I came here on a Wednesday night and they were having a wine tasting. They also had all their wine…read morebottles half off, which was nice. I have been here a couple times to do a pizza and mozzarella class. I'm going to a limocello class at the end of the year. I came here with a wine group that I'm a part of I typically like sweet wine so I ended up getting a can of Moscato. I got the Margarita pizza and just so you know all their pizza is well done like almost burnt so if you don't like that, you need to tell them so. The pizza was OK. I would've liked more sauce on it. We sat outside and it was really nice. The staff is so friendly and helpful. We even had one of their staff take a picture of all of us. I think next time I come, I may try one of their pasta dishes.

I found pictures from this restaurant in my phone and realized I hadn't left a review. So here it…read moreis! My bestie and I decided on having dinner here one summer afternoon. I ordered what looks like the Alfredo rolls (I remembered being on a meatless month). Looking at the menu now, I don't see that as an option unfortunately. My bestie ordered a sausage pizza. I remembered both of us being very impressed with our dishes and wanting to return when we were in the area. The service was great and seating was plenty. The vibe was modern pizzeria in a family type setting. Casual and cozy overall.

I pass by this place all the time and never made a point to stop until today and I have to say I…read morewas underwhelmed. There was nobody in there. The lady at the cash register was nice but didn't say too much when we inquired about the menu due to it being our 1st time there. We decided to get 2 slices and a 6 piece wing. I was shocked that the total was $42. We got the supreme slice and it literally didn't taste like anything. The wings were ok. They had a buffalo type sauce on them but they could have been seasoned more. I guess this would place is for kids with them having the huge 36' pizzas but I'm glad I tried it.

As a native New Yorker I love a good pizza. I've been going to this place for years since they've…read morebeen open. The pizza slices are rather huge and they're very delicious. I just wish they put more sauce on the pizza. Today I ended up getting it through DoorDash and I got a large extra cheese pizza. I got it well done and it was. It's kind of hit or miss but it's definitely a place. I would check out if you like Pizza or other Italian type dishes. The bathroom could use an update.

Over time, I've now had both styles of pizza, lasagna, and a salad. Everything has been excellent…read more I am not sure what goes into their ranch dressing but it's addictive. Last night when I stopped in one of the owners was eating with his adorable family. His girls are the cutest. 10/10 highly recommend.

Tortugas came up on Yelp and was suggested by the front desk at the hotel. Went and ordered a pizza…read moreto go and enjoyed a cold beer while waiting. It smelled amazing and the service was great. Got the thin crust pizza back to the hotel and I was disappointed. The crust was chewy and seemed under cooked? I could not enjoy our supper like we had wanted. Just passing through but would not go back again.

Excellent Pizza & calzones Highly recommended!…read moreAlways consistent with the cooking & correct orders Steak Calzone is my Favorite!

Carry out pizza joint service was quick and friendly the ambience was a local pizza jointread more

My wife and I came by here for the first time for dinner. In particular we were mainly interested…read morebecause they sell Pizza By the Slice and it has a good star rating on Google. Well, upon arriving, the pizzas that were out and available for the pizza by the slice option were not appealing to the eye at all. They unfortunately looked like they had been sitting out for hours. Dry and no signs of being fresh whatsoever. Not to mention we spotted multiple flies crawling on the pizzas and the other food out on the "display" area. Because of this, we quickly changed our mind and almost walked out but still decided to give it a chance by ordering a pizza fresh. As far as the customer service goes, the lady who helped us was very kind. Additionally, we were able to order a half and half pizza (Half Margherita and Half Supreme) and we liked having that as an option. The pizza was done and ready to go within about 10 min. We took the pizza as carry out to eat at home. As far as the taste, it was okay. It wasn't bad but it also wasn't great. The flavor was average. I did question the freshness of the ingredients after experiencing how the other pizza and items were displayed by the checkout counter. Overall, unfortunately we did not have a great first impression/experience and therefore we don't see ourselves going back.

I was apprehensive to say the least when my friend chose this restaurant for lunch the other day…read more The grounds are overgrown and messy looking and there's an old broken down order board in the parking lot. Inside was a little better, looking clean but worn. The drink and ice machine was broken, which they apparently did not know until after they took our order. To their credit they found some bottled water and coke in the back and offered to refund our drinks. The food was on display on the counter in a case, but I was concerned because there didn't seem to be any sort of temperature control, just various pizzas, calzones, and more sitting out at room temperature. We chose what we wanted and they heated it up and brought it to the table. I got a Stromboli with sausage and pepperoni, and my friend got a slice of supreme pizza and one of stuffed pizza. The food actually didn't taste bad. My Stromboli was brushed with garlic butter when it was heated up which was nice, but unfortunately it was still cold in the middle. All in all, I won't be back. There are SO MANY great pizza and pasta joints in the area, this one just doesn't stack up.

Very friendly wait staff. Popped in for a quick lunch and everything was fresh and delicious. Had…read morethe personal size Honolulu pizza. The perfect amount of lunch. Quiet and small location, will absolutely be back

The food was absolutely wonderful!!! A lot better than the other options here in small town…read moreColumbiana!! we did pick up and ate it at home. price was great for the amount of food. my salad was fresh with fresh vegetables and huge pieces of FETA which is my fav!!! the amount of toppings on each slice is amazing you get a piece of something in every bite. we had a XL Super Supreme Medium Greek salad personal cheese!! price point isn't bad for the freshness

I'm surprised I've never reviewed Bertolone's before, I've visited quite a few times! Tucked in the…read morecorner of a shopping center in calera, this family owned restaurant is a real gem. When you walk in, you come face to face with a big cooler full of all sorts of heavenly cakes and desserts. I like to size them up before I sit down so I have an idea of what I want when the meal is over. I usually get the Lasagna Bianca. A bertolone's original, this delicious dish boasts chunks of Italian sausage, a creamy, cheesy sauce, and turnip greens. Rich and satisfying, it can't be missed!! The tables are stocked with chunks of bread and bottles of dipping sauce made onsite. The interior is warm and inviting, with one large wall dominated by pictures of the family that founded Bertolones and Joe's Italian. Please check out this great spot!

Update for 2026: I have visited this restaurant once each year for the past three years, and the…read morefood is always first-rate! The lasagna is awesome, the ravioli is flavorful, and all the ingredients are fresh and delicious. However, the service this year, provided by Amanda, was less than stellar. My dining party was one of only two in the restaurant at about 3pm, and Amanda was terribly impatient with all of us and seemed irritated. Her unfriendly, rushed manner is why I'm updating this review and reducing the rating by one star. So, if you go, expect great food but you might have a poor experience with your server. Original review from 2024: "Stopped at the restaurant after seeing advertising on the highway. This visit was absolutely perfect! Our waitress was helpful answering questions about the menu and food. She even allowed me to try a sample of the soup before ordering. That was awesome! I tried the lasagna and I absolutely recommend it! The sauce is delicious! Also delicious was the oil/pesto blend served at the table with bread. That was so tasty, we ordered a bottle of it to take with us!"

We ate here last night. Food was really good as always. I had the short rib pasta and the beef…read morecarpaccio. Delicious. Service was just ok this time. Our server, he, was just bland. No energy but was attentive. A very upscale design in the restaurant.

TRE LUNAAAAAA!! This place has been living rent free in my…read morehead since I left. One of my friends chose this restaurant for our girls night out & it was an absolutely perfect choice. We all agreed beforehand that we wanted to try a new place that felt pretty relaxed and had outdoor seating. This place gave everything, plus some! We didn't have to wait long for a table, and our waiter was very attentive & knowledgeable about the menu. He answered all of our questions & helped me decide what to order. The outdoor seating is spacious & it was nice to hear the live music coming from a neighboring business. My friends got the Goofy Foot drink & said that it was good but definitely on the stronger side w/the tequila. I opted for a glass of Riesling, it was delicious & paired perfectly with my meal. We didn't get any appetizers. I ordered the fish of the day: Red Snapper w/a Sweet Pea, Tomato & Saffron Risotto 20/10 I always judge food on whether it's "first bite" good & every piece on my plate passed the test. One of my friends chose the Smoked Salmon Pizza, which I was a bit skeptical about at first, but I tried a slice & it was so good. Definitely an out of the ordinary pizza combo that made me rethink all the ways smoked salmon can be used. Another friend ordered the Grilled Ribeye w/Brussel Sprouts & Mashed Potatoes, she loved it! The espresso martinis were also delicious. I wanted a cannoli for dessert but they were sold out, unfortunately. Overall, I'll definitely be returning b/c the food, pricing & atmosphere are all worth the drive. Can't wait to try the lunch menu next!