Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Skytop Garden Eats

    3.5 (2 reviews)

    Skytop Garden Eats Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Skytop Garden Eats

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dee S.
    129
    246
    1597

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 30,128 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Blackfish

    Blackfish

    3.8(282 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$$

    We dined here again on Saturday, August 30, 2025. Good as it ever was! Veronica and the Blackfish…read moreteam make this restaurant consistently inviting and memorable. We started with the Blackfish classic--the hen egg wrapped in freshly smoked salmon--a must-order every time we visit. For entrées, we enjoyed the lobster agnolotti and the crispy dorade in a saffron sauce. To finish, the freshly baked beignets were light, warm, and so GOOD! Every course was outstanding. We've been coming here twice a year for over a decade, and it never disappoints. Don't forget--it's BYOB, so plan ahead. We'll definitely be back.

    More like 3.5 stars. We did the 7-course tasting menu ($115 per person), and I'm really not sure…read morehow I should feel about it. Part of me feels the tasting menu tonight is a bit of a letdown. 1) The caramelized onion with cream sauce is super salty to the extent that I couldn't eat it. My husband was hungry so he ate both without much thinking, but later he said the high sodium level became obvious towards the end. 2) One of the two main dishes: the scallops are super salty too! But I still ate them as there are only three medium-sized scallops anyway. 3) Seating is super tight, almost uncomfortable. You're literally on top of each other. So the restaurant became very loud and it's hard to hear clearly what the servers are saying. We didn't hear the "inedible sea grass" part, so I was poking the sea grass after I finished my single oyster. The lead female server almost "yelled"'at me. We also witnessed her harshly tell the male server to move faster to clear one table, which we find unnecessary as he was already moving as fast as the tight space allowed him to. But our tall young female server is very friendly--her warm mannerism makes us feel better during the long wait between courses. My favorite out of the seven-course tasting menu is: the smoked salmon with poached egg. It has a very balanced flavor and the texture combination makes the dish interesting. Maybe it's better not to do the tasting menu especially if it's your first visit, as it doesn't allow you to make any choice.

    Photos
    Blackfish - Veal Chop

    Veal Chop

    Blackfish - Foie Gras

    Foie Gras

    Blackfish - 1975 Haut Brion

    See all

    1975 Haut Brion

    Jasper's Backyard - Taco Thursday

    Jasper's Backyard

    3.7(432 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$

    Overall a very enjoyable lunch for 7 of us ladies. First time here. But such a bad start and I was…read morea bit skeptical at first. Our table was pre-set with silverware wrapped in cloth napkins, water glasses filled and appetizer plates. My appetizer plate looked like it went through the dishwasher but had lots of crusty food stuck on it. It was gross. I cannot believe that plate made it to the table for a patron to see. The person setting the table had to be blind. Also, my water had a partical or small bug. I was concerned about the cleanliness of the place. I didn't want to ruin it for the others so I let it go. And that was it for the bad stuff. All 7 of us enjoyed our lunch. My shrimp BLT wrap was delicious. Fries were good and plentiful. Cob salad was huge and the other sandwiches were fresh and good as well. Service was timly and efficent. The place is huge with a few different rooms for dining. I would come back if in the area again.

    Had an incredibly unsatisfactory meal here today. We got 2 sandwiches that could not be held in…read moreyour hand! Nothing on the menu said you would have to eat them with a knife and fork. A big $90 disappointment!! The pork sandwich looked like a can of wet dog food put on top of a hoagie roll! In Philadelphia, when you order a pork sandwich with provolone, broccoli rabe, and long hots you do not expect to get what you see in this photo! It was so wet that bun was soggy all the way through. Worse than cafeteria food. The tomato/burrata sandwich was about 5-inches tall and there was no way to get it in your mouth. The cucumber was sliced too thick and the mound of arugula centered on top of the tomato like a dome pushed everything up and over the sides. It might have been a great sandwich if it had been one thin layer of tomato, one thin layer of burrata, one thin layer of pickled onion, one thin layer of arugula, and one thin layer of cucumber, with pesto on a delicious ciabatta roll but it wasn't. What is it with restaurants who think things have to be supersized and over-stuffed?! In this case, everything slid off the sandwich and it could not be put back together. They should have called it a Humpty-Dumpty. Just trying to eat it was embarrassing and super messy. Didn't care for the mac & cheese at all. It was too runny and I did not care for the flavor. The menu was not specific enough to know what they put in it to make it taste the way it did. I have made mac & cheese with all types of cheese and love them all but you can never go wrong with good old plain mac & cheese with no fancy flavorings. They served it with a spoon for a reason - you couldn't eat it with a fork! The cheese sauce fell right between the tines when I tried. Great ambiance and the service is always adequate. I have had better food here so I hope they improve these 3 dishes before I return. I don't fancy spending $90 for lunch that I can't eat.

    Photos
    Jasper's Backyard - Great event space

    Great event space

    Jasper's Backyard - Salmon

    Salmon

    Jasper's Backyard - This is where we were sitting in February

    See all

    This is where we were sitting in February

    Hook & Ladder Sky Bar

    Hook & Ladder Sky Bar

    3.5(76 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    Beautiful location, spacious seating (even in the little private area we were in), and a great…read moremenu/bar selection. Was there earlier this month for a retirement party of 50+ people with lots of different tastes and dietary restrictions, but Hook & Ladder had us all covered. My table and I tried the generously sized charcuterie board, Brussels sprouts, mushroom soup (soooo good!!), and for my entree, I ordered the braised beef rib (also excellent). We had a lot of salmon orders at the table, too, and every plate was empty before the dessert menus came around -- I didn't try the crème brûlée or bread pudding, but they both looked like a nice end to a great meal. The staff had a bit of a hard time keeping up with drink orders and refills, but we're a pretty heavy drinking crowd with a lot of different tastes, so that's no surprise. They were friendly and timely in clearing plates and silverware though, and the bartenders were friendly and swift. It's not easy accommodating such a large group, so I can see us coming back here for future big events. I can also see how it would be a good place to celebrate any kind of special occasion with a smaller crowd, too.

    Love this sky bar. It's chic, nice ambience located on the 2nd floor of a hotel. The food selection…read moreis fantastic and everything we ordered were delicious. Forgot to take some pictures but I did for my Chilean sea bass. It was melt in your mouth and love the ginger scallion infused flavor in it. One of the best sea bass I've had! Would definitely come back here again!!

    Photos
    Hook & Ladder Sky Bar
    Hook & Ladder Sky Bar
    Hook & Ladder Sky Bar

    See all

    The Great American Pub

    The Great American Pub

    3.0(322 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$

    Stopped in for lunch with a few friends, and it was a really nice time. I'd been there a handful…read moreof times with Green Conshy Collaborative, and those were fun, but on those evenings, they just ordered a bunch of appetizers to share. Always enjoyed those, but this time, I went to eat an actual meal with friends. Our server was really friendly and attentive, kept an eye on us as she passed by, and gave some good recommendations from the menu. I ordered a Cubano sandwich that came with their homemade chips. The sandwich was really good, and I thought the chips were pretty good too. I get what other reviews say mentioning that they're a bit floppy, but I thought they were fine. I'd be down to go again sometime, though I would like to check out Flanigan's Boathouse sometime too!

    Always on the lookout to try new places and the photos of The Great American Pub looked enticing…read moreenough so off we went. This place is huge with plenty of outdoor seating (with gliders) multiple dining rooms each with their own bar and a rooftop deck. Starting off strong. The brisket fries were tasty, cheesy and kept their shape even under the brisket. Things went downhill from tThe roast beef has good flavor but was not served as hot as we would have liked. Our waitress did not come back around until after we had eaten so the opportunity to try and get it remedied did not present itself. My burger was good enough but not juicy or flavorful. Just a basic bar burger. Sandwiches come with house made chips which usually are my favorite, sadly these chips were rubbery, stale, and dull. If you're not going to include fries with your sandwiches make sure your chips are edible. The rooftop offers a different limited menu that offers a few of the same items the dining rooms have with some different "lighter" additions. We will try and come back when it's cooler to check it out. Three stars for this trip with room for improvement: Food = just okay Atmosphere = comfy and relaxed Service = definitely could have been better

    Photos
    The Great American Pub
    The Great American Pub - Fish n chips, steak frites

    Fish n chips, steak frites

    The Great American Pub

    See all

    Skytop Garden Eats - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...