Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Simply Vainilla

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 2:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Simply Vainilla Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Simply Vainilla

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 months ago

    Best pastries ever, this lady is a genius when it comes to taste and presentation, the quality is unmatched!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Yami P.
    0
    20
    42

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Simply Vainilla

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon

    4.1(26 reviews)
    3.0 mi

    Stopped here for breakfast before the beach and had a salami and cheese sandwich on pan de agua. It…read morewas so good, definitely one of the best sandwiches I've had. Pair it with a jugo de parcha My boyfriend is from Puerto Rico, and this place brought back so many memories for him. The staff was incredibly friendly and made us feel right at home. They even had their son training, and he was doing a great job! You can tell a lot of the customers are regulars, which made the atmosphere feel warm and welcoming. Can't wait to come back next time I'm in the area! Paramos aquí a desayunar antes de ir a la playa y pedimos un sándwich de salami y queso en pan de agua. Estaba demasiado rico, definitivamente uno de los mejores sándwiches que he probado. Acompáñenlo con un jugo de parcha Mi novio es de Puerto Rico y este lugar le trajo muchísimos recuerdos. El personal fue súper amable y nos hizo sentir como en casa. Incluso tenían a su hijo entrenando y lo estaba haciendo excelente. Se nota que muchos de los clientes son habituales, y eso hizo que el ambiente se sintiera aún más cálido y acogedor. Definitivamente no veo la hora de volver cuando esté por el área.

    Another day, another bakery! This Puerto Rican bakery serves authentic Puerto Rican sweets and…read moresandwiches, and they also have another location in Tampa. The space is spacious with plenty of indoor seating, and the service was quick and efficient. I tried the media noche sandwich made with their sweet pan sobao bread, along with their coffee and a cheese pastry. The pastry was huge and tasted really good, but the texture was a bit off for me. It was overly flaky, which made it messier than usual to eat. Don't get me wrong--it was still delicious, just a little harder to manage! As for the sandwich, it didn't quite hit the mark. It wasn't bad, but it felt like it was missing something--maybe just a better balance overall of the ingredients. That said, I think the prices here are great, especially considering the portion sizes. I'd definitely come back to try other sandwiches and explore more of their sweet treats. There's a lot on the menu that looks promising!

    Photos
    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon - Las de Cayey mallorca sandwich with ham and swiss - A new favorite from La Creación Bakery.

    Las de Cayey mallorca sandwich with ham and swiss - A new favorite from La Creación Bakery.

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon - Pastelillo de guayaba y queso

    Pastelillo de guayaba y queso

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon

    See all

    Selina's - Selinas Red Velvet

    Selina's

    3.7(3 reviews)
    3.0 mi

    Horrible experience. I ordered cupcakes for my office and everyone got sick. There was literally a…read moreline of people to vomit in the bathrooms. And the actual cupcakes tasted like they were baked in a Honda. I don't think cupcakes should smell like diesel. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!

    I heard about Selina's red velvet cupcake delivery when I was watching Bay News 9 in my dentists…read morewaiting room! Imagine being in such bad pain and needing a root canal but your brain drifts off to cupcake land! I was intrigued by Anthony's story. He started baking and perfecting his mom, Selina's, red velvet cupcake recipe. Once they were as good as Moms, he began selling them on FB to help raise money for his mom's breast cancer treatment! How could any human not be moved by that business model!?! I went home and looked them up on FB and "Liked" their page. I carefully read the order details and didn't hesitate to order my first dozen red velvet cupcakes! Please keep in mind, Selina's only sells red velvet with cream cheese cupcakes or a full cake. I messaged Anthony with my first order to be delivered a few days later, on a Saturday afternoon. The cost was $15 (plus tax) for the 12 cupcakes and $3 delivery fee. Saturday came and knock knock on my door.... there's a sweet young man smiling at me and handing me the MOST DELICIOUS red velvet cupcakes I have ever eaten! The cream cheese frosting was so creamy and smooth. Definitely not grainy like most! I know he makes his mama proud! My middle son is picker than picky and raved about these. He helped polish off the dozen and then asked when I was ordering again!? I have since ordered once more and it was consistently as amazing as the first time! And don't forget to tip Anthony!!!

    Photos
    Selina's
    Selina's - The best red velvet cupcakes you've ever eaten!!!

    The best red velvet cupcakes you've ever eaten!!!

    Selina's

    See all

    Puerto Rico Bakery - Cafe con leche and cakes at Puerto Rico Bakery

    Puerto Rico Bakery

    4.4(16 reviews)
    1.8 mi

    While picking up food from Martin's Indian Restaurant, I noticed Puerto Rico Bakery and was…read moreimmediately impressed by its beautiful decor. Out of curiosity, I decided to step inside and explore. The server was very friendly and guided me through the various sweet options available. I decided to try the Flan from their menu. After lunch, we enjoyed the Flan, and it was absolutely delicious. The taste was perfect, with a smooth and creamy texture that we loved. I'm looking forward to returning soon to explore more of the bakery's offerings!

    If I could, I'd give this new bakery 3.5 stars. I rounded it up for the coffee and great service…read more There's not many Puerto Rican bakeries in this area. One of them recently sold their business to Ricopan. That's very sad, because I really loved their guava & cheese quesitos and turnovers. This particular bakery is in a shopping plaza on the corner of Kingsway & Windhorst Rd. I was greeted right away by a very pleasant gentleman. He offered samples of bread pudding. It had good flavor, but the texture was different than what I'm used to. My aunt used to make the best bread pudding. I really need to stop comparing things to what I've had in the past. I decided to get the mallorca with ham & cheese, some pastries, and a café con leche. The coffee was very good. I like that he made it stronger for me. The sandwich had a nice presentation, but there wasn't much filling. They used American cheese instead of a white cheese. Let's just say that it's not my favorite mallorca sandwich in the area. As for the mallorca pastry/bread, it just didn't taste as good as what I've had on the island. I like the sweeter & softer version. However, I do like the tornillos, palmeras, and quesitos. This bakery has a lot of potential. It was somewhat busy on a weekday morning. Hopefully they do well in this area. I really need to go back to try other things like the filled donuts. I did see flan, flancocho, tembleque, and tres leches in the case. I'm just picky when it comes to anything Puerto Rican. Both sides of my family used to make some amazing comida. Please don't let my review discourage you. Try it for yourself.

    Photos
    Puerto Rico Bakery - Puerto Rico Bakery Interior - There's a lot more seating than what you see here.

    Puerto Rico Bakery Interior - There's a lot more seating than what you see here.

    Puerto Rico Bakery
    Puerto Rico Bakery

    See all

    Simply Vainilla - customcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...