It is true the food is amazing. Beware, do not go during a Packers game or you will wait an hour for a seat. This place can get really loud at times. We go during the week so we can converse and get served! Trivia night is a blast. The food and portions do not disappoint. Staff are friendly and owner is usually out and around. read more

Seiberts Pub has a very nice small Chicago style pub appeal. One of the previous tenants; who was a designer, actually designed the place. I'm being completely honest here, if you ever get disappointing food, the chef's in the back either were on strike or sick, lol. The food is outstanding and nicely sized in portion. They do take pride in what's being served. The wait staff are outstanding and attentive. They have trivia during the beginning weekdays and have video poker, but other than that, their's no other entertainment nights. I wish they did though. The bartenders are extremely friendly and may converse with you if the night is slow. Try the Reuben, wings, fish on Friday's (first come first served as it gets crowded fast), Monkeyfries, burgers, and Rueben rolls. Enjoy! read more

Yummy pork wings! Kellie is an amazing bartender and really take care of you! Love this place!

Wow - FINALLY a place that checks all the boxes: great food (that didn't come from a Sysco truck), awesome atmosphere, super friendly crowd and the cherry on top; appropriate prices!! We drive the various routes between southeastern Wisconsin and the Rockford Illinois area and we have tried every single restaurant, large or small, out of the way or on the main drag and this is the only place I dream about going back too. read more

This place is so good and always has a great atmosphere with friendly servers. Only wish it was bigger.

Excellent food. I was very impressed for "pub food". The English Chips with truffle oil and Parmesan cheese was great. The Hog Wings were tender and flavorful. The food wasn't over seasoned and everything was cooked to perfection. I will definitely come here again for a great meal and Guinness on tap! read more

Stopped for lunch with friends. First time here for both of us. Ordered the BLT ranch wrap with chips. Very good. Friends ordered chicken sandwiches and they all enjoyed it. Will definitely come back again. read more

Sieberts Pub - Chicken BLT ranch wrap was awesome. - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

Went here with a group of friends, and enjoyed myself. The corned beef was good, but not over the top. I still enjoyed it. The restaurant reminds me of an older style Victorian house. Cool concept. read more

Great food, but even better service. The ladies at Siebert are the best. Always have a smile on the face and you are always greeted warmly. Food arrives fast and always perfect! Can't say enough about the service, and a special shout out to Tia! Without exception, the best bar/restaurant operator we've ever had the pleasure of dealing with! read more

Love this place for reliably great food, chill, fun atmosphere, and occasional trivia nights. We are and will be regulars. Try their Italian beef, meatloaf, corned beef, and French onion soup. Yummmm. read more

The worst experience I have ever had a restaurant. Kim was rude, mean, and disrespectful to her customers by calling them names and telling them everyone hates them because of a complaint that the order was wrong. It was the worst thing I have ever witnessed from an owner of a restaurant. If you eat there, don't expect your order to be right or expect to be yelled at from the owner. read more

Excellent service The food was awesome. Had a great burger and the nachos were outstanding. We will definitely be back read more

Great food, great atmosphere. We are local and visit Sieberts very often. Fish fry is one of my favorites in the area and their wraps are absolutely delicious. Highly recommend checking this place out. read more

I went with a friend for a Friday fish fry. Had a great perch dinner and was also impressed with their wine selection. Will definitely go back. read more

Seiberts and the staff are absolutely great. I cannot recommend the monkey fries and the Reubens enough, they are the best ever!!

I love their food. We go often. But last Friday all the staff had no masks. Patrons were close and massless. I won't be going again for a while. read more

Food was delicious. A must stop if you are driving thru and looking for a place to eat. Staff was friendly and did a great job.

Dave! Meatloaf sucks. who puts meatloaf on the char broiler? Other than that I love this place

My favorite is their hamburgers and french fries! Old bar that has a wonderful atmosphere and friendly service. Highly recommend!

This is one of our favorite places to eat. I hightly recommend the sweet potato fries, with their aioli.

Had the cheese curds, french onion soup and Reuben w/sweet potato fries. Everything was delicious. Small place with great food and service. The only thing that would make it better would be to add fried pickles to the menu ;-) Definitely recommend if in the area. We will return again next time we make a run over the border for some cows read more

Thumbs up quaint charming place. Good burgers too! Fun trivia bar pursuit small enough to want to join in Good service friendly help

This is my favorite local place, with everything that I'm looking for in a restaurant. The place is adorable, with the look and feel of an old tavern, and the food and service are wonderful. We particularly enjoy the monkey fries and the Cobb Salad with Steak is perfect and burgers are perfect. We recently attended "Trivia" night on Tuesday, and had a blast. read more

My wife and I enjoy coming here for the Friday Fish Fry. The perch is outstanding and something you can rarely find at fish frys around where I live in Illinois. The fish fry is also very popular and Fridays are really busy. We've also tried and liked the salmon, burgers, and beef brisket sandwich. The beer selection is decent but tends to be more mainstream domestic. I have also tried the clam chowder but it is more of a corn chowder with bacon; still tastes good and I get it every Friday but it is hard to taste clam. read more

The service and food here are fantastic. You must order the Monkey Fries - A pull apart delight made from fries mixed with a fantastic Cheddar cheese sauce, formed into a log, topped in more Cheddar cheese sauce and apple wood smoked bacon. My wife and son ordered the angus burger with grilled onions and an egg served on a cabata bun which they thought was delicious. I tried a bite of my wife's and I must agree. The fries are fresh cut. read more

I was looking for a solid dinner spot within easy distance of both Twin Lakes and Lake Geneva, and yelp pointed us here!! The fish fry is what we came for and it did not disappoint. The boy prefers perch to cod, and both were outstanding in my opinion! We did have to wait for an open table, but it was not tediously long, and there was cold beer to be had in the meantime. read more

This was my first time visiting Sieberts for food with a friend. We were able to sit outside on the small patio, and it was perfect outside. Our waitress was very attentive, and checked on us the perfect amount of times. I had the fried green beans as an app, and they were delicious, especially the sauces they give you on the side. For the main course my friend had the fish tacos, which she said were awesome. I had the reuben and it was so good and HUGE I had to take half of it home, and couldn't finish all of the french fries. I'd definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for something to eat in the area. The inside of the bar is a bit small, but in perfect weather, take some time and enjoy the deck! read more

Solid burger and the Rueben was very good. Monkey Fries are a great version of bacon cheese fries plus the sauce for them is awesome. All in all portions were large and this sort of pub food is great for the area. Friendly service and great comfortable atmosphere makes this place a winner. read more

Reuben was awesome, shepherds pie, and....monkey fries. But forget the rest. Bring 12 of your hungriest friends and try to finish the monkey fries. Mmmmmm....... read more

Loved, loved, loved the Reuben! The corned beef was shredded rather than poor quality slices that you get everywhere else. Our server was fantastic! I will drive out of my way to come here again! read more

A great neighborhood tavern in Salem, with excellent bar fodder and friendly, attentive staff. Has a gravitational pull extending up to Paddock Lake and down to the Illinois state line--even to Antioch and over to Bristol. read more

Absolutely delicious Reuben, and the tuna steak sandwich was quite tasty too, although the wasabi sauce it's served with is a bit overpowering for my taste - I'd prefer a wasabi mayo so the flavor of the tuna steak has a chance to shine. The bartender who greeted and waited on us was SUPER friendly - loved the vibe she gave the place. We look forward to our next visit! read more

Great little spot in an old building in WI. Great food and service each time. Higher end bar food. Meatloaf and Reuben sandwich were both outstanding. Been back a few times, can get loud when Hawks are playing, but great service and they were pretty busy for Monday night football read more

I'm rating Sieberts 5 star because it's best in town for a groovy place to grab lunch, a drink or two, and the best fish fry in the area! Keep it up Sieberts! Plus they try as hard as they can, given their "miller lite" clientel to stock some good micro brews, or as close as they can get to craft brews! read more

Truley amazing food. They take the traditional 'Bar Food' scheme and add a delicious twist. 3 things that you should order while here, the ruben, hog wings, and the monkey fries! My only complaint is that the bar area tends to be a bit cramped at times. Other then that, if you havent made your way out here, certainly give it a try! read more

Best Lake Perch that I've had! Had to wait a lil bit at the bar but that was to be expected on a Friday night during Lent. DEFINITELY WORTH THE WAIT! Crab cakes were outstanding and recommended. We will be returning for the food and awesome staff!! read more

Sieberts Pub - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

See all

Great food!! The Reuben is amazing. Absolutely delicious. I also really liked the mushroom bruscetta appetizer. There's a drink, I think it's called purple haze, that tastes like a grown up version of Purplesaurus Rex kool-aid. Also went for music trivia there on a Thursday night. Super fun crowd, the guy that runs the trivia is great. I honestly couldn't believe that this place is in my back yard. Seriously a hidden gem. read more

No room when you enter the place. You basically are in the room with the wrap around bar. Very little seating for dinner and the food was nothing special. read more

First trip tonight. We will be back. Classic local pub feel. Great service. Amazing food. Small and the bar is on the louder side. I had the french onion soup and the reuben sandwich. Oh my goodness. The soup was wonderful; flavorful and not too salty. The reuben was as good as I have had anywhere - including delis in NYC. Fresh, great balance... read more

Great local spot. The jalapeño grilled cheese is amazing. Service can be slow when they are busy, especially Friday and Saturday dinner hours. My go to lunch order is the chicken salad wrap with sweet potato fries. I highly recommend this place. read more