Worst pizza I've ever had. Weird cheese, raw dough and way too weird ingredients. I would have…read moretaken the pizza to a homeless person but they likely wouldn't eat it either. Service was good. That's it.

We were on a vacation in Englewood and our friends recommended we try the pizza here . Very…read morethankful! Seriously top 5 pizza I have ever had! Worth a trip ...if you are a pizza snob such as we are ! We ordered the meatball pizza and the carne anbondanza ! Because we wanted high protein ! So delicious and perfectly cooked ! The pizza dough is fantastic! Made in house every day and you can tell the freshness! Ourtstanding !!!! the Sassy Tarts bakery within the same space is great for deserts, to take home ! They are delectable!!! Highly recommend!!!

One of the not so good pizzas I have ever had. It was $18 with double pep and double cheese,…read morehowever the pepperoni was not what we felt was double. It had an odd smell in the cheese and the look was of cheddar? It was very think and the taste not good. I would have just liked to return it but instead, will not go back. Sorry to post a bad review but the whole pizza needs tested better to bring your ratings and business up to par.

Not sure what happened over the past year but the food has gone downhill. Makes me very sad. The…read morepizza was so bland and soft. It wasn't crunchy and delicious like it was last year.

Well what a let down. From the 'Fresh from the cardboard box' tiramisu to the food service grade…read moresauce and toppings made in the 'ultra exclusive' blodgett oven, this pizza is on par with any random bowling alley, and that might be a stretch. Now, in fairness, considering there is literally no other good pizza for miles, I guess this gets an extra star. I guess. So disappointed. I've never had a saltier pizza in my life. Utterly inedible.

Very good local pizza. Thin crust. Very nice. We will…read moredefinitely be back next time we're in town.

The ambiance here is amazing! You can't go wrong with the old Florida style bar! Great for drinks…read moreor the bar bites menu!

Food and service were great! We'll come again for a repeat!…read more Sat by the window for a beautiful water view!

Went to south beach couple weeks ago and as always the food was very good. The service was very…read moregood but the dessert we had was the best!!!! They called it the boca banana pie!!! OMG SO GOOD!!!

This is definitely one of the most popular spots on the island!! It's a perfect lunch spot on the…read morebeach. We enjoyed lunch and drinks after getting to the area before being able to check in to the hotel. Obviously everyone was trying to get there around noon on a Saturday, but we only had a 15 min wait to sit outside. The vibe was so nice, and the food was exactly what we wanted with a great view! Totally should get there

Easy pick up, good pizza…read more We called and ordered for pickup. As crowded as it was, the food was ready - and the pizza was good.

Super fast carry out times- we ordered garlic bites, chicken bacon ranch pizza and pepperoni pizza…read more No complaints ab any of it! It has a different style crust which is chewy and not as tough.

Chicago tavern style has made its way to North Port! The cupped and charred pepperoni pizza had…read moreeverything we expected, spicy sauce, generous amounts of spicy pepperoni and a thin tavern style crust that held up and was crunchy. We also ordered a chicken sandwich that had the softest sub roll topped with a good amount of ingredients and a perfect cheese pull. The person who took my order was incredibly pleasant and just as friendly when I went for our pick up. Being from Chicago it was so great to find a pizza that lived up to its name.

First time visit to this Pizza spot. We ordered the Extra Large Deluxe thin crust square cut…read more Pizzas very good and was covered with an abundance of goodness. Thoughts a little more sauce would make it perfect. This is a pick up or Dash door delivery. We picked up. Give them a try.

Finally tried a pizza from Johnny Tomatoes in Venice, off of Tamiami near Walmart…read more(Tamiami/Jacaranda). For all the hype that this is NJ thin crust, I personally, was disappointed. The Pepperoni Pizza we had was ok, not great nor bad. I have been down here for almost 3 years and have yet to find "authentic". Jersey or NY Pizza. There are plenty of places in Venice that offer good pizza. Food is very personal and many if not most, like tastes that remind them of what they might have grown up with. This doesn't only apply to pizza. I like Asaros (takeout), and places like Naples and Made in Italy for bar size pizza (eat in). I have tried others like Angelos, Sicilia's (sic), and others. They too are ok, but not what I prefer as a go to "pie". I would say give Johnny Tomato's a try. The staff are nice and it might be good for you. I would say the crust is similar to Dominos. For those of you who might not like my judgement, just for background, I grew up in NJ, worked 4 years in a Pizzeria in Madison NJ (Romanelli's) and have been spoiled by NY pizza from John's Pizza off of Broadway (old church bldg) and in Jersey City. I love Regina Pizza in Boston (original location on Thatcher St in the Northend) and loved the Haymarket Pizza in the late 80's the first time I moved to Boston. Don Pepe's in New Haven CT is great too, though their lack of style in slicing pizza ticks me off. They just hap hazardly cut it which ever which way! I also love Detroit and Chicago deep dish ... different styles but nonetheless delicious. Don't take my word for it, but try Johnny Tomatoes for yourself. I love people whom are trying to bring a slice of their home to Florida! Support these entrepreneurs!

Sorry, attempt #2 was a huge fail. Asked for extra sauce, extra cheese, well done and not cut…read more Extra sauce, if there was any, was dropped on over the cheese in 4 spots. There was hardly any cheese on the pizza (had to add more at home), it was NOT well done as I had to put it in the oven to crisp it up, and it was cut. So that's basically 4 strikes. Won't be back!!!