Came back in mid October for lunch. An influencer on instagram posted here and said it was recently renovated with cool decor and I thought she posted that they had these funky looking Indian "pizzas." I'm sure it looks better at night, for it wasn't anything special during the day. The velvet couch we sat on was nice though. Unfortunately we didn't arrive until about 15 minutes prior to lunch service being over. Hours posted for lunch were until 3:00, however upon arriving there was a sign on the door saying they stop serving lunch at either 2:30 or 2:45 (don't remember as again this was mid October). We felt bad walking in there because there was only maybe 1 or 2 other tables in there still, however they said we were welcome to sit and have lunch. We said we'd be quick.We really shouldn't have done this because it was clear they wanted us out quickly. The menu was a bit confusing. "Choose one protein, one sauce, and one bread OR vegetarian dish and a bread (Plain Naan, Garlic Naan, Tandoori roti)." Ok? We ended up splitting a Chicken Tikka masala and the cucumber appetizer (don't remember what it was called). He forgot to bring the cucumber app until we were done with the entree and we didn't realize it was a dip. We ended up taking that home. The last ten minutes of us eating our waiter was staring at us and clearly wanted us to wrap up. Again, I wouldn't come here close to 3:00 for lunch. That was a mistake. As far as the food, the Tikka masala could have used a tad more flavor (we asked for it mild but could have bumped that up a bit) and I didn't care for the cucumber appetizer. It was minty? and spicy. Overall I feel that House of Naan is better for New Haven Indian cuisine. read more

Sitar - Chicken Tikka Masala - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

I've been hearing nothing but great things about Sitar so me and my bestie went to check them out since she also loves Indian food. You walk in and you're immediately met with the smell of delicious cooking that will instantly get you excited for the meal that's about to come. I decided to have a strawberry lassi because I've never had one before, I normally always get a mango one, and I'm glad I did because it was delish! We kicked off with the lamb samosas and veggie platter and WOW what FLAVORS. Each bite was an experience, and so so tasty. My friend got the chicken biryani and I went with the chicken tikka masala and can I just say how impressed I was that our food stayed warm the whole entire time? Like it was still steaming as we packed it away, I was so impressed with that because there's nothing I hate more than lukewarm food being brought out to me. Regardless of that, my masala was incredible and I was sad I had to stop myself so I could save room for dessert. Because then I filled up on basically all of the cheese naan and it is some of the best I have ever had and if you're visiting New Haven and want authentic Indian food, this is the place to go. read more

See all

A New Haven classic for Indian. Just recently was in and out of there in 30 minutes for a quick lunch. I was in a hurry. Servers picked up on this and moved fast. The food was amazing--chicken vindaloo was appropriately spicy and the roti was perfect. I will return. read more

Sitar is amazing! We came here as a group of 3 for lunch. They have a great lunch deal which they say is served in "lunch portions" but I thought was still a good amount of food. For all their food, they ask for a spice level (I believe the options are mild, medium, and spicy). We started off with the Achari Gobi which we got as medium (I believe) and it was quite spicy! We all loved it. Each of us got a curry - Saag, tikka masala, and vindaloo. They were all great and the spice levels we requested (one mild and 2 spicy) were all very appropriate and delicious. Their naan was also delicious. Perfect mix of crispy edge and soft inside. I can't wait to go back again for lunch! read more

See all

We've driven past Sitar for years and finally decided it was time to check them out! I don't know what the restaurant looked like previously inside, but I know they just renovated and it's really nice! We were adventurous and tried goat for the first time, and we thought it was delicious! The malai chicken kebab was flavorful and not dry at all. Friendly and attentive staff. Would definitely come back here! read more

See all

They have a lovely restaurant right off the Farmington canal trail - I go for the lunch special of chicken tikka masala and garlic naan- excellent portion size and absolutely delicious food! The service is very friendly and accommodating. Try it out! read more

Orderd takeout for lunch, and I am obsessed with how good the food is! I ordered the lunch special Chicken Tikka Masala & garlic Naan, to drink a mango Lassi and for dessert some kheer! Let me tell you, the food was hot, so fresh and delicious! The waiter was very pleasant & friendly when I came in to pick up my order. FYI, there is some construction going on around the building, but don't be alarmed they are still open and can easily be accessed. I will be back again! read more

One of my go-to Indian restaurants in New Haven! The first thing they gave us when we sat down were a few flavorful crackers with sauces as a snack and it was already off to a great start. We got my go-to orders of Bhindi Masala (a staple Indian dish made with okra, whole and ground spices, herbs, onions & tomatoes) and Saag Paneer (a popular Indian vegetarian dish made of spinach and other leafy greens (called saag) and paneer (Indian cottage cheese)) and we were very satisfied. It all came with a large side of rice. It didn't look like a lot when the food arrived, but it turned out to be a lot more than we expected. I think both dishes could have used some more spices + flavor which is why I give this place 4/5 stars, but it was still great. The two of us shared both and we even had a decent amount of leftovers to take home and enjoy later! Because of that, I found it was reasonably priced. The interior was home-y and next door, there was a even a family party going on (looked like a birthday celebration?) Would definitely come again in the future. (This place also has a lot of allergy-free options which is perfect for my other friend who is allergic to a lot, including sesame.) read more

Sitar - Saag Paneer Bhindi Masala - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

This was our first time eating at the restaurant and got the lunch special. We got some vegetable samosas that we sweet & savory. My wife got the lamb vindaloo, basmati with garlic naan. She enjoyed. I got the chicken tiki masala, basmati rice and garlic naan. The chicken was tender and the sauce was good. read more

See all

Amazing people who work here, I really wanted butter chicken/makhni and despite it not being on the menu I ordered from they made it for me 10/10 taste and people the food was sooo good read more

Sitar - Chicken Tikka, Chicken Curry - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

This is my go to spot for Indian food in the area. Delicious food! Great service! Their flavors are a real standout.

We got the lunch special, so delicious! Also loved that they had appetizers/small plates until $10. We had a great time: very nice space as well as a friendly and charming waiter. read more

I have a friend that has an allergy to Canola oil and it led us to this gem of a place. Parking, like most places in New Haven, kinda stinks buuuuut there are several garages right near by. The food was great, best garlic naan I have had, the baingan bharta was extremely good as well. Staff was exceptionally friendly. 100% plan on going back! read more

See all

The food is fantastic. The garlic naan is yummy. And I always order the Sag Paneer and vegetable Samosas. I'm glad they can cater to different spice levels. While I like my head to explode my husband not so much. It's really a great place to get delivery from especially if you don't feel like cooking. read more

Stopped in for lunch. The chicken korma and naan bread was fantastic. The lunch portion was good and so was the price. The service was speedy too. The restaurant was clean and relaxing. I would definitely come back the next time I'm in the area. read more

Sitar - Chicken korma with naan - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

BEST Indian food in the state of CT! I recently discovered Sitar on Doordash and tried the chicken tikka masala and the naan bread. The price was a little high but then I tasted the food and realized it was worth it. You'll never be able to have sub-par Indian food after eating at Sitar. read more

I had alu gobi and tikki masala. the food was outstanding, the service too, the restaurant is beautiful with a very nice ambience and a lot of natural light. I can't wait to be back! they also have great lunch specials if you are hungry in the middle of day! Thank you to all the staff here, you are amazing! read more

4.5 stars. Came here after touring Yale with my family and it was definitely worth it. We ordered off the lunch special menu, you can pick a sauce, a protein, and a bread (Naan, Garlic Naan, Tandoori Roti). For me, I chose the saag with paneer and garlic naan. The saag paneer was super flavorful and eating it with the garlic naan was so good. The lunch special also comes with rice and the quantity of rice you get was plenty. The vegetable samosas were also really good. Perfectly crispy on the outside, and inside is nice and fluffy and very well seasoned. They also come with three sauces, and I really enjoyed the tamarind sauce. However I do feel that the samosas were a bit expensive, $6 for 2, but the lunch special was around $13 which I think was really good value for the quality and quantity of food you get. The service was also really good; the waitress consistently checked up on us and even switched out our plates after we finished the samosas. I really appreciate how attentive our server was. Overall I would highly recommend giving this place a shot if you are ever around the area. read more

See all

Good service and best Indian cuisine in downtown, New Haven, Connecticut. Delicious food read more

Good Indian buffet with ok service... We were roaming in Yale University and looking for an Indian restaurant. we saw this and had their buffet. They had a good option in appetizer and main course as well. We had salad-soup-chicken appetizers and curry. But seems staffs were not interested in the buffet. We kept asking for bread and we got it so late. Ignoring that, it was good buffet read more

See all

I have ordered delivery and went to the restaurant twice and never disappointed. The service is always good and the food is delicious. The prices are reasonable and the portions are generous, I always leave with a doggie bag and always look forward to heating them up. read more

I recently moved to Ct. and was thrilled to see Sitar on Door Dash. I don't know if it is related to the restaurant that used to be in Spfld, MA. We used to go there for lunch breaks and celebration meals. We were all very sad to see it go. I can now state that Sitar New Haven is wonderful! My chicken curry was flavorful and just the right amount of heat for "mild." This is my new Indian restaurant go-to. I didn't find their prices high giventhe quality of food. read more

Sitar is an excellent Indian restaurant in New Haven..the lamb Rogan Josh and pudeena Naan are my favorites! read more

See all

Pretty good Indian food. I feel like it's kinda expensive. The most traditional Indian food you'll find in the area.

It's been a while since I visited Sitar and this visit back was nothing short of fun!! The nostalgic feel of being back here felt so good and Sitar still reigns as one of the best Indian restaurants in New Haven, and possibly in CT. My friends and I were very well taken care of by Vasanth (spell check) and the food was amazing. I got the paneer masala and garlic naan. They have plenty of options for vegetarians which is one of the main reasons I love them. I'm so eager to go back again this summer. read more

I ordered the chicken curry and finally was able to receive the spice level I have been desiring for a while ( Spicy). The food was very tasty. read more

I've only ordered delivery and takeout from them. They were my go to place throughout the pandemic. Everythimg was always delicious and on time, with generous portion sizes. Their lamb is the most tender I've had at any Indian restaurant. It melts in your mouth every time, which is hard to do, since lamb can overcook quickly in curries. My favorite dishes are any of the lamb dishes and the dal. Thanks for making my pandemic a little brighter! read more

I got one of their lunch deals delivered on a winter weekend. It was very quick. The lunch menu is short, but the prices are those good ol' lunch deal prices. I got the chicken tikka masala, and Tim M got the lamb saag. Both dishes were just ok. I know lunch sizes are meant to be smaller, but the lamb saag only had three pieces of lamb in it. Flavors were good, but I was a little irked that the dish wasn't more green. The chicken masala was also ok, though I found the chicken a bit chewy, as if it was over cooked and/or once frozen. Garlic naan is a recommended addition - always! read more

Excellent food and service!! Prompt, considerate, and cheerful servers. Conveniently located and glad the road construction around is mostly done! read more

This place is a solid traditional American style Indian sit-down restaurant in New Haven. It has everything you would expect from one of these places with above average service and food quality. The menu doesn't have anything too special, but has all of the classic dishes you would be looking for. All of the food I had seemed fresh and well-seasoned. The samosas and onion bhaji were hot and crispy. The chana masala I had was delicious and very spicy as requested. The poori bread is also hot and fresh. The waiters were attentive and nice. They can accommodate vegan customers on many dishes by leaving out the ghee on things like chana masala, bindhi masala, beigan bartha, aloo gobi, etc. Sitar is a good option for a reasonably priced Indian comfort food meal. It's good for sit-down or delivery and provides some reliably good standard Indian fare. read more

I haven't eaten here since before Covid, and I was really disappointed. The service was great, and the ambiance is nice. The Chinese restaurant-style menu (pick a protein, pick a sauce) is a disaster. The protein (lamb) was over cooked, the sauce was reheated, and the dish was served slightly over room temperature. The meat was tough and the flavors didn't meld. The ma'am, however, was excellent. read more

3.5 stars to be precise, but it's officially getting 4 because of great service. I tried the garlic naan, shrimp vindaloo, and chicken vindaloo. Overall, the food here is definitely on the lighter side for Indian, which I definitely appreciate. It seems that they aren't as cream-based as many other Indian restaurants I've tried. The garlic naan was piping hot and delicious, but could have used a tad bit more salt/garlic. The shrimp was tender and juicy, but the curry it was in was a bit too tomato-y. Finally, the chicken vindaloo was savory but missing just a little bit of that signature spicy/savory taste. Overall, the portions were very generous. There weren't a lot of people in the restaurant at all, which is very spacious. This made for fast/frequent service. Location wise, it's a little past the Whitney/Grove intersection off by itself down the street on Grove, so a bit random, but definitely not far from campus. In summary, I would say the food here is solid but lacking a little special something that makes it irresistible. Good option if you're looking for Indian but don't want to fall into a gigantic food coma afterwards! read more

Sitar - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Samosa and daal were very good. Came with lots of sauces and was packaged well. Would def come here for Indian again!!! read more

Sitar - Daal - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Came to Sitar for their lunch buffet and it did not disappoint. A great selection of traditional Indian dishes and desserts. You dont find em like these in the south and they were only $10. Will be back next time I am in New Haven. read more

The restaurant is quite large with lots of tables. We ordered the lamb madras, tandoori mixed grill, and garlic naan. Everything was delicious!! The flavor was rich and the curry was the perfect amount of "medium spicy." The meat was so tender and the garlic naan was actually garlicy unlike some other places when I order garlic naan. This place will definitely become my go-to place in new haven for indian food! read more

Sitar - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

I'm love food and always try ethnic restaurants. This place is so good that every time I go there, I try something new. It's that good. Service is the way it should be. Very polite and respectful. read more

One word: perfection. I don't always eat chicken tikka masala, but when I do, I prefer Sitar. Just kidding. I always eat chicken tikka masala, but Sitar is the gold standard in New Haven. Hands down. No competition. Unequivocal champ in the arena. The end. Edited to add: the buffet is not nearly as good and is kind of bland. I suspect not as much of the spice mixture is used for the buffet. Don't do it. Order off the menu and adjust to your own spice level. read more

Sitar - The goldilocks experience for chicken tikka masala (mild, spicy, death) - Indian Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

We've walked past it so many times and finally stopped in. Great food and wonderful staff! Definitely recommend.

I think Sitar is really slept on! I immediately noticed how polite and attentive our waiter was. They insisted on changing out our plates and made me feel like we were at a super fancy restaurant. The lamb in the chicken korma was tender and still tasted great the next day. The portions are very similar to the other Indian restaurants in New Haven but the dishes are on the spicier side. Overall I would love to come back and support this restaurant! read more

We had a great time celebrating our birthday there. Staff were warm and patient. We will definitely return.