We had a wonderful first visit to this restaurant and will definitely return! I ordered the chicken club salad with honey mustard dressing, and it was absolutely delicious! The chicken was perfectly grilled and paired nicely with savory bacon crips. My husband ordered a traditional pepperoni and sausage pizza and he was pleased with every aspect of its presentation and combination of ingredients, not to mention the pleasure of having leftover slices to continue enjoying tomorrow. The owners are friendly and gracious and made us feel so welcome. They are adding a bar to the restaurant, which will create additional seating for 40. We will definitely be back!! read more

Went a distance to get here as its been compared to Vincents vinnie pie and had to see how it shapes up. Well first crust very much the same. Cheese same great taste, pepporni was plenty of it and also great. Saugage there was not as much but actually tasted better! Not near the grease level. Excellent and while a shade under vinnies they have the advantage of being open week day afternoons and they take credit cards... So new favorite Pizza. An added plus a big menu too and there garlic knots are super. read more

Had a piece of my neighbors pie and it was great. My sister called and said they were ordering from Shelly Pie ,I had been there several times and they never made the pie like I ordered. I thought I would give it a try again. I ordered a pie to be lightly done. When I got it even the cheese had burn marks. So I called and they said they would make another. Had to make a trip back down to pick up the re-make. I saw a pie that came out that looked good. So I thought mine would look that way also, big mistake. But it was better than the one I took back but not by much. They didn't offer anything for the incondenience but an apology. My sister doesn't complain but her's ways even worst than mine. In fact the crust was hard and the cheese was even burnt more than mine. I know it will be a long time if ever I go back. read more

Another good quality and excellent service, meal at Shelly's. Went for my Birthday meal loved Shelly's pizza last time I was here and couldn't stop thinking about it so I had to make the return. And it didn't disappoint keep doing what your doing. Would recommend read more

Shelly Pie is a favorite in our house. My boys ask for it often and lovingly refer to it as "pizza slop" it is cheesy and greasy but so so so yummy. read more

I haven't been to Shelly Pie in a while. Best pizza I've had in a long time. I introduced Shelly Pie to a fellow pizza connoisseur which we ate there. He gave it 10 out of 10 and said it was just what he needed. Service was excellent too. Can't wait to go back. I need to try the sicilian! read more

Best garlic rolls I've ever had! We ordered a small pizza with sausage and banana peppers and it was amazing! Between the two of us, we each had a slice and a half- it was so huge but so hard to put down! Definitely my new go-to pizza spot! read more

Went last night for the first time. Wasn't sure exactly what to expect. It was EXCELLENT!!! The pizza was incredible...the crust perfect!!! The service was very good...the wait a little long for the food BUT...it is all made from scratch and too order so well worth the wait. I would go out of my way to have this pizza. It is BYOB and cash only (but there is an ATM machine inside the restaurant). Very casual and friendly atmosphere. The menu is huge with what looked like to be many selections I can't wait to try. YEA SHELLY!!! Thanks for the best pizza around!!!!!!!!! read more

Stopped here VERY randomly on a road trip and could not have left happier. The pizza was great, you could see the attention given to the whole pie, and everything was top notch. We had no idea where we were when driving into Turtle Creek haha, but left feeling like we had comfortably known the staff for years. Hope to make it back some day and do it all again! read more

We had eaten here before in the restaurant and had always been very happy. This time we booked their party room for our daughters graduation party. We could not have been any more happy with our choice, from the location to the food to the staff! Mike (one of the owners) was nothing but patient with my daughter and I as we completed the details several days prior. The food was exactly what we had come to expect from Shelly Pie. When we walked in to complete the decorating on the day of the party, the staff had everything setup, right down to the water on the tables and the real silverware wrapped and in place. Every detail was completed and waiting for us. Once I had a moment to settle in, I realized that Mike and Jim (one of the other owners) were in the kitchen, along with their staff, eyes deep in the prep. Once our party was started, Jim was constantly checking with his wait staff, making sure they had what they needed so that we had what we were expecting. The waitresses were outstanding, always on top of the details, yet never "in the way". Again, I want to thank everyone from Shelly Pie! We received nothing but great comments about your food and service from our guests and my wife and I will recommend you folks every chance we can! read more

My favorite place to get pizza. To keep it short, my only problem is the pizzas are never the same. It's not a bad thing, but when you get the ones that have too much grease, little bummer. read more

A very nice experience for lunch. We shared a medium pizza -- and brought half back with us. It has a great flavor -- the crust is delicious and the sauce is slightly sweet. It's nice that it's hand-tossed so the crust is irregular -- some of the pie has a thin crust while other slices have a nice wide crust. I also got my favorite: a well-done oven-baked Italian hoagie. The hoagie could have been left in the oven for a few minutes longer but the flavor was terrific. It was also nice to be waited on by Carly -- Shelly's niece. What an interesting, friendly and nice young gal. Thanks for the great food and the great service !! read more

Great service, pizza & stuffed banana peppers. Shelley pie was also very affordable that is a recipe for success. I am now a customer for life. read more

The service was great! My husband and I shared a delicious antipasto salad! We ordered a pepperoni pizza to share. I had high hopes because of rave reviews I have heard and read and was disappointed in the pizza. I felt like it was very bland, greasy and lacked enough cheese. read more

Solid pizza joint with huge portions, quality food and great service! Bring your appetite and be ready for left overs. A real gem in this part of town. read more

This was a great pizza place! Unfortunately, when I went it was on a Sunday. This was unfortunate because 3x my husband tried to Order something and they were out. Then I tried to Order the Ruben and they were out of bread. However, they gave us free pepperoni fries to make up for it. Their potatoe skins were so delicious that even though the waitress didn't bring the sour cream we ate them all before we even noticed which my daughter thought was hillarious. The pizza was huge and so delicious!!! I recommend you try it, but don't bother going on Sundays. read more

A few people from work said to try the best Pizza in the city... they were very right!!! wow, the sauce and cheese is amazing, the dough ... yummy!! and shall i say HUGE. read more

We've heard about Shelly Pie but this was our first visit. It greatly exceeded our expectations. Erin, our server, was very helpful making suggestions of foods to try. She was attentive without being intrusive. We shared a pizza. It was deliciously- and huge!! We will definitely be back. read more

Not a bad pie. I got a small pepperoni pizza. I prefer a more spicy sauce. Theirs is mild to sweet. There is a lot of crust, which tastes good. You WILL get a lot of toppings! This made for a greasy pie (pepperoni will do that). The place seems good and the staff is good. There is more on the menu than the pizza. I saw folks with burgers, sandwiches and pasta. I had my expectations too high for the pie. See my pictures for more. read more

See all

Good pizza. Great prices. Atmosphere is lacking. Service is good some days. No gluten free here. Best when it's hot.

Usually very good but this place is hit or miss with the freshness of their dough. Two out of Six times I have gotten a bad pie to the point where I though I was going to chip a tooth on the crust. Anyone who ever worked in a pizza place can tell when dough is not fresh or over proofed. Sometimes it dries out on top and creates a pudding skin type effect on the raw dough. They roll it out anyway and think that by putting the hard pieces on bottom that it will change when cooked. It does change to the point of having little oyster cracker shaped hard bits all over the bottom of your pie. One time they were as hard as pieces of eggshell. In my opinion this is not satisfactory when you are play 12 plus dollars for some bread and cheese. The last one I got had an over proofed crust made out of old dough and did not taste anything like what it normally does. I will give it another try but I hope someone who works there reads this and makes some changes and addresses these problems. If it keeps happening I am going to have to start going to Vincents. read more

I would not order anything except the pizza, not because the other menu items are not appealing, but the pizza was just that good. This place is a must try for pizza in the eastern suburbs of Pittsburgh. The environment inside was not bad either. We caught the 1 o'clock nfl games and had a couple of pies , this made for an enjoyable afternoon. read more

I am from East Pittsburgh, and I have eaten take-out pizza from this restaurant twice since they opened. The pizza is delicious, filling a missing place in the tri-boro area. The crust was yeasty and crusty, definitely handmade, not formed by a machine. I ordered pepperoni and mushroom once, and another time I got sausage; each time the toppings were generous. When I picked up the pizzas, the employees were friendly, the restaurant was clean. I took a menu, the appetizers looked delicious, and section on the back saying "wings coming" was especially interesting. Overall, this was a pleasant experience, and I am definitely going to go again. read more

Bomb pizza if you dig mounds of tasty toppings and cheese. I'm a big pizza fan and this is a winner. It's a little messy but so worth the napkins to eat it. The sausage was very good as was the mushroom pie as well. It's out of my way but I think it would be worth the drive . read more

Awesome unique style pizza. If you ever had a vinnie pie from Vincents pizza on rt30 then you know what you're getting. If not make the trip to try it out. You'll be hooked! This place has the pizza from what used to be Vincents. There's none other like it. Biggest pizza with the most toppings I've seen. read more

We love Shelly Pie.The stuffed banana peppers are awesome and love the thick crust Sicilian pizza.

Shelly's pies are the best! If you loved Vincent's, you'll love hers even more. Shelly holds the secret recipe and has improved it. Great atmosphere and great food. Try the polenta with marinara and the garlic knots. Save that garlicy butter to dip your pizza bones into! read more

In Turtle Creek, this is probably the best pizza place, However, it's not in the top 10 pizza places in Pittsburgh or anything. Their Shelly pie is seriously enormous. If you order pepperoni and like your pizza to actually taste like a giant piece of pepperoni and upon completion of the pizza wish to turn into a pepperoni, then order it. If you are so/so on pepperoni, do not order it. Most people probably wouldn't complain about too much pep - but this place puts WAY too much on their pizza. There is never enough cheese on the pie. The crust appears to be super thick, but it's just the outer ring of the pie... in the middle, it's always incredibly way too thin that it's impossible to eat by hand. Certainly try for yourself... I believe it's one of those acquired taste type of pizza. You can tell this is a relation to Vincents pizza. Not much of a difference. read more

Shelly Pie is definitely worth the trip. Our group tried three different types of pizza and liked them all. The prices are very moderate.

The pizza is the best in Pittsburgh. The wedding soup and stuffed hot peppers are wonderful. I highly recommend visiting this place. They do not have a liquor license. It is BYOB. They do have a separate room that holds about 50 for meetings etc. read more

I have eaten at Shelly Pie at least 50 times since they opened and have never had a bad meal. The place is spotless, the staff friendly, the prices reasonable and the food delicious. BYOB in the dining room. Take out orders are ready when they say they will be and have always includes the necessities. Try the specials, they're awesome! read more

SHELLY PIE!!! The real deal! The pizza is AWESOME, DELICIOUS, FRESH and the restaurant is very nice and clean! The staff is friendly and personable!! This is almost as important as the food and I think these people understand that!! So many restaurants need to take a lesson!! Keep it up SHELLY PIE!! I would just like to mention that. I grew up going to Vincent's Pizza Park. It was like no other pizza, that is a fact.... As others have noted, it was sad when they closed. We all waited as they worked in the building and finally reopened. The pizza was BACK!! I have been there about 5 times since it reopened. It was good. BUT I FOUND SHELLEY PIE and I prefer it over Vincent's. I found it while I was driving past the former VFW where Shelly Pie is and I saw someone walking out with a pizza wrapped in butcher block paper on cardboard.... I quickly looked it up and had to try it!!! We get it once a week!! read more

Delicious! Friendly staff, really wonderful food and nice atmosphere. One of our favorite spots. Also love the BYOB!

Worth every penny. Large servings, be sure to try the garlic parm bacon fries! These pizzas are massive, 2 of us split a medium and we still left with half a pizza that lasted us another 2 days! We'll be back!! read more

Great pie, great stuffed peppers, great service and very cool location! Pizza was just as good the next day after a reheat! Beer would be nice, but I'm fine with a more family vibe. We will be back! read more

Lived up to the hype. Large pizza was massive, way to big for just 2 of us. Crust was so thick, and the pizza was loaded with toppings. Highly recommend! read more

Tried Shelley pie last night for the first time after many friends suggested it. Ordered a medium with pepperoni mushroom and onion. Very impressed! The crust is thick and crunchy and the cheese and toppings are perfect. Very similar to how Vincent's used to be back in the day except better. 5 stars. read more

When I'm in the mood for the cheesiest most loaded pizza, I go to Shelly's. I normally ask for it a little more done than normal as the crust can get soggy from all of the toppings. For takeout it's wrapped in paper, for dine in they have a nice little dining area. But besides the pizza, my favorite dish, the thing dreams are made of, is the garlic knots! Oh my! They are fried not baked so they are crispy on the outside and warm fluffy pillows on the inside, swimming in a decadent pool of butter and real garlic.....sooo yummy! read more

Found my new favorite place to eat!!! Great food, huge portions, huge selections, great specials. Can't wait to go back and try more stuff. Pleasant people, BYOB. read more

This place is great! Its definitely an alternative to going to Vincent's Pizza PArk, especially when they were closed for a while. Prices here are a little less than Vincents and the pizza is very close to Vincents. Only downfall is they have no alcohol for purchase though you are allowed to BYOB. Parking isnt that great but not a big deal. Overall a great place. read more