The service was really nice, the environment was great. 100% recommended and I'll comeback definitely

Nothing beats the original but this spit does come close! A drive to SF is not always possible but this place is! If you're craving award winning pizza this is it! The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is casual, making it an easy spot for a quick meal or a laid-back hangout. While the original Slice House will always have a special place in my heart, this location definitely holds its own and is a fantastic alternative when you're in the area. read more

Where to begin. I genuinely would come to slice house once a week when frequenting the Castro Valley marketplace. The pizza options in terms of slices and pies were great. Ive noticed a shift where dam near every single slice option has bacon/ ham/ pork options. I do not eat any type of pork and its disappointing that it's become the case. Ive also noticed this at other slice house locations. I used to really enjoy the Big Papa that they took off the menu and replaced with a similar option that includes pork. Every week I check the slice house line up options and maybe 1 (basic cheese) are non-ham eating friendly. The Bay Area is a diverse place. Would recommend some market research on the diverse groups and eating habits of those that live in and frequent the locations. Authentic pizza can be made that doesnt require every option to include pork. I know they have other menu options but sometimes you dont want to buy a whole pie. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Medium 12" Big Papa - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

I visited this Slice House once several months back when I was in the area. I remembered that it's much smaller than the one I usually go to in Mountain View. This particular Slice House is located inside the market store. There were some seating there. They had some similiar items as the one in MV. I got a slice of Detroit style of Something, but I do remember it being tasty. Service was pretty friendly. I had to wait a few minutes until someone stepped out of the kitchen when I first got there. I found parking on the street pretty close to the place. Not too bad. 3.5 stars read more

Amazing pizza as usual High quality ingredients, great for a quick eat, and consistently good. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Amazing pizza as usual High quality ingredients, great for a quick eat, and consistently good. - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

I feel like from the times I've had Slice House, you can never go wrong for a quick slice on the go. They have a variety of pizzas you can choose from. They have vegan and gluten free pizzas but sadly those don't come in slices. Hoping and crossing fingers they're able to provide that option in the near future! They're located in the Castro Valley Marketplace that has so many things you can do while you wait for your pizza to be prepared. They sale drinks like fountain sodas and also alcoholic drinks like beer and wine. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Regular pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

We love this place! And always go to the one in San Leandro. We go here when we are in the area This place never disappoints So excited to have another one in the east bay. Its our favorite!! We love all the options! Cant go wrong I promise read more

My pizza slices of choice were the Wiseguy and the BBQ Chicken (Friday Pizza of the Day, NY style). Both slices were delicious and HUGE! I believe each slice was only $6.50. Service was friendly and fast. In addition, I ordered a cannoli, but the cream was just ok. Here's What I Think ... This is a good spot to go if you want something a little different than your local pizza shop. The prices are reasonable and the slices are huge. I'll be back. If you're in the neighborhood and in the mood for pizza, give Slice House a try. read more

See all

We recently tried Slice House in Castro Valley and were really impressed. We ordered a Sicilian-size pepperoni and sausage pizza along with a large Hawaiian pizza, and both were solid choices. The pizza itself is really good, especially the crust--perfect texture and flavor. One thing I loved about the Hawaiian pizza is that the pineapple is thinly sliced, not those chunky tidbits that keep falling off. It makes a huge difference and keeps every bite balanced. Portions are generous, and the serving size is definitely great value for the money. We also ordered the cannoli, and it was pretty good--nice way to end the meal. The shop is located inside the Castro Valley Marketplace, which makes it a convenient stop. On top of the food, the service was awesome. Shoutout to Collin--he was friendly, helpful, and made the experience even better. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

I order frequently from slice house using DoorDash. Yesterday was a first that the pizza GMA Sweet Gino was unlike any pizza I have gotten in the past. It was more than disappointing , it was like a bad joke . It was very thin, flat, with very little sauce and cheese and tasted like a stale cracker. It was completely cold and had obviously sat around for a very long time . Not cool! read more

Slice House delivers on their pizzas everytime and it's an affordable way to feed a large group of people ~ The cheese, pepperoni and combo are great ~ read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

Great place with yummy pizza. I waited a little bit to give a review because I wanted them to sort out their workflows and I can say the improvement is great. Early on I would show up and my pizza would be ready but I was not told nor was it out for me to find. I can say they now consistently call names, ask me what my name is when I walk in, and I have a great take out, delivery, or dine in meal. I really love the creativity of the pizza options and the option to have multiple types of crust size. My favorite is the Cal Italia! The saltiness of the prosciutto and the sweetness of the drizzle make it the best! They have some good happy hour rotations daily and the hot oil is delish. One day I wanna try some pasta but for now, I'm sticking to the za :) They have rotational slices daily so you can try something new each time. I'm excited to pick out my free birthday slice this week! read more

See all

Cute little spot a ha red indoors with a plethora of other food businesses and an organic grocery store. The staff were kind and seemed to be having fun although they were incredibly busy! read more

See all

Semi ordered online and by the time I got to cashew valley from FREMONT it only took five minutes for it to be ready It's inside a market but at 7 o'clock at night almost everyone was there for pizza. Fast friendly service all the tables are kept clean The pizza is consistently good as always. Ordered the grandma's sweet Gino's and Detroit motorhead. Two entirely different pizzas, but both delicious. read more

See all

Pizzas taste good but the dough is way too hard and chewy. Tried sweet gino grandma style and loved the sweet sauce but did not like that the sauce was only on half of the pizza (grandma style). Wise guy, didn't enjoy the ricotta and sausage part but the pepperoni and green onions were good. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - wiseguy - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all

I've been a fan since Tony had Pyzannps in Castro valley. Slice house never, ever disappoints The sweet Gino is my fav. The CV location is inside the public market so pretty cool to go and look around and shop there as well. The pizza is always delicious, I've never had a bad experience and service is always fast and good. read more

See all

Slice House by Tony Gemignani? Here in CV!?! We've been waiting forever for their Milpitas location to open up. Thankfully, we had a opportunity to try this location which is located in the Castro Valley Marketplace and takes over the space where The Cannery Kitchen & Tap used to be. Small seating area, though the marketplace added additional seating around the area. One unisex restroom at Slice House. They were crowded for a Sunday night. Download their app and sign-up an account to receive an instant $5 off your first order. Order with the cashier, pay, and provided your name which they will call when your order is ready. We ordered a couple of slices to share. *Detroit Style - Rosa: Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Thick & Thin Cut Pepperoni, Basil (4.5/5). I enjoy the bready thickness of this crust and the toppings on this. *New York Style - Webbs Double Sausage: Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Sliced Link Sausage, Cup n Char Thin Pepperoni, Red Onions, Romano, Oregano, Garlic Oil (4/5). Flavorful and what you would expect in a NY style slice with a nice crisp thin crust. It hit the spot. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Great pizza by the slice and friendly staff. Lots of options and toppings available all inside a convenient marketplace location. I love this pizza from the city in Little Italy - they have a by the slice next to the more fancy sit down restaurant - here it is a stand alone Slice House. Endless variety here. Also specials of the day for those that want more excitement. I tend to like the pineapple pizza in SF as its real pineapple - but didn't see it here. They serve wine and beer and I had a fountain drink. Very family friendly location with both indoor and outdoor seating. read more

See all

Great New York style slice, which, as all of us know, is very lacking in the Bay Area. Definitely get a slice of both Sicilian style and the classic thin crust. Love the ready-made slice options (and they reheat great at home)! read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Slices split and reheated at home - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

First time trying this spot, it's was recommended by a friend, and ai much say the pizza slices hit the spot "very satisfying " Veggie, Spicy Honey , and sausage . The slices are well/nice/big and filling. The staff was also helpful, I will definitely be back. Based on my personal experience, I highly recommend this establishment read more

I can't say enough good things about the pizza here! I'm originally from NEPA (old forge, so called pizza capital) and it's been a challenge finding decent pizza in California. Slice house is amazing! I've never had a bad slice from here and I crave it often. You cannottttt go wrong! Give it a shot. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all

I LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE. Fire pizza with so many options. Each pizza is unique with great flavors and a perfect crust. The outstanding component imo is the hot oil and ranch combo with the pizza that really makes it stand out. The service is pretty fast if it's just a slice, but if you're getting a whole pizza don't forget to order ahead bc it does take a minute for them to chef it up as expected. The ambience is really calm. It's inside the marketplace, which has a lot of other shops as well. It's usually not too crowded and you can find a table to eat at. It's pretty quiet and clean. read more

See all

This was my first time trying Slice House and I loved it! We tried the Detroit Motörhead pizza. The pizza was cooked well and the bread wasn't too chewy. The toppings to bread ratio was perfectly even! It did take awhile for our order to finish, but it was reasonable as they made the pizza fresh. You have the option of buying just a slice at whatever is at the window as well. This location is located in a supermarket square like building. There's an entire supermarket along with other small businesses and eateries around it. You have the option of eating indoor or outdoors with plenty of seating! Can't wait to come back and try the other pizzas! read more

See all

I've been here multiple times and everytime the food is excellent! Anytime I pass by the market place I have to get a pizza! I've even ordered for a very large party! The kids Loved the pizzas. Salads were excellent! Will order from here again for the party. #dublingreengators read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - All the pizzas. They even carried them out for us. - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all

We LOVED our Detroit deep dish style pizza. I can't speak to anything other than our order as it's our first visit to Slice house. The baked cheese edges, drool! The fact that the sauce sits on top allowed us to each choose how much or how little sauce we preferred. It was perfect! Ngl, it was a bit pricy. And before taking it home and eating it, I would have said I won't go back. But after tasting it, my daughter and I both felt it was worth the cost. AND, when you break it down, we got four meals out of our one pizza so we paid less than $9.00 per meal. Thats a bargain nowadays. Will definitely go again. read more

You mean I finally don't have to travel to Oracle park to get some Tony's pizza?!! Say less! We decided to try get the pepperoni slice and this other slice with white sauce, bacon, and ground beef (I forgot the name). They were both amazing but we preferred the pepperoni. The quality is unmatched! Crispy thin crust and yes you can fold it like a sandwich. The size of the slice is def worth the $7-8. It's huge and one slice was enough for me. read more

See all

Oh wow! I could've swore I gave a review earlier being this was my only place to get pizza slices. Normally I would say how much I love this place. Today not so much. Why is 2oz ranch $1.25? Whatever happened $0.25 and $.50? I went right across the street to Safeway and bought a bottle of ranch for 2.49 so I wouldn't have this issue again. That's insane for that little container. Also, what happened to Sweet Gino, it used to almost fill the box and it was a lot thicker. I just wanna know what happened. ‍ inquiring minds want to know. It's a slice that cost more, but it was so less. I need answers. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Little sweet Gino - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all

Been getting their pizza since the first restaurant Tony's original restaurant in Castro Valley! It was the very best ever! We have continued to get pizza forever! Besides, zero ambiance, cold place! Tonight we came to the Slice House in the Market Place! THE MOST DISAPPOINTING PIZZA we have EVER GOTTEN ANYWHERE,!!! There was barely a tint, color of tomato sauce!!!! ! Barely could see it! ! Cheese, none that we could see! It was hard and tasteless, not even warm!!! Maybe sat there way too long! Mine was Peperoni, my husband's was Peperoni and Salami I believe! You should be ashamed of yourself serving this! I also ordered a salad, the one with the walnuts! Received a very tiny container of oil, and a very tiny container of some dark vinegar, I could not make out the taste ! Gross! Large salad, Some good Italian dressing would have been great! Tony, get a grip and go back to serving great food please! Not worth our money, especially in this economy! Sorry, but had to post it! I JUST NOW POSTED THIS AWFUL REVIEW AND YOU HAVE WRITTEN BACK THANKING ME FOR MY GREAT REVIEW,!!!! WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU.?? I THINK YOU BETTER RE READ IT AGAIN BEFORE THANKING ME FOR MY GREAT REVIEW, (NOT) THE WORSE REVIEW I HAVE EVER LEFT, PAY ATTENTION AND RE READ WHAT I WROTE, I noticed you have done this before to another bad review! TONY, PLEASE CHECK THIS OUT, YOU NEED TO SEE THIS,!!! read more

Best pizza by far!! Not very much seating, but parking is good. We ordered the deep dish chicken bacon ranch; fire! Enough said!

This used to be the best pizza chain in the Bay Area, but they've really lost their touch as they've expanded. Given how expensive they are now, it's just not worth it. The employees really don't seem to like working there, the pizza is about a 7 out of 10 at most locations, and they don't allow half-and-half options anymore. They seem to be going the "charge more and provide less" route--which is typical when private equity buys you out and ruins everything. I've since found a few other places that are a much better experience, so I've stopped going entirely. I used to go twice a week. read more

This is our 2nd time coming to this pizza place they are well thin crusty dough which is my main ingredient for my pizza, quick, cleaned and service were excellent. Ambiance nothing really standout it always same as any other places. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - We ordered WISEGUY pizza.. - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

The crust is chewy and delicious Never disappoints! Even if it's a bit on the pricey side we always get our pizzas from Slice House.

This slice house is in a food hall in Castro Valley. You order at the counter and pick up. The seating is a little tight, so you might have to look around for a place to sit. We had the combo Americano and the Sicilian. Boy, these slices were huge! They were delicious, and we'd like to come back and give them another try. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Combo Americano slice - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all

It's a great slice of pizza. Quick service, friendly people, clean restaurant. Go get a slice read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Wise Guy & Americano Combo - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

I've been waiting for there to be a Slice House by Tony Gemignani in the East Bay closer to us, and love that there is a new addition to the Castro Valley Marketplace (and the slice house) is now here! I'm a big fan of Tony's pizza and also Pizza de Laura over here in Berkeley (the owner trained with Tony). I've def had my share of Tony's from the OG location in SF, inside Chase Center, and slices from locations in SF, Walnut Creek, San Leandro, and now Castro Valley. Served more so grab & go, although there is seating at the market to eat in-person, I grabbed some slices as I was on the run. Can't go wrong with their classic slice of cheese, pepperoni, and the Detroit-style Hawaiian (comes with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Honey, Smoked Ham, and pineapple rings, not chunks!). To note: they offer NY, Detroit, Grandma, and Sicilian-style pizza. I would research their menu for a few minutes before ordering because there's some decisions of flavor and style to be made! They also offer antipasti options like meatballs, specialties like the meatball sub, salads, dessert, a few pastas, and fun retail items like Tony's Hot Oil and a to-go pizza kit. FYI: 2oz. sides of ranch are $1. Other sides include house-made local hot honey, pesto, and grandma sauce :) Next time I'm in the area, I'm def coming back and hey, might even order a whole pie. It's just distinguishing the style that always gets me! Worth the trip, worth a little splurge for this novelty bite. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - The classic slice of Tony's NY-style cheese - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

I'm a huge fan of slice house, I originally would go to the one in SF & then living in Castro valley I started going to the one in San Leandro so I think adding this to the Castro Valley Market Place was a great idea & thankfully Castro Valley seems to be on the up & coming when it comes to restaurants & business which is cool to watch since I've been here for about 13 years now. The service is always fast in my opinion but I typically am a 2 slice type of person. I don't really care what anyone says but a good cheese pizza is hard to find & theirs is damn good by daughter gets a slice from here almost every Tuesday it's her favorite treat of the week I also enjoy the one with mascarpone & Italian sausage on top - it's minor when it comes to spice but I personally love spice so I always add hot honey. In my opinion the pizza is great on its own so it doesn't really require all the extra toppings. I'm also a fan of the crust it kinda taste like sourdough? As for the ambiance it's inside of the market - the seating is all over the place & this seems to be one of the busier restaurants in here. You can also get draft beers from here, desserts, salads and pasta. The customer service is friendly & fast which is also a plus. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

Best pizza! Great quality and taste, love this place!!!! Crust is also bomb if that's your thing as well ;)

Even though there was a bad review regarding the staff and service on one particular occasion the food was said to still be delicious.... Pizza is AMAZING!!!! So glad we decided to try this Gem. Location had me worried but just know it's inside of what seems to be an inside market... you go in this building and there's a meat market, other food places and a small grocery market. BUT, if you try this place you will be so happy you did. Never been to the east coast but this is what imagine the pizza is like. Such big pieces, it's like two in one and you have to fold it in half. The deep dish was amazing, omg I want some more, lol . read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Can't remember what the name was but it's delicious - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all

Lots of choices of pizza. Huge slices. Yummy! You can buy a healthier drink from the grocery in the building if you don't want soda. Friendly service. Chairs and tables are available if you want to eat in, but can be loud during business hours. read more

I had never heard of this chain before, was in town for work and we went here for lunch at the recommendation of a co worker. All our pizza was delicious! I got the Grandma and it was really really good. Service with a smile and a laugh. Wish I knew about this place before I moved out of state, because let me tell you, good pizza is hard to find where I live now. Hopefully I'll be back to try more someday. read more

Slice House by Tony Gemignani - Pizza Near Me - Castro Valley, California

See all