The best NY Style thin crust in South Hills! Gooey cheese, savory sauce, the best toppings, and ooohhhhh that crust- crisp, chewy in the middle and so flavorful! This pizza is so good that you may have to plan ahead... Delivery is great, but the wait for this precious pie can be long! Call ahead for delivery or pick up for the real deal, straight out of the oven, best pizza EVER! IT'S THAT GOOD! read more

Slice on Broadway - Supremo... O. M. G. !!!! Slice is AMAZING - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Three different pizzas and big man salad, we couldn't decide which we loved the best, every bite delicious. A grubhub fail but that won't stop us from ordering, we'll just go pick it up! read more

The food is great, always fresh and tasty. Delivery is quick and food is always still hot. Would have given 5 stars but the girl on the phone is always rude and aggressive when taking my order read more

Vegetarian / Veggie pizza awesome, and those spinach & cheese knots are yummy, good service, and always pretty fast

Not the best pizza, but it's not horrible. It's your average Pittsburgh pizza, however, their garlic knots are to die for!! Absolutely love them and I order from this place just for those. read more

Love this business -Pizza A+ But, I had to deal with Chris. He was rude on the phone while I was placing my order-and even ruder in person. I had 4 bucks that I was placing in the tip jar and as he spoke to me-just as I was about to drop it in-I quickly took it back! Hope he is not working next time I order-or I may have to go elsewhere. read more

TRASH! 1 hr 40 minutes for delivery. Pizza was cold. Cheese was congealed. Pizza was not even close to being round. Called to express my displeasure and they did not really seem to care. Really? Don't waste your money. read more

Slice on Broadway - Garbage - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Revisited this place last friday night. I used to get it all the time a few years when I lived in Greentree but since I moved there are no shops close to me. This was MORE than worth the drive. This is hands down the best traditional style pizza in Pittsburgh. The crust has so much flavor, the ratio of cheese to sauce is spot on, and their service is excellent. That is saying a lot since my pickup interaction was only a couple minutes. I will be making the trip a lot more often in the future. read more

Not usually one to complain, especially about Slicr, but this last time ordering was a real shocker! I had ordered their spicy Italian hoagie which was $9.50 expecting to receive a decently hefty sandwich. Upon arrival I took the hoagie out of the bag and there was virtually no meat on the sub. Mostly banana peppers and 3 baby slices of pepperoni. Completely unacceptable to price a hoagie at almost $10 and give the customer seasoned bread with literally no meat on it whatsoever. read more

Slice on Broadway - Worst "hoagie" I've ever had. No meat. $10. Waste of time. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Considering Friday night's weather and SLICE's proximity, we were left with no choice but to order in. SLICE has a slew of "specialty pizzas" with foreboding names such as The Slaughterhouse Five, The Supremo (images of a 50 foot tall oceanic beast wrecking Tokyo are conjured), and The Green Monster... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdGP9r1yElg We tried the Frisky Billygoat and were astounded by its successful gourmet aspirations, none of which were lost in delivery. On a rapier-thin crust, the FB is topped with the standard red sauce and mozzarella AND fragmented meatballs to bring the beef, goat cheese (!) to bring more hot , baked cream to the procession, and roasted red peppers for the char and natural sugars. Trolls beware, this billygoat will knock your petty, whiny, finicky ass (did yer ma cut the crusts off of yer pb&j's as a kid?) from the bridge but quick. Kay and I also shared one of SLICE's myriad hoagies in The Venetian. With a name that sounds like the title of an independent film, The Venetian gets those who order it a bounty of fixings and fillings that include sopressata, Genoa salami, mozzarella, provolone, artichoke hearts, fresh spinach, sliced red onions, and a singin', swingin', stingin' house balsamic vinaigrette all held together by a Breadworks baguette. While I could have used more meat in my hero, I was gastronomically impressed with its astronomically imaginative build enough to not mind. I kept thinking I had requested delivery from a cafe, not a pizza parlor. Roll the dice, and try SLICE. They put most of their competition on ice. Order twice, thrice... read more

Slice on Broadway - The Frisky Billygoat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The pizza is always a hit here, never has been a miss. Their pizza dough is thin. The red sauce is smooth (bear with me as I try to describe it), but it's like they puréed the tomatoes, allowing the sauce to stay thicker and chunkier. It is definitely homemade. The toppings are well distributed. The specialty pies are also very good. Next time I have one I will give details. The bread sticks are thin, brushed with a garlic butter, with oregano and parm. You can order the sticks with cheese for extra. However, I fancy just the regular sticks. Slice on broadway offers a big menu of specialty pies, hoagies, and salads. They also offer a "Ginormous" pie that is 20" 16 cuts. The prices are very reasonable and this place is one of my favs! Minimum free delivery of $10 orders, can pick up, or dine in. read more

See all

I purchased a pizza with extra cheese and when I call some man said because of the sauce that's the reason. That's the most stupid thing anyone has ever said to me. The workers there especially the woman who checked me out her she constantly sniffed and rubbed her nose like she snorted something,once I looked at the cooks they looked high like they smoked weed or something else. Never buy pizza from Slice on Broadway in Beechview. I do not know about the other places but this one do not go to read more

I'll start by saying I've never left a review online before pertaining to food. I'm pretty easy to please. That being said, it's pretty hard to mess up pizza. However, I want to take this time to congratulate Slice for accomplishing this daunting task. Maybe it had something to do with the fact that it took a little under an hour and a half to arrive and was cold and hard as a rock when I opened the box. Flavorless and difficult to chew. Almost inedible. I'm tempted to compare it to pizza flavored cardboard, but that would be an insult to pizza flavored cardboard. They were closed by the time I tried to call and discuss the "pizza" that they had delivered, so I can't comment on their customer service. ...but the bottom line is that I could have made myself a better pizza using the stale hamburger buns, ketchup, and near expired shredded taco cheese in my kitchen. Save yourself $20 and the 20 minutes you'll spend trying to reheat/revive the "pizza" before throwing it away and giving up. Buyer beware. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I have stopped by here twice now, once with my father for lunch and most recently a couple of Tuesdays ago with my wife for dinner. Both times we were enthusiasticly greeted by the person behind the counter immediately after walking through the door. SLICE on Broadway is actually located inside of an old house. The room that you first enter into is a smallish dining room with a window to order your food on the right and some coolers with beer, soda and water on your left. What I really like about the place though is that you can walk up the stairs (watch your head if you are over 6 foot as I have hit it on each visit while walking up) to another dining room that has seating for 22 and a TV. Both times that I have come here I have ordered the ginormous pizza (20") with a topping, sausage on the first visit and pepperoni on the most recent. The pizza is brought up the stairs by one of the workers and served to you. As with all pizzas this pizza can judged on it's three major parts: the crust, the sauce and the cheese. My favorite part of this specific pizza is the crust. It's fairly thin which means the bottom gets a bit crispy which I loved and it also has some good taste. The cheese and sauce are both harder for me to describe since I feel like the toppings covered the flavor. However they were in good proportion to each other which led to the cheese not falling off and it not being dry. The bottom line is that this is quickly becoming one of my favorite pizza spots and I will surely be back here again in the future. Not only is the pizza superb but the people that work here are friendly as well. read more

A friend and I showed up around 7 on a Thursday evening and within 10 minutes we received a piping hot pie. We sat at a table on the sidewalk in front of the shop and watched the T roll by. Occasionally the owner/pizza maker/ waiter/ cashier/ dish washer popped out from behind the counter to chat and see if we needed anything. The crust is what makes this pizza fantastic. It's super thin, crispy and coated in a light dusting of cornmeal. For how thin the crust is it is surprisingly sturdy which in my opinion is a MUST. No one wants to try and dangle a scalding hot slice into their mouth as all of the toppings slide down you chin. The sauce is slightly sweet but tasted mostly like fresh summer tomatoes. Top that off with fresh mozzarella and fresh picked basil and you have a pizza that can't be beat. A large pizza and two Cokes was $15. If you're in the South Hills stop by SLICE, the owner and the pizza is great. You wont be disappointed. read more

Our veggie pizza arrived cold & soggy. It slid in transport. It also took an hour & a half to be delivered, we were advised it would be 45 to an hour. Hopefully this is an off night & not the norm. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I've had pizza here many times, and I absolutely love this place. The staff is very friendly and the pizza is always good. If you are ever in Beechview then you have to eat here. read more

Ordered the margarita pizza, and pasta. If you're looking for good sauce- this is the place. Hands down the best pizza sauce, super fresh ingredients. Guys inside are super nice, they get busy so I recommend order a little ahead of when you want the pizza and it's well worth it! read more

Truly vegan pizza options are few and far between in the South Hills. After many disappointing phone calls to my local pizza spots, asking if their crust dough is vegan, my husband came across SLICE. SLICE explicitly labels which pizzas are vegan, or can be made vegan, on their website. We ordered a Garden pizza (lots of veggies, marinara, and no cheese) and drove in to pick it up. As far as vegan pizza in Pittsburgh goes- it was stellar. The Garden pizza WAS a bit on the soggy and floppy slide and a little more spendy for the size than I usually spring for, but SLICE is not a bad option for a vegan pizza by any means read more

Unexpected little spot in the middle of a neighborhood. Friendly staff. Steak sandwich was excellent. Pizza crust was very good. read more

See all

I live just a couple blocks from Slice on Broadway. It's not my favorite local pizza place but sometimes I'm just really in the mood for it. Their pizza is a thinner crust and is 0% greasy. The pizzas are also very reasonable priced. The ginormous pizza is a great value, and man is it huge. Even though I live walking distance from the pizza shop, I sometimes get delivery if I'd been drinking or if I have company over. Their delivery services are not long and have never taken longer than estimated. They also have lots of coupons that I get in the mail fairly often and they are usually some sort of combo. They're a great deal. The workers are also very friendly and are very hard workers. I recommend their steak salad, garlic knots, and pineapple pizza. read more

Twenty minutes longer than the already hour and fifteen minute delivery estimation and we're left with this. This is now the second time our delivery has been cold, despite being only 10 minutes away from the shop. For what it's worth, once we warmed up the pizza in our own oven it was good, but not good enough to justify the service. Next time we'll just get a frozen pizza from the grocery store. read more

This is a great delivery or eat in spot for a quick slice of pizza! So far I have had plain, pepperoni, and my favorite is their Cheesy Dreams pizza! The inside is nothing special but its always been very clean when I have been in there and the staff is very friendly. Check their website for coupons! I have also had some of their hoagies and they have been good also. read more

Slice on Broadway is a teeny tiny, heavenly smelling spot on Broadway Avenue in Beechview. Since I had recently just returned from traveling, I decided that takeout would be easier and more convenient than sitting down inside to eat. I phoned in my order while stuck in traffic, and the young man who took my order was very understanding when I inquired how long it would take to prepare my order. He said 25 minutes tops, which was perfect; I placed an order for a large (12 slices) Slaughterhouse Five pie and a Florentine hoagie. I arrived in about 15 minutes, after navigating through a neighborhood I never even knew existed, and nabbed a prime parking spot right in front of the restaurant. Slice on Broadway is situated on a street that has a few small mom and pop businesses, houses, and a live track for the T (watch out!). They were finishing up my order when I walked in, but I was happy to wait a few extra minutes if it meant I was going to walk out of there with a piping hot pizza. My total came to $25 for the two items... the pizza itself was extremely reasonably priced ($16) given the quality of ingredients and overall size. The Slaughterhouse Five is topped with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, capicola and prosciutto -- I basically died and went to Italian heaven. I can't quite explain to you how hard it was to drive the extra 15 minutes home with that pizza in my car. It took everything I had in me to not grab a piece right out of the box at a red light! The Florentine hoagie ($8), was good albeit a tad disappointing. I thought I was guaranteed a home run by selecting this proscuitto, mozzarella, spinach and pesto mayo combination, but when I got home and we opened the bag... wah wah wahhhhh. The sandwich was a rather petite 10" baguette and the fillings were skimpy. My boyfriend said he loved it, but I thought it left a lot to be desired. Perhaps it could've used some more proscuitto and spinach... whatever it was, it definitely could've been a little more substantial for the price. On the positive side, they do use fresh Breadworks baguettes, which are a nice and tasty touch. If you need any evidence that I will go back to this place again and again, I can tell you that two days later, we had a conversation about what we should get to eat, and Slice on Broadway came up. Twice. Whenever we do decide to go back, I know the Slaughterhouse Five will be on the agenda, and possibly another more generic pizza as well, so that I can really experience all this place has to offer. You know, just in case that first delicious, perfect pizza didn't completely convince me. read more

See all

If you like thin-crust pizza this is the place to go. I'd say it's a tie between here and Fiori's in terms of pizza quality. For some extra kick, get the everything seasoning on top, really adds great flavor! Their steak hoagie is pretty good, but they really skimp on ingredients compared to other place's hoagies. For example, I had ONE small leaf of lettuce on each half of the hoagie. Like seriously? Lol. Hoagie tasted good but definitely was not worth $12. Also, it infuriates me when I go in to pick up an order and the girl working the counter never fails to subtly push you to leave a tip. She always says "Top line is for the Tip! Bottom line is for the total". I have never been to any other pizza place that EXPECTS you to leave a tip and even pressures you to for PICKUP orders! read more

The slaughter house pizza was very good. Thin crust but piled high with toppings. Came in on a Thursday afternoon and there was no wait at all. Walked in ordered, grabbed a pop( Boylan Birch Beer) and sat down. Looking over the rest of the menu I will be most likely go out of my way and come back here. Pizzas come in 3 sizes. Small, Large and ginormous. I ordered a small and ate half of it and was full. I would check this place out sometime. It's worth it read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I'm a big fan of Slice On Broadway. Their pizza is the perfect combination of crispy and chewy and the right balance of cheese and sauce and their slices are huge. A plus is they deliver to Mt. Washington (even though their website says they don't). Slice On Broadway is a must try! read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Ordered pickup on a Saturday. Small pepperoni, small thick crust spicy sausage, and cheesy bread sticks. The food came out of the oven when I picked it up. Flavor of the crust was doughy (in a good way). The sauce wasn't to sweet as some places are. The sausage could have been more spicy but the taste was good. Would order a larger size of the regular pizza as its thin and not super filling. Somewhat expensive at $32 for all 3 items. Don't like that they charge more for thick crust. The staff wasn't overly friendly and seemed a bit shady. But, overall the pizza was flavorsome and will order again. read more

Pizza is not bad. My review concerns their delivery radius. They have delivered innumerable times but today they refused. I'm 2.4 miles away. read more

Tried them on a whim...and never again. 2 hours and 15 minutes for delivery. Called multiple times to get an update and was told "we can only work with what we have". Pizza arrived cold and half of the order was missing. Called and had to argue for money back. Horrible all around. read more

Tasteless and over priced.. and my order arrived incomplete. Horrible experience. Plenty of other pizza that's better

I just moved to Pittsburgh a few months ago and have been ordering pizza like it's my job. Yinz like your pizzerias! SLICE has been my favorite by far! I ordered a Margherita pizza and it was fantastic. I could tell the ingredients were fresh and high-quality. The crust was the best part! So perfectly crispy and with great flavor. read more

The pizza itself is good, I've always been satisfied and it's one of my wife's favorite. However, we hardly ever order because the delivery is, at times, awful. I live less than a 1.5 miles away and they always say they'll be there in an hour, and it always 30 minutes late. Even as I'm typing this waiting for my order it's over 20 minutes past the ETA. If you're able to stop in or at PNC, I say definitely get a pizza. If you're ordering delivery just add at least 30 minutes to their estimate. read more

If I could give them more than ****** I would...if you haven't tried this place...you should you won't be disappointed...I did and keep going back...reasonably priced, food delivered still hot and simply in a word AWESOME. thanks I order from Beechview by the way. Keep up the great service :D read more

The other night while a bit inebriated, my friends starting talking about ordering a pizza and I started looking forward to eating a delicious slice of NY style plain cheese. The opted to go for Sicilian crust. I was crushed and started fantasizing about NY style and this desire was still there when I woke up! So a couple days later, I search Yelp for the best NY style pizza near me. Now, I have my go to pizza places for "in-between" crusts, but not for thin. (My totally personal understanding of pizza crusts is as follows:) NY style: difficult to hold with one hand. Super thin, cheesy, greasy, yum Inbetween: A fair amount of crust but not overpowering. Capable of holding multiple toppings Deep Dish: Self explanatory and generally not my bag Now, to satisfy my NY style craving, sources pointed to Fiori's, which I love and grew up on, but wasn't in the mood for, and Slice. I opted to give Slice a go! They don't deliver out my way (bummer,) so I drove 10 minutes or so to pick it up. The inside of the restaurant is small, 3-4 tables and then the counter. The other patrons were friendly and talkative and made me wish that Slice had been open when I lived in Beechview as I'm sure I would have been a regular. Service was also very friendly and fast. Did the pizza live up to my 2-day long daydream? Not quite, but it was still very good. I'm still on the hunt for my favorite thin crust but this was a pretty good contender. But what's really going to keep my coming back to slice are the hoagies! I'm not typically a huge fan, but the description of the Italian sold me and I was not disappointed. From the varierty of meats and cheeses to the baguette style bun it was served on, it was delicious. Will happily order again. read more

One of my top 3 favorite pizza places in the burgh. It isn't an overwhelming amount of cheese like Fioris or Mineos (which I love both). If you're looking for a thin, tasty pizza that won't put a ball of cheese in your tummy, this is the place. Good toppings, and pretty cheap. The one in dormont is super small though, so don't expect to come there with a party and all be seated. More of a take-out spot. Their pepperoni is awesome. read more

Slice on Broadway - Large pepperoni from Slice. Very impressive! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

GIMME ALL THE BREAD AND CHEESE. This place is becoming one of my go to pizza spots. Their cheese pizza has a great thin and crisp crust with the sauce complimenting every other ingredient very well. You have to get their rolls, the pepperoni and cheese ones are my favorite! read more

Amazing pizza every time but if you want to eat in less than almost two hours, I'd pick it up. Still waiting at 8:06 for a pizza ordered at 6:25. read more

I really like Slice. The regular pizza is always great, definitely thin crust. This time I tried the Margherita for the first time, and it's my new fave. The sauce was tangy, with the perfect amount of basil on top. The crust (like their regular pizza too) is oven-crunchy. My only complaint is that I don't think the cheese was buffalo mozzarella, it wasn't that deep white.... looked like regular mozz. The pizza was still great tho, I'd get it again for sure. They also have the blood orange San Pellegrino, which adds bonus points in my book. Delivery is always fast and the drivers are always nice. read more

Slice on Broadway - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

They have forgot garlic knots twice for deliveries. Very unreliable in orders. Food is good but service is lacking