serritella's for decades, and that ends now. We will not be back. We had dinner there last night, and ordered a $35 Sangiovese. Didn't find out til today that the Gitone Sangiovese is only available for sale at (drum roll, please) Trader Joe's FOR ONLY $4.99 A BOTTLE! Serritella's, where do you get off reselling it for 7 times the retail price?! That's ridiculous! The other thing that we didn't like was when we got the bill for dinner. This restaurant is now charging a higher price if you use a credit card, because (as our waitress explained) a lot of restaurants in Carmichael are doing this, like Rice Bowl. What the heck?! Serritella's, you're missing the mark and not valuing your customers. read more

Great polenta and amazing clam chowder! And a very nice atmosphere. Service is great!

i like their pastas Service is amazing I will come back soon! Thank you so much for your service and food

Using a gift certificate that was given to us, my Dad, husband, and I came to Serritella's for dinner one evening. We were promptly seated and provided with breadsticks. We decided to start with an order of bruschetta to share, and we each ordered a different dish, so we could sample a little bit of everything. The bruschetta was unlike any other we had ever had before, and we all agreed that the stray from traditional was not our favorite. It had some sort of spreadable cheese on it, which traditional bruschetta does not. It almost tasted like cream cheese and did not work for us. For my dish, I decided to order the primavera. My husband ordered ravioli, and my dad ordered the lasagna. All in all, the pasta dishes were average. Nothing spectacular and nothing out of the ordinary that would make us drive out of our way to come back. The layout of the restaurant is a little strange with it being two different restaurants housed in the same building. The space is large and modern, but didn't set a distinctive ambience. read more

My wife and I recently moved to Carmichael and were craving Italian food. I did a quick search for places near us and had a hard time finding anything but pizza places. Serritella's was close so we headed there hoping for best. .. .Yes they serve pizza and we will try theirs when we are in the mood. We were greeted immediately by a very cheerful hostess and escorted to a table. We were given 3 menus, one with the pizzas, one with their specialty cocktails and craft beers (non-craft too but I don't drink those), and another with their entrées and sides. Our waitress swung by and asked us if we needed more time. We told her we were new to the area and she excitedly welcomed us. She shared a little history of the restaurant and also how the chef had added new things to the menu. We wanted to try a variety of pasta so we ordered the combo, selecting lasagna, tortellini and spaghetti all with a meat sauce and a side of meatballs. Everything was absolutely delicious. The pasta was all cooked perfectly and the meat sauce was very flavorful. Even though we were absolutely stuffed, we couldn't pass up desert. My wife ordered their Profiteroles and I got the chocolate mouse cake. These were the tallest Profiteroles we have ever seen! The pastry was nice and airy, stuffed with vanilla ice cream and loaded with whipped cream. We struggled to finish eating our dessert. My chocolate mouse cake was one of the best I have had. We told them we are definitely coming back. We have to try the whole menu read more

The food waa delicious. The service was impeccable and the ambiance was perfect. This was the first time here and it will not be the last.

I'm on the fence, I want to give them four stars for the service and the gnocchi. But unfortunately I didn't enjoy either of the entrees I ordered. At 4:00 on a Tuesday they were empty! But as we finished around 5:00 they began to fill with customers. The restaurant itself was very large and beautifully designed. It has a large bar in the center that you can sit at as well as many tables and booths. Our waiter was wonderful. He served us everything we asked for in a very timely manner and was very kind. :) The gnocchi with Gorgonzola was to die for. Get it, get it, get it! The appetizer bread seemed undercooked to me. I wish it had been toasted more. As an entree I ordered the Saltimbocca - Chicken with prosciutto in a Dijon and mozzarella sauce. The sauce reminded me of hollandaise. Very thick and definitely mustard-y. Not my favorite. It came with cheese ravioli which was actually very tasty, but it was lukewarm. :( I also tried fettuccini Alfredo which was just okay. The sauce just wasn't very flavorful. The chicken Parmesan was good, but the crust wasn't very crispy. Overall, the entrees were just okay. Too bad because the restaurant is beautiful and the service was great! read more

See all

Food was very good but service was slow. Had the lasagna and it was a huge portion. Had to keep asking for more breadsticks.

Food was great! Service not so, was in large group, waitress asked at opposite end of table than I was, if anyone wanted appetizers, I didn't hear her, she proceeded to argue with me instead of apologizing and saying, oh I'm sorry what would you like? did take a while for entries to get to table, like I said we'll come back for food because it was great! read more

I've lived nearby for years but never stopped in until tonight, and I'm so glad I finally did. I wouldn't call myself an Italian food expert, but I've had my fair share, and this place really stands out. The service was prompt and just right for the atmosphere--quiet, clean, and very welcoming. Ben was our server, and he absolutely nailed it. He made thoughtful suggestions to enhance our meal without feeling like he was trying to upsell us, which I really appreciated. He was respectful, accommodating, and made the whole experience even better. Overall, I couldn't have asked for a better evening, and I'm already planning my next visit. I'll also be picking up some gift cards so my friends can experience this hidden gem for themselves. Highly recommend! read more

In case you didn't know Serritella's Italian is now serving Brunch on weekends at 10:00 am. Second Brunch visit and everything was great, service food ambiance. Hopefully they will put Brunch menu on the website, but for now. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

I ordered the linguine seafood combo and it came out quickly! They were able to accommodate my gluten free pasta which was great. A couple things though. Only one mussel and 3 shrimp which I wish there was more but they had a lot of clam and scallops which made up for it a bit. Also I would have liked more sauce. All and all though, I really liked the pasta and the wine and will be back. This is a family favorite of ours read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Linguine Seafood Combo - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

We met friends and had a great dinner and drinks! The food by the new chef was delicious too!

The food is still great though I miss the old timey location. Breadsticks are still perfectly simple and hot as hell (ask for the peanut butter- it's a tradition). We had the cheese plate and chicken and eggplant parmesans. It was all delicious. read more

Serritella's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Lovely cheese plate - Italian Near Me - Carmichael, California

Great stuff kind of short and I ordered so hard simple order of fries did not get them crispy and you get very little for $5

We checked out Serritella's for the first time yesterday. Serritella's is located in the Milagro's Centre next to River City and Mesa Mercado. We were seated right away in the corner with our group of 7. Staff was friendly and attentive! We were given homemade breadsticks on the house which were good - the kids loved them! For appetizers, we ordered the Prosciutto Wrapped Shrimp and Garlic Bread. Both were good, nothing amazing, but they both had good flavor. I ordered the Saltimbocca with Spaghetti as my entree and it was okay. Spaghetti was cooked al dente and the chicken was seasoned nicely. My husband ordered the Veal and it was dry and way under seasoned. Same with the Salmon entree that someone else in my group ordered. We actually asked for salt for the table at one point. Overall, the food wasn't anything to write home about, but also wasn't the worst meal I ever had. I think the chefs need to put some more love in their cooking. I don't think we'll be back unless we're in dire need of some Italian food and even then, this sadly wouldn't be my first choice! read more

See all

First off, you should know that Serritella's currently adds a 3.8% charge to your bill if you pay with a credit card. They do NOT tell you this upfront. It is NOT included on the menu and you will NOT hear about it until the check arrives. This hidden fee is in direct violation of California Senate Bill 478 which went into effect July 1, 2024. Secondly, because of the food hall style of the Milagro mall, Serritella's shares their space with what appears to be a Japanese restaurant in the back. It is not part of the Italian restaurant, so don't be confused. Other than this, the atmosphere and food is good. The service is polite, friendly, but very SLOW. It took at least 45 minutes from ordering to entree delivery. And then, after dinner we had to ask for the check and then ask for them to charge our card and then ask why they added a hidden fee to the dinner. Obviously, the hidden fee soured our dinner experience and made us wonder if we'll be back. Current feeling is probably not. But if you live nearby, and don't mind hidden fees, their no-frills traditional Italian food is of good quality and well prepared. read more