Have ordered from here several times for pick up. Best pizza I've had in the greater Pittsburgh area consistently, and the service is always great and friendly. Many of the side appetizers are great as well, like the buffalo fries. Finding decent pizza in Pittsburgh is a struggle, so I highly recommend it. read more

The pizza and meatball parm dinner are absolutely delicious! The pizza is huge. I made 3 meals out of the 8 cut. The meatball parm is perfect too. You definitely get a lot of food for a low price. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is super clean. Highly recommended! read more

My friend insisted on ordering from Shelly Pie saying it was the best pizza around. I have to say that this pizza just was not to my liking. It was very greasy, the dough was uneven, but I loved all the cheese. Some people swear by this place though, I just am not one of them. The dough was extremely thick on the edges which I enjoyed, but it just fell apart in the middle where the dough was paper thin. The pools of grease gathered over the paper thin center making it fall apart even more. Unless I'm in a bowling alley I do not expect my pizza to be that greasy. Any time you have to clean the top of the pizza with multiple paper towels, you can't help but be skeptical of the pizza quality. But again that cheese was the closest thing to a redeeming quality that I could find. Liberally spread across the surface it was cheese heaven, although it started to harden up quicker than most. The other thing I didn't like particularly, granted it is minor, was the shape of the pie. It isn't really circular or particularly close to it. Maybe some people like the very long shape of the pie, my friend thought it made it unique. To me it looked lazy, although me not liking the pizza was probably a factor in that opinion. I really did want to like this Pizza as I really love supporting small local businesses, but I will not be ordering from Shelly Pie again. A lot of people really love it and I hear the building is the old VFW and looks very nice. I wish the best to Shelly Pie but you won't find me there any time soon. read more

Last night we had a surprise birthday party for my Mom in Shelly Pie's Hayward Jackson room. Everything about the party was amazing! The room was set up beautifully. We had the pizza buffet with appetizers (hot banana peppers and wings). It was absolutely delicious and there was plenty of food for all of our guests. They used nice plates and silverware and really made it nice for us. Our friends and family who have not been here raved about how great the pizza was! Our waitress, Gina, was very efficient, sweet, and accommodating. When preparing for the party, Shelly and the other owners were kind and accommodating. I would highly recommend Shelly Pie's Restaurant for a party or just to go get a pizza! Thanks for everything, Shelly, Gina and the Shelly Pie team! Gina Rudolph read more

Sitting area/restaurant area was nice and spacious for a pizza shop. The pizza is big and very tasty. A tad bit too much flour on the bottom. read more

So, I needed to find a place to take lunch into a local business and found this place to be closest and not a chain. I try to support small biz as much as possible. I needed to to feed 10-12 people and ordered 3 large pies. I was not aware that they did not put the pies in boxes, rather they just staples paper onto cardboard. It was quite the challenge to transport. Nevertheless, I managed to get to my meeting and a few people asked if this was from another shop up the street. I told them no, it's Shelly Pie. The pies were fantastic, bacon and pepperoni on one, black olive and green peppers on the second, and white pizza with tomato and ricotta. I cannot wait to go back. read more

Sit down visit from Chicago and we are first time visitors! This pizza and shrimp scampi was outstanding! Kudos to the chef!! We will most definitely be coming back! read more

Shelly Pie - This is a medium pepperoni and sausage pizza! It was absolutely amazing! ! - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

The pizza was really delicious! The service was amazing, since the place was so packed with patrons. I think there were several parties going on, and it was so loud that I couldn't hear my husband talking to me from across the table. I deducted a star for the noise level. We will probably just call ahead and take it home next time!! read more

BEST PIZZA in the Burgh, great atomsphere and friendly staff. The location was a former VFW Chapter and they give a most generous Vet discount, just ask for it (as a Vet I suggest you don't ask for the discount if you haven't served our GREAT country). Their pizza is often not a standard round due to the old style hand tossed dough, which often makes for an abundant oversized pie, toppings are extremely generous as well. WELL WORTH the higher than normal pizza price compared to the many of the other subpar pizza chain establishments. I only go for the pizza and occasional salad, but they have many other menu items that ALWAYS look very appetizing. BAR is now open. read more

My first review ever... Felt I should disclose that. I consider myself a pizza connoisseur, and in this town I've had them all. Today I feel compelled to highlight the excellent service I received today at Shelly Pie. This being my first visit after hearing good thing, I was greeted as if I was a regular. I was guided into the right pizza choice (they didn't let me order a large) by two pleasant ladies. Before I even got my food I was sold and knew I would return. I am a regular, and frequent other "local" establishments that many Pittsburghers will claim as their favorite pizza place, but sometimes at these "other" establishments they treat like you're just another order placed. I look forward to Shelly Pie growing to be in the conversation of Best Pizza in the Burgh.... read more

Unfortunately during this pandemic Shelly pie is only selling product to go. However, it is just as good as always, wonderful dough and plentiful toppings. Looking forward to the time when we'll be able to eat in again, but in the meantime picking it up and eating at home is still a real pleasure. read more

This is the best pizza in an area known for great pizza. Simply the best. But not just great pizza, their other menu items are equally as good. Daily specials run the gamut from food your grandmother made to Italian specialties. Great soups, especially the Wedding soup. read more

Fantastic pizza and great service . Glad to see a building resued and past remebered

Wow! So i went to Shelly Pie today for the first time with some people at work... When we drive into Turtle creek and saw the building that it was in (old VFW building)..I was skeptical... But went inside and the place was really nice... And really busy.... Ordered the pizza as everyone said how good it is.... I've got you say...i was impressed! Got pepperoni and sausage... It was loaded up! The sausage was definitely the best sausage ice ever had on a pizza! It was oily pizza....i think they drizzle olive oil over top of it... Didn't think i would like that, but i didn't mind it at all. They must use a light olive oil. Co workers also ordered fries... Garlic parm.... Should've seen the size of it! Was enough fries for four or five people. Will definitely be back to Shelly pie read more

The pizza is absolutely amazing! And would it be a Pittsburgh restaurant if they didn't have delicious ranch to dip the pizza in? Everything I've ever ordered at Shelly Pie has been awesome. The service is always great, with very welcoming staff. Definitely worth every penny! read more

First time ordered, I got a fish with extra cheese and fries. Fish came plain no cheese. Called let them know they messed up my order. Didn't want anything but for them to pay attention. Second order which was today ordered Italian sub and French fries, well they got my order right but got added ingredient....hair! I found hair in my sandwich. Called to let them know and was told "the cook is bald". Really???I could care less it came from somewhere. Will not order from there again. I normally give three strikes but I am done. read more

This is one of my favorite places to eat. The pizza is excellent! Prices are decent. Very clean. Nice friendly staff.

I make it back to Pittsburgh to see family about once a year and have always tried to visit Vincents to get a real pizza fix. The last two years we were unable to get into Vincents. I read about Shelly Pie on Facebook and made reservations for family on our most recent visit. The pies are very similar to Vincents with the same wonderful crust, huge size, and all around goodness with a bit less grease. All the family loved the Shelly pies. The next time I come back to Pgh, I won't hesitate... back to Shelly Pie. read more

I went in and ordered a black olive and sauteed banana pepper pizza. The pizza was huge for a medium and had a ton of toppings on it. The banana peppers were spicier than I expected but pizza tasted great. However, the crust wasn't as tasty as I was hoping it would be. The employees at the restaurant were all friendly and helpful, since it was my first time there. The place was busy, but even so the service was quick and professional. read more

Ok, I admit it, I'm late to the game in trying Shelly Pie. I'm a diehard old fan of the Vinnie pie, and had my first pizza at Vincent's Pizza Park several decades ago. Fast forward to 2017. Vincent, god rest his soul, is gone. Vincent's Pizza Park is pretty darned good but not quite the same, and now we've heard that upstart Shelly Pie has been operating for a few years down the street with a competitive product. This demands an investigation. Well I did my due diligence. I visited Shelly pie and ordered a pizza, and even brought the leftover home for a midnight snack, breakfast and lunch the next day. I proudly proclaim Shelly Pie as the second best pizza ever to grace the Three Rivers region, the first being the late Vincent Chianese. Ok, Vinny's gone, so the mantle goes to -ta da-, Shelly Pie. With Vincent's Pizza Park closely behind. Shelly Pie's pizza isn't quite perfect - yet - but it's darned good. The decor is far nicer than Vincent's (remember the fake plastic grapes and lights hanging from the ceiling in the old VPP? Can you say fire hazard?), but minus 2 points for a small imbalance in the salt in the crust. I don't like a lot of salt but even I felt that it came up short in that department, a bit bland. But the sausage was awesome! Rich sausage taste, punctuated with hot pepper and fennel... Mmmm. And Shelly Pie has the same great "sauce" on the pizza pan rendered from the sausage and veggies you choose, and you WILL dip crust pieces in this sauce and eat them or you're never coming back. THUMBS UP, Shelly Pie, you folks ROCK, and I will be back and next time I will bring my friends! read more

The Family Loves Their Pizza, Huge Pizza . Shelly's Pie Has No Problem Putting Lot's Of Toppings On There Pizza.

Great food here. It's very filling and always perfectly baked. The time that they say it's ready, it's ready. They're not stingy with the toppings. Fairly priced. One of the best pizza joints in the area. Just wish they were a little more friendly on the phone but besides that, it's great read more

My first time trying it after hearing from a few people that it was good pizza. I ordered a large pepperoni & mushroom for take out. I was told 20 minutes, I go inside in 20 minutes, follow all of the signs pointing to where you pick up the take out orders, there's no one behind the counter, that's ok though, there's plenty of employees standing around the doorway to the dining room, one of them is bound to see me and come over, or go get whoever is supposed to be there. I waited a good 5 minutes, finally someone comes over, gets my pizza and rings me up. $24. and some change. A bit pricey, but if it's as good as they say, I'm ok with it. I go directly home, open the HUGE box, I'm immediately disappointed, a small pizza in a huge box. I get my plate, pick up a piece of pizza, NOT cut through, so you know what that means... yep, all the toppings slide off an the crust rips off of it because you see not only is this pizzas slices not cut past the crust, it's a complete soggy mess. There's also a wet piece of paper under the pizza that once I got out my own pizza cutter and cut my pizza, I had to pick that paper out of the mix of soggy dough and toppings. Last but not least, the pepperoni was not cooked. I realize that you can eat pepperoni slices right from the package, but I like my pizza toppings cooked along with the pizza, it was kinda gross. If I ever go there again, it won't be take out. I may give it a try in the dining room, because at least that way I can ask for it to be cut, cooked, and maybe it won't be as soggy. Don't believe the hype. read more

After being raised on the rival Vinnie Pie since the early 1980s, and seeing it wane recently, I was all but happy to make the trip to Turtle Creek to try a Shelly Pie. To say it was good would be an understatement. This is the best pizza in Pittsburgh!! No topping skimping, and they're fresh...you can't even see the crust underneath all of the toppings. The small pizza can easily feed 3 people. Shelly is really nice, and the rest if the staff is really friendly, too. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, the decor has local WWII memorabilia around the restaurant. You can get other food besides pizza there, but I didn't try it...yet. I recommend Shelly Pie to anyone looking for something completely different from lame-o chain pizzas. Parking lot there, and maybe even on, or right next to, the busline. Takes credit/debit cards and cash. Word of advice: if you intend to take it home, line your car seats or trunk with a garbage bag...there is some grease from the cheese and meats, and these pizzas come wrapped in paper on top of a slab of cardboard. read more

I ordered it half pound cheeseburger very good me to perfection I also ordered a pie and it also is very good. Will not be my go to place just moved to the neighborhood thank you Shelly pie! read more

Great pizza, great price You can feed a family of 4 with a couple salads (for mom & dad) and a large pie with drinks $35 again the pizza is awesome read more

This pizza was great. If you like a lot of toppings and a crust that you can basically eat as another sandwich, this is the pizza for you.

The pizza is tough, heavy, greasy, overly topped, and overly priced. The entrees are pretty good, although the same genorosity that applys to the pizza toppings, does not apply to red sauce. Unless you like your eggplant dry as a bone, ask for extra sauce. And check your take out before leaving, I get the feeling they don't like special requests. Good lunch specials sometime. It is best to avoid Turtle Creek for pizza all together, 5 shops and they all pretty much stink. read more

I'm sorry I have no idea how this place has such good reviews. I ordered through door dash and it is the worst pizza I have ever had. I would much rather each a frozen tombstone pizza than ever eat this again. The only pro about this place was that delivery was very fast. Now all the cons. Clearly whoever made this pizza had no experience making pizza. The crust all the toppings sit in was paper thin while the edge crust was two inches thick. I ordered half toppings which I assumed was to have toppings on half the pizza, but was wrong on that as there were handfuls if giant chunks of canned pineapple all over the pizza. I have nothing against canned pineapple but these pieces were what you would find in a fruit salad, just huge chunks. The pizza also arrived cold and soggy that I couldn't even pick up a slice without all of the topping immediately sliding off. May I mind you this pizza arrived within 20 minutes of ordering. So I have no idea how it got so soggy and cold so darn fast. Just do yourself a favor and order from anywhere else. Anywhere. read more

Went there with 2 friends,got medium pie 2 waters 1 coke,over 26 bucks. 1 topping,pepperoni,was so greasy such a rip off,no one was full and half the piece was a bubbled up crust. Find a new place to take hungry people its all greasy read more

shelly pie the best im tired of reading some reviews on here complaining about their food you people can do any better i think not ill always patronize them food is good keep up the good job haters will always be haters love some comments on here i can get cheaper then go there this business isnt going to close over a customer read more

Working out of town and found this pizza place. The best pizza in town great subs and great prices, very friendly staff no alcohol but it is byob read more

So good I am from Florida and I saw the great comments...and I was not disappointed great food I will definitely be back

Awesome pizza! Exceptionally friendly staff and great atmosphere. One of the top 3 pizzas in Pittsburgh. Well worth the drive to Turtle Creek. read more

We tried Shelly Pie tonight via Door Dash. Both the BBQ Chicken Pizza and the Traditional Tomato Sauce with Pepperoni & Mushrooms were delicious . . . great crust and quality toppings! My only complaint is that the slices were almost all "enormous." We had to slice the largest pieces in half so folks could manage holding/eating them successfully. Some tried a technique in which you fold a slice in half . . . point of the triangular slice back to the outer edge of the crust . . . thinking it would make the size more manageable for consumption. But, then the toppings spilled out. I suppose one could resort to eating it with a fork, but we're just NOT that kind of a family. We like to eat our pizza with our hands, as nature intended. Planning to try Shelly Pie again soon. read more

Very good food here. I love the pizza because it has the little pepperoni that I love and it's comfort food. Their stuffed banana peppers are great and their fish sandwiches are outta sight. The staff is very friendly and I have always enjoyed my visits here. I would definitely recommend. read more

I love this place. Ive been a fan of Vincents Pizza for 40+ years however their quality has gone down lately and Shelly Pie has become my new favorite Pizza place. read more

Corkage was $4 on the website, but upped to $10 when we arrived. We had water instead of the rot gut wine and cheap beer they had. And then there's the pizza. Huge but lousy. Greasy, wet, and overloaded with toppings. We could not even taste the sauce. The crust was thick even though we ordered the thin traditional crust, and it was uncooked in the center. If you like pizza, don't go here. read more

Great pizza! Thicker outer crust, thinner under crust. Delicious, well seasoned sauce. Plenty of cheese, wouldn't recommend extra! Steak is delicious, and the meatballs are as well (hoagies and toppings). The salads are large and they even offer family sized salads for the table! Very clean place. Looked like a municipal building on the outside, but the inside is well maintained and comfortable! Only downfall was finding it, and passing it twice before realizing where the parking was (to the right in a side lot, turn at the light after the pizza place). Handicap accessible ramp in the front, tables are a good wheelchair height. Bathrooms are handicap accessible with locking door and bars, so it's very wheelchair friendly. Would definitely recommend trying this place out! read more

Went a distance to get here as its been compared to Vincents vinnie pie and had to see how it shapes up. Well first crust very much the same. Cheese same great taste, pepporni was plenty of it and also great. Saugage there was not as much but actually tasted better! Not near the grease level. Excellent and while a shade under vinnies they have the advantage of being open week day afternoons and they take credit cards... So new favorite Pizza. An added plus a big menu too and there garlic knots are super. read more